It's been so long since he's posted in anything but Announcements that he has to work through all of the old posts first.
_________________ ~Sharess on AmiaWiki~ Priestess, politician, prostitute "[They] were moving in on me like Sharessans on a new broad in the bath house" - Tracer Bolt AmiaWiki mod (mostly inactive)
Joined: 01 Jul 2006 Location: The City of Fallen Angels, Ca
Hehe. And I'm of the thought that they're useless. Sorry >.>
To me, thought bubbles are something fit for a comic or a book (in that case, the idea of thoughts being read) but not in game. But that's just me. ::shrugs::
Insults within them are even worse. They're cheap, cowardly and makes you, as a player, look like an ass.
Hehe. And I'm of the thought that they're useless. Sorry >.>
To me, thought bubbles are something fit for a comic or a book (in that case, the idea of thoughts being read) but not in game. But that's just me. ::shrugs::
Insults within them are even worse. They're cheap, cowardly and makes you, as a player, look like an ass.
Reminds me of the superhero with the power to.. read those thought bubbles!
But mostly, thought bubles can be fun in moderation but insulting stuff is just plain stupid and childish.
"OMG lok at me, i is insult1n u and u can not retort! lol!"
_________________ "Most assume that all the followers of Lathander are great morning people. They're very wrong." "I think we are the only group where AD&D stands for Attention Deficit Disorder."
There are interesting situations where a thought bubble works well. At Dusk Haven, my main character Valdor was to be bound to (see: married) Delin for 100 seasons, and he said "during which time we may have children". This was a public ceremony so she couldn't exactly blurt out anything aloud, but she did put up a nice thought bubble rather quickly too: . o O (Children? I hadn't even thought about that...) - it can be a way to participate in roleplay when it isn't appropriate for your character to speak.
There are interesting situations where a thought bubble works well. At Dusk Haven, my main character Valdor was to be bound to (see: married) Delin for 100 seasons, and he said "during which time we may have children". This was a public ceremony so she couldn't exactly blurt out anything aloud, but she did put up a nice thought bubble rather quickly too: . o O (Children? I hadn't even thought about that...) - it can be a way to participate in roleplay when it isn't appropriate for your character to speak.
Thanks, but no one in this thread had called into question the ability for people to make jerkass comments in thought bubbles.
If my other post sounds odd, it's because it was one sentence from a longer post on the subject. (It went, "I think blah blah blah. (insert quote) This is a great example of how blah blah. Blah blah what I was saying before.") Then I realized that I was replying to a discussion that had ended years ago, so I deleted all the other parts of it.
My post right here is also an example of how at times I consider an OOC explanation preferable to giving someone the impression an action had no IC basis.
If you absolutely must have thought bubbles for your character, you can send them to yourself as a Tell.
As I see it, there are more-elegant and less-elegant tools for characterization, but even the least refined of them is preferrable to a character that shows no signs of having an inner life whatsoever.
I don't recall using a thought bubble on Amia, but you know, the last time I saw someone else use one it wasn't the thought bubble that annoyed me. It was the several self-appointed arbiters of RP standing nearby who started spamming the talk channel with OOC remarks.
Joined: 06 Jan 2008 Location: ANU, behind the coffee mug (+10 GMT)
.oO(Hey! I can read minds!)
If you emote something, surely we can see it? What is the point of emoting a thought, if other's can't see?
*Looks at the child thoughtfully, his face expressionless except for a small shimmer in his eye*
Encourages RP (and yes I know I'm not the best emoter) far better than the thought bubble can.
_________________ 2009's Second Most Overall Contributing Player
As I see it, there are more-elegant and less-elegant tools for characterization, but even the least refined of them is preferrable to a character that shows no signs of having an inner life whatsoever.
I don't recall using a thought bubble on Amia, but you know, the last time I saw someone else use one it wasn't the thought bubble that annoyed me. It was the several self-appointed arbiters of RP standing nearby who started spamming the talk channel with OOC remarks.
Well that just illustrates the point even more clearly.
Granted, thoughts do give us insight into how a character functions, but the Talk channel is just too crowded a channel to deliver those insights, not to mention it confuses the hell out of people as to whether they can actually see something in a characters expression or eyes that hints at it.
I would prefer it if a player instead took that thought bubble and turned it into those cues that give other characters a subtle hint about their state of mind. But as with those players crowding the Talk channel with OOC messages that only serve to infuriate and not help, I just can't expect everyone to make the effort.
My thinking is that sending a thought bubble to yourself at least notes your character's gut reaction in the log (assuming you're hanging onto your log) and if you're really super at typing, gives you something on the screen to work with as you attempt to describe your character's feelings without plugging their brain into a flashing neon sign.
Thought bubbles can short-circuit the fun in role-playing and trying to figure out what the other guy is thinking (and maybe not succeeding every time) or trying to convey what your guy is thinking. That said, I don't recall the last time I saw one, except here on the forum.
If you emote something, surely we can see it? What is the point of emoting a thought, if other's can't see?
Well, this is probably the most common argument against thought bubbles, but it's also a poor one. We're not playing this game for the characters, we're playing it for ourselves, the players. It's like watching a movie or reading a book: you might as well ask what the point is in moving camera angle so as to show something interesting the character in the scene can't spot, or why an author should give insights into the backgrounds of the characters and places the protagonist encounters if (s)he doesn't know that about them. Just like films and books, RP is meant to entertain the players. Personally, I'll never understand or agree with the notion that RP is about pretending to be your PC and shutting off yourself. PCs are tools, pawns, characters to mess around with and do entertaining things to. As a player, I don't at all mind having more insights into the story than my character ever would, because I'm not my character and I don't want to be.
The point that emotes do a better job at encouraging RP is good, though. That's why I prefer them, as well. It means both parties have to make a bit of an effort to convey and interpret character intentions, and probably is more interesting. But I don't think thought bubbles should be condemned on the basis that other characters shouldn't see them; they don't, but players do, and that's the point.
_________________
On Joon, Kjetta wrote:
The guy that probably has sexual fantasies about masturbation. I mean, Iron, you're a bookworm nerd that even in your wildest escapism fantasies flee to the internet to play the role of another bookworm nerd? Come on!
Joined: 06 Jan 2008 Location: ANU, behind the coffee mug (+10 GMT)
I suppose it is a tad like the anti-language tags argument.
But the main thing I have against thought bubbles is the capacity to insult people. I can't do anything against:
.oO(You're an idiot)
But I can against
[Language I Can't Speak] You're an idiot
The latter I can demand to know what was said. The former, I suppose, I could respond with:
.oO(Oh look! A rock)
.oO(And another rock!)
.oO(I wonder how many rocks are here?)
.oO(1)
.oO(2)
And spam them like that until they get the point, or the ever-sarcastic:
.oO(I can read his thoughts! Can he read mine?)
.oO(Do you hear me yet?)
.oO(Do you hear me yet?)
.oO(Do you hear me yet?)
But my point is, it is needless insult that has no IC way of getting to your character, and thus must be directed at the player.
_________________ 2009's Second Most Overall Contributing Player
I completely agree. Even if there's nothing wrong with thought bubbles in principle, and they can theoretically be used to good effect (though I've not used them in three years), they're mostly just abused. Good taste and the genuine desire to entertain yourself and your fellow players (and I can't think many things that entertain me more than seeing others enjoy my writing) is what makes the difference between lame and OK.
_________________
On Joon, Kjetta wrote:
The guy that probably has sexual fantasies about masturbation. I mean, Iron, you're a bookworm nerd that even in your wildest escapism fantasies flee to the internet to play the role of another bookworm nerd? Come on!
I've seem thought bubbles that bring in humor or help you understand the character's facial reactions a bit better.
Most of the time I see something that could be IC, but because it's a thought, itn't reactable to.
Meh.
*Amazingly, Weston can't read thoughts and completely missed that!*
_________________ Weston Carter ~Salandran~ : Retired Carters Leave Amia
1) A long time ago I used a thought bubble to insult somebody. My character was p'd off and so was I ATM. In truth though in essence the thought bubble equated to both the feelings of my character and myself the player. I realize now all it probaly did was p off the player and thusly, probaly the character.
2) I do not like thought bubbles.
Now, I thought to myself after reading this, that there must be some reasons to insulting thought bubbles.
Maybe the player receiving insulting thought bubbles(Usually from character and player) should evaluate the reasons for receiving them. I for one never received an insulting thought bubble.
I can say that there have been cases when it seems that a player isn't necessarily making time fun for other players(this occus freqently in the UD), thus, instead of this player going in a tell and saying "You must be some complete idiot", instead it comes out oOThis person is a complete idiot.Oo
Now is this a good way to deal with it? Certainly not. But in all honesty there are not many ways to deal with a player you hate who owns a character you hate who can kick your characters butt.
But yes, there is a real easy way to not only make thought bubbles an actual part of RP, but even those silly insulting ones..........have mind readers.
The reason why in Menzobarranzan people can't even think bad thoughts in front of a Matron is cause usually a Matron mother can read thoughts....as well as illithids and all sorts of creatures.
This way if another person types oOwhat a complete idiot.Oo the response...just as it happens in the stories will be something to the effect of "Oh so you think I'm an idiot do you?"
Mind you only very few players should be allowed this power.
But since mind readers DO NOT nor ever will exist in Amia, all you'll get is some rule about which thought bubbles are allowed(Only nice thoughts), and which ones are not(ANY mean thought).
oO I think Thought bubbles should be nulled and disallowed altogether....BECAUSE there are no mindreaders about. Oo
Joined: 12 Oct 2005 Location: On a Disk, carried by four elephants, which stand on a gigantic turtle.
MagnumMan wrote:
There are interesting situations where a thought bubble works well. At Dusk Haven, my main character Valdor was to be bound to (see: married) Delin for 100 seasons, and he said "during which time we may have children". This was a public ceremony so she couldn't exactly blurt out anything aloud, but she did put up a nice thought bubble rather quickly too: . o O (Children? I hadn't even thought about that...) - it can be a way to participate in roleplay when it isn't appropriate for your character to speak.
This expresses my opinion on the matter.
_________________ I keels u with my axe!
"Do ye know where the Holy-Flamin' Frost-brand Gronk-slayin' Vorpal Hammer o' woundin' an' returnin' an' Shootin'-Lightnin'-out-yer-bum is?"
Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 11 guests
You cannot post new topics in this forum You cannot reply to topics in this forum You cannot edit your posts in this forum You cannot delete your posts in this forum