|
|
|
TormakSaber
|
Posted: Fri, Feb 19 2010, 0:33 AM |
|
|

Player
Joined: 16 Dec 2004 Location: Somewhere
|
|
It has literally been over 5 years.
Robert has long since changed Leggomi's name to Leggomi Indrire. Long since. Before I as a DM, even. (and ergo before Robert was a DM: We were made DMs simultaneously along with Alchas, who is no longer a DM.) Among others: Infernal Pain and AlanaMolov were not DMs at the time either.
I'll be offended in his stead that you're actually making an issue of this. Genuinely offended that you would even bring it up again without looking at post dates.
_________________ Davion Telemos - Monk of the Four Winds Korthan Isharnos - Dragon Shaman of Thunder Spirit Zamasham
|
|
|
|
 |
|
Selvec Darkon
|
Posted: Fri, Feb 19 2010, 2:34 AM |
|
|

Player
Joined: 12 Oct 2005 Location: On a Disk, carried by four elephants, which stand on a gigantic turtle.
|
|
I feel it comes down to what you consider a title, and what you consider a nickname. As according to Amia rules, you cannot give yourself a title/honourific, such as "Azarack, Lord of Cordor" or "Devlin of Winya", but you can have nicknames, such as "John "Bones" Fiddlesticks". The format on how the nickname is delivered can cause people to view it as a title/honourific. Example "John The Mighty", which could seem like an honourific, one the character hasn't earned.
_________________ I keels u with my axe!
"Do ye know where the Holy-Flamin' Frost-brand Gronk-slayin' Vorpal Hammer o' woundin' an' returnin' an' Shootin'-Lightnin'-out-yer-bum is?"
|
|
|
|
 |
|
Geld Yaztran
|
Posted: Fri, Feb 19 2010, 7:06 AM |
|
|

Player
Joined: 05 Jul 2006
|
|
Sorry Tor, just stating the facts..though it is good then that it has been changed.
But honestly the whole name thing is kind of tough. The reason I saw it as an issue...even if it was in the past, is because, regardless of the amount of time since it's posting, it still reeked of a sort of blind eyed favourtism. And this leads to my point:
Who determines when someone SHOULD be granted a title of sorts? One DM? The Head DM? Any DM? Who?
So what it all boils down to is:
Who grants these titles? Who decides who deserves them? And what happens when one DM grants/permits a name that another DM doesn't? And are there even any standards as to what would cause someone to gain a title?
Honestly, outside of OOC names like Ty2567, most names, including Jack King of Cordor should be allowed.
There have been many people in books, and life in general, who have given or gone by titles such as king and lord. And sometimes, they don't even fit the person.
Hell, there's a probably a homeless bum out there right now who everyone calls "The King of Central Park", though he is hardly a real king.
Torm, try not to pop a blood vessel over something that is not worth getting heated about...such as this topic.
|
|
|
|
 |
|
Nekhy
|
Posted: Fri, Feb 19 2010, 9:01 AM |
|
|

Player
|
There obviously isn't a single answer to anything regarding names, and one approach doesn't fit all situations. We go by what the majority of the staff thinks.
Selvec Darkon wrote: I feel it comes down to what you consider a title, and what you consider a nickname. As according to Amia rules, you cannot give yourself a title/honourific, such as "Azarack, Lord of Cordor" or "Devlin of Winya", but you can have nicknames, such as "John "Bones" Fiddlesticks". The format on how the nickname is delivered can cause people to view it as a title/honourific. Example "John The Mighty", which could seem like an honourific, one the character hasn't earned.
But this has a lot to do with it. People tend to think what they see is what they get. If they see a dude named King of Cordor, many people will automatically go for it, even if they think it's stupid. That's because we all metagame little things all the time, and above all we metagame names. And it affects the RP, whether we want it or not.
So, it's less hassle for everyone to have some rules with the names.
|
|
|
|
 |
|
Dev Disco
|
Posted: Fri, Feb 19 2010, 9:18 AM |
|
|

HRM Chicken I of Amia
Joined: 02 Jun 2005 Location: Amsterdam
|
IronAngel wrote: Haam Untheric (the only guy around who's from Unther) Beardless Igor (a Rashemi berserker known for his distinct lack of facial hair) Restless Stream (a lively Water Genasi who never knew her parents and therefore had no real name) Banshee-Ellie (a bard known for his terrifying Curse Song) Garn the Grim (an old Tyrran veteran who never speaks about his past and is never known to smile) Joon of the Binder (a priest of Oghma, duh) Willard of Arabel (a Purple Dragon dispatched to Amia from Arabel, Cormyr) Fox-at-Twilight (actually a canon NPC moon elf)
I doubt any of those would be a problem, so I don't see what we're discussing anyway. They are allowed by the rules as well.
_________________ Say 'no' to JSBF!
|
|
|
|
 |
|
IronAngel
|
Posted: Fri, Feb 19 2010, 9:47 AM |
|
|

Player
Joined: 29 Sep 2005 Location: Helsinki, Finland
|
|
Um, which was exactly my original point: that there are plenty of cooler options than First Name Last Name, and that the rules allow it. I was ordered to "stop espousing" it, though, so I assume at least someone has a problem with it.
_________________ On Joon, Kjetta wrote: The guy that probably has sexual fantasies about masturbation. I mean, Iron, you're a bookworm nerd that even in your wildest escapism fantasies flee to the internet to play the role of another bookworm nerd? Come on!
|
|
|
|
 |
|
Dev Disco
|
Posted: Fri, Feb 19 2010, 10:01 AM |
|
|

HRM Chicken I of Amia
Joined: 02 Jun 2005 Location: Amsterdam
|
|
I bet it has to do with you writing prose as dense as a black hole.
_________________ Say 'no' to JSBF!
|
|
|
|
 |
|
O'Raghailligh
|
Posted: Fri, Feb 19 2010, 12:16 PM |
|
|

Player
Joined: 04 Jan 2009 Location: NZ
|
Dev Disco wrote: IronAngel wrote: Haam Untheric (the only guy around who's from Unther) Beardless Igor (a Rashemi berserker known for his distinct lack of facial hair) Restless Stream (a lively Water Genasi who never knew her parents and therefore had no real name) Banshee-Ellie (a bard known for his terrifying Curse Song) Garn the Grim (an old Tyrran veteran who never speaks about his past and is never known to smile) Joon of the Binder (a priest of Oghma, duh) Willard of Arabel (a Purple Dragon dispatched to Amia from Arabel, Cormyr) Fox-at-Twilight (actually a canon NPC moon elf)
I doubt any of those would be a problem, so I don't see what we're discussing anyway. They are allowed by the rules as well.
I gotta say ,this quote does actually seem to be exactly what IronAngel has been going on about, and I must say that i disagree with it wholeheartedly. Nicknames should be left to the IC aspect of playing. Especially when they are pumped full of cheese like many of the examples that have been just listed.
|
|
|
|
 |
|
O'Raghailligh
|
Posted: Fri, Feb 19 2010, 12:19 PM |
|
|

Player
Joined: 04 Jan 2009 Location: NZ
|
|
Superman of Krypton.
Ironman of Ironhold
GreenGoblin of (insert goblin faction name here)
|
|
|
|
 |
|
Dev Disco
|
Posted: Fri, Feb 19 2010, 12:29 PM |
|
|

HRM Chicken I of Amia
Joined: 02 Jun 2005 Location: Amsterdam
|
|
Well, you can try to make a rule that explicitly lists what is common sense, but you can also look at the number of people using those names. Which, I think, is about zero if not completely zero.
As I have said a few times before: most problems exist in people's head.
_________________ Say 'no' to JSBF!
|
|
|
|
 |
|
IronAngel
|
Posted: Fri, Feb 19 2010, 12:30 PM |
|
|

Player
Joined: 29 Sep 2005 Location: Helsinki, Finland
|
O'Rag: Yes, but how do you make the distinction between a "real name" and a "nickname"?
You have to remember that this is what characters may have been called all their lives. There are no official IDs in the Realms. You rarely get a last name, and unless it's a big deal, you rarely use it even if you get one. The Revised Forgotten Realms Campaign Setting itself states that most people are known by a first name and either their home location, their patron deity or their profession. Pete the Blacksmith, John of Tyr and Bob of Beregost are the norm in the world we play. For many characters, their name is what they've always been called.
The distinction is therefore pedantic and OOC, not IC: we may know that my PC was born into the Dewitt family and named Elliot at birth, but no PC in game knows it and Banshee-Ellie has been called that for as long as he remembers. So typing "Elliot Dewitt" over his name would be artificial and inspire metagaming.
Or Restless Stream: a freak Genasi child abandoned at birth never got a name. Someone compared her to a restless stream, and the name stuck. She adopted it, because it was comforting to have some name. She simply has nothing else. It would be completely unjustified and pointless to make up an OOC name for the sake of server rules, if that name has absolutely no relevance to the PC.
Your examples are completely different. They're not names, and furthermore, they're lame. That's the key difference: you say my examples are cheesy, but they're far from it. They're awesome, and if you disagree you're wrong.  Or more seriously, the judgement of that should be up to the DMs but you should follow your own gut instinct until they tell you otherwise. And even then, you should defend your choice. If you can't defend it, it obviously wasn't a very good choice to begin with.
It all boils down to good taste, nothing else.
_________________ On Joon, Kjetta wrote: The guy that probably has sexual fantasies about masturbation. I mean, Iron, you're a bookworm nerd that even in your wildest escapism fantasies flee to the internet to play the role of another bookworm nerd? Come on!
|
|
|
|
 |
|
TormakSaber
|
Posted: Fri, Feb 19 2010, 15:05 PM |
|
|

Player
Joined: 16 Dec 2004 Location: Somewhere
|
Geld Yaztran wrote: Sorry Tor, just stating the facts..though it is good then that it has been changed.
But honestly the whole name thing is kind of tough. The reason I saw it as an issue...even if it was in the past, is because, regardless of the amount of time since it's posting, it still reeked of a sort of blind eyed favourtism. And this leads to my point:
Who determines when someone SHOULD be granted a title of sorts? One DM? The Head DM? Any DM? Who?
So what it all boils down to is:
Who grants these titles? Who decides who deserves them? And what happens when one DM grants/permits a name that another DM doesn't? And are there even any standards as to what would cause someone to gain a title?
Honestly, outside of OOC names like Ty2567, most names, including Jack King of Cordor should be allowed.
There have been many people in books, and life in general, who have given or gone by titles such as king and lord. And sometimes, they don't even fit the person.
Hell, there's a probably a homeless bum out there right now who everyone calls "The King of Central Park", though he is hardly a real king.
Torm, try not to pop a blood vessel over something that is not worth getting heated about...such as this topic.
No, don't you EVEN bring up that titles arguement again. That was seven pages of people doing nothing but complaining about Avadon over and over and i dare to bet he didn't feel very good about it. I'm stopping this one right now. Drop it Gled. Period.
_________________ Davion Telemos - Monk of the Four Winds Korthan Isharnos - Dragon Shaman of Thunder Spirit Zamasham
|
|
|
|
 |
|
ainjyll
|
Posted: Fri, Feb 19 2010, 17:15 PM |
|
|

Player
Joined: 14 Jun 2006 Location: wilmington, nc
|
|
Titles themselves should be left in the hands of DM's to give out or approve. However, where do people think last names came from anyways? They're bastardizations of exactly what Iron is talking about. In America, Johnson is a pretty common last name. Johnson or John's son.
_________________  "I once took the high road and it took me straight to hell and I stood there all by myself." -Hank III
|
|
|
|
 |
|
Xaviera
|
Posted: Fri, Feb 19 2010, 20:47 PM |
|
|

Player
Joined: 07 Aug 2006 Location: Temple of Love
|
ainjyll wrote: However, where do people think last names came from anyways? They're bastardizations of exactly what Iron is talking about. In America, Johnson is a pretty common last name. Johnson or John's son.
Or job names: Smith, Faber, Cooper, Mason, Baker, Hunter, Wright, Miller...
_________________ ~Sharess on AmiaWiki~Priestess, politician, prostitute "[They] were moving in on me like Sharessans on a new broad in the bath house" - Tracer BoltAmiaWiki mod (mostly inactive)
|
|
|
|
 |
|
ainjyll
|
Posted: Fri, Feb 19 2010, 21:27 PM |
|
|

Player
Joined: 14 Jun 2006 Location: wilmington, nc
|
Xaviera wrote: ainjyll wrote: However, where do people think last names came from anyways? They're bastardizations of exactly what Iron is talking about. In America, Johnson is a pretty common last name. Johnson or John's son. Or job names: Smith, Faber, Cooper, Mason, Baker, Hunter, Wright, Miller...
Exactly.
_________________  "I once took the high road and it took me straight to hell and I stood there all by myself." -Hank III
|
|
|
|
 |
|
Geld Yaztran
|
Posted: Sat, Feb 20 2010, 14:33 PM |
|
|

Player
Joined: 05 Jul 2006
|
|
Actually Torm, I am arguing that Avadon of Wiltun is a completely justifiable name. He is from and protects Wiltun.
I am not arguing whether he did enough to get the title. That is the point. To me, he deserves it based on principle alone. He is from Wiltun.
But what about something like The Raven King. Maybe he has a bunch of birds around him or something. Something not implausible in amia or dnd.
To me the ones that are problems are ones that break the fourth wall. References to people/places on Earth in Amia cheapens the experience.
And Tormy, when I asked who decides who gets what, I meant, have you dms ever gotten into disagreements about a name?
|
|
|
|
 |
|
IronAngel
|
Posted: Sat, Feb 20 2010, 15:39 PM |
|
|

Player
Joined: 29 Sep 2005 Location: Helsinki, Finland
|
Geld Yaztran wrote: And Tormy, when I asked who decides who gets what, I meant, have you dms ever gotten into disagreements about a name?
Often, but it's rarely a big issue because the player is happy to change it to something suitable and won't appeal the case (which is always an option).
All in all, I don't think there's ever been much fighting over common sense when it comes to names. Between DMs, or DMs and players. If you really think the decision was unjustified, you can appeal to the team and make a strong case which they'll then have to discuss and vote on. After that, though, there's not much to do but huff and puff.
_________________ On Joon, Kjetta wrote: The guy that probably has sexual fantasies about masturbation. I mean, Iron, you're a bookworm nerd that even in your wildest escapism fantasies flee to the internet to play the role of another bookworm nerd? Come on!
|
|
|
|
 |
Who is online |
Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 11 guests |
|
You cannot post new topics in this forum You cannot reply to topics in this forum You cannot edit your posts in this forum You cannot delete your posts in this forum
|
|