View unanswered posts | View active topics * FAQ    * Search
* Login 




Forum locked This topic is locked, you cannot edit posts or make further replies.  [ 165 posts ]  Go to page 1, 2, 3, 4  Next
Dead
 
PostPosted: Sat, Nov 14 2009, 10:45 AM 

User avatar

Player

Joined: 26 Apr 2009
Location: Tarkuul

What should pally do, or even better what pally shouldn't do so it doesn't become a fallen one.

I heard some stories about DMs giving the fallen widgets to the pallys for traveling with abyssal blooded or evil characters. Is this true?

If it is I will be more specific and ask what should a pally of Lathander do since the dogma of lathander says that everyone can turn to light (there is always a new dawn).

If not than what are the reasons (examples?) of pally becoming a fallen one?

_________________
Image
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~ Login: Narkudauman

~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~ ╬ Join the Magisterium Mortis ╬


 
      
BrainSplitter
 
PostPosted: Sat, Nov 14 2009, 10:55 AM 

User avatar

Player

Joined: 06 Apr 2005
Location: Victoria, Australia

My 'Hit List'

Working with (known) members of Evil Faiths or Organizations.

Working with Demons, the Undead, Devils, or other strongly evil creatures.

Condoning, Permitting, or Performing torture of any kind.

Condoning, Permitting, or Performing an assault against a subdued or non-combative person. (Unarmed, Surrendered, Captured, Unconscious, etc)


There are other situations, however they're rather variable and situational. THe first two -might- be skated by based on circumstance, but it's rare.

_________________
Mostly Retired


 
      
Dead
 
PostPosted: Sat, Nov 14 2009, 11:00 AM 

User avatar

Player

Joined: 26 Apr 2009
Location: Tarkuul

Known members means that my character knows that he/she is evil or that it is generally known that that person is evil but my character is unaware of that?

_________________
Image
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~ Login: Narkudauman

~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~ ╬ Join the Magisterium Mortis ╬


 
      
The Peacock
 
PostPosted: Sat, Nov 14 2009, 11:34 AM 

User avatar

Player

Joined: 17 Feb 2007
Location: Patrollink ze borderz! Wo ist das Hahn!?

Paladins will, in pnp, ALWAYS smite an evil party - if they've been known to commit, or are seen committing any act opposing the Paladins vow. It's really up to you - your discretion and what-not.

If the Dogma of Lathander offers the light to those that have fallen from his 'ideal' path, then attempt to reinforce your path in persuasion to those that are of evil alignment.

However - it's very clear that Paladins will NOT tolerate acts of evil in ANY circumstance and are devoutly set out to smite the ties of evil.

If I'd play a Paladin - Ew... People already know how lore-bias I am...

_________________
Image
'Ze Cock! Ze Cock ist shtill aut der!! Kapitulation feiern - NEIN DANKE!'


 
      
Silvarus
 
PostPosted: Sat, Nov 14 2009, 11:42 AM 

User avatar

Player

Joined: 23 Sep 2005
Location: Jyväskylä, Finland, Europe

Playing a paladin is not easy, but damn is it awesome when done right.

_________________
Gagis Silvarna, the Robocop with wings who shoots lasers from his fingertips
Lily Havthorn, the Waukeenar
Silwe, the elf


 
      
The Peacock
 
PostPosted: Sat, Nov 14 2009, 11:49 AM 

User avatar

Player

Joined: 17 Feb 2007
Location: Patrollink ze borderz! Wo ist das Hahn!?

Basically, Paladins smite all evil, quelch the land of Toril from Evil, vanquish powerful foes, care for the ill and downhearted, care for the unfortunate, do not pick up loot (as that is desanctifying a body), do not steal, do not berate, do not allow their emotions to beget them etcetera, etcetera.

_________________
Image
'Ze Cock! Ze Cock ist shtill aut der!! Kapitulation feiern - NEIN DANKE!'


 
      
Silvarus
 
PostPosted: Sat, Nov 14 2009, 11:53 AM 

User avatar

Player

Joined: 23 Sep 2005
Location: Jyväskylä, Finland, Europe

lathandier wrote:
Basically, Paladins smite all evil, quelch the land of Toril from Evil, vanquish powerful foes, care for the ill and downhearted, care for the unfortunate, do not pick up loot (as that is desanctifying a body), do not steal, do not berate, do not allow their emotions to beget them etcetera, etcetera.
I have a char that also has monkish oaths on top of all that:

I shall forgo private ownership
I shall live in poverty
I shall live in celibate chastity
I shall never commit an evil act
I shall not associate with anything that I know does evil that could be avoided
I shall never tell a lie or mislead intentionally
I shall always give fair warning and due quarter to my enemies
I shall try to avoid stealth, subterfuge, attack from the rear and ranged weapons
I shall never eat a living creature and I shall try my best to take from nature only what can be taken without doing damage to any living plant
I shall defend the faiths of the Triad
I shall uphold the Law wherever I am
I shall promote order and all that is good
I shall never betray a confidence or a comrade
I shall never abandon a friend, an ally or a Noble cause
I shall put the benefit of the poor and the less fortunate and general good before myself
I shall be humble in thought, word and deed
I shall avenge the wronged
I shall not harm an innocent man. I shall rather take to myself any harm directed at the innocent
I shall not steal
Every moment of my life shall be devoted to the faith of Ilmater
If I fail to follow this may my sinful soul be damned

... I need to play him more.

_________________
Gagis Silvarna, the Robocop with wings who shoots lasers from his fingertips
Lily Havthorn, the Waukeenar
Silwe, the elf


 
      
The Peacock
 
PostPosted: Sat, Nov 14 2009, 12:10 PM 

User avatar

Player

Joined: 17 Feb 2007
Location: Patrollink ze borderz! Wo ist das Hahn!?

Yep. That's how I'd play a Paladin. For sure...

People would hate me though - which is a good thing on a server where everyone wants to be friends.

_________________
Image
'Ze Cock! Ze Cock ist shtill aut der!! Kapitulation feiern - NEIN DANKE!'


 
      
Nekhy
 
PostPosted: Sat, Nov 14 2009, 12:14 PM 



Player

Hooboy, another pally debate arising? Should we just link to the previous ones and skip this one?


 
      
Silvarus
 
PostPosted: Sat, Nov 14 2009, 12:29 PM 

User avatar

Player

Joined: 23 Sep 2005
Location: Jyväskylä, Finland, Europe

Nekhy wrote:
Hooboy, another pally debate arising? Should we just link to the previous ones and skip this one?
Pfft. We haven't found anything to argue about yet.

_________________
Gagis Silvarna, the Robocop with wings who shoots lasers from his fingertips
Lily Havthorn, the Waukeenar
Silwe, the elf


 
      
hendrack
 
PostPosted: Sat, Nov 14 2009, 12:30 PM 

User avatar

Player

Joined: 24 Sep 2007
Location: Vienna

Easy on Amia. Metagame alignment or fall. :D

Quote:
If not than what are the reasons (examples?) of pally becoming a fallen one?


Don't think its wise to post dirty laundry in public.


 
      
IronAngel
 
PostPosted: Sat, Nov 14 2009, 12:45 PM 

User avatar

Player

Joined: 29 Sep 2005
Location: Helsinki, Finland

Well: always keep in mind your oaths, whatever they are. Consider them honestly, without the bias of "I have to justify this somehow so I can hunt/be OOC friends/profit/whatever." If you take your RP seriously, I doubt you're going to Fall without warning: you're likely to have visions or sensations of disapproval, perhaps reprimands from your clerical superiors, or a short-term Fall you can fairly easily atone for. We don't Fall paladins trigger-happily out of mere spite, and it's never irreversable or an OOC punishment. If you RP, our goal is to support your RP, be it with a Fall widget or otherwise. Knowing and avoiding a Fall OOC is rather contrary to the spirit of RP, IMO; just player your PC honestly and sincerely, and see what comes.

_________________
On Joon, Kjetta wrote:
The guy that probably has sexual fantasies about masturbation. I mean, Iron, you're a bookworm nerd that even in your wildest escapism fantasies flee to the internet to play the role of another bookworm nerd? Come on!


 
      
Goblin
 
PostPosted: Sat, Nov 14 2009, 13:10 PM 

User avatar

Player

Joined: 02 Sep 2008
Location: Scotland

Paladins are hard to play ~right~, but very rewarding for those who can. I can see Pallys falling because of various reasons as were pointed out in the thread, it makes absolute sense. Pallys are supposed to be the champions of everything that is good and pure and rockin'.

_________________
"O God of Earth and Altar,
Bow down and hear our cry,
Our earthly rulers falter,
Our people drift and die,
The walls of gold entomb us,
The swords of scorn divide,
Take not thy thunder from us,
But take away our pride."


 
      
IronAngel
 
PostPosted: Sat, Nov 14 2009, 13:13 PM 

User avatar

Player

Joined: 29 Sep 2005
Location: Helsinki, Finland

There's no "right" and "wrong" way to RP. You may fail and fall, but that's IC. You didn't play "wrong."

_________________
On Joon, Kjetta wrote:
The guy that probably has sexual fantasies about masturbation. I mean, Iron, you're a bookworm nerd that even in your wildest escapism fantasies flee to the internet to play the role of another bookworm nerd? Come on!


 
      
hendrack
 
PostPosted: Sat, Nov 14 2009, 13:17 PM 

User avatar

Player

Joined: 24 Sep 2007
Location: Vienna

IronAngel wrote:
There's no "right" and "wrong" way to RP. You may fail and fall, but that's IC. You didn't play "wrong."


I disagree on that. If you want to play your pally on his right path, based on the OOC knowledge about his/her dogma and fall due to false OOC assumptions, I'd say I played my pally wrong.


 
      
Goblin
 
PostPosted: Sat, Nov 14 2009, 13:19 PM 

User avatar

Player

Joined: 02 Sep 2008
Location: Scotland

No no, there's absolutely a wrong way to play a Paladin. I can't see any way to justify doing it wrong. Obviously if you're intentions are to become fallen you'd do that silly stuff that would have dire consequences to your bind to the faith, but going out on purpose with an evil Drow/Demon-blood guy who openly sacrifices everything in his path to Lloth, or your best buddy for the day, the guy you're grinding with, happens to be some psycho Cyricist who openly does nasty nasty things - then yes, you're doing it wrong. WRONG.

_________________
"O God of Earth and Altar,
Bow down and hear our cry,
Our earthly rulers falter,
Our people drift and die,
The walls of gold entomb us,
The swords of scorn divide,
Take not thy thunder from us,
But take away our pride."


 
      
The Peacock
 
PostPosted: Sat, Nov 14 2009, 13:21 PM 

User avatar

Player

Joined: 17 Feb 2007
Location: Patrollink ze borderz! Wo ist das Hahn!?

And let it begin.

_________________
Image
'Ze Cock! Ze Cock ist shtill aut der!! Kapitulation feiern - NEIN DANKE!'


 
      
Estatica
 
PostPosted: Sat, Nov 14 2009, 13:33 PM 

User avatar

Player

Joined: 25 Apr 2008
Location: Australia, GMT +8

lathandier wrote:
Basically, Paladins smite all evil, quelch the land of Toril from Evil, vanquish powerful foes, care for the ill and downhearted, care for the unfortunate, do not pick up loot (as that is desanctifying a body), do not steal, do not berate, do not allow their emotions to beget them etcetera, etcetera.

This, of course, when done slightly wrong this leads to much asshattery by both the smitees and the paladin.
And from my experience, there's not many people who can manage to do that.


 
      
Nekhy
 
PostPosted: Sat, Nov 14 2009, 13:36 PM 



Player

lathandier wrote:
And let it begin.


Aaaaaaaaaameeeeeeen!




This is the age-old morals discussion, which is the more evil act out of the two?

Commit an evil act of killing someone, let's say by execution, to save a hundred innocent people? Murder is evil, so you fall! Or do you? Does the end justify the means? Depends on your patron deity.

Paladins of Tyr with personal slaves in Calimport? Or let's say, paladins of Mulhorandi deities with slaves. They don't fall for committing such a horrendous crime as slavery, because of cultural relativism.

It's black and white with lots of shades of gray, too.


 
      
Goblin
 
PostPosted: Sat, Nov 14 2009, 13:40 PM 

User avatar

Player

Joined: 02 Sep 2008
Location: Scotland

There can be no grey area for a Paladin though, that's what makes it so hard. You're evil, you get the smite. You're good, you get the stoic, moderately annoying companion who won't let you do anything fun.

_________________
"O God of Earth and Altar,
Bow down and hear our cry,
Our earthly rulers falter,
Our people drift and die,
The walls of gold entomb us,
The swords of scorn divide,
Take not thy thunder from us,
But take away our pride."


 
      
Nekhy
 
PostPosted: Sat, Nov 14 2009, 13:55 PM 



Player

Yeah, there IS a clash between the Core/Greyhawk and Forgotten Realms interpretation of the paladin, which is what makes it less black and white than one would think. Iron's been writing a lot about this on the forums, with proper referencing to lore sources, too.

It actually makes playing a paladin far more difficult to have these culturally dependent variants around instead of a single blueprint paladin to suit all sizes.


 
      
Yurell
 
PostPosted: Sat, Nov 14 2009, 14:26 PM 

User avatar

Player

Joined: 06 Jan 2008
Location: ANU, behind the coffee mug (+10 GMT)

I'm one of the people who campaign for a more solid black/white line (see the pages of discussion about undead ... still glad that we managed that peacefully), but there are always shades of grey.
Are you choosing the 'less evil' act? Was it your intention to choose between the two for the least evil? Was self preservation your intention? Does it matter what was apparently less evil, or ultimately less evil? Did you enjoy it? Basically ... what was your motive, how much did you know and how soul crushingly evil was it?

An example, self-slaughter is extremely frowned upon by Christianity, but throughout history it has had periods of being seen as a noble way to go. Is the paladin who kills himself committing an evil act? The slave example that Nekhy gave? Murdering a demon-spawn child? When your god judges you, does he judge you by the same metre-rule that the other gods judge their paladins by?

One of the best RP I had was in a PnP session when we found some goblin children ... my paladin wanted them destroyed, but the CG Elf said no. What would have been the right thing to do? To kill the goblins, I would have needed to subdue the elf ... or I could have let the children live and start a new goblin tribe to terrorise the villagers. Is my god such an arse that he'll damn me no matter what my decision?

A paladin does not have to be an Exalted character, there is wriggle room, so long as you can justify it to your god. I've seen RP where the paladin couldn't convince himself that his actions were right but evidently his god thought so.

Also, what constitutes an ultimately evil act? This came up in the spells debate, but there I was arguing about the inherent nature of magic, here I ask in general.
An example - I see a man attacking a woman, and I save her by subduing him ... that was good, right? What if she were a criminal? Is my act evil? What if she's not a criminal, but goes on to mother someone who becomes a tyrant ... my act caused that, which is quite clearly evil, so was the act evil?

There may be moral absolutes in D&D, but there is always the Neutral Alignment ... an act can be not good but also not evil, in itself does this no create a 'shades of grey' tolerance between the two?
For an Exalted Character, I could see the argument of a solid defining line, but for a paladin? How is a Paladin supposed to tell at a glance when someone is evil, for example? What if he can't, and his god gives him his monthly once-over and Falls him for his actions?

I know I presented a lot of hypothetical situations, but that's because a) I believe moral relativism does have some importance in D&D and b) Because it's late at night and I'm quite tired.

_________________
2009's Second Most Overall Contributing Player

يمكنني استخدام مترجم جوجل


 
      
Dramatic_Prince
 
PostPosted: Sat, Nov 14 2009, 14:48 PM 

User avatar

Player

Joined: 11 Sep 2008

Nekhy wrote:
Depends on your patron deity.

I wholly agree with this. My hin paladin is a guardian-type character.
She stands for wholesome hin values of family and friendship and is not duty-bound to actively seek out and smite evil.
That's for the crusader-types to do.

_________________
Image
Prescia the Pristine Voice


 
      
-Cloak-and-Dagger-
 
PostPosted: Sat, Nov 14 2009, 14:52 PM 

User avatar

Player

Joined: 09 Feb 2009
Location: England

There are a million and one different kinds of Paladins.....Different races, different cultural backgrounds, different dogmas and so on. But none of those dogmas give the go ahead to do things like Torture and Murder and I think its things like that I would say are absoltely definetly deserving of a Fall. Aside from those, theres no way you can make a list of fall worthy crimes because every deity has his own rules. IMO, its up to the player to intepret his character's deities dogma and make his own list of things he can and cant do. Thats the hard bit. If you're struggling to intepret Lathanders dogma as to whether its OK to associate with evil people in the name of showing them the error of their ways? Have your character find another Lathanderite (Theres plenty of them about just now) and have a philosophical debate. Really struggling? Ask a DM to possess one of the priests in the Cordor Chapel or the Nesek temple and join in. More fun than the forum.


 
      
The Peacock
 
PostPosted: Sat, Nov 14 2009, 14:57 PM 

User avatar

Player

Joined: 17 Feb 2007
Location: Patrollink ze borderz! Wo ist das Hahn!?

I'll use Meldrium as an example.

Many people think he's evil. In fact, he was voted third most evil on the server or something (thanks Amia)... But he's not. He acts completely out of good-heartedness for his patron Deity. And I execute that with the intentions of knowing he will be perceived as he is, but keeping it firm toward the Dogma of his Patron Deity...

Morally, some people think what he does is wrong. But to his standards, in comparisson with Tel'Quessir and his people, there is no grey area. His patron Deity orders him to kill all Dhaerow, exempting those of Eilistraee, without any hesitation.

So... Quite often times, that's what happens. Is this evil? Comparitively to others in the realms whether it be Human, Dwarf, Gnome, Hinn or Tiefling no. OOCly to people, yes. People who believe in equality, yes. But to the realms, he would be doing everyone a favor.

_________________
Image
'Ze Cock! Ze Cock ist shtill aut der!! Kapitulation feiern - NEIN DANKE!'


 
      
Cori
 
PostPosted: Sat, Nov 14 2009, 15:26 PM 

User avatar

Player

Joined: 10 Aug 2005
Location: Ottawa, Ontario, Canada

I'm going to re-state what some others said above though, and say that there is no *wrong* way to play your pally.

Neither humans NOR the gods are perfect. The gods can be petty, they squabble and fight amongst each other. They aren't perfect, they are just absurdly powerful. Might makes right, basically.

So even if you OOCly know the various things that might make you fall, not being perfectly strict to lore IC is still not "wrong". Its normal (I'd say "human" ...but I suppose you could be anything from an elf to a kobold, here on Amia). If you believe you are doing what's right, but your diety disagrees...so be it! Then you fall, you ICly learn something, you atone. Or you persist in thinking your diety is in the wrong, in which case you stay fallen, or turn away from your god possibly to another, or possibly to fall to darkness. Who knows! That's RP. And that's character development. But what it *isn't*....is playing a paladin "wrong".

The only way to play anything wrong, would be to flip out OOC because things don't go as you expected, and quit.

I for one, much as I *obviously* want to come out of an encounter "ahead", or with a "win", much prefer a chance of failure to at least exist. Whenever my BG goes about getting ehr epic fiend book, I intend to ask that whatever DM works on it with me inserts a chance to not succeed somehow. And if I fail, well, I guess I'll have to try again. Not the end of the world.

_________________
Role with the Punches...
Elan: A 10% chance is pretty unlikely, but everyone knows that a one-in-a-million chance is a sure thing!


 
      
BlackDahlya
 
PostPosted: Sat, Nov 14 2009, 15:34 PM 

User avatar

Player

Joined: 17 Aug 2005
Location: Land of the Scorching Sun, Empowered by Global Warming

I am actually curious to see you playing a paladin, Lath. Even though he would probably be similar to Meldrium in the sense of duty.

But if you really decide to play one, I hope to meet him and be on his good side, rather than meet him as an evil character. >_>;;


Anyway, I have to agree with Nekhy there. If I was not feeling so lazy (I kind of just woke up), I would make a forum search and add links to other previous threads discussing that.

Which reminds me... would a DM accompany a paladin's story on the PC Story forums or do they only accompany In Game paladin RP?

I am asking because I am actually curious (not worried or afraid of consequences, but genuinely curious) about the events that my paladin of Bahamut have been going through on the thread I have been writing.

Some DMs might still remember his story (he is an old character, albeit not as regularly played as my others) and this might help when accompanying what has been going on and probably making judgement calls.

If anything happens, I am pretty sure he will suffer the consequences in game, after I am back playing. Supposing the story is been accompanied, that is. I doubt the DMs would offer some guidance/ruling on the ongoing story. But if for some reason a DM has been accompanying that and wishes to do something about it, feel free to PM me and I will add whatever could be/is being the consequence as the tales are written.

Do not get me wrong. I am just curious, really!

_________________
BlackDahlya

Once Upon A Time Played
Adr'ael Ken'rahel, Auron Teken’ath, Aurora Mesodias, 'Daniel' Daoskinaxarijikkym, Eilin'ira, Helena Rios, Layla Faircurrent, May'Une Do'Ndar, Mellinda Tellus, Michael of Cliffside, Rizzen of Twilight, Valkirya d'Claddath


 
      
DolphinRacer
 
PostPosted: Sat, Nov 14 2009, 16:42 PM 

User avatar

Player

Joined: 01 May 2009
Location: GMT-8 Bangor, Washington

Being a paladin ruined my marriage! Okay well not really but it did in a sense. Being a paladin that completely puts his faith first is fun but hard. In one instance on another server it cost my character his fiance >.>

_________________
Sir Taelar Ardelyn of Wiltun
Winner of the Razor Tongued Award 2015!


Kira "Penny" Sigers
Better than Boulderdash!


 
      
Mr Mago
 
PostPosted: Sat, Nov 14 2009, 16:44 PM 

User avatar

Player

Joined: 26 Aug 2005
Location: Sweden

There's one important aspect to remember about Amia, when it comes to playing a Paladin:

- You can't smite evil at sight, because the evil, will pop right back up moments later.

It's not a constructive way of ensuring the survival of good and eradication of evil.

You'll have to think of other ways than just using your sword, if you want to spread good on Amia.

_________________
Darthion Illys

Join the Banites!


 
      
Yossarin
 
PostPosted: Sat, Nov 14 2009, 19:47 PM 



Player

Joined: 23 Jan 2006

Isn't it more honest for you to ask, "How do I make a paladin fall?"


 
      
Falling Spider
 
PostPosted: Sat, Nov 14 2009, 19:48 PM 

User avatar

Player

Joined: 29 Mar 2009

A question on torture, as this is a vague concept I've had for a while.

A paladin of say, Kelemvor. Instead of outright killing a sentient undead, he captures it and makes sure it's too weak to fight. He then experiments on said sentient undead for the purpose of determining weaknesses, how it works, etc. He takes this knowledge, makes sure it's written down, and spreads it throughout the Kelemvorite and civilian community.

Does it count as torture/anti-paladinism?

Quote:
"How do I make a paladin fall?"

Paladin has wiped his hands on the decorative hanging towels instead of the bath ones.

Paladin has fallen.

_________________
Gahnn Bluetusk
Aleksandr Vespermouth II
"Malnutrition is scarier than any beastie."


 
      
Mr Mago
 
PostPosted: Sat, Nov 14 2009, 19:55 PM 

User avatar

Player

Joined: 26 Aug 2005
Location: Sweden

Falling Spider wrote:
A paladin of say, Kelemvor. Instead of outright killing a sentient undead, he captures it and makes sure it's too weak to fight. He then experiments on said sentient undead for the purpose of determining weaknesses, how it works, etc. He takes this knowledge, makes sure it's written down, and spreads it throughout the Kelemvorite and civilian community.



Goooooooooooooooood... Anakin... Goooooooooooood.

_________________
Darthion Illys

Join the Banites!


 
      
A Majestic Dwarf
 
PostPosted: Sat, Nov 14 2009, 20:15 PM 

User avatar

Player

Joined: 09 Oct 2006
Location: Wales

That seems very much like "Greyguard" behavior.... not true paladin behavior. He may let other people study them on an "Ignorance is Bliss" way of working though and just do the smiting.

_________________
Avatar Picture from Brinawilliamson.com

Player of:
- Whurak Thunderhammer
King of Barak Runedar and all round Vengeful Dwarf
- Alvian Tegleiwalla
Nerdy Painter Elf with a Silly hat


 
      
Grymia
 
PostPosted: Sat, Nov 14 2009, 20:39 PM 

User avatar

Player

Joined: 14 Dec 2004
Location: Kohlingen, and a Basement in Canada

Aurora wrote:
That seems very much like "Greyguard" behavior.... not true paladin behavior. He may let other people study them on an "Ignorance is Bliss" way of working though and just do the smiting.


Paladins don't just need to be big dumb killing machines either.

Research is a VALID way to do what was being asked (not torture, justl ooking up/trading info with folks on what works for them when killing undead)


 
      
Mr Mago
 
PostPosted: Sat, Nov 14 2009, 20:51 PM 

User avatar

Player

Joined: 26 Aug 2005
Location: Sweden

"Experiment" on an undead?

Isn't that what they do in Tarkuul?

_________________
Darthion Illys

Join the Banites!


 
      
Grymia
 
PostPosted: Sat, Nov 14 2009, 20:52 PM 

User avatar

Player

Joined: 14 Dec 2004
Location: Kohlingen, and a Basement in Canada

Kinda.

Then again, trial and error in combat can work wonders as well. ^^;


 
      
Nekhy
 
PostPosted: Sat, Nov 14 2009, 21:13 PM 



Player

Just don't suggest studying undead like that for the Eternal Order. Unless you want to be smitten. And not in the nice sense!


 
      
A Majestic Dwarf
 
PostPosted: Sat, Nov 14 2009, 21:31 PM 

User avatar

Player

Joined: 09 Oct 2006
Location: Wales

Grymia wrote:
Aurora wrote:
That seems very much like "Greyguard" behavior.... not true paladin behavior. He may let other people study them on an "Ignorance is Bliss" way of working though and just do the smiting.


Paladins don't just need to be big dumb killing machines either.

Research is a VALID way to do what was being asked (not torture, justl ooking up/trading info with folks on what works for them when killing undead)


Oh I know that.... but in a religion such as the Kelemvorites, which ranges from Lawful Good to Lawful Evil, I can see the paladins having a "We leave the research to them guys, we don't ask, they don't tell" style of things.

_________________
Avatar Picture from Brinawilliamson.com

Player of:
- Whurak Thunderhammer
King of Barak Runedar and all round Vengeful Dwarf
- Alvian Tegleiwalla
Nerdy Painter Elf with a Silly hat


 
      
TormakSaber
 
PostPosted: Sat, Nov 14 2009, 21:54 PM 

User avatar

Player

Joined: 16 Dec 2004
Location: Somewhere

Can I lock this yet?

_________________
Davion Telemos - Monk of the Four Winds
Korthan Isharnos - Dragon Shaman of Thunder Spirit Zamasham


 
      
IronAngel
 
PostPosted: Sun, Nov 15 2009, 17:19 PM 

User avatar

Player

Joined: 29 Sep 2005
Location: Helsinki, Finland

I'll lock you for spam!

I think it's misleading to discuss whether this or that can be done. What's good for the goose is not good for the gander, and this applies to paladins:

Every situation is unique.

This is 100% true and has nothing to do with moral relativism or a black-and-white game world. I've explicitly stated it now, so you can't claim ignorance. You can't use that as an argument against me. If you want to refute my claims, find another argument; not that I suspect it to be easy. (I've said this many times before, and I've generally been falsely critisized by assuming I support some kind of moral relativism in the game; this is false.)

Act X can be realistically Good or realistically Evil. (It is never purely one or the other, but it's more on than the other anyhow.) However, this does not mean that a similar Act Y is the same. Paladin X saving Child A at the expense of losing invaluable information to save the world, is not the same act as Paladin Y saving Child B at the expense of losing invaluable information to save the world. Act X might be right for Paladin X, but it does not automatically mean Act Y is also right for Paladin Y.

The two are not identical. As long as there is even one difference, as slight as it may be, they're two different situations. And you cannot assume two different situations are judged the same. That's why it's misleading to look for specific guidelines and example scenarios to trust on. They might apply. But they also might not.

_________________
On Joon, Kjetta wrote:
The guy that probably has sexual fantasies about masturbation. I mean, Iron, you're a bookworm nerd that even in your wildest escapism fantasies flee to the internet to play the role of another bookworm nerd? Come on!


 
      
GreatPigeon
 
PostPosted: Sun, Nov 15 2009, 22:22 PM 

User avatar

Player

Joined: 04 May 2009
Location: London, UK

Properly done paladin- cool
paladin- meh
lame ass i know nothing about my diety paladin- *puke*

The best 'paladin' is a gray guard :)

_________________
The Peacock wrote:
[GreatPigeon] is better than me.


Uncle-Opustus wrote:
Just before I fall asleep, I like to pretend it's just a public feat so Pigeon can succeed in politics and save the world from poverty... with his unicorn and shining armour and Excalibur.


 
      
FA_Frey_XC
 
PostPosted: Tue, Nov 17 2009, 10:55 AM 

User avatar

Player

Joined: 18 May 2005
Location: XC HQ Alpha, Sol System, Sirius Sector.

IronAngel wrote:
I'll lock you for spam!

I think it's misleading to discuss whether this or that can be done. What's good for the goose is not good for the gander, and this applies to paladins:

Every situation is unique.

This is 100% true and has nothing to do with moral relativism or a black-and-white game world. I've explicitly stated it now, so you can't claim ignorance. You can't use that as an argument against me. If you want to refute my claims, find another argument; not that I suspect it to be easy. (I've said this many times before, and I've generally been falsely critisized by assuming I support some kind of moral relativism in the game; this is false.)

Act X can be realistically Good or realistically Evil. (It is never purely one or the other, but it's more on than the other anyhow.) However, this does not mean that a similar Act Y is the same. Paladin X saving Child A at the expense of losing invaluable information to save the world, is not the same act as Paladin Y saving Child B at the expense of losing invaluable information to save the world. Act X might be right for Paladin X, but it does not automatically mean Act Y is also right for Paladin Y.

The two are not identical. As long as there is even one difference, as slight as it may be, they're two different situations. And you cannot assume two different situations are judged the same. That's why it's misleading to look for specific guidelines and example scenarios to trust on. They might apply. But they also might not.


NWN & D&D DO NOT USE RELATIVISTIC MORALITY.

Thank you, Tormak, you can lock now.

:P

Regards,

_________________
Image
"Come under the flag of truce, and brook no treason... for mineself is Death, and care not whom knows mine touch."
- Frey Asaid'De Majere


 
      
Goblin
 
PostPosted: Tue, Nov 17 2009, 11:21 AM 

User avatar

Player

Joined: 02 Sep 2008
Location: Scotland

That's really the point, I've heard the argument over and over - to which I most certainly agree, that this D&D world in which we're playing where characters are encouraged to play by their chosen Deity's creed - doesn't really leave room for the grey areas - for Paladins. While I'd be willing to accept a settlement who give praise to say, Tymora - who'd be much better suited to Uthgar or Chauntea or something - but were founded by Tymorans and that's just the way it is - yet follow her ~ways~ very loosely, as it's quite impractical for them to do so to the letter.

Paladins do NOT have that luxury, if they did - they wouldn't be Paladins. Lets put it into some perspective, a Paladin is essentially the chosen champion of their deity - most of the time. They ~are~ the rockin', and they won't question what God McGod wants them to do. I mean who would? Skeptics? A Paladin can't be skeptical, they are the champions of their faith - the word of their patron is the law, if they act outside of it, it should be like stabbing themselves in the eye with something really painful.

Paladins by what ~we~ in the real world might know them aren't the same as FR Paladins, they're not even Jedi who get to do things just 'cause. They're Paladins, they're bound and the bondage goes beyond 'hmm, well maybe...', it'd definitive - it's true, it's Paladin-esque, it's (censored) righteous, man! PALADIN!

_________________
"O God of Earth and Altar,
Bow down and hear our cry,
Our earthly rulers falter,
Our people drift and die,
The walls of gold entomb us,
The swords of scorn divide,
Take not thy thunder from us,
But take away our pride."


 
      
The Peacock
 
PostPosted: Tue, Nov 17 2009, 12:09 PM 

User avatar

Player

Joined: 17 Feb 2007
Location: Patrollink ze borderz! Wo ist das Hahn!?

I hate people who think that making friends (IC) in this game is the most important thing. ESPECIALLY if they're a Paladin.

D'you think Elminster got where he was by hugging every Drow?! HMM!?!?

EDIT: The reality of this world is that there ARE stakes, there ARE known races that slaughter and rape. There ARE paladins who will simply kill someone who is detected of being evil.

Although, the belief is suspended because we allow Kobolds (known killer-reptiles) and Goblins, Orcs, and Drow walk the surface freely... I do have to say this: Not everyone deserves the right to be treated like a human, because not everyone is human.

_________________
Image
'Ze Cock! Ze Cock ist shtill aut der!! Kapitulation feiern - NEIN DANKE!'


Last edited by The Peacock on Tue, Nov 17 2009, 12:12 PM, edited 1 time in total.

 
      
Yurell
 
PostPosted: Tue, Nov 17 2009, 12:10 PM 

User avatar

Player

Joined: 06 Jan 2008
Location: ANU, behind the coffee mug (+10 GMT)

Even within the bounds of absolute morality there are acts that are debatabley good and debatabley bad ... doing a good deed for a bad reason may not earn you good kudos, for example, but doing it for a good may. D&D may not use relativistic morality, but there is still room for interpretation within the bounds of the absolute.

_________________
2009's Second Most Overall Contributing Player

يمكنني استخدام مترجم جوجل


 
      
Goblin
 
PostPosted: Tue, Nov 17 2009, 12:37 PM 

User avatar

Player

Joined: 02 Sep 2008
Location: Scotland

Just because a Paladin's action might be the least popular, say - slaying the Kobold babies - doesn't mean it's the wrong action. Those are things the Paladin must deal with, whether his comrades - who may not be Paladins - agree or not.

Nothing - NOTHING - can get between the Paladin and their code.

_________________
"O God of Earth and Altar,
Bow down and hear our cry,
Our earthly rulers falter,
Our people drift and die,
The walls of gold entomb us,
The swords of scorn divide,
Take not thy thunder from us,
But take away our pride."


 
      
Cori
 
PostPosted: Tue, Nov 17 2009, 16:53 PM 

User avatar

Player

Joined: 10 Aug 2005
Location: Ottawa, Ontario, Canada

Bear in mind this: Who taught the Paladin this code?

Did his/her god step down from their home plane, and say "Hey there Bob. I see you want to be my paladin. Great! Do this, this and this, but don't EVER do that, this, or most especially that. Oh, and if you see someone whom you detect as evil, kill them on sight, mmkay?"

I *suppose* there's instances where that might actually have happened....but that'd be pretty rare. A paladin would've learned their code through the church, and/or the paladin order they are a part of, *if* they are a part of an official paladin order. Which means they learned from people. People are not always perfect. People, even goodies like priests, might still have ulterior motives, or have teachings clouded by their own desires. The paladin might not be taught *perfectly* what to do and not do. They might not have even been taught everything they need to know. They might've been taught just the basics.

So a pally shouldn't know everything about what to do or not do. Not perfectly and accurately, at least. They might *think* they know perfectly of course. Heck, they very likely *will* think they know perfectly. I think that's rather a side effect of shoving that stick up their arse when they become an actual pally.

Also - the concept that pally's will auto-smite everyone whom they detect as evil is frankly...dumb. Half of any city they ever walk into would have to be smote instantly if they did that. Major politicians and nobles would be lying in blood regularly, I'd wager, if they did that. *Detecting* that someone has an evil aura shouldn't and wouldn't be good enough to kill them. Witnessing an evil act that is evil enough to justify execution (which granted, depending on the pally and/or their order, that action might not have to be all-that evil) - THEN it makes sense that they'd smite, MAYBE. Because there's also laws, and a pally walking up and smiting a noble in the middle of the streets, with a claim of having witnessed him steal candy from little sally....that very well might get the pally executed for murder.

Pally's should not be played as lawful-retarded any more than CE folks should be chaotic stupid.

_________________
Role with the Punches...
Elan: A 10% chance is pretty unlikely, but everyone knows that a one-in-a-million chance is a sure thing!


 
      
Goblin
 
PostPosted: Tue, Nov 17 2009, 17:05 PM 

User avatar

Player

Joined: 02 Sep 2008
Location: Scotland

Which is exactly the reason - why it is possible to play a Pally ~wrong~.

_________________
"O God of Earth and Altar,
Bow down and hear our cry,
Our earthly rulers falter,
Our people drift and die,
The walls of gold entomb us,
The swords of scorn divide,
Take not thy thunder from us,
But take away our pride."


 
      
IronAngel
 
PostPosted: Tue, Nov 17 2009, 17:07 PM 

User avatar

Player

Joined: 29 Sep 2005
Location: Helsinki, Finland

The latest posts are just talking past my point; they're in no way a reply to what I said, nor do they refute the very strong argument I make. (That is, the existance of absolute and real Good and Evil does not imply the simplicity, universality or purity of their manifestations. Most arguments are based on such a false assumption, and cannot survive the realization that it just isn't true.)

KingCreeper, you say you've heard the argument over and over. Did you read my argument? You certainly don't respond to it, let alone prove it wrong. You're talking about paladins in general, based on your opinion.

Sorry if I sound irritated, but I am: it really gets on my nerves that, over and over again, people fail to acknowledge my argument and respond to it. It would be fine if they disagreed! That's what interaction is about. But when they don't even seem to understand what I say or respond to it, it's rather frustrating.


You make a good point about paladins and their relation to their patron's dogma, but you also shoot yourself in the foot: you say there is no gray area for the paladin. Typically, this is is understood to mean that there's no gray area between good and evil, chaos and law. But you see beyond this: you say there's no gray area between the paladin's actions and the will of his patron.

We've established that paladins are above all obedient to their god. But now you run into problems: some say there's no gray area in regards to good and evil, and you say there's no gray area between the paladin and his god. However, you can't combine the two. The purity of Lawful Good and the immediate interests and orders of your patron god can and will conflict, sooner or later. There will be a time that you're forced to choose between doing what you think is good and right, and what you think is your god's will in the matter. And what you choose will not be clear, it will not be absolute: it is a very gray area. It may be there's no right answer, or that there are several. It may be that one solution is right for one paladin but wrong for another. Ultimately, it is between the god and paladin (IC), player and DM (OOC) to solve this case by case. You might be able to give general guidelines, but you will never be able to specify absolute and certain rules that apply to every potential situation: because every situation is unique.

As a side note about skepticism: I should think that many gods outright expect their paladins to be skeptical and doubtful, occasionally. Unwavering certitude is actually an unhealthy faith. If you read about the personal faith of many of the world's greatest champions of religion and moral, you'll find that they've faced serious crises that forced them to critically question their faith. Especially good gods, but I imagine evil ones too, would probably encourage their followers to be critical and honest to themselves. Only that way can they truly understand and embrace their personal faith and act as the paragons they're supposed to be. The will of a god is never clear, and a follower should always strive for better understanding by reviewing his beliefs and questioning dogma. In my opinion, a paladin who doesn't do that cannot be a paladin for very long. Fundamentalism is rarely honest or healthy.

And about playing a paladin wrong: this is impossible. I already said that above. How can you RP "wrong"? You play a person, and you make that person behave like you think that person would behave. If it's not how a paladin should behave - well, you've played a person who has failed as a paladin! Good for you, that's some serious character developement, right there! Just because your PC fails as a paladin IC, does not mean that you have played him wrong.

Edit: I also agree with Cori above.

_________________
On Joon, Kjetta wrote:
The guy that probably has sexual fantasies about masturbation. I mean, Iron, you're a bookworm nerd that even in your wildest escapism fantasies flee to the internet to play the role of another bookworm nerd? Come on!


 
      
Goblin
 
PostPosted: Tue, Nov 17 2009, 18:33 PM 

User avatar

Player

Joined: 02 Sep 2008
Location: Scotland

I actually believe I'm shoving forward a contrast of what you were saying Iron, you're trying to say it can't be black and white, and I'm trying to say that it absolutely has to be black and white. Whether you're annoyed or not a Paladin has to be a Paladin, if he walks a grey path then he's pretty much just another do-gooder warrior. Paladins adhere to a code, a strict code - they live a life of prayer and good. Compared to anyone else they really are supposed to be living saints. Tyr's clergy can be the wrathful sword of justice, or the protective shield of the law. A Paladin of Torm is the great defender, the virtuous, the disciplined - perhaps he will adhere to the code of his patron more than any other, he must heed and be loyal even if it means that people won't like him - oo'er! And to continue the Triad what about Ilmater? His Paladins might not be so eager to crush every baddy in the world, but they'll still stick to his holy scripture and save the sick and infirm. On the other hand, a Paladin of Ilmater might take the word more seriously and instead of curing and healing, go to the source and destroy whatever is causing the horrible-ness. Even if it's a Kobold with the sniffles who's spreading a curious plague through City X, I'm sure the Pally would do everything he could - to do the ~right~ thing.

Now boil all of that into the standing Triad (lets face it, they probably account for most of the Paladin population), you have the upstanding, lawful awesome of Tyr who won't hesitate to destroy the evil-do'ers just 'cause, and you have the unwavering loyalty of the Torm-machine who's bound so strongly to the code that it's unlikely he'd ever fail without some critical reason - and the compassionate resolve of Ilmater, who although will take on the weight of the burdened and ease the suffering of the sick or even just the hungry - along with his willingness to destroy the cruel and the wicked.

The idea that any of these Paladins would let an innocent child die for information to ~save the world~ is inconcievable, it may not be the wise or smart thing to do but I'm absolutely certain the Paladin would choose the right, hard way - than the quick and easy way. Saving the child, and in time the world also.

It's even more realistic to assume that the Paladin would WILLINGLY give his life instead, I'm frankly saying that the Paladin wouldn't even give in to doubt and allow himself to choose another path after seeing the right choice. It might appear ~retarded~ to the outsider who doesn't get his dedication to the word or to the man, but to him it will always be a simple choice. Do whats ~right~.

_________________
"O God of Earth and Altar,
Bow down and hear our cry,
Our earthly rulers falter,
Our people drift and die,
The walls of gold entomb us,
The swords of scorn divide,
Take not thy thunder from us,
But take away our pride."


 
      
Display posts from previous:  Sort by  
Forum locked This topic is locked, you cannot edit posts or make further replies.  [ 165 posts ]  Go to page 1, 2, 3, 4  Next


Who is online

Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 8 guests


You cannot post new topics in this forum
You cannot reply to topics in this forum
You cannot edit your posts in this forum
You cannot delete your posts in this forum

Search for:
Jump to:  
Powered by phpBB © 2000, 2002, 2005, 2007 phpBB Group