View unanswered posts | View active topics * FAQ    * Search
* Login 




Forum locked This topic is locked, you cannot edit posts or make further replies.  [ 165 posts ]  Go to page Previous  1, 2, 3, 4  Next
TormakSaber
 
PostPosted: Wed, Nov 18 2009, 7:57 AM 

User avatar

Player

Joined: 16 Dec 2004
Location: Somewhere

I highly doubt the god personally falls each paladin. Too busy. I imagine that there's this codex governing the divine energy. You break it, boom.

Anyways, there was no forcing. "Kill this little girl." You don't HAVE to. If you don't, the village burns. Because the Paladin does not know the true nature of the little girl, the evil he commits is evil in his heart: He intends to wholesale murder this innocent child. No matter what it was for. He did it. If it was a real little girl, she'd have died, and he'd have fallen as well.

And if he does nothing and lets the village burn, then he falls for negligence. For doing nothing when he could have done something, he loses the power to Make A Difference. Use it or lose it.

FYI: This is still a dumb topic.

_________________
Davion Telemos - Monk of the Four Winds
Korthan Isharnos - Dragon Shaman of Thunder Spirit Zamasham


 
      
Yurell
 
PostPosted: Wed, Nov 18 2009, 7:59 AM 

User avatar

Player

Joined: 06 Jan 2008
Location: ANU, behind the coffee mug (+10 GMT)

TormakSaber wrote:
I highly doubt the god personally falls each paladin. Too busy. I imagine that there's this codex governing the divine energy. You break it, boom.


If the Fall cares only about moral absolutes in that fashion, regardless of circumstance, then it should also care that it's not a little girl and is in fact a lich.

_________________
2009's Second Most Overall Contributing Player

يمكنني استخدام مترجم جوجل


 
      
TormakSaber
 
PostPosted: Wed, Nov 18 2009, 8:14 AM 

User avatar

Player

Joined: 16 Dec 2004
Location: Somewhere

Never said it didn't care abut cirucmstance. In the end every situation and every god is different etc etc

_________________
Davion Telemos - Monk of the Four Winds
Korthan Isharnos - Dragon Shaman of Thunder Spirit Zamasham


 
      
IronAngel
 
PostPosted: Wed, Nov 18 2009, 15:37 PM 

User avatar

Player

Joined: 29 Sep 2005
Location: Helsinki, Finland

I somewhat agree with Tormak, by the way: the paladin will have failed, no matter what he chooses, and must atone. However, that doesn't answer the question: which should he choose? Should he commit the greater evil for the greater good, or refrain from committing evil and thus indirectly cause more evil. Yurell does have a point, though: you are not morally responsible for actions that are not in your power to affect. If we forget all the "exceptions" and "third options," and simply assume the paladin must either choose action or inaction: he is not a free moral agent. If you are incapable of doing the right thing, you cannot be held responsible for doing the wrong thing.

But then, you might assume the paladin shouldn't have been caught in the first place, and thus is responsible. My take on it is this, however: his shame and guilt self-imposes a Fall. He cannot continue to be a paladin without atonement, because he knows he has done wrong. In this case, the deity does not make him Falll; he does. And on the other hand, if he reasons that he had no choice, and that all is fine and dandy: he will not show the required compassion and sacrifice expected of a paladin, and the deity may Fall him.

But whether he Falls or not is irrelevant. Knowing full well, or suspecting, that he will Fall regardless, the paladin still has to make the right decision.

_________________
On Joon, Kjetta wrote:
The guy that probably has sexual fantasies about masturbation. I mean, Iron, you're a bookworm nerd that even in your wildest escapism fantasies flee to the internet to play the role of another bookworm nerd? Come on!


 
      
DolphinRacer
 
PostPosted: Wed, Nov 18 2009, 15:51 PM 

User avatar

Player

Joined: 01 May 2009
Location: GMT-8 Bangor, Washington

[quote="Mr Mago"You'll have to think of other ways than just using your sword, if you want to spread good on Amia.[/quote]


Pfft, if you want to try to spread good and righteousness without always using a sword, make a cleric.

I'm used to playing on servers with really strict rules governing paladin behavior and where it was really easy to fall. Example I spent months working at RP to have my character become a paladin of his patroness, and finally earned it. Two months later I fell because I traded away my characters weapon (a custom job yes but one that he had most of his adult life RPwise) for a slightly better one. However my character didn't realize that the weapon he had was divine in origin, namely from his own patroness. It was enough to cost him his status as a paladin for a month until he could prove himself.

The point of this being that in my opinion Paladin is not just a class (nor is Monk for that matter) but a way of life. It's a mindset and behavior that is molded almost completely by the religion of the individual in question and a dedication and devotion that in some cases goes far beyond the boundaries of reason in its execution. I don't mean to imply that I think all Paladins are complete idiots about their religion, but they all are, or at least should be, zealots of one degree or another for their faith. As someone who comes from servers where multi-classing with Paladin and Monk was for the most part forbidden to reflect these classes as a way of life and not just a profession, I can be very picky about the way people play those two classes. Granted I usually won't confront people about it, but I am always annoyed by characters with monk levels that don't actually RP and command of ki or self-discipline. One person tried to explain this as their character was too mentally insecure and unstable to actually be a monk, but that doesn't seem like a valid excuse, if you consider that if you are that mentally unstable you probably lack the self-discipline to learn to use the abilities that monks have. Similar problems arise with Paladins now and then. I see paladins that are interacting with beings that are anathema to their religion as if they were friends. Paladins simply don't do that in my book. Not saying they'd immediately chop their head off, but paladins should have utter conviction about their beliefs and would as a result not make friends with creatures or members of faith that their religion opposes. You have no idea how badly stuff like that bothers me.

Another thing that bothers me a little is that, in Paladins I've seen at least, there is often too much cooperation between different religions paladins. Just because you are a force for good, doesn't mean you're always going to agree with this other guy who is a force for good under a different deity. Doesn't mean you're going to try to smite the guy, but I can see preaching matches and religious arguments as a real (and really amusing) possibility.


If you're playing a paladin and going for the standard one, this would be my checklist:

Arrogant
Commanding
Utterly Devoted to their Faith
Zealous in execution of superiors orders
Zealous in prosecution of evil
Zealous in prosecution/disdain for other religions
Stubborn about compromising with anyone that disagrees with them
Really really good at smacking evil things
Forceful in personality (not necessarily in a good way)

_________________
Sir Taelar Ardelyn of Wiltun
Winner of the Razor Tongued Award 2015!


Kira "Penny" Sigers
Better than Boulderdash!


 
      
IronAngel
 
PostPosted: Wed, Nov 18 2009, 16:44 PM 

User avatar

Player

Joined: 29 Sep 2005
Location: Helsinki, Finland

Truth be told, I personally find that a boring, uninspired and inaccurate depiction of a paladin. The way you describe your Fall, it does not seem that the standards of paladins on your server were higher or better. Quite the opposite: they were poor, false, misguided.

People seem to have this gut reaction that "Strict, absolute, singleminded = Quality standards, serious RP." That's just not true. I think we should strive for honestly, well-developed opinions and critical thought in trying to find the most accurate and best RP standards, rather than let our natural knack for elitism and fundamentalism blind us. Amia does not avoid multiclass restrictions or alignment rules for races because our standards are somehow lower or looser than other servers'. No, we don't have them because we think they're inaccurate, arbitrary and unhelpful to RP.

My ideal paladin would be:

Humble.
Ever-searching, ever-doubting, ever-discovering, and as a result, balanced and strong in their faith.
Wise and able to look at things from different perspectives, yet firm in what they believe to be right.
Gentle and merciful, dealing justice where it is due but taking no pleasure in cruelty.
Respectful to their enemies.
Fearless in face of necessity, but never compromising the greater good or throwing their life away out of pride or a foolish notion of heroism.

I've always had the idea that paladins are as good and virtuous as people come. And to me, that means they trek the golden mean. They are neither inflexible nor whimsical, spiteful nor afraid of confrontation, foolhardy nor cowardly, hermits nor dandies. I think Aristotle pretty much nailed it, and I don't see why paladins would have their own standards - they're measured by the same virtues as everyone else is, they're only held to a higher measure of that standard. The general opinion that paladins should be irrational and fanatic in their faith, uncompromising to the point of foolishness, anti-social and arrogant jerks with poles up their asses - it makes no sense. Paladins are the examplary paragons of what is good and right; the above-mentioned traits certainly don't set a good example. Hence: they cannot define the ideal paladin, for me. But they're also possible, since not all paladins are perfect, and not all people have the same idea.

_________________
On Joon, Kjetta wrote:
The guy that probably has sexual fantasies about masturbation. I mean, Iron, you're a bookworm nerd that even in your wildest escapism fantasies flee to the internet to play the role of another bookworm nerd? Come on!


 
      
Goblin
 
PostPosted: Wed, Nov 18 2009, 16:51 PM 

User avatar

Player

Joined: 02 Sep 2008
Location: Scotland

Eh, I'd more or less put all of that in Iron, as the ~journey to becoming~ a Paladin.

Quote:
Ever-searching, ever-doubting, ever-discovering, and as a result, balanced and strong in their faith.


To me that says Champion of Torm (or other deity) more than true Paladin. The post before you hit the nail on the head, whether it's boring or not - it's the qualities of a Paladin. If you can't adhere, play a Fighter with a strong faith, because you're not a Paladin. :roll:

_________________
"O God of Earth and Altar,
Bow down and hear our cry,
Our earthly rulers falter,
Our people drift and die,
The walls of gold entomb us,
The swords of scorn divide,
Take not thy thunder from us,
But take away our pride."


 
      
IronAngel
 
PostPosted: Wed, Nov 18 2009, 16:58 PM 

User avatar

Player

Joined: 29 Sep 2005
Location: Helsinki, Finland

Says you. With nothing but your personal intuition to back it up.

But I have my personal intuition too, and I'm clearly as convinced as you. I have been able to rationally explain and defend it for several pages. Why is your intuition better or more accurate? Because you've played paladins? Well, so have I, and I've spent the last four years of my life studying ethics, first in high school and now in university. When I don't do that, I'm reading about the Forgotten Realms. Your personal authority is no higher than mine; so what is it, in your argument, that makes it better than mine?

The idea that you would make any distinction between the faith of a paladin, a divine champion and a cleric makes no sense to me. Obviously, every paladin, cleric and divine champion has a unique personal faith that no one else can share; in that sense, they're different. But there's no reason to assume, no rational evidence, that paladins in general believe in their god differently than divine champions or clerics.

Moreover, being a paladin is no static quality. You don't take a road to become a paladin, and then be one. You're always on that road, you're never ready, you can never be content with what you've achieved. As Nietszche put it: "Man is something to be overcome." You are never the Übermensch. You are always on your way, pointing to Him.

Mind you, I'm not saying that your idea cannot also be correct: there's no reason to believe a paladin could not be as you describe. But that does not mean that it's not also possible that other ideas are viable. That's why my argument is stronger, I believe: I accept pluralism and several viable concepts, within a set of basic rules. You try to narrow it down to one right idea, but the general concept of the class just isn't as narrowly defined. Just because you don't like something or think it's the best option, doesn't mean it's not possible.

_________________
On Joon, Kjetta wrote:
The guy that probably has sexual fantasies about masturbation. I mean, Iron, you're a bookworm nerd that even in your wildest escapism fantasies flee to the internet to play the role of another bookworm nerd? Come on!


 
      
Dark Immolation
 
PostPosted: Wed, Nov 18 2009, 17:03 PM 

User avatar

Developer

Joined: 20 Apr 2008
Location: The downeaster "Alexa"

IronAngel wrote:
But then, you might assume the paladin shouldn't have been caught in the first place, and thus is responsible. My take on it is this, however: his shame and guilt self-imposes a Fall. He cannot continue to be a paladin without atonement, because he knows he has done wrong. In this case, the deity does not make him Falll; he does. And on the other hand, if he reasons that he had no choice, and that all is fine and dandy: he will not show the required compassion and sacrifice expected of a paladin, and the deity may Fall him.

But whether he Falls or not is irrelevant. Knowing full well, or suspecting, that he will Fall regardless, the paladin still has to make the right decision.


Have to agree with that. A partial reason for the Fall can be all within the paladin's state of mind. If the paladin freaks out and starts doubting his faith for a while: possible fall. If the paladin commits an act of evil knowinging, thinking it's for the greater good, but later doubts and ask "was it worth it?": possible fall. Paladin does an act which he thinks is good, just plain good and right, but is actually against deity's will: you get the picutre.

At least that's how I interprited it. Clerics get their power and spells based off of prayer to the god, and pretty much agreeing to spread the spoken word of the clergy. Pretty much just a glorified worshipper. They come to truly believe in the god and have faith in it, but it's the prayer that gives them their power. Paladins' on the other hand get their powers from faith. Faith that what their god says is the pure and utter truth, faith that they can always do the right thing, pretty much working towards becoming perfect in the god's eyes, and believing it is fully in their ability to do so. If that faith is broken between the god and paladin, or within the paladin himself, he slips from that power. Maybe not horribly, but faith is the only thing that got him there in the first place.

That said, to finally give my reacation to the situation, assuming I could absolutely only choose those two options and disregarding the unknown reality, a typical paladin of Torm would most likely choose to kill the child, IMO. Expecting to be fell, yes, but Tormites are duty-bound, quite extensively. It would be a Tormite paladin's duty to prevent evil, and if the situation called for it, prevent a larger evil over a lesser. I imagine the mere allowance of an evil does infact constitute some amount of sin, no matter the circumstance, but it is still his duty to see to stopping the most evil. If he falls, so what. Duty to Torm first, whatever personal status you loose second.

Even if the child was real and the lich went on to kill the whole village of Warftown, at least the (ex)paladin could say he fufilled his duty of trying everything he could to prevent more evil. Evil was gaunranteed in the situation, whatever happens, some evil will be commited, by him or the lich. His only hope is to act to prevent the most of it. He'd most likely feel horrible about killing an innocent, and probably agree fully that he'd deserve to fall, even if Torm didn't, and fall himself mentally for killing the girl. No matter, he has the responsibility as a Tormite. And as a paladin, probably self-deprecate to the point where he'd say "It was my fault, I did get caught by the lich."

But again, that's just my take on the given situation and going with a "typical" paladin. By that I mean a strereotypical cookie-cutter paladin, not taking into account personal ethos, personality, mindset, wisdom, strength of faith, ideas, and what he ate for breakfeast that morning. So it pretty much means nothing to anyone, anywhere. There is no general "right and wrong" answer you can blanket, all situations are singularly unique. Like I said before, it doesn't matter what you choose, so long as you think about it as your character would. Even if you Fall, you're right on a RP basis.

If you ask me, never, ever, ever for one moment change what you beleive your character would honestly reason to do, just because you think that's what he's supposed to do it because of his class, or because you think it 's what DM's want to see. For it is in that moment you stop roleplaying and start reading the script from a fairy tale.


Last edited by Dark Immolation on Wed, Nov 18 2009, 17:08 PM, edited 1 time in total.

 
      
Nekhy
 
PostPosted: Wed, Nov 18 2009, 17:07 PM 



Player

IronAngel wrote:
Says you. With nothing but your personal intuition to back it up.


This is really the crux of the matter. There's not really a whole lot of canon material to describe the paladin's mentality, except for the few basic things such as being lawful and good and not willingly committing evil acts.

Those are the rules. The rest is opinion. No way around that little fact!

I doubt the knights of Charlemagne were quite so pious to be LG, so even historical (or mythological, if you prefer) sources don't get closer than imagination and opinions.


 
      
IronAngel
 
PostPosted: Wed, Nov 18 2009, 17:14 PM 

User avatar

Player

Joined: 29 Sep 2005
Location: Helsinki, Finland

Yep. It doesn't mean nothing can be said about the matter, though. Rather, it means we can present our own views and possible scenarios, and possibly analyze and critisize other opinions from our own position (spoken out loud). It can increase our understanding of different options, perhaps make us more convinced in our own interpretation, and it's just outright fun. (This is much better than actually playing a paladin in game!) But in the end, you can't prove another idea wrong as long as it stays within the broad rules that have been documented and accepted about paladins.

You can, however, point out that opinions which rule out all options but one are wrong, insofar as you can point out a single example that falls within the rules and differs from the suggested standard. What does that tell us? It's best to have a loose theory that can stand the test counter-examples, rather than a narrow one which crumbles at the first poke.


Also, this is a winner, as far as practical thoughts about RP go:
Dark Immolation wrote:
If you ask me, never, ever, ever for one moment change what you beleive your character would honestly reason to do, just because you think that's what he's supposed to do it because of his class, or because you think it 's what DM's want to see. For it is in that moment you stop roleplaying and start reading the script from a fairy tale.

_________________
On Joon, Kjetta wrote:
The guy that probably has sexual fantasies about masturbation. I mean, Iron, you're a bookworm nerd that even in your wildest escapism fantasies flee to the internet to play the role of another bookworm nerd? Come on!


 
      
Goblin
 
PostPosted: Wed, Nov 18 2009, 18:11 PM 

User avatar

Player

Joined: 02 Sep 2008
Location: Scotland

~not even going to continue~

_________________
"O God of Earth and Altar,
Bow down and hear our cry,
Our earthly rulers falter,
Our people drift and die,
The walls of gold entomb us,
The swords of scorn divide,
Take not thy thunder from us,
But take away our pride."


 
      
Cori
 
PostPosted: Wed, Nov 18 2009, 18:11 PM 

User avatar

Player

Joined: 10 Aug 2005
Location: Ottawa, Ontario, Canada

Yesyes! The part Iron just quoted by Dark Immolation is without question ~THE~ single most relevant thing said about paladin RP, and RP in general, that I've read in this entire thread.

As a side note - notice I gave NO choices in my scenario. I just asked "What do you do" - classic GM/DM modus operandi. Everyone chose to eitehr do nothing, or kill the "child". Granted, it's a bit tough in a forum discussion like this for someone to try other options, like asking questions, or such, because this isn't a text-based rp forum. In game, or even if we were in a PnP game, presumably you'd act a bit different since it'd be a live scenario, and I'd expect people would ask questions.

Regardless - there's still implied statements that falling is a failure, and it really is not. It's very likely one of the best opportunities for rp and character development, if treated with the respect it deserves. You get to atone, self-deprecate, question, and "find" your faith. Or utterly lose your faith, of course. Nothing says you'd have to remain a paladin after a fall. You could even decide that the paladin life isn't for you, or that you aren't worthy. You could go divine champion, and still serve your diety, or you could take the path of arrogance (IC arrogance) and decide your diety is an arse, and tyhat you are worthy, and if he won't have you, then you'll show him. You'll show them all! Classic turn to darkness, after all.

_________________
Role with the Punches...
Elan: A 10% chance is pretty unlikely, but everyone knows that a one-in-a-million chance is a sure thing!


 
      
Nekhy
 
PostPosted: Wed, Nov 18 2009, 18:31 PM 



Player

DolphinRacer wrote:
Another thing that bothers me a little is that, in Paladins I've seen at least, there is often too much cooperation between different religions paladins. Just because you are a force for good, doesn't mean you're always going to agree with this other guy who is a force for good under a different deity. Doesn't mean you're going to try to smite the guy, but I can see preaching matches and religious arguments as a real (and really amusing) possibility.


This is actually in direct opposition to what the 3E Player's Handbook says about the matter on page 43.

To quote, "All paladins, regardless of background, recognize in each other an eternal bond that transcends culture, race and even religion. Any two paladins, even from opposite sides of the world, consider themselves comrades."

Of course, this is slightly trickier in Forgotten Realms, but I don't recall any rule or piece of lore in FR canon material that would in fact counter this bit.

Had to point that out, because it reads to me you are basing your view of the paladin class on this mythical, "true archetype". Which doesn't exist, at least in the canon lore as far as I know.

KingCreeper wrote:
~not even going to continue~


Why not? What we've come down to is whether the zealot paladin character is the "true paladin" or not. "True paladin" supposedly meaning the canon archetype. All you have to do is point out where the archetype is said to be the true paladin in canon material, and you got yourself a strong case.

I guess else we'll settle for the canon lore lacking in defining a true paladin, and instead only giving a rough guideline on which every player and DM builds their version of a paladin.


 
      
bluntpencil2001
 
PostPosted: Wed, Nov 18 2009, 18:31 PM 

User avatar

Player

Joined: 12 Nov 2009
Location: Scotland

In my opinion, if a Paladin is given a choice between a great evil happening (a village being massacred) and committing a (arguably) lesser evil, such as killing a child, he should find a third option.

Paladins do not commit evil acts. Committing an evil act, of any real magnitude, will cause a Fall.

Paladins should not be committing lesser evils, they should be attempting to do no evil at all.

It's hard, maybe even impossible at times, but it's the effort that matters.

Unless you're a Hoarite Paladin, then you just smite the bastards. :P


 
      
Yurell
 
PostPosted: Wed, Nov 18 2009, 18:37 PM 

User avatar

Player

Joined: 06 Jan 2008
Location: ANU, behind the coffee mug (+10 GMT)

bluntpencil2001 wrote:
In my opinion, if a Paladin is given a choice between a great evil happening (a village being massacred) and committing a (arguably) lesser evil, such as killing a child, he should find a third option.

Paladins do not commit evil acts. Committing an evil act, of any real magnitude, will cause a Fall.

Paladins should not be committing lesser evils, they should be attempting to do no evil at all.

It's hard, maybe even impossible at times, but it's the effort that matters.

Unless you're a Hoarite Paladin, then you just smite the bastards. :P


Well, technically they didn't commit an evil by stabbing the girl, and if the thought going through his mind was "I must stop the lich from destroying the village" rather than "I must kill the girl" he didn't sin in thought, either.

_________________
2009's Second Most Overall Contributing Player

يمكنني استخدام مترجم جوجل


 
      
IronAngel
 
PostPosted: Wed, Nov 18 2009, 18:38 PM 

User avatar

Player

Joined: 29 Sep 2005
Location: Helsinki, Finland

Nekhy wrote:

Why not? What we've come down to is whether the zealot paladin character is the "true paladin" or not. "True paladin" supposedly meaning the canon archetype. All you have to do is point out where the archetype is said to be the true paladin in canon material, and you got yourself a strong case.

I guess else we'll settle for the canon lore lacking in defining a true paladin, and instead only giving a rough guideline on which every player and DM builds their version of a paladin.


I guess it's more complicated than that, if he wants to stick to the exaxct position he's held so far: even if there is a "true paladin" archetype, a typical paladin that represents the majority of paladins, and even if it is what KingCreeper makes it out to be: that still does not prove it is the only possibility. He still has to prove that a paladin must be a "true paladin" in order to be a paladin at all.

Why I find the claim so useless is that it's practically impossible prove. Unless there is primary canon material that clearly states "X applies to all paladins" and no other material contradicts this (most paladin generalizations are contradicted or put into perspective by individual novel and sourcebook paladin NPCs, btw), stating individual examples of archetypical paladins does nothing to prove your case. You can show me a thousand white swans, but that still does not prove that black swans cannot be.

_________________
On Joon, Kjetta wrote:
The guy that probably has sexual fantasies about masturbation. I mean, Iron, you're a bookworm nerd that even in your wildest escapism fantasies flee to the internet to play the role of another bookworm nerd? Come on!


 
      
Cori
 
PostPosted: Wed, Nov 18 2009, 18:46 PM 

User avatar

Player

Joined: 10 Aug 2005
Location: Ottawa, Ontario, Canada

To further Iron's point with my own opinion: if we *did* end up boiling things down to "all paladin's must be like x", I'd imagine it would also result in other classes being boiled down in a similar manner "all thieves must be like x", "all BG's must be like x".

Frankly, if it did come to that, there'd be no point in having Amia...the game wouldn't be about the characters or character development, or even choices. It'd be a hack 'n' slash. There'd be no more "What do you do?". It'd come down to "You are in this scenario. You attack." in which case, what use would the players be? The GM would effectively control everything by being the one to set up the scenario's. I suppose it could become a choose your own adventure...but even with options to choose turning left or right at the T-junction, the story would already be written, and we'd be hamsters in a maze, nothing more.

I prefer what we have now, thanks. Character differences are what makes this a game worth playing.

_________________
Role with the Punches...
Elan: A 10% chance is pretty unlikely, but everyone knows that a one-in-a-million chance is a sure thing!


 
      
Dark Immolation
 
PostPosted: Wed, Nov 18 2009, 18:54 PM 

User avatar

Developer

Joined: 20 Apr 2008
Location: The downeaster "Alexa"

bluntpencil2001 wrote:
In my opinion, if a Paladin is given a choice between a great evil happening (a village being massacred) and committing a (arguably) lesser evil, such as killing a child, he should find a third option.

Paladins do not commit evil acts. Committing an evil act, of any real magnitude, will cause a Fall.

Paladins should not be committing lesser evils, they should be attempting to do no evil at all.


I have to point out that this makes fine IC reasoning, and even a great train of thought for the paladin IC, but as an OoC opinion, kind of backwards, of course only in my opinion though. Rather, the character could very well think "Gaah! I'm a paladin! I can't dot ANY wrong. I can't do either evil! I-I Just...can't! *dilema*", but as a roleplayer you should never rule out such an option if the character's personallity and thinking called for such.

Sorry if that comes off like I'm calling your opinion wrong, I'm really not trying to! >_< I just find it would make more sense to base the PC's actions off of what he or she would reason, rather than OoCly thinking "My PC is a paladin, I absolutely cannot under any circumstances do anything un-paladin-like because they would fall, and if he falls, I've done something wrong." That's for any class really, I think. "My character is a mage, so he has to hang out with mages." "My character is Evil align, and that means he has to go out of his way to commit evil." Such thoughts usually lead to people making the same "personality" over and over and you end up with a party of stereotypes and players who don't play characters, but instead classes.


 
      
bluntpencil2001
 
PostPosted: Wed, Nov 18 2009, 19:06 PM 

User avatar

Player

Joined: 12 Nov 2009
Location: Scotland

Sometimes falling is the best decision to take.

After all, telling a lie makes a paladin fall, and lying is sometimes necessary.


 
      
Xaviera
 
PostPosted: Wed, Nov 18 2009, 19:12 PM 

User avatar

Player

Joined: 07 Aug 2006
Location: Temple of Love

My first reaction was to say 'kill the girl'. Upon reflection (a bit too late for the kid... :twisted: ) I'd pick not doing anything. The entire situation could be a set-up or illusion and you have no way of judging the truth of the lich's words.

[EDIT to expand on the above: And then, whether he falls or not, probably dedicating himself to rebuilding Wharftown while bearing the burden of his sin/failure until he feels that he has redeemed himself.]

Now, if you were standing on top of the tower watching him toss hellballs closer and closer to Wharftown... Hm. I'd probably do neither and somehow futilely try to attack him or disrupt his spell-casting.

_________________
Image
~Sharess on AmiaWiki~
Priestess, politician, prostitute
"[They] were moving in on me like Sharessans on a new broad in the bath house" - Tracer Bolt
AmiaWiki mod (mostly inactive)


Last edited by Xaviera on Wed, Nov 18 2009, 19:17 PM, edited 1 time in total.

 
      
Dark Immolation
 
PostPosted: Wed, Nov 18 2009, 19:13 PM 

User avatar

Developer

Joined: 20 Apr 2008
Location: The downeaster "Alexa"

bluntpencil2001 wrote:
Sometimes falling is the best decision to take.

After all, telling a lie makes a paladin fall, and lying is sometimes necessary.


Exactly! There ya go, you're thinking with your character's head instead of your own. :D

There's no need to think "Because he's a paladin, he can never reason to anything un-paladiny, even if it makes sense for his personality." He's a person, after all, not a machine.

*thumbs up*

Oh and...

Xaviera wrote:
Now, if you were standing on top of the tower watching him toss hellballs closer and closer to Wharftown... Hm. I'd probably do neither and somehow futilely try to attack him or disrupt his spell-casting.


But Xavi... epic spells can't be disrupted! :twisted: Muahahahaha!


 
      
Goblin
 
PostPosted: Wed, Nov 18 2009, 19:17 PM 

User avatar

Player

Joined: 02 Sep 2008
Location: Scotland

Because people want Paladins to be easy, and simple. They want their Paladin to be flexible and super-cool and everybody's friend. Well ok they really ~should~ be everyone's friend, but aside from that - the only true Paladin is the ~true~ Paladin. Yes, you must be the zealot, more-so than the Cleric. If you're not, then you're not a Paladin at all, and until you get that scary zeal you - are not - a Paladin.

Rogue, the Rogue can be anything you want him to be. A petty thief, a badass killer, a charming swashbuckler - whatever. Villain or Hero.

Fighter, the Fighter can be all of the above with a little more swashbuckling th an charm (at the very base idea). Villain or Hero.

Barbarian, the Barbarian doesn't need to adhere to anything - maybe personal honour if that's the way you do it, another versitale character class. Villain or Hero.

Cleric, the Cleric is the Supersize menu choice - for folks who want EVERYTHING. There's plenty of opportunity, there are no real deity restrictions - clergy = good stuff. Villain or Hero.

Druid, the Druid almost as devout as the Paladin, but perhaps with a more flexible approach - their chaotic nature allows plenty of room for what's cool or not, again, there are few restrictions. Villain or Hero, though based usually on perspective and circumstance - Druids are ~crazy~.

Bard, well... neither Hero nor Villain. Ok I lied, they can be both - obviously.

Ranger, probably the most versatile class in the game (along with Fighter for obvious reasons), very few restrictions and a lot of appeal - typically, a fun RP clas. Villain or Hero.

Then comes the P word - Paladin, this class ~has~ or should have deity restrictions, alignment restrictions that are the most severe of all classes - the moral obligations make any flexibility - null. Your Paladin is living for one cause, like the Druid with a balance in Nature, the Paladin wants everything to be rockin', and good, and pure. They will fight like psychopaths to make it that way if necessary. Some, and I say ~some~ of them are wise, while others focus more on martial prowess than spellcasting. Regardless of mental ability, they can still tap into their god's favour in at least one way. Hero or Fallen, no longer Paladin, no longer servant of faith - do not pass go, do not collect $200.




I have a weird way of getting a point across, I don't like to argue or be condescending - I'd have been happy to leave the topic, I was dragged back in for another round. Simply put, a Paladin is a really cool class and I can see why people would want to play it, but unless you're willing to play a boring, cookie-cutter character, or are able to work that without destroying the Paladin code for you and your Pally-pals, then just don't play one at all, because you're taking something away from the game - and it hurts me, inside.


Earlier I rolled up a Paladin/Ranger, it would've been fun but Corellon had something against LG'ness, even though he has Paladins and stuff - weird. It doesn't have to be cut and dry, a character can be built the way you want it to be - as long as he's going to champion his faith and always do what matters, then he is a Paladin.

I'd be an asshat if I said I was absolute and that my way was the right way. But if there's going to be restrictions on Paladins, and if their rules are going to be enforced or they fall - then it's probably better to read up on what makes a Paladin from whatever sources you can find. I have, and I'm quite fond and passionate of the class.

_________________
"O God of Earth and Altar,
Bow down and hear our cry,
Our earthly rulers falter,
Our people drift and die,
The walls of gold entomb us,
The swords of scorn divide,
Take not thy thunder from us,
But take away our pride."


 
      
Xaviera
 
PostPosted: Wed, Nov 18 2009, 19:18 PM 

User avatar

Player

Joined: 07 Aug 2006
Location: Temple of Love

I guess I'd make a lousy paladin, then. :wink:

_________________
Image
~Sharess on AmiaWiki~
Priestess, politician, prostitute
"[They] were moving in on me like Sharessans on a new broad in the bath house" - Tracer Bolt
AmiaWiki mod (mostly inactive)


 
      
Dark Immolation
 
PostPosted: Wed, Nov 18 2009, 19:43 PM 

User avatar

Developer

Joined: 20 Apr 2008
Location: The downeaster "Alexa"

KingCreeper wrote:
Then comes the P word - Paladin, this class ~has~ or should have deity restrictions, alignment restrictions that are the most severe of all classes - the moral obligations make any flexibility - null. Your Paladin is living for one cause, like the Druid with a balance in Nature, the Paladin wants everything to be rockin', and good, and pure. They will fight like psychopaths to make it that way if necessary. Some, and I say ~some~ of them are wise, while others focus more on martial prowess than spellcasting. Regardless of mental ability, they can still tap into their god's favour in at least one way. Hero or Fallen, no longer Paladin, no longer servant of faith - do not pass go, do not collect $200....

I have a weird way of getting a point across, I don't like to argue or be condescending - I'd have been happy to leave the topic, I was dragged back in for another round. Simply put, a Paladin is a really cool class and I can see why people would want to play it, but unless you're willing to play a boring, cookie-cutter character, or are able to work that without destroying the Paladin code for you and your Pally-pals, then just don't play one at all, because you're taking something away from the game - and it hurts me, inside.....

I'd be an asshat if I said I was absolute and that my way was the right way. But if there's going to be restrictions on Paladins, and if their rules are going to be enforced or they fall - then it's probably better to read up on what makes a Paladin from whatever sources you can find. I have, and I'm quite fond and passionate of the class.


I seriously doubt anyone will fault you for having strong opinions about paladins, Creeper :wink: . In fact, no one is truly disagreeing with you except in that saying not all paladins are the same. Not just because of diferences in dogma, not just because of differenes in beleifs, but because difference in characters. As far as I consider, no ones "plays" a druid. No one "plays" a wizard. No one "plays" a paladin. Well all play characters that are those things.

As far as paladin is concerned, no one is saying that paladins characters should not hold up strong codes or morals because of their position, at least I'm not. What I'm saying is that you should never limit yourself to what you character can and cannot do because of class alone, but rather the character. Your character is trying their damnedest to be a paladin, it doesn't mean they always succeed, it doesn't mean they never make mistakes, and it surely never means they can never have opinions of their own. A character first, class later. Otherwise, you only have as many personalities in the game as classes.

My second point is that you're kinda basing your opinion of a "true paladin" off of a standard that does not exist, at least not in these Dungeons and Dragons gaming experience. I recal only once a general "code" given for paladins, and even then, it was only to guide people in their RP, not restrict them. That's what deity and dogma are for. There are general guidelines and and a alignment requirement, just like druid, just like cleric if you take the One-Step rule. You can site no stone tablet for what exactly a paladin constitutes no more than we can, based off of the general assumptions.

It's that vagueness alone, whether intentional or not, that gives anyone any creativity in this game when thinking of character concepts. You can fault people for having their own idea of "rockin' " paladins no more than we can fault you for seeing them in the light of "Knights in Shining Armor."


 
      
Goblin
 
PostPosted: Wed, Nov 18 2009, 19:48 PM 

User avatar

Player

Joined: 02 Sep 2008
Location: Scotland

It's crystal clear what a Paladin ~should~ be. There shouldn't be that much room for players to stretch the boundries of such a class, just for the sake of their character. For any other class, yes - certainly - flesh out and progess, turn into a butterfly. A Paladin should already be there though. They don't have to dress like knights in shining armour to be the knight in shining armour.

_________________
"O God of Earth and Altar,
Bow down and hear our cry,
Our earthly rulers falter,
Our people drift and die,
The walls of gold entomb us,
The swords of scorn divide,
Take not thy thunder from us,
But take away our pride."


 
      
Nekhy
 
PostPosted: Wed, Nov 18 2009, 19:49 PM 



Player

Nobody ever said people aren't entitled to have different opinions on paladins. What we're arguing is that it's your opinion, not a true archetype pulled from the canon lore or rules. It's true in your opinion, sure. But it's not the only true paladin in this campaign.

But...

KingCreeper wrote:
[...]But if there's going to be restrictions on Paladins, and if their rules are going to be enforced or they fall - then it's probably better to read up on what makes a Paladin from whatever sources you can find. I have, and I'm quite fond and passionate of the class.


Why on earth would we enforce rules on paladins based on anything else than Forgotten Realms and Core D&D rules? OK, house rules are all dandy and nice, but they're house rules and house rules from other people's campaigns posted around are relevant to the specific campaigns they were made for. They can be nice as inspiration for individual characters, sure.

But we're playing a 3E Forgotten Realms campaign, and relevant material to our campaign is found in books like Player's Handbook, Forgotten Realms Campaign Setting, various novels, Player's Guide to Faerun and Champions of Valor, for example. That's where the "true" paladin for this campaign comes from, and it ain't one type of holy warrior in black and white.

KingCreeper wrote:
It's crystal clear what a Paladin ~should~ be. There shouldn't be that much room for players to stretch the boundries of such a class, just for the sake of their character. For any other class, yes - certainly - flesh out and progess, turn into a butterfly. A Paladin should already be there though. They don't have to dress like knights in shining armour to be the knight in shining armour.


Simply is not, according to any campaign official material.

Mind that I don't say it cannot be clear in your opinion. But you're presenting your opinion as a certain fact, which it isn't in FR campaign.


Last edited by Nekhy on Wed, Nov 18 2009, 19:59 PM, edited 1 time in total.

 
      
Yurell
 
PostPosted: Wed, Nov 18 2009, 19:56 PM 

User avatar

Player

Joined: 06 Jan 2008
Location: ANU, behind the coffee mug (+10 GMT)

KingCreeper wrote:
It's crystal clear what a Paladin ~should~ be.


I disagree - here's an example that Iron (IIRC) is fairly fond of - should a paladin be opposed to slavery?

_________________
2009's Second Most Overall Contributing Player

يمكنني استخدام مترجم جوجل


 
      
IronAngel
 
PostPosted: Wed, Nov 18 2009, 19:58 PM 

User avatar

Player

Joined: 29 Sep 2005
Location: Helsinki, Finland

I would like to refer you to Elaine Cunningham's novel Thornhold. It is a Forgotten Realms novel in which a paladin order, the Knights of Samular, plays a major role. One of the main characters is a young paladin who does his best, but seems to run into trouble and fail a lot. It's very enlightening overall, not to mention some of the highest quality D&D fiction you'll find.

You say it's crystal clear what a paladin should be, yet you haven't proven it. It's one of the oldest debates in D&D history, so it's certainly not crystal clear. If you read the recommended novel, and accept the fact that it describes actual paladins in the world we play in, you'll probably see that as well.

Edit: Oh, and then there's Piergeiron Paladinson, the Open Lord of Waterdeep. He's a politician who has to accept the realities of running a city diplomatically - that includes letting criminal organizations do their own dirty work, diplomacy with wicked foreign nations, and working with a council of Masked Lords who you can't be sure are always doing everything quite the honorable way.

_________________
On Joon, Kjetta wrote:
The guy that probably has sexual fantasies about masturbation. I mean, Iron, you're a bookworm nerd that even in your wildest escapism fantasies flee to the internet to play the role of another bookworm nerd? Come on!


Last edited by IronAngel on Wed, Nov 18 2009, 20:03 PM, edited 1 time in total.

 
      
Goblin
 
PostPosted: Wed, Nov 18 2009, 20:03 PM 

User avatar

Player

Joined: 02 Sep 2008
Location: Scotland

Look, it's fine - turn Paladins into whatever you want them to be. It's not my responsibility to say whether or not folks should or shouldn't play whatever class they want to, if you don't like what I have to say then don't goad me into saying it.

Paladins should be super-Holy, zealots, rockin'. There are a million ways to be a super-holy-rockin'-zealot, but the fundamental structure should always be there. Shall we at least agree that the foundations of a Paladin should be to be true and great?

_________________
"O God of Earth and Altar,
Bow down and hear our cry,
Our earthly rulers falter,
Our people drift and die,
The walls of gold entomb us,
The swords of scorn divide,
Take not thy thunder from us,
But take away our pride."


 
      
IronAngel
 
PostPosted: Wed, Nov 18 2009, 20:06 PM 

User avatar

Player

Joined: 29 Sep 2005
Location: Helsinki, Finland

You keep saying we're doing something to paladins, turning them into something they're not.

Please, stop this. It is not good academic argumentation. You have not shown that your opinion is based on any fact. How things "should" be is irrelevant; we are discussing how they are, in fact.

I do agree a paladin should be Lawful, Good, chivalric, in service to his deity; that's what's said about them in the class description. That includes true and great, I suppose. I do not agree that they must be stubborn zealots - I think the ideal paladin is quite the opposite, and this is evident in many of the most famous paladin NPCs of the Realms. (Gareth Dragonsbane and Piergeiron Paladinson come to mind. Perhaps Texter, too.)

_________________
On Joon, Kjetta wrote:
The guy that probably has sexual fantasies about masturbation. I mean, Iron, you're a bookworm nerd that even in your wildest escapism fantasies flee to the internet to play the role of another bookworm nerd? Come on!


 
      
Nekhy
 
PostPosted: Wed, Nov 18 2009, 20:19 PM 



Player

KingCreeper wrote:
Look, it's fine - turn Paladins into whatever you want them to be.


We're in fact trying to get paladins as close to the Forgotten Realms standard as possible, if anything. It certainly is different from your view of paladins, but... it is the Forgotten Realms take on paladins.

Blame Wizards of the Coast and Ed Greenwood for turning paladins into this version, if you want to blame someone.

Well, WotC in fact did a slight turnaround with paladins in 4E. 4E paladin would appear to be somewhat more of a stereotypical zealot than 3E paladin is. But 3E is a bloated mass of contradictions and hypercharged lore, whereas 4E is a streamlined and simplified game.


 
      
Goblin
 
PostPosted: Wed, Nov 18 2009, 20:30 PM 

User avatar

Player

Joined: 02 Sep 2008
Location: Scotland

Alright! Sheesh you guys are getting really dogged toward me here. If there's no problem - don't change it. I'm not going to dictate one way or the other. If you have the material to see for yourself what Paladins are made of then you don't need me to tell you how I see it. You're so fussy!

_________________
"O God of Earth and Altar,
Bow down and hear our cry,
Our earthly rulers falter,
Our people drift and die,
The walls of gold entomb us,
The swords of scorn divide,
Take not thy thunder from us,
But take away our pride."


 
      
Yurell
 
PostPosted: Wed, Nov 18 2009, 20:30 PM 

User avatar

Player

Joined: 06 Jan 2008
Location: ANU, behind the coffee mug (+10 GMT)

KingCreeper wrote:
Look, it's fine - turn Paladins into whatever you want them to be. It's not my responsibility to say whether or not folks should or shouldn't play whatever class they want to, if you don't like what I have to say then don't goad me into saying it.


Goad you into saying it? We are having a discussion, and we value everyone's opinion. We're asking you to provide evidence that your opinion on how a paladin behaves is how it should be, and providing examples that demonstrate where we believe the situation breaks down ... we're trying to reach some form of agreement, and that can only happen if both sides discuss.

We are not 'turning' paladins into anything - we're treating them as we interpret Forgotten Realms paladins to be. If you disagree with our interpretation, then that is fine, but for stating that paladins definitely should be one way is different, and so all we're asking for is evidence, and providing logical counter examples.

The question I directed at you was a trick question, as it stands ... there are canonical examples for each case, if you tried to argue paladins should be one or the other.

We're fine with "If you meet xyz then IMO you're a well played paladin", but there's the dubious "Iff* you meet xyz then you are a well played paladin."


*Iff means "if and only if"

_________________
2009's Second Most Overall Contributing Player

يمكنني استخدام مترجم جوجل


 
      
bluntpencil2001
 
PostPosted: Wed, Nov 18 2009, 20:36 PM 

User avatar

Player

Joined: 12 Nov 2009
Location: Scotland

Paladins don't have to be zealots, but they must be of a lawful personality, and must be so good, to the point where they do no evil (intentionally, at any rate).

In Forgotten Realms, like all divine casters, they must have a deity, but they don't have to be a zealot. It really depends on the personality there.

A Ruby Rose Knight of Sune or a Paladin of Chauntea, Ilmater or Lathander is less likely to be a fiery zealot than a Paladin of Helm, Kelemvor, Hoar or even Torm. Of course, a Paladin of Sune, Chauntea, Ilmater or Lathander could be a fiery zealot, it really depends on individual personality. 'Paladin' is a class, not a personality.


 
      
Yurell
 
PostPosted: Wed, Nov 18 2009, 20:44 PM 

User avatar

Player

Joined: 06 Jan 2008
Location: ANU, behind the coffee mug (+10 GMT)

KingCreeper wrote:
Alright! Sheesh you guys are getting really dogged toward me here. If there's no problem - don't change it. I'm not going to dictate one way or the other. If you have the material to see for yourself what Paladins are made of then you don't need me to tell you how I see it. You're so fussy!


There's no need to snap at us - we're just having a discussion to try and prove that between your solid black and solid white are shades of grey. We're not picking on you, we just disagree with your point. It really isn't anything personal - Iron and I have filled pages before, and if it were meant personally I'm sure one of us would be dead by now :P

_________________
2009's Second Most Overall Contributing Player

يمكنني استخدام مترجم جوجل


 
      
Goblin
 
PostPosted: Wed, Nov 18 2009, 20:47 PM 

User avatar

Player

Joined: 02 Sep 2008
Location: Scotland

Alright. Well without appearing hostile, or snapping - or being a jerk in any way I shall ask.

If a Paladin isn't a zealot, or holy-warrior who stands by the morality and other codes defined by his patron - then what exactly is he?

_________________
"O God of Earth and Altar,
Bow down and hear our cry,
Our earthly rulers falter,
Our people drift and die,
The walls of gold entomb us,
The swords of scorn divide,
Take not thy thunder from us,
But take away our pride."


 
      
Yurell
 
PostPosted: Wed, Nov 18 2009, 20:50 PM 

User avatar

Player

Joined: 06 Jan 2008
Location: ANU, behind the coffee mug (+10 GMT)

A lawful good follower of her deity bound by a code of ethics and conducts ... so long as she remains within those bounds she can be anything IMO - overzealous, chivalric, reserved, whatever, so long as she doesn't break her paladin code-of-conduct, her deities will or the LG alignment.

_________________
2009's Second Most Overall Contributing Player

يمكنني استخدام مترجم جوجل


 
      
Goblin
 
PostPosted: Wed, Nov 18 2009, 20:53 PM 

User avatar

Player

Joined: 02 Sep 2008
Location: Scotland

But, what is the Paladin's code-of-conduct, if not all the things I said in the past? And without the rigidity of the Paladin's discipline, would they not just be a LG Fighter?

_________________
"O God of Earth and Altar,
Bow down and hear our cry,
Our earthly rulers falter,
Our people drift and die,
The walls of gold entomb us,
The swords of scorn divide,
Take not thy thunder from us,
But take away our pride."


 
      
Nekhy
 
PostPosted: Wed, Nov 18 2009, 20:57 PM 



Player

KingCreeper wrote:
If a Paladin isn't a zealot, or holy-warrior who stands by the morality and other codes defined by his patron - then what exactly is he?


A lawful good divine warrior, a servant of a patron god, that accepts paladins. Typically LG, LN and NG deities, but FR also accepts other specific deities to have paladins. Bound to his/her code of conduct (which is conveniently left undefined in canon lore). Essentially, this:

Image

The rest is very undefined, left up to the player and the DM to define. Examples of numerous different types of paladins are given as NPCs in novels and FRCS, for example. The code of conduct typically depends on the patron deity, though. Still, it isn't defined in the rulebooks. I've never found it, and I have looked for it.


Last edited by Nekhy on Wed, Nov 18 2009, 20:58 PM, edited 1 time in total.

 
      
Yurell
 
PostPosted: Wed, Nov 18 2009, 20:57 PM 

User avatar

Player

Joined: 06 Jan 2008
Location: ANU, behind the coffee mug (+10 GMT)

I'd imagine that the code of conduct would be similar for all paladins, though differing depending on faiths, the person who taught you, although I'd imagine stealing, lying, doing evil deeds etc. would be in there.

For more detail, you'll have to wait for someone else, and everything here is just my opinion, I could be wrong (I don't read FR novels at all ... after head-desking so many times at plot induced stupidity I just gave up).

Edit: Thanks Nekhy, you answered the question for me :P

_________________
2009's Second Most Overall Contributing Player

يمكنني استخدام مترجم جوجل


Last edited by Yurell on Wed, Nov 18 2009, 20:59 PM, edited 1 time in total.

 
      
555444333
 
PostPosted: Wed, Nov 18 2009, 20:58 PM 

User avatar

Player

Joined: 08 Oct 2005
Location: Czechia

Hey Zealot-Zealot.

Go read this The how not to play a Jerkass Paladouche (a learning by example comic)

OOTS is there to be learnt from. Foo'

_________________
ImageJys'zyne Do'larn


Man, this account is over 10 years old. Where do I get my old man beard?


 
      
Nekhy
 
PostPosted: Wed, Nov 18 2009, 21:09 PM 



Player

Image

The above is also enlightening regarding the codes of conduct (notice plural; the core rules posted in my previous speak of 'a' code of conduct, not 'the' code of conduct).

The previous snapshot was from Player's Handbook, btw, and this one in this post is from Forgotten Realms Campaign Setting.


 
      
Goblin
 
PostPosted: Wed, Nov 18 2009, 21:18 PM 

User avatar

Player

Joined: 02 Sep 2008
Location: Scotland

See, this is excellent stuff that should be available to everyone thinking of rolling up a Paladin. I'll admit my main experience is always with the Triad, so rigidity and unwavering lawfulness are going to be critical in my mind.

From just those little paragraphs of source material, people could easily get the feel - and general idea of how the Paladin they are creating might be.

_________________
"O God of Earth and Altar,
Bow down and hear our cry,
Our earthly rulers falter,
Our people drift and die,
The walls of gold entomb us,
The swords of scorn divide,
Take not thy thunder from us,
But take away our pride."


 
      
bluntpencil2001
 
PostPosted: Wed, Nov 18 2009, 21:25 PM 

User avatar

Player

Joined: 12 Nov 2009
Location: Scotland

More on the Code of Conduct... from the Player's Handbook.
Quote:
Code of Conduct
A paladin must be of lawful good alignment and loses all class abilities if she ever willingly commits an evil act.

Additionally, a paladin’s code requires that she respect legitimate authority, act with honor (not lying, not cheating, not using poison, and so forth), help those in need (provided they do not use the help for evil or chaotic ends), and punish those who harm or threaten innocents.

Associates

While she may adventure with characters of any good or neutral alignment, a paladin will never knowingly associate with evil characters, nor will she continue an association with someone who consistently offends her moral code. A paladin may accept only henchmen, followers, or cohorts who are lawful good.


 
      
Nekhy
 
PostPosted: Wed, Nov 18 2009, 21:27 PM 



Player

These same paragraphs are available, for example, in Forgotten Realms wiki. Or used to be, now they have pretty much changed to 4E which is NOT applicable on Amia. They're also posted around the net (should be used with caution, always checking where the author got their information from), and there's a Paladin Guide written by IronAngel here on the forums. Iron made it good, with references to the original texts and all.

What we cannot do is copy great parts of the source material directly on the forums, because it's copyrighted.

Edit: Yeah, that's the Code of Conduct spelled out... it's reaaaaaally vague and leaves a ton of room for interpretation. It just states you have to act Lawful and Good in different words, essentially. Or explains what Lawful and Good means. But notice how it speaks nothing of zeal or chivalry, even. It just says, once again, act lawful good.


 
      
IronAngel
 
PostPosted: Wed, Nov 18 2009, 21:37 PM 

User avatar

Player

Joined: 29 Sep 2005
Location: Helsinki, Finland

The revised Forgotten Realms Campaing Setting (2e) has the following to say:

Quote:
Paladins are fighters of a higher calling than most common warriors.
They fight for a strongly held moral and ethical code, and are held to
exacting standards in all their actions. Failure to live up to their moral
and ethical alignment results in their downfall, and the stripping of all
special abilities granted by the paladin class.

There is no specific paladin's code, no set of do's and don'ts by
which paladins are graded on a pass/fail basis. The closest thing to
such a code is "Quentin's Monograph," a short treatise on the nature
of alignment and paladinhood by a retired paladin. In addition to
flowery descriptions of early endeavors and practical advice on the
care of weapons and animals, the monograph summarizes what it calls
the Paladin's Virtues.

The listing is not all-inclusive, and every paladin grades and
emphasizes these virtues based on his or her own personal ethos and
religious background. Paladins may obey all these virtues to the letter
and still lose their special status, or flout one virtue in the name of
another and still retain paladinhood. In this fashion, a paladin may
exist outside an organized hierarchy or even lead rebellions and wars
against unjust or evil causes. It is possible under these virtues that one
paladin may even fight another, both seeking to defend a different
paladin.s virtue or interpretation of all of them.

Paladins in the Realms, like priests, are devoted to a particular
deity. The most common paladin deities are those which embody
action, decision, watchfulness, and wisdom. Torm and Tyr are both
popular deities for paladins, as is Ilmater, who stresses the need to suffer
to attain one.s goals. All these gods are good and lawful in their
basic alignment.

Paladins also serve deities who present themselves as being good
but not necessarily lawful, and lawful but not necessarily good. These
include Azuth and Helm, who are lawful and neutral in their outlook,
and Mystra, Deneir, Lathander, and Milil, who are good and neutral.
Chauntea and Mielikki are also neutral and good, but tend to attract
more druids and rangers than paladins, though there are exceptions.
No gods who claim true neutrality, evil, or chaos in their ethos and
morals have paladins operating in their name.


The following is an excerpt of the aforementioned Quentin's Monorgraph, by no means an absolute OOC rule set but a religious IC text which reflects common beliefs of paladinhood:
Quote:
The paladin's virtues are:
An organized approach brings the most good for all.
Laws exist to bring prosperity to those under them.
Unjust laws must be overturned or changed in a reasonable and
positive fashion.
People rule: laws help.
Cause the most good through the least harm.
Protect the weak.
Goodness is not a natural state, but must be fought for to be
attained and maintained.
Lead by example.
Let your deeds speak your intentions.
Goodness radiated from the heart.
Give others your mercy, but keep your wits about you.

_________________
On Joon, Kjetta wrote:
The guy that probably has sexual fantasies about masturbation. I mean, Iron, you're a bookworm nerd that even in your wildest escapism fantasies flee to the internet to play the role of another bookworm nerd? Come on!


 
      
Cori
 
PostPosted: Wed, Nov 18 2009, 22:00 PM 

User avatar

Player

Joined: 10 Aug 2005
Location: Ottawa, Ontario, Canada

Personally, I don't ascribe "chivalry" to being a necessity for a paladin. That's a fairytale necessity for a knight.

Not teh same thing. But sadly, most people tend to intermix the two.

A paladin must be good...but that doesn't even necessitate being "nice", in my opinion. My personal favourite rendition of a paladin was a "Champion" in a novel called One Good Knight by Mercedes Lackey. Totally not what you'd picture a paladin as (and technically, it wasn't a paladin, but a champion), but that was what , in my opinion, made the CHARACTER so fascinating. Namely...that it was a character, not a class.

The way the champion character was written, it's how I'd play a paladin, if I were to make one. The virtues and codes the champion operates under are quite similar to those of a paladin, in my opinion. edit: I'd of course add in significantly more religious context to my paladin. The Champion in the novel was not so religious based, due to the world in which the story takes place.

_________________
Role with the Punches...
Elan: A 10% chance is pretty unlikely, but everyone knows that a one-in-a-million chance is a sure thing!


Last edited by Cori on Wed, Nov 18 2009, 22:15 PM, edited 1 time in total.

 
      
IronAngel
 
PostPosted: Wed, Nov 18 2009, 22:12 PM 

User avatar

Player

Joined: 29 Sep 2005
Location: Helsinki, Finland

My bad, I remembered wrong: it was honor that was the additional requirement, not chivalry. I should've checked my sources before I opened my mouth. :oops:

_________________
On Joon, Kjetta wrote:
The guy that probably has sexual fantasies about masturbation. I mean, Iron, you're a bookworm nerd that even in your wildest escapism fantasies flee to the internet to play the role of another bookworm nerd? Come on!


 
      
Wilagins
 
PostPosted: Mon, Nov 30 2009, 18:21 PM 



Player

Joined: 28 Nov 2009

I have propblems with alot of the paladins I've seen in this game simply because they are usualy rather closed minded. Which is why I usualy play Lathanderite paladins. Guiding people toward the light usualy makes more friends for your ideals than simply smiteing everyone who might in anyway be evil.

The intent and action of the individual is more important than the circumstance of their birth, and there are always tales of even deamonbloods turning to the light after great struggle. It's a matter of different types of victory asfar as I see it. To simply kill evil is one thing, to guide one away from evil is more complete, like the opposite of paladin turned blackguard.. you've antycorrupted the person in a greater victory over darkness than a simple killing, shown them the light and gained vicotry in the arena of free will. ofcourse, if they aren't repentant or willing to turn from evil... that's why you have the sword at your hip.


 
      
Display posts from previous:  Sort by  
Forum locked This topic is locked, you cannot edit posts or make further replies.  [ 165 posts ]  Go to page Previous  1, 2, 3, 4  Next


Who is online

Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 14 guests


You cannot post new topics in this forum
You cannot reply to topics in this forum
You cannot edit your posts in this forum
You cannot delete your posts in this forum

Search for:
Jump to:  
cron
Powered by phpBB © 2000, 2002, 2005, 2007 phpBB Group