View unanswered posts | View active topics * FAQ    * Search
* Login 




Forum locked This topic is locked, you cannot edit posts or make further replies.  [ 72 posts ]  Go to page Previous  1, 2
TormakSaber
 
PostPosted: Sun, Nov 28 2010, 6:54 AM 

User avatar

Player

Joined: 16 Dec 2004
Location: Somewhere

Again, re read his post.

_________________
Davion Telemos - Monk of the Four Winds
Korthan Isharnos - Dragon Shaman of Thunder Spirit Zamasham


 
      
Wolfking6116
 
PostPosted: Sun, Nov 28 2010, 6:59 AM 

User avatar

Player

Joined: 10 Jan 2008
Location: -5 GMT

Dark Immolation wrote:
The only people that are sincerely worried about the people they kill coming back in retaliation are the ones who kill relatively unprovoked(aka brigands, bandits, assassins, and instigators). And the only ones of those that actually get retaliated against are the ones that forgo the proper IC measures to avoid the consequences.


lolwut...?

Far from the truth I'm afraid.

I've seen people who were attacked for some unprovoking reason, won the fight and expected the loser to forget the event. Since that char didn't care too much about the whole thing, he intended to just forget it himself and decide not to bring it up when he saw the other character. Later on he passes by said loser, loser and his friends decide to jump the char.

I'm really sorry, but people who 'instigate' are not the only ones who would appreciate a rule being stated that players have to show the OOC kindness of forgetting the event. I apologize if the above scenario seems 'too specific', by the way.

_________________
Jack Tesilent - Jack's Bio
Image


 
      
wakaman
 
PostPosted: Sun, Nov 28 2010, 9:58 AM 

User avatar

Player

Joined: 08 Jan 2006

TormakSaber wrote:
It hasn't "implanted memories" at all. Re read the post. And then remember that gods and DMs are above such things as "logic", so they can do it anyways.


My argument is something like this:

Learning of faces and events is likely to be quite severely impacted by physiological changes which occur during death in RL. Assuming that death as a natural phenomenon, that is, the physiological changes which occur during death, are quite consistent between Amia and RL, it seems quite clear that learning would also be impaired in death in Amia.

Having proposed that, the next point is that if learning is impacted, there is an impairment, or an absence of, a formed memory. Hence, if this is true, then death in Amia should lead to amnesia of faces and events under normal conditions. The only way in which this would not be the case, based on these assumptions, is if memories would in fact be implanted into the dead person - because they were never there in the first place due to impairment of learning.

It seems to me that Yossarin's IC explanation resolves why there is no emotional memory of the event of death, but there is still no explanation as to why there is a 'narrative', or episodic memory, of the event at all, when physiologically there really shouldn't be. I might be misunderstanding something, and I'll be happy to be proven wrong.

The gods, and DMs always have a final say. I think we all concede to that. But a logical explanation of why that choice was made ICly is still not forthcoming, at least not in my eyes: As a DM you can decide that the gods decided to prevent you from having the emotional memory of the event of death, but why do you have an emotional or alternatively a narrative (episodic) memory of the event at all, when physiologically speaking you shouldn't?

Or is normal physiology different in Amia?

Or am I totally misunderstanding something?


 
      
Yossarin
 
PostPosted: Sun, Nov 28 2010, 10:01 AM 



Player

Joined: 23 Jan 2006

Totally misunderstanding, yep.


 
      
wakaman
 
PostPosted: Sun, Nov 28 2010, 10:34 AM 

User avatar

Player

Joined: 08 Jan 2006

Yossarin wrote:
Totally misunderstanding, yep.


I've read and re-read your post, and I can't seem to understand it any other way.

I'm for sorry for imposing on you to explain yourself again, but can you please help me to understand what I'm misunderstanding?


 
      
Yossarin
 
PostPosted: Sun, Nov 28 2010, 16:40 PM 



Player

Joined: 23 Jan 2006

The fact that I wasn't being serious and was actually being facetious and the truth is that I don't give a damn about it, and when you start discussing it to death as though I were trying to impose something on others as a DM, it is embarrassing.


 
      
Fierene Havenstar
 
PostPosted: Sun, Nov 28 2010, 19:29 PM 

User avatar

Player

Joined: 03 Nov 2008
Location: Hopping around the space time continum

Ummmm, when my character got assassinated I was told by a DM that my character could not remember the last 15 mins leading up to the assassination.

Sure I was rather rankled but I went with it. It saved me from the silly, 'Well, you killed me so I have to kill you back." Nonsense. That's right, nonsense. I asked myself what would generate more RP? Not more PVP.

Yep, not knowing.

Now if you'd rather instantly know your killer I think I've seen here you can do that. But if you, instead, have to RP to find out with the knowledge that you may never know. It makes for some great RP.

Just saying.

_________________
Ari'aerath Dlues'athsha ~ Silver Singer with the Bow of the Sun
Clarette Feohn ~ Magic is Art.
Victoria Marrs ~ "I have an herb for that."


 
      
BlackDahlya
 
PostPosted: Sun, Nov 28 2010, 21:13 PM 

User avatar

Player

Joined: 17 Aug 2005
Location: Land of the Scorching Sun, Empowered by Global Warming

If the main worry is that the assassinated player will metagame the assassin who was fully helmet and disguising his voice and no name was ever mentioned...

Take screenies before, during and after the whole thing so if the murdered metagames that you did it, you can prove to the player (and the DMs if the case needs be taken a step higher) that there was blatant metagaming and maybe even griefing.

_________________
BlackDahlya

Once Upon A Time Played
Adr'ael Ken'rahel, Auron Teken’ath, Aurora Mesodias, 'Daniel' Daoskinaxarijikkym, Eilin'ira, Helena Rios, Layla Faircurrent, May'Une Do'Ndar, Mellinda Tellus, Michael of Cliffside, Rizzen of Twilight, Valkirya d'Claddath


 
      
Hrothmus
 
PostPosted: Sun, Nov 28 2010, 23:17 PM 

User avatar

Player

Joined: 08 Jan 2010
Location: Virginia

Hmm... well any decent assassin knows you go underground for a while after a hit, particularly a high profile hit. I would change my appearance, name, and hangout spots.

If your target can FIND you... you fail as an assassin.

_________________
Characters:

Fel'Brin - I am one with the shadows


 
      
ainjyll
 
PostPosted: Sun, Nov 28 2010, 23:55 PM 

User avatar

Player

Joined: 14 Jun 2006
Location: wilmington, nc

When I was much younger I was in a quite horrible car accident. Shattered my left femur, broke every rib on my left side, punctured lung, lacerated spleen and minor concussion. Funnily enough, I remember barely a lick of the whole thing. The last thing I remember is seeing the grill of the van that hit me barreling down on me about 30 feet (10 meters roughly) away. Then, next thing I know, I'm waking up in the hospital with all types of tubes coming out of me and everything really, really, really hurts. When the EMT's arrived on the scene, they said that I was still conscious and coherent. I could tell them my name, my address, who the president of the U.S. was, the date, my phone number, my parent's names and their places of work and contact numbers... but I don't remember any of it at all.

At first, I lost about 6 hours previous to the accident. Over the span of about a year it slowly came back to what I've got now. That was roughly 10 years ago.

Now, I wasn't killed, but I came damn close. I had my last rites read to me and everything. So, I can buy that a character forgets some stuff when they die pretty easily. I don't believe that the amount that's forgotten should be quantified, however. I believe it should be left up to the players to determine the amount forgotten in order to best create a story for the characters involved.

_________________
Image

"I once took the high road and it took me straight to hell and I stood there all by myself." -Hank III


 
      
billytheid
 
PostPosted: Mon, Nov 29 2010, 0:08 AM 

User avatar

Player

Joined: 12 Aug 2010
Location: Terra Australis

You could replace "let's go kick his arse" with "Far out.... I'm never going near anyone that even looks like that guy again" but then that would require fear of consequences... something Amia lacks in spades.

They say 'learn from your mistakes'... it's kind of sad when people see the mistake as not drinking the right potion as opposed to getting into a fight with someone who can thrash them.

_________________
Jess Incognito: F.L.A.G. Inc.
Gharl Killith: Hobgoblin Headhunter
Olaf Grudgebringer: Bad tempered Dwarvern Weaponsmith
"But thats mainly because I'm an Aussie and what you guys call flaming and rudeness I call a normal conversation."


 
      
wakaman
 
PostPosted: Mon, Nov 29 2010, 0:29 AM 

User avatar

Player

Joined: 08 Jan 2006

Yossarin wrote:
The fact that I wasn't being serious and was actually being facetious and the truth is that I don't give a damn about it, and when you start discussing it to death as though I were trying to impose something on others as a DM, it is embarrassing.


I don't think you were trying to impose yourself on anyone, and I never intended to convey that in my posts. I realize that you were trying to address concerns which were raised in this topic. I'm sorry that it came across as such, and I want to apologize publicly to you for the embarrassment: it really was not my intention. Like I said before, and you are absolutely right about this, I tend to over-think things like this in terms of reasons and logic, and this is a failing on my part, not a reflection on you or anyone else at all.

My intention in these posts was to try to bring up and possibly address a question which has been niggling in the back of my mind for a long time, and which I don't have an adequate answer to. This bothers me because it means that I cannot explain, to myself, why something happens in the world of Amia in which my characters exist and I therefore can't properly integrate that into my RP. To me, this is therefore an important concern. I also think that the question of why recent memory is preserved after death is important to address in an IC manner in general, even though it is more of an OOC measure, because it may affect immersion, and RP, for some players.

My issue isn't so much that the OOC measure is there, because there seems to be good reason for it. My issue is that I can't grasp how to explain it in an IC manner that adequately satiates my nit-picky mind and fits with the setting in a seemless way. At the moment, it just doesn't make sense that such a thing should happen at all. But there is always a way around things like this, and loopholes in logic can always be created. I just don't want to create it myself, because I don't actually have the authority to dictate how things work on Amia, and I therefore wanted a DM to 'lay down the lore' about this. Ideally, though, I think the lore would have to be backed with evidence or reason for it to be accepted, because it would indulge some player's sensibilities and would also be understandable and acceptable to everyone. Though again, it's not absolutely necessary and in the end, it's the DM's call, and I accept that too.

I didn't make that clear in my initial posts, and I apologize for that.


 
      
Dark Immolation
 
PostPosted: Mon, Nov 29 2010, 0:56 AM 

User avatar

Developer

Joined: 20 Apr 2008
Location: The downeaster "Alexa"

billytheid wrote:
You could replace "let's go kick his arse" with "Far out.... I'm never going near anyone that even looks like that guy again" but then that would require fear of consequences... something Amia lacks in spades.


Associative learning requires memory.

Tell me, are you afraid to go to sleep, even though you've likely had nightmares before? As in seriously scared out of your mind to fall into slumber? No? Well that's natural.

Why? Because you forget them relatively soon after you wake up. You may have the scariest, most bone-chilling nightmare, and maybe as soon as you wake up you say "Gosh, I can't go back to sleep." But given time, maybe half an hour, you will forget the details, the fear, the apparent pain, and you fall asleep again like it never happened.

If death worked the same way as that, "Far out, I'm never going near etcetc" would be the proper reaction for maybe a day or two. But what's to be cautious of? It's like you're waking up from a dream. All you know is that you were awake, then you were awake again. All you know is that you were fighting, and then you weren't.

Death should work, and has worked thus far on Amia, as a kid putting his hand on a hot stove. It's pain is real and it is remembered. Perhaps, as time passes, the actual details are lost over a long deal of time, but the general feel, and more importantly, the memory of that pain that followed keeps the kid from doing it again until he gains the sense not to do it for himself.

I won't got as far to say that death-memory-loss has no RP value whatsoever. Heck, in some settings, it might. But as I see it on Amia, it would stifle more RP than create.

As is, victim gets killed and someone comes across his body. When raised, he may recall the [apparent] looks of whoever killed him, go to scrounge up some help to track him down, put up flyers up, post a bounty, start a vendetta or recall the even sometime down the road for a deeper and more meaningful background if and when he ever crosses that PC again. Maybe even start a mass search for the "masked man."

In case two, victim gets killed and someone comes across his body. He gets raised and.... well he gets raised. Assassin gets away and no RP follows. Everyone just wakes up from a bad dream and goes about their business.


Last edited by Dark Immolation on Mon, Nov 29 2010, 0:59 AM, edited 1 time in total.

 
      
Estara
 
PostPosted: Mon, Nov 29 2010, 0:57 AM 



Player

Joined: 23 Feb 2007

You're still overthinking it, wakaman. :) Just...

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=BuQRWEKt4pg


 
      
wakaman
 
PostPosted: Mon, Nov 29 2010, 2:36 AM 

User avatar

Player

Joined: 08 Jan 2006

Dark Immolation wrote:

In case two, victim gets killed and someone comes across his body. He gets raised and.... well he gets raised. Assassin gets away and no RP follows. Everyone just wakes up from a bad dream and goes about their business.


What about the assassin, who can continue to further whatever plot he/she is concocting and therefore generate much more long-term conflict and intrigue RP?

I understand your concern that causing memory loss prevents short-term RP after the event and also seems to encourage people to be slack with their RP of disguises etc. And that makes perfect sense. But the flip-side is that lack of memory loss also encourages espionage/pvp without any consequences or risk whatsoever, and I don't see the balance in that. It seems to encourage one type of RP and stifle another.


 
      
Dark Immolation
 
PostPosted: Mon, Nov 29 2010, 3:09 AM 

User avatar

Developer

Joined: 20 Apr 2008
Location: The downeaster "Alexa"

wakaman wrote:
What about the assassin, who can continue to further whatever plot he/she is concocting and therefore generate much more long-term conflict and intrigue RP?


That can happen and has happened now with people remembering what happened up to death. Just because things are remembered doesn't guarantee that the perpetrator will get caught, especially if they're smart about it. A perfect example is a situation between my character and a guy who was killing elves around the isle. He got a description of "an elven man in black and purple". And speaking with the victims actually led him on a long line of RP, longer I'd say than if no one could remember anything at all. It would merely mean he would have to catch the person in the act.

Quote:
But the flip-side is that lack of memory loss also encourages espionage/pvp without any consequences or risk whatsoever, and I don't see the balance in that. It seems to encourage one type of RP and stifle another.


I don't see your reasoning there. The consequences become more real in the case people can face retaliation for not being smart or cunning in their killings.

What is the "risk" in killing a person, who when raised, cannot tell anyone anything about what happened prior to the actual fight? As long as you don't commit murder under a streetlamp with witnesses, you're in the clear. No risk. No fun. Again, the only thing the murderer has to worry about is witnesses. And he leaves no trace for RP to follow except "Hey, 5 more people have been found killed in the forest. No one knows/saw anything, so lets just go stand around there and hope he's dumb enough to commit murder in front of use while we're there."

The alternative presents common sense being rewarded, rather than making an easy cop-out for PC's that don't take the time to be good at their job. Remembering helps build infamy, mystery, and last but certainly not least, fear. Or at least a healthy amount of caution. An elven killer in purple and black in on the loose. You're walking through the forest. There's a guy near the lake. Is that purple and black he's wearing?! No, it's more like grey and a deep blue... maybe the reports were wrong... nah, it couldn't be him. Is it? Let's go find out.

^That is a heap more inspirational for RP than every raised person becoming your cliche traumatic-event amnesia patient, IMO. But even then, with the current system(or lack there of), it's still possible to have him. It'd just not be the norm, however.


 
      
tsukasa1991
 
PostPosted: Mon, Nov 29 2010, 3:36 AM 

User avatar

Player

Joined: 18 Jul 2009

i like that someone brought up another point

when you die... why would you NOT be afraid of your killer??!?!?! (unless you happen to be immune to fear >.>)
whenever maggot kills someone it is usually as part of a fear mongering thing, the murders serve little other purpose now (from what im willing to tell) and when maggot is killed by something he knows little about he is SCARED. that right there makes him not like certain people, even weaker people than the ones that killed him. now not all pvp is going to lead to that or else he would fear everything sooner or later... but for certain well done rp it is deserving of some real consequences.

sure, remember who killed you. remember. in your dreams you see his face, and it haunts you... youll never go back into those woods again.

why dont we see much of this?
(we are not superheros. even they get scared sometimes too)

_________________
Plays-
Maggot Bucktooth (Retired)
Giando Paladrious (Retired)


 
      
billytheid
 
PostPosted: Mon, Nov 29 2010, 8:54 AM 

User avatar

Player

Joined: 12 Aug 2010
Location: Terra Australis

tsukasa1991 wrote:
i like that someone brought up another point

when you die... why would you NOT be afraid of your killer??!?!?! (unless you happen to be immune to fear >.>)
whenever maggot kills someone it is usually as part of a fear mongering thing, the murders serve little other purpose now (from what im willing to tell) and when maggot is killed by something he knows little about he is SCARED. that right there makes him not like certain people, even weaker people than the ones that killed him. now not all pvp is going to lead to that or else he would fear everything sooner or later... but for certain well done rp it is deserving of some real consequences.

sure, remember who killed you. remember. in your dreams you see his face, and it haunts you... youll never go back into those woods again.

why dont we see much of this?
(we are not superheros. even they get scared sometimes too)


this...

and if people are unwilling to accept either 'forget through death' or 'detained until plot is over' as a consequence of being caught spying then they are not worth including in RP. If you get busted but still manage to spill the beans and foil a plan of some kind then you are, while not breaking any rules directly, a total wanker.

_________________
Jess Incognito: F.L.A.G. Inc.
Gharl Killith: Hobgoblin Headhunter
Olaf Grudgebringer: Bad tempered Dwarvern Weaponsmith
"But thats mainly because I'm an Aussie and what you guys call flaming and rudeness I call a normal conversation."


 
      
Selvec Darkon
 
PostPosted: Mon, Nov 29 2010, 10:10 AM 

User avatar

Player

Joined: 12 Oct 2005
Location: On a Disk, carried by four elephants, which stand on a gigantic turtle.

Quite simple. The character is jaded by his/her many many experiences with death on the isle. The characters of Amia must deal with the constant possibility of living in a world where death isn't just a certainty from age, it's a certainty from anything. This is a world in which your own pants can eat you. Death to a character in this world would suddenly be less scary, as they always have to deal with it, they would become jaded by it. Furthermore, the presence of resurrection magic in such vast quantities on Amia, means death is not the end.

Though in saying this, to be afraid of someone who kills someone else, you have to remember them. Personally I will stubbornly stick with my characters remembering everything after death.

_________________
I keels u with my axe!

"Do ye know where the Holy-Flamin' Frost-brand Gronk-slayin' Vorpal Hammer o' woundin' an' returnin' an' Shootin'-Lightnin'-out-yer-bum is?"


 
      
ainjyll
 
PostPosted: Mon, Nov 29 2010, 14:49 PM 

User avatar

Player

Joined: 14 Jun 2006
Location: wilmington, nc

Just because you can come back from death, doesn't mean it's not painful. Getting into a fight with a sword-carrying barbarian and being hacked down from 400 HP to -17 HP is painful. I don't care how jaded a person may be, they're not going to openly accept that level of pain on a daily basis like nothing happened.

_________________
Image

"I once took the high road and it took me straight to hell and I stood there all by myself." -Hank III


 
      
Kudark
 
PostPosted: Mon, Nov 29 2010, 16:25 PM 

User avatar

Player

Joined: 14 Dec 2009
Location: The Dark Side of the Moon

It's how you role-play it too.
My character knows of a couple people who are perma-dead and this affects his view on death. he doesn't take it so lightly, and is rightfully afraid for his life and that of the ones he cares for. He knows it can be permanent.

As for memory, I RP him remembering up to the point of death, it's not easy to forget someone trying to kill you...trust me.

_________________
Image


 
      
Scimiter
 
PostPosted: Mon, Nov 29 2010, 16:51 PM 

User avatar

Player

Joined: 25 Apr 2009
Location: Canada

Just cause I feel like kicking in on Arelith the rule is in place for about five minutes memory loss before death and nothing /of/ death cause Death is actually a map you go to till you get rez'd or pass through the gate. When I killed Daniel off for almost a year for RP reasons he lost about 80% of his memory though there was a deity involved so guess that doesn't really count but worth noting it RP based use. Just remember to ask a DM to get involved and don't just remove memories and say a deity did it

_________________
Guys I play:
Finng Meras
Joshua Steel
Daniel Makie
Celub Elubmiire
Tristan
Len'ionel

Image


 
      
Display posts from previous:  Sort by  
Forum locked This topic is locked, you cannot edit posts or make further replies.  [ 72 posts ]  Go to page Previous  1, 2


Who is online

Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 6 guests


You cannot post new topics in this forum
You cannot reply to topics in this forum
You cannot edit your posts in this forum
You cannot delete your posts in this forum

Search for:
Jump to:  
cron
Powered by phpBB © 2000, 2002, 2005, 2007 phpBB Group