View unanswered posts | View active topics * FAQ    * Search
* Login 




Forum locked This topic is locked, you cannot edit posts or make further replies.  [ 53 posts ]  Go to page 1, 2  Next
Izzzt
 
PostPosted: Wed, Jun 23 2010, 6:39 AM 



Player

Joined: 15 Dec 2008
Location: Rochester, New York, USA

This question has recently come to mind for me, due to some RP ingame. Specifically, dealing with drow shadowdancers. Behold, why it is important:

Disco wrote:
It’s an unwritten rule, but please try to observe the traditional PnP rules that govern the use of the Hide in Plain Sight feat. For example: Using it only when within 10 feet of a shadow (that isn’t your own). Also, if the Light spell is cast on you it can negate the use of Hide in Plain Sight.



NWN, the NWN-wiki, and the v3.5 Core Rules state that the spell Light does not provoke a Spell Resistance check. But some players claim it does, and some players claim a DM has told them it does. Can I get a rulin' on this, please?

_________________
Plays as:
Richard Branno: Helmite Turnipfarmer
Herial Ghalen: The Merriest Man on Amia


 
      
TormakSaber
 
PostPosted: Wed, Jun 23 2010, 8:09 AM 

User avatar

Player

Joined: 16 Dec 2004
Location: Somewhere

Quote:
Light
Evocation [Light]
Level: Brd 0, Clr 0, Drd 0, Sor/Wiz 0
Components: V, M/DF
Casting Time: 1 standard action
Range: Touch
Target: Object touched
Duration: 10 min./level (D)
Saving Throw: None
Spell Resistance: No


This spell causes an object to glow like a torch, shedding bright light in a 20-foot radius (and dim light for an additional 20 feet) from the point you touch. The effect is immobile, but it can be cast on a movable object. Light taken into an area of magical darkness does not function.

A light spell (one with the light descriptor) counters and dispels a darkness spell (one with the darkness descriptor) of an equal or lower level.
Arcane Material Component

A firefly or a piece of phosphorescent moss.

_________________
Davion Telemos - Monk of the Four Winds
Korthan Isharnos - Dragon Shaman of Thunder Spirit Zamasham


 
      
Gravemaskin
 
PostPosted: Wed, Jun 23 2010, 10:05 AM 

User avatar

Player

Joined: 29 Jul 2007
Location: Norway: Home of the Trolls

It would however need a touch attack check, and thus technically become subject for epic dodge though, right?

_________________
Adair - Druid and part time treant cosplayer


 
      
Uberuce
 
PostPosted: Wed, Jun 23 2010, 10:13 AM 

User avatar

Player

Joined: 11 Nov 2005
Location: Near the bar.

My personal advice: just follow the NWN engine and cast it for the Hide penalty it gives. If the 'dancer respects the no-HiPS thing and doesn't care to argue about Epic Dodge or SR, then great. If not, they still have have HiPS, and I refer you to Marv's opinions on hitmen in Sin City.


 
      
Mathias of Constantinople
 
PostPosted: Wed, Jun 23 2010, 10:14 AM 

User avatar

Player

Joined: 10 Aug 2008
Location: Québec

This became a big discussion for the drow yesterday. From Tormak's post, can we safely assume it's okay to cast light on drow using the cantrip with low caster levels, or even items that cast low level light? The problem expressed yesterday was that drow SR should resist it.

Even though it seems d20 says no SR too (http://www.d20srd.org/srd/spells/light.htm) it would still be useful to hear a ruling.

_________________
Image


 
      
TormakSaber
 
PostPosted: Wed, Jun 23 2010, 10:15 AM 

User avatar

Player

Joined: 16 Dec 2004
Location: Somewhere

The ruling is as I posted. It has no SR.

_________________
Davion Telemos - Monk of the Four Winds
Korthan Isharnos - Dragon Shaman of Thunder Spirit Zamasham


 
      
Mathias of Constantinople
 
PostPosted: Wed, Jun 23 2010, 10:18 AM 

User avatar

Player

Joined: 10 Aug 2008
Location: Québec

Thanks, this will clear up lots of problems in the future.

_________________
Image


 
      
P Three
 
PostPosted: Wed, Jun 23 2010, 13:15 PM 

User avatar

Player

Joined: 18 Dec 2008

For reiteration, that means if you get slapped with a Light spell/item effect, no HiPSing/ShadowJumping. Period. Correct?

_________________
Bobo_Underhill wrote:
Ley lines, y'all. Just let me go wrangle up my cowboy boots and lasso us up some magic.

Yee-haw!


Aly'dra Zau'ana: Priestessish Of Eilistraee
Danika Nefzen: Druid of the Earthmother
Delia Am'Anodel: Paladin of Torm


 
      
Shade of Blue
 
PostPosted: Wed, Jun 23 2010, 13:50 PM 

User avatar

Player

Joined: 06 Aug 2008

Gravemaskin wrote:
It would however need a touch attack check, and thus technically become subject for epic dodge though, right?


"The character avoids all damage from the first attack of each round."

_________________
Merrien wrote:
Hee hee hee hee hee.... snakes wearing sweaters....


 
      
Dieu_Le_Fera
 
PostPosted: Wed, Jun 23 2010, 13:52 PM 

User avatar

Player

Joined: 29 Jun 2009
Location: Philadelphia

Quote:
For reiteration, that means if you get slapped with a Light spell/item effect, no HiPSing/ShadowJumping. Period. Correct?


It's an unwritten rule.. it's up to the player to decide to be a good sport about it or not. That's what I gather anyway...

_________________
Image

"It is by the holy beans of Java that thoughts acquire speed, the hands acquire shakes, the shakes become a warning, it is by Java alone that I set my mind in motion."


 
      
xordae
 
PostPosted: Wed, Jun 23 2010, 14:01 PM 

User avatar

Player

Joined: 01 Jul 2005
Location: Germany

All a character needs for Spell Resistance to kick in is for the spell being casted on him to be perceived as a threat. Bioware did not intend Light in such a competitive role as a SD-breaker, and that is why there is no SR or any other check on it. This in my mind invalidates the unwritten rule, because there is no unwritten counter, and if so, it would be tedious to interrupt combat every time and roll dice.

I was Light-ed once or twice before with an SD character and it was, well, kinda lame. Anyone with a single caster level can do it and there's nothing you can do about it. Unless you are one of these cheapskates that flickers in and out of HipS ALL the time, which is ironically just what the Light thing is supposed to prevent. So weighing all this up, I'm not gonna stop using HipS when light is cast upon me any longer. The spell already creates a penalty to Hide/MS, without any saving throw, and that shall be enough.


 
      
Yurell
 
PostPosted: Wed, Jun 23 2010, 14:17 PM 

User avatar

Player

Joined: 06 Jan 2008
Location: ANU, behind the coffee mug (+10 GMT)

xordae wrote:
All a character needs for Spell Resistance to kick in is for the spell being casted on him to be perceived as a threat.


Wrong. Some spells (such as Light) do inherently have no susceptibility to spell resistance, even in PnP. Light is one of them. And yes, there is a counter. Darkness > Light.

_________________
2009's Second Most Overall Contributing Player

يمكنني استخدام مترجم جوجل


 
      
Gunz
 
PostPosted: Wed, Jun 23 2010, 14:39 PM 



Player

Joined: 01 Jul 2006
Location: The City of Fallen Angels, Ca

There is also light immunity gear out there. ^.^

_________________
My Characters:
Yuilith Kethil Menaiivan Garadeth


 
      
Moonangel
 
PostPosted: Wed, Jun 23 2010, 14:43 PM 

User avatar

Player

Joined: 28 Nov 2009

Light does not stop you from hipsing in either pnp or by nwn mechanics. The ''unwritten rule'' is completely made up and not even enforced, I never bothered with it.


 
      
Xaviera
 
PostPosted: Wed, Jun 23 2010, 15:52 PM 

User avatar

Player

Joined: 07 Aug 2006
Location: Temple of Love

Um... if you're out in the daylight, how do you know if you have light on you (because I personally can't tell, there being no effect icon or anything!), and how long does it last? If 10 game min/level (20 RL sec/level?), I guess you need to ask the caster how he cast it and then figure it out?

_________________
Image
~Sharess on AmiaWiki~
Priestess, politician, prostitute
"[They] were moving in on me like Sharessans on a new broad in the bath house" - Tracer Bolt
AmiaWiki mod (mostly inactive)


 
      
blackvswhite
 
PostPosted: Wed, Jun 23 2010, 16:09 PM 

User avatar

Player

Joined: 08 Nov 2008

Can we get a cantrip put it that nullifies dev crit and GS as well, just for balance purposes?


 
      
Dwagin
 
PostPosted: Wed, Jun 23 2010, 18:07 PM 

User avatar

Player

Joined: 08 Aug 2006
Location: The Land of Nod

Why'd you let them hit you with it in the first place is my question... any time as a SD casting starts you should hit the HIPS button if its not a 100% allied situation. Should even have your finger on it. If not sneak off to stealth if you're not alone. If a caster is in range of you to cast the cantrip version of this you're also in STABBYFACE range and the moment they start casting it is green/go time to commencerating the stabbulating. You can be joyous in the fact that you just KD/sneaked him into oblivion. Its just a matter of time before the Timestops start. Its your job to stop it before it does.

_________________
Dwagin [Duh-wa-GIN] N. - 1a. Small and cute thingum, particularly fond of four legged scaled creatures of the metalic and chromatic varieties.

-Extraordinarily ordinary in the mostest of ways.


 
      
DerkDerkistan
 
PostPosted: Wed, Jun 23 2010, 18:39 PM 

User avatar

Player

Joined: 18 Jan 2009
Location: Earth

Dwagin wrote:
Why'd you let them hit you with it in the first place is my question... any time as a SD casting starts you should hit the HIPS button if its not a 100% allied situation. Should even have your finger on it. If not sneak off to stealth if you're not alone. If a caster is in range of you to cast the cantrip version of this you're also in STABBYFACE range and the moment they start casting it is green/go time to commencerating the stabbulating. You can be joyous in the fact that you just KD/sneaked him into oblivion. Its just a matter of time before the Timestops start. Its your job to stop it before it does.


This.

But with the caveat that the mage should hostile first before casting the Light spell.

Oh, and to answer Xaviera's question, you get a little puff of magic above your head to tell you it expired.

_________________
Remember when I knew a boxer, baby


 
      
HellScourge
 
PostPosted: Wed, Jun 23 2010, 18:50 PM 

User avatar

Player

Joined: 17 Jan 2007
Location: GMT+1

Yurell wrote:
xordae wrote:
All a character needs for Spell Resistance to kick in is for the spell being casted on him to be perceived as a threat.


Wrong. Some spells (such as Light) do inherently have no susceptibility to spell resistance, even in PnP. Light is one of them. And yes, there is a counter. Darkness > Light.



Correction.

Greater Darkness > Light > Darkness

Which is only avaible to.. BG'S!

_________________
"Most assume that all the followers of Lathander are great morning people. They're very wrong."
"I think we are the only group where AD&D stands for Attention Deficit Disorder."
TeroSNS wrote:
Hello Everyone [...] I like tentacles [...] :)


 
      
Xalyth
 
PostPosted: Wed, Jun 23 2010, 19:25 PM 

User avatar

Player

Joined: 06 Jul 2008

HellScourge wrote:
Yurell wrote:
xordae wrote:
All a character needs for Spell Resistance to kick in is for the spell being casted on him to be perceived as a threat.


Wrong. Some spells (such as Light) do inherently have no susceptibility to spell resistance, even in PnP. Light is one of them. And yes, there is a counter. Darkness > Light.



Correction.

Greater Darkness > Light > Darkness

Which is only avaible to.. BG'S!


wrong

Greater darkness > continual light > darkness > light

_________________
I sleep with the Libris Mortis under my pillow.

---Carstina Blackweave---
Speaker of Tarkuul
Headmistress of the Magisterium Mortis


 
      
Silvarus
 
PostPosted: Wed, Jun 23 2010, 19:30 PM 

User avatar

Player

Joined: 23 Sep 2005
Location: Jyväskylä, Finland, Europe

HIPS?

BURN KILL PURGE DESTROY!

That is all.

_________________
Gagis Silvarna, the Robocop with wings who shoots lasers from his fingertips
Lily Havthorn, the Waukeenar
Silwe, the elf


 
      
Grymia
 
PostPosted: Wed, Jun 23 2010, 19:39 PM 

User avatar

Player

Joined: 14 Dec 2004
Location: Kohlingen, and a Basement in Canada

Moonangel wrote:
Light does not stop you from hipsing in either pnp or by nwn mechanics. The ''unwritten rule'' is completely made up and not even enforced, I never bothered with it.



To Quote the 3.5 DMG:

Hide in Plain Sight: A Shadowdancer can use the Hide skill even while being observed. As long as she is within ten feet of some sort of Shadow, a Shadowdancer can hide from view in the open.


Then, to quote the Light Spell
Evocation [Light]
Level: Brd 0, Clr 0, Drd 0, Sor/Wiz 0
Components: V, M/DF
Casting Time: 1 standard action
Range: Touch
Target: Object touched
Duration: 10 min./level (D)
Saving Throw: None
Spell Resistance: No

This spell causes an object to glow like a torch, shedding bright light in a 20-foot radius (and dim light for an additional 20 feet) from the point you touch. The effect is immobile, but it can be cast on a movable object. Light taken into an area of magical darkness does not function.

A light spell (one with the light descriptor) counters and dispels a darkness spell (one with the darkness descriptor) of an equal or lower level.

Arcane Material Component
A firefly or a piece of phosphorescent moss.

---

So, Prithee my good fellow: How does one happen to be within ten feet of Shadow, when they're a Radiating light source for 20 feet?


 
      
blackvswhite
 
PostPosted: Wed, Jun 23 2010, 20:02 PM 

User avatar

Player

Joined: 08 Nov 2008

Quote:
So, Prithee my good fellow: How does one happen to be within ten feet of Shadow, when they're a Radiating light source for 20 feet?


they make shadows on any objects within those 20 feet?


 
      
Logicality
 
PostPosted: Wed, Jun 23 2010, 20:09 PM 

User avatar

Player

Joined: 23 Apr 2008
Location: The Otherworld

Any shadow they jump into is going to be instantly destroyed by the light surrounding them.

_________________
"A somebody was once a nobody who wanted to and did." - Anonymous


 
      
blackvswhite
 
PostPosted: Wed, Jun 23 2010, 20:14 PM 

User avatar

Player

Joined: 08 Nov 2008

do they have to jump into it, or be within 10 feet of it?


 
      
Glyph
 
PostPosted: Wed, Jun 23 2010, 20:40 PM 

User avatar

Player

Joined: 10 Jun 2010

"if daylight, how?..."

stand under a tree, duh, trees cast shadows in daylight. as for how to tell, enable shadows in options, and zoom in.

if your gunna ignore light don't RP a shadowdancer.


 
      
Grymia
 
PostPosted: Wed, Jun 23 2010, 20:47 PM 

User avatar

Player

Joined: 14 Dec 2004
Location: Kohlingen, and a Basement in Canada

Normally, yes. But if you're a walking lightsource yourself..


 
      
Jyro X
 
PostPosted: Wed, Jun 23 2010, 20:50 PM 

User avatar

Player

Joined: 04 Dec 2009
Location: North Carolina (EST/GMT -5)

Here's my opinion since there's no "established" rule.

If the caster isn't willing to roll a touch attack roll to beat my defense, then I will still HiPS as it already gives penalties to hide/ms. However, if they roll a touch attack and beat my defense, then I will not HiPS.

Since it's all based on homebrewn mechanic rulings.

Last time I had light cast on me, I was told by a DM I could no longer hide, -period-. So, given that it's an "unwritten" rule, I will use the above as my guideline unless otherwise told by a DM in a case-by-case basis.

Edit: Not to mention the short duration of the light spell by low caster levels. The only thing that stinks is not being able to tell when the spell wears off as there is no buff that appears on your buff bar. And one would assume you would be able to shrug the effects off as easily as you do with the "debuff" option. Considering it technically counts as a "buff" for some reason.

_________________
Image
Image


 
      
xordae
 
PostPosted: Wed, Jun 23 2010, 20:52 PM 

User avatar

Player

Joined: 01 Jul 2005
Location: Germany

Glyph wrote:
if your gunna ignore light don't RP a shadowdancer.


Exactly. RP.

In PvP things are a little different. I won't have a cantrip castrate my most powerful ability.


 
      
DerkDerkistan
 
PostPosted: Wed, Jun 23 2010, 20:53 PM 

User avatar

Player

Joined: 18 Jan 2009
Location: Earth

As I said, when Light wears off, it gives a puff above your head to tell you so.

And, the AoE for Continual Light does induce a Touch Attack.

_________________
Remember when I knew a boxer, baby


 
      
Weylyn_SotW
 
PostPosted: Wed, Jun 23 2010, 20:55 PM 

User avatar

Player

Joined: 30 Mar 2010
Location: The Netherlands

Glyph wrote:
if your gunna ignore light don't RP a shadowdancer.


If you're gunna ignore the fact that a touch spell requires a touch attack roll against the SDs considerable dodge AC, don't play a spellcaster?

People build their entire characters around HipS, and I object to a cantrip being able to disable it without any possible way to counter. The only overriding spell available normally is darkness, which is a lvl 2 spell, and that'll take you at least a round to cast even IF you instantly notice the light effect. If you have BoT, there's the option of using the anti-light from the same cantrip, but both of those options require you to be a spellcaster rather than a shadowdancer.

If HipS can be so easily disabled, can we please get fumble charts for the dev critters among us?

*rolls attack* Natural 1
*rolls to confirm* Natural 1
*checks chart* Dev Crit - You cut off your own head, you clumsy bastard.

_________________
Shynt'iira, Ilharess d'lil Qu'ellar My'ana


 
      
Dark Immolation
 
PostPosted: Wed, Jun 23 2010, 20:56 PM 

User avatar

Developer

Joined: 20 Apr 2008
Location: The downeaster "Alexa"

xordae wrote:
In PvP things are a little different. I won't have a cantrip castrate my most powerful ability.


Why not? Because that's exactly what it does.

Quote:
People build their entire characters around HipS, and I object to a cantrip being able to disable it without any possible way to counter.


I can count the times I've walked into the market and not seen a "Tome of Darkness" in there. 15 castings of darkness right now that anyone can use, no UMD required. And even then, darkness scrolls are buyable in that same store. There's really no excuse for any SD ignoring the Light rule when they legitimately have googobs of ways to neutralize it, except they can't be arsed to follow the rule and give up hipspamming.


Last edited by Dark Immolation on Wed, Jun 23 2010, 21:00 PM, edited 1 time in total.

 
      
Jyro X
 
PostPosted: Wed, Jun 23 2010, 20:58 PM 

User avatar

Player

Joined: 04 Dec 2009
Location: North Carolina (EST/GMT -5)

Weylyn_SotW wrote:
*rolls attack* Natural 1
*rolls to confirm* Natural 1
*checks chart* Dev Crit - You cut off your own head, you clumsy bastard.

I lol'd hard IRL.

_________________
Image
Image


 
      
Glyph
 
PostPosted: Wed, Jun 23 2010, 21:02 PM 

User avatar

Player

Joined: 10 Jun 2010

...then should we assume light is pitiful and continual light is required to dispell? what about a fighter windmilling about with a torch? what about combust or delayed fireball? (fire makes light, fact)

seriously though, if I stand there casting light, contunual flame, have alchemists fire on my blade, holding a torch, in daylight, etc, and your still using hips/shadowjumping/whatever it is you do, ima log out. simple as.


Last edited by Glyph on Wed, Jun 23 2010, 21:06 PM, edited 2 times in total.

 
      
TormakSaber
 
PostPosted: Wed, Jun 23 2010, 21:02 PM 

User avatar

Player

Joined: 16 Dec 2004
Location: Somewhere

xordae wrote:
All a character needs for Spell Resistance to kick in is for the spell being casted on him to be perceived as a threat. Bioware did not intend Light in such a competitive role as a SD-breaker, and that is why there is no SR or any other check on it. This in my mind invalidates the unwritten rule, because there is no unwritten counter, and if so, it would be tedious to interrupt combat every time and roll dice.

I was Light-ed once or twice before with an SD character and it was, well, kinda lame. Anyone with a single caster level can do it and there's nothing you can do about it. Unless you are one of these cheapskates that flickers in and out of HipS ALL the time, which is ironically just what the Light thing is supposed to prevent. So weighing all this up, I'm not gonna stop using HipS when light is cast upon me any longer. The spell already creates a penalty to Hide/MS, without any saving throw, and that shall be enough.


Didn't read Topic:

No. There are spells that do not allow Spell Resistance in DnD, even if you have spell resistance. Light in one of them.

SR does not work.

_________________
Davion Telemos - Monk of the Four Winds
Korthan Isharnos - Dragon Shaman of Thunder Spirit Zamasham


 
      
TormakSaber
 
PostPosted: Wed, Jun 23 2010, 21:03 PM 

User avatar

Player

Joined: 16 Dec 2004
Location: Somewhere

Glyph wrote:
...then should we assume light is pitiful and continual light is required to dispell? what about a fighter windmilling about with a torch? what about combust or delayed fireball? (fire makes light, fact)

seriously though, if I stand there casting light, contunual flame, have alchemists fire on my blade, holding a torch, in daylight, etc, and your still using hips, ima log out. simple as.



That's not a good approahc to a problem and is more likely toget you slapped on the wrist for logging out in the middle of RP/a conflict. There is a right way and a wrong way to handle a problem and this is the wrong way.

_________________
Davion Telemos - Monk of the Four Winds
Korthan Isharnos - Dragon Shaman of Thunder Spirit Zamasham


 
      
TormakSaber
 
PostPosted: Wed, Jun 23 2010, 21:05 PM 

User avatar

Player

Joined: 16 Dec 2004
Location: Somewhere

Quote:
People build their entire characters around HipS, and I object to a cantrip being able to disable it without any possible way to counter.


I does. Welcome to shadowdancing, get behind me, I played one for over 4 years,a 20 SD, and helped establish the Shadowdancing culture on the entire server along with a few others.

_________________
Davion Telemos - Monk of the Four Winds
Korthan Isharnos - Dragon Shaman of Thunder Spirit Zamasham


 
      
TormakSaber
 
PostPosted: Wed, Jun 23 2010, 21:06 PM 

User avatar

Player

Joined: 16 Dec 2004
Location: Somewhere

blackvswhite wrote:
do they have to jump into it, or be within 10 feet of it?



HIPS is within 10 feet.

Shadow Jump is in shadow, to in shadow.

(Yes, I 'm making a ton of posts, sorry.)

_________________
Davion Telemos - Monk of the Four Winds
Korthan Isharnos - Dragon Shaman of Thunder Spirit Zamasham


 
      
TormakSaber
 
PostPosted: Wed, Jun 23 2010, 21:06 PM 

User avatar

Player

Joined: 16 Dec 2004
Location: Somewhere

blackvswhite wrote:
Quote:
So, Prithee my good fellow: How does one happen to be within ten feet of Shadow, when they're a Radiating light source for 20 feet?


they make shadows on any objects within those 20 feet?


This rule was discarded when it was discovered how much it was confusing people. The current, todate (for a few years now) rule on SD is; If Lit, no HIPS, period.

_________________
Davion Telemos - Monk of the Four Winds
Korthan Isharnos - Dragon Shaman of Thunder Spirit Zamasham


 
      
TormakSaber
 
PostPosted: Wed, Jun 23 2010, 21:08 PM 

User avatar

Player

Joined: 16 Dec 2004
Location: Somewhere

HellScourge wrote:
Yurell wrote:
xordae wrote:
All a character needs for Spell Resistance to kick in is for the spell being casted on him to be perceived as a threat.


Wrong. Some spells (such as Light) do inherently have no susceptibility to spell resistance, even in PnP. Light is one of them. And yes, there is a counter. Darkness > Light.



Correction.

Greater Darkness > Light > Darkness

Which is only avaible to.. BG'S!


No.

Greater Darkness > BoT Cont Light > Darkness > Light.

_________________
Davion Telemos - Monk of the Four Winds
Korthan Isharnos - Dragon Shaman of Thunder Spirit Zamasham


 
      
TormakSaber
 
PostPosted: Wed, Jun 23 2010, 21:09 PM 

User avatar

Player

Joined: 16 Dec 2004
Location: Somewhere

blackvswhite wrote:
Can we get a cantrip put it that nullifies dev crit and GS as well, just for balance purposes?


38 fort will make you functionally immune to Dev except on bad luck. Decent AC WILL make you immune to Dev, even WITH bad luck.

GS: Dispel, reality potions, AoE effects

Don't start the argument that you've lost before it began.

_________________
Davion Telemos - Monk of the Four Winds
Korthan Isharnos - Dragon Shaman of Thunder Spirit Zamasham


 
      
Weylyn_SotW
 
PostPosted: Wed, Jun 23 2010, 21:13 PM 

User avatar

Player

Joined: 30 Mar 2010
Location: The Netherlands

blackvswhite wrote:
a cantrip

TormakSaber wrote:
38 fort


Which base class did you take that gave you 38 fort at 1st level?

The point was that the counters are on entirely different orders of magnitude. No other ability in the game is so easily castrated as HipS, and that's for characters that more often than not have little else going for them.

_________________
Shynt'iira, Ilharess d'lil Qu'ellar My'ana


 
      
Glyph
 
PostPosted: Wed, Jun 23 2010, 21:14 PM 

User avatar

Player

Joined: 10 Jun 2010

ok, then I shall remember the screenshot button and heck, you can dispell light with darkness, no? use darkness! like I said originally, RP and don't cheat just because you can.

If i end up fighting someone shadow jumping in daylight on plains after all this, I will demand they lose XP.

*chills and watches family guy, is assuming light DOES stop hips, deal with it.*

if its only avaliable to blackguard get potions or something, im using a trout as a club, improvise!

RP wise, im getting a little sick of the excuses here, if you are light up like a christmas tree, how do you expect to HIDE IN PLAIN SIGHT, cantrip or no.

ed: maybe let shadowdancers use those assassin smoke bomb things or something, I don't see why not its a logical use of items.


 
      
Moonangel
 
PostPosted: Wed, Jun 23 2010, 21:17 PM 

User avatar

Player

Joined: 28 Nov 2009

The sensible thing would be to just forget about this unclear unofficial ruling which is impossible to enforce and a pain to keep track of in pvp and go with WYSIWYG... light gives a -10 penalty to hide and doesn't block anything. GS had a page long rule about how to threat it which was removed for the same reason, that it kept being discussed and argued once a month.


 
      
TormakSaber
 
PostPosted: Wed, Jun 23 2010, 21:20 PM 

User avatar

Player

Joined: 16 Dec 2004
Location: Somewhere

Weylyn_SotW wrote:
blackvswhite wrote:
a cantrip

TormakSaber wrote:
38 fort


Which base class did you take that gave you 38 fort at 1st level?

The point was that the counters are on entirely different orders of magnitude. No other ability in the game is so easily castrated as HipS, and that's for characters that more often than not have little else going for them.


Don't get hit.

Those four years of an SD I mentioned? For 2 of them he was an Assassin. I didn't get Lit once. Because I knew how to play my character. If you're going to be an SD, learn to not get hit with Light. IT's as simple as that.

You have no grounds to complain. HIPS is one of the single most powerful abilities in the entire game bar none. Light counters it. This is how it is and how Shadowdancer has worked since its inception. To change it means the class is no longer a Shadowdancer. It's not really up for argument, on the PnP side or the NWN side. If Lit: No HIPS.

Quote:
If i end up fighting someone shadow jumping in daylight on plains after all this, I will demand they lose XP.


This is the wrong way to go about it too. The more correct method would be to yes, screenshot and if possible alert a DM, if the problem is extremely grievous. But not after first making an attempt to politely and amicably speak to the other player first and see if they just didn't understand.

Quote:
The sensible thing would be to just forget about this unclear unofficial ruling which is impossible to enforce and a pain to keep track of in pvp and go with WYSIWYG... light gives a -10 penalty to hide and doesn't block anything. GS had a page long rule about how to threat it which was removed for the same reason, that it kept being discussed and argued once a month.


No, Valas. And that is the exten of which I will carry out yet another conversation with a banned player with an obsession.

Light blocks HIPS, and Light doesn't use SR. there's your ruling and the topic's pretty much done, as far as everything's concerned. Every question was answered and the debate won't change anything, since the shadow and light game is a fundamental part of te shadowdancer class.

_________________
Davion Telemos - Monk of the Four Winds
Korthan Isharnos - Dragon Shaman of Thunder Spirit Zamasham


 
      
Dark Immolation
 
PostPosted: Wed, Jun 23 2010, 21:21 PM 

User avatar

Developer

Joined: 20 Apr 2008
Location: The downeaster "Alexa"

Is there anything being looked into that will check if an SD has a light effect on before allowing them to HiPS? Haven't heard anything on the "fix" front in a while now.

It's just seriously frustrating seeing these same sentiments on HiPS use over and over again. I've said before, I've had several SD's, some even that I've partied with say, "If there's nothing mechanically preventing me from HiPSing, then I'm going to do it anyway." The Light-HiPS rule is a rule as any other. Follow it. It shouldn't be that hard to understand. But if it's insisted upon by people disregarding this rule, we should find a way to implement it mechanically, or some other remedy. Otherwise, and I respect and thank the SD's that I've found to follow it, but we may as well not have the rule if we're not going to enforce it.

Quote:
The point was that the counters are on entirely different orders of magnitude. No other ability in the game is so easily castrated as HipS, and that's for characters that more often than not have little else going for them.


Yeah, but again, you're talking like there isn't a counter out there. It's been said numerous times in this thread that Darkness, just plain old darkness, overrides Light. As in, if you're in the actual AoE of Darkness, HiPS to your heart's content. But for gods sake when you're in the middle of the desert, at noon, and someone casts light on you and you do not have Darkness, honor it.


 
      
TormakSaber
 
PostPosted: Wed, Jun 23 2010, 21:25 PM 

User avatar

Player

Joined: 16 Dec 2004
Location: Somewhere

Quote:
I've said before, I've had several SD's, some even that I've partied with say, "If there's nothing mechanically preventing me from HiPSing, then I'm going to do it anyway."


The rule is enforced, but it's hard for a DM to handle breaches that we are not made aware of. If you see this, you need to tell us.

Quote:
It's just seriously frustrating seeing these same sentiments on HiPS use over and over again.


This is every NWN server ever. They all hate HIPS because it is 100% absolutely broken, and that's why it's always discussed.

_________________
Davion Telemos - Monk of the Four Winds
Korthan Isharnos - Dragon Shaman of Thunder Spirit Zamasham


 
      
Jyro X
 
PostPosted: Wed, Jun 23 2010, 21:28 PM 

User avatar

Player

Joined: 04 Dec 2009
Location: North Carolina (EST/GMT -5)

It's still considered a touch attack and the person casting it should have enough maturity to roll a touch attack if they expect the SD to honor that rule.

_________________
Image
Image


 
      
Glyph
 
PostPosted: Wed, Jun 23 2010, 21:31 PM 

User avatar

Player

Joined: 10 Jun 2010

...k, if someone is shadowjumping around me in daylight on plains I will tell them to quit it THEN demand xp be docked if they refuse to stop. better?

@valas, what you are saying is exactly what I mean. you can't hide if you are emitting light, it is physically impossible to hide near someone while emitting light. I don't care if your hide stat has a -10 penalty or not you are emmiting light!

ed: I just had a very good idea though to be fair, why not hide near another light source, like splinter cell where you walk through the searchlights to avoid the guys with FLIR goggles :) i'd buy that if you RP it


 
      
TormakSaber
 
PostPosted: Wed, Jun 23 2010, 21:33 PM 

User avatar

Player

Joined: 16 Dec 2004
Location: Somewhere

Two wrongs don't make a right. If you get hit, don't HIPS. don't drag it into a "you need to give to me before you recieve" because both sides will do it all the time and no one gets anywhere. Start by doing it yourself first.

Besides, you are a PvP vet, Mr. Jyro. You know the odds of getting said roll off in combat or any hostile situation are about zero. Take what you get, and dont get hit, or if you do, learn to cornersneak, because there are non SD cornersneaks out there that do their job better than an SD, and if they're lit?

They can still hide. And so can you, if you learn the lost, forbidden art of Cornersneak.

Quote:
...k, if someone is shadowjumping around me in daylight on plains I will tell them to quit it THEN demand xp be docked if they refuse to stop. better?


No... you will tell them the rule... politely... explain it... and if you two can't resolve it, then you get a DM. And I suggest not going into it with any demands towards the player or the DM. I notice this sort of attitude a lot in all your posts and I figure it's best to wean you off it now when you're a new player before you get some very rude awakenings later on down the line. You need to chill out and relax. Don't be so confrontational and don't be so ready to point the gun at others and demand the DMs punish them for every slight. It won't get you a good reputation, neither with players, nor DMs.

_________________
Davion Telemos - Monk of the Four Winds
Korthan Isharnos - Dragon Shaman of Thunder Spirit Zamasham


 
      
Display posts from previous:  Sort by  
Forum locked This topic is locked, you cannot edit posts or make further replies.  [ 53 posts ]  Go to page 1, 2  Next


Who is online

Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 5 guests


You cannot post new topics in this forum
You cannot reply to topics in this forum
You cannot edit your posts in this forum
You cannot delete your posts in this forum

Search for:
Jump to:  
Powered by phpBB © 2000, 2002, 2005, 2007 phpBB Group