I was speaking with a freind, and he mentioned that the DM team said respawning is an IC action. I am just wondering if this is true. If this is true, does this mean that, any attack on cities is doomed to have no effect. Massive huge well planned attack on winya by orcs and drow, kills half the NPC population. what does the NPCs do? "press respawn" Or is it as I believe it is just a game mechanic, that really should not have any barring on IC actions and thoughts and so forth.
i believed i read recently in a thread, a DM state that respawning was an OOC thing, but lets see what they say
-in addition, your friend may be talking about being brought back to life, resurrection and such, which in PnP the soul must be willing, here in Amia, the same can applied, though this would mean permadeath unless I'm mistaken, -that- would be a IC choice
_________________ Alastrine -The Sword Mage
Ambrosius -The Cursed Crusader
Cáedere -The Emissary of Velsharoon
Lance Elliot Honestfellow The 3rd -The Scoundrel
Serwin of The Bloodfire Clan -The Bloodfire Dwarf
Solace -The Tainted Ranger
Weir- The Archer Hireling
Last edited by Stealth_Vicious on Sun, Apr 19 2009, 5:24 AM, edited 1 time in total.
Joined: 16 Jun 2007 Location: Leather chair, USA. Tell me about your mother.
I'm no pro, but I had it explained to me that it was one of those "if the soul is willing." things. Wanna stay dead? Right on. More air for me.
I'm pretty sure NPC's have been picked off (recently even) but as far as PC's are concerned, everyone treats death differently. Some people make it epic and sad, others pop on a band aid and skedaddle.
Frankly I doubt video games would be as popular if there wasn't a way to cheat death.
It's a good question, though I've got no clue what the official ruling is on it.
_________________ We are all here on earth to help others; what on earth the others are here for I don't know.
Respawning is only for PCs though, as far as I know. Dead NPCs don't get any fancy redo buttons
But yeah, I always saw pc's respawning as IC, as you go to the fuge plane, and for reason X get back to your home, or wherever you died.
well i would think that the button itself is purely OOC, it's a game mechanic, but the fuege plane or however its spelled is a way of dealing with the OOC-ness of it all, trying to give it reason? so maybe there is and IC-ness to it
_________________ Alastrine -The Sword Mage
Ambrosius -The Cursed Crusader
Cáedere -The Emissary of Velsharoon
Lance Elliot Honestfellow The 3rd -The Scoundrel
Serwin of The Bloodfire Clan -The Bloodfire Dwarf
Solace -The Tainted Ranger
Weir- The Archer Hireling
Joined: 26 May 2006 Location: Down Under, calculating your demise with blunt expressions.
Better to not be in a position to respawn in the first place I reckon. That way it's not really important whether it's IC or OOC because it's irrelevent.
Joined: 13 Aug 2005 Location: Oregon ('OR-ə-gən') [-8 GMT]
It's as IC as you can make it.
I had a lot of fun with another player when we both died in Caraigh. We ended up both having to respawn, and we sat around and conversed in the Fugue Plane until Reset. Since you don't ever remember anything that happens there when you're returned to life, it was sort of interesting. After we both wound up in Wiltun, we just sort of assumed that we were brought back there and revived by the Fisherman.
_________________ Those trees won't burn themselves down. (by Maryn)
Brought back by a random npc or whatever to the enxt best City and there raised then. That is as far as it goes IC.
Stuff like: I will magically disapear and reapear in the enxt city if you kill me and remember everything. Not so much.
_________________ "Most assume that all the followers of Lathander are great morning people. They're very wrong." "I think we are the only group where AD&D stands for Attention Deficit Disorder."
Joined: 18 May 2005 Location: XC HQ Alpha, Sol System, Sirius Sector.
Yea, and that's what inevitably the newer player who's digging so much the conflict RP fails to realize....
That person that just chopped off your goddamn head? Yea, your not going to remember much of that, because, well, YOU DIED FFS.
I really did like it before when Amia actually had a rule, or perhaps it was percieved as such, that when you died you lost the memory of the last, oh, just say 5 minutes before you got wacked.
Sure, you'll remember hating that SOB and having words.. but after that?
Dunno.
Now.. it's "I'll get you for killing me twice yesterday!"
"No you won't Bobo! !!! Not if I kill you first again!"
When you cannot die a permanent death, the line between conflict RP and griefing is very VERY fine, mah friends.
Regards,
_________________ "Come under the flag of truce, and brook no treason... for mineself is Death, and care not whom knows mine touch."
- Frey Asaid'De Majere
You can tell if two characters have an ongoing death grudge because, every time they fight the game music fades away to be replaced by some cheesy battle theme from Hercules or Xena. Bystanders beware, these hapless warriors typically miss a lot and accidentally hit you more than they do each other, so accordingly you have a limb loss probability greater than if you were in The Clone Wars and Revenge of the Sith.
That is how I go.
Sometimes I just hit the respawn because it's not going to matter so much past penalty what just happened. [probably me being stupid out solo].
But other times I've made it matter a lot. Something went well, blessed be [diety]. Try having your character afraid of death good and properly. Had a few respawns I've ignored and a few I've made matter because it just flows better for it to matter than be another "oh, oops, setback".
_________________ Weston Carter ~Salandran~ : Retired Carters Leave Amia
Joined: 12 Oct 2005 Location: On a Disk, carried by four elephants, which stand on a gigantic turtle.
I remember a conflict I got in with Ray Ray (Mr Rogers), back in the day. He tossed Xal off a cliff and kicked him around. Dispite how much it was tempting to run back and push him off the cliff, next time I saw him as Xal I didn't do a thing, just kept walking. It wasn't till much later, when Xal put together memories and from what others said happend, that he realised what had happend and whom to blame.
_________________ I keels u with my axe!
"Do ye know where the Holy-Flamin' Frost-brand Gronk-slayin' Vorpal Hammer o' woundin' an' returnin' an' Shootin'-Lightnin'-out-yer-bum is?"
Joined: 09 Feb 2006 Location: Queensland, Australia.
Lalelilolu wrote:
Frankly I doubt video games would be as popular if there wasn't a way to cheat death.
Diablo II in Hardcore mode had about 80% of the numbers that Softcore had, spread across all realms, the Asia realm having almost 120% of HC players compared to SC. It also sold over 1 million copies in only the first two weeks of it's release.
(For those unaware, Hardcore mode is basically when you die, it's permanent, there's no 'cheating' death, no raises, no second chances etc.)
_________________ Current characters: Nazeris Defir Malicar Drakespire
Over on Arelith they've got a 'Mark of Destiny' you get 10 lives (including whether you die from lag or whatever) and that's it. You get more xp and level faster but you basically undergo permadeath after your time is up. Very few people choose it, but those who do, really swear by it...
You have to choose the option upon character creation and you can't go back and change your mind if you don't like it.
_________________ Illithira Frostmaiden (Snow Elf) Guardian of the Frostfell Elithiel Issatheerin (Shadow Elf) She who Lurks Isolia Oussea'lylth (Sun Elf) Apprentice Wizardess
Over on Arelith they've got a 'Mark of Destiny' you get 10 lives (including whether you die from lag or whatever) and that's it. You get more xp and level faster but you basically undergo permadeath after your time is up. Very few people choose it, but those who do, really swear by it...
You have to choose the option upon character creation and you can't go back and change your mind if you don't like it.
I like this,... as long as raises/resurections don't count in it.
_________________ Click here for the navis & lukavi portraitpacks preview & download.
Joined: 09 Feb 2006 Location: Queensland, Australia.
belgianbonzai wrote:
soundofastream wrote:
Over on Arelith they've got a 'Mark of Destiny' you get 10 lives (including whether you die from lag or whatever) and that's it. You get more xp and level faster but you basically undergo permadeath after your time is up. Very few people choose it, but those who do, really swear by it...
You have to choose the option upon character creation and you can't go back and change your mind if you don't like it.
I like this,... as long as raises/resurections don't count in it.
I'm pretty certain it's the act of death that removes 1 life, not respawning. Else people would just log off when they died and wait for a server reset.
_________________ Current characters: Nazeris Defir Malicar Drakespire
Lovely way to grief others, to kill them a few times. Even in fully RP'd PvP it's quite possible for the smart. Very bad sports and cruel, but not impossible. I hope they got a way to revert some deaths, too. Or do they just ban people for "not really breaking the rules, but not really playing fair either"?
The addition has been especially applauded by those who play characters who tend not to enter dangerous situations, as the extra experience from the Mark of Destiny gives them more reward and incentive for simply roleplaying socially with others.
That said, i for one dont care what Arileth do or dont do.
The main reason for the not careing is... (see first line)
Yeah, but that doesn't mean they cannot have any good ideas at all like any server or module.
So their ideas COULD be a nice addition to amia (even though they might need adapting a few rules/parameters)
Only thing is that it takes Dev time, and DM's need to figure out which parameters to swap to amianize the ideas.
Anyway, I'm not going to promote the idea further, as it's not really the point of the thread. But if something like it would get implemented ever, I'm sure I would try it out.
_________________ Click here for the navis & lukavi portraitpacks preview & download.
oh no! Arelith rewards RP over OOC hunting! it must be a bad idea! don't take advice! oh no! they have -real- racial tension involving monstrous races! we better make ours giggly! or better yet.... Drizzts!
please don't respond with the usual "and lets make our characters die if they don't eat or drink" because thats not what I'm going for.
I suppose using Clinton as an example won't do any good... thats all I got.
That. Sure they might have some ideas. Infact it's great they have some. But lets not be cheap and just Rip them Off.
Amia has Amian ideas, version of things. Something might emerge, something might not. Amia rewards RP, but doesn't persecute 'those seen to be OOC hunting all the time' (which is a very easy to abuse definition).
And we don't have giggly monsters - go to Ultrinnan anytime and you'll see how frikkin giggly the drizzts are.
Do your research, fanboy.
_________________
Man, this account is over 10 years old. Where do I get my old man beard?
He can enjoy it all he likes. I just hate the way he wrote his argument, not taking earlier discussion into account (Ie, the quote) and then paints a strawman of the server and staff.
I just burnt the strawman.
_________________
Man, this account is over 10 years old. Where do I get my old man beard?
you don't think its a good idea to have the choice of limited lives for some kind of RP benefit?
there are a lot of people on amia who refuse to associate with anything arelith whatsoever. there are some things they do that could be made to fit amia well. The mark of destiny caters to the RP side of amia being for everyone.
I don't have an issue with the concept, its the method of communication used earlier! This is a much better statement, it caters for both spectra nicely.
_________________
Man, this account is over 10 years old. Where do I get my old man beard?
Joined: 30 Aug 2008 Location: Some planet known as Earth
I really like the xp-over-time system...it encourages people to rp to raise their xp amount..currently to raise your xp amount you hunt monsters for hours and engage in little to no rp due to buff duration.
..the issue with it is favoritism...and the fact that so many people are already lvl30, in arelith it works better for them because leveling is much slower.
Oh and I might like some Arelith script systems, and even some player rp style, but i loath their dm team with passion.
..and yes, JJJerm bans people if he feels like their doing something wrong, he's made it quite clear who 'rules' the place without exception... virtual dictatorship.
...which is why I huggle Amia all day long because of our 'semi-democracy', and 'need for proof' policies. Oh and the big one, second chances, for many people..warnings or temp banns, and other things for players.
..instead of always the black and white "Oh rule broke, permanent ban"
The rules here are also more open and able to slowly shift in time.
you don't think its a good idea to have the choice of limited lives for some kind of RP benefit?
there are a lot of people on amia who refuse to associate with anything arelith whatsoever. there are some things they do that could be made to fit amia well. The mark of destiny caters to the RP side of amia being for everyone.
Since it is entirely voluntary, and is something people choose for themselves rather than have forced on them by others, I think in this instance "there is nothing stopping you from deciding your own character is permanently dead after 10 deaths" applies here.
you don't think its a good idea to have the choice of limited lives for some kind of RP benefit?
there are a lot of people on amia who refuse to associate with anything arelith whatsoever. there are some things they do that could be made to fit amia well. The mark of destiny caters to the RP side of amia being for everyone.
Well, I disagree with that, honestly. IT's very abuseable and at the end of the day doesn't increase RP qualitatively. If you cna put together some rockhard stats that show me that it's the Mark improving RP and not simply the players involved, I might change my mind.
_________________ Davion Telemos - Monk of the Four Winds Korthan Isharnos - Dragon Shaman of Thunder Spirit Zamasham
A great way in increasing xp gained while RPing is to help people have fun.
_________________ Dwagin [Duh-wa-GIN] N. - 1a. Small and cute thingum, particularly fond of four legged scaled creatures of the metalic and chromatic varieties.
Joined: 11 Nov 2006 Location: A Clean, Well-Lighted Place
If you want to gain XP by RPing. This is what you do.
You RP doing something that would grant you XP. For instance, your a wizard and you do experiments or a WM sparring. Anything relevant.
Then, when a DM makes a daft shout asking if you have any requests, instead of your usual "a billion DCs" or "A pony", you send him/her a tell notifying him/her about your training RP.
We, at least I, really want to give plain and pure XP as a reward for this kind of RP, but we forget to. If you manage to request it, politely, and not demand it, you should be golden.
Of course, even if you catch me drunk on the client you will not be able to get more XP per hour this way compared to monkeystomping with Uce and Uncle-Opusuts, but still. It's a cool way of learning stuff.
_________________ To err is human; to forgive divine, but VENGEANCE IS MINE!
Players don't need fancy gizmos to get them to roleplay. All those are doing is imposing certain conditions which allow a player to enter a certain state of mind. But at any time if a player concentrates they can enter that same state of mind without any gizmos. The regularly roleplaying population of Amia would seem to indicate that when you work on your RP, you don't need to be Batman to be good at it.
Joined: 06 Jan 2008 Location: ANU, behind the coffee mug (+10 GMT)
Kjetta wrote:
If you want to gain XP by RPing. This is what you do.
You RP doing something that would grant you XP. For instance, your a wizard and you do experiments or a WM sparring. Anything relevant.
Then, when a DM makes a daft shout asking if you have any requests, instead of your usual "a billion DCs" or "A pony", you send him/her a tell notifying him/her about your training RP.
We, at least I, really want to give plain and pure XP as a reward for this kind of RP, but we forget to. If you manage to request it, politely, and not demand it, you should be golden.
Of course, even if you catch me drunk on the client you will not be able to get more XP per hour this way compared to monkeystomping with Uce and Uncle-Opusuts, but still. It's a cool way of learning stuff.
Yup there's that. If you're on at off hours it can be annoying, but persevere! Whenever a DM hops on, wave that little green wand of yours ... it will get you one, errr, 10/e of the way to the next level.
_________________ 2009's Second Most Overall Contributing Player
If you want to gain XP by RPing. This is what you do.
You RP doing something that would grant you XP. For instance, your a wizard and you do experiments or a WM sparring. Anything relevant.
Then, when a DM makes a daft shout asking if you have any requests, instead of your usual "a billion DCs" or "A pony", you send him/her a tell notifying him/her about your training RP.
We, at least I, really want to give plain and pure XP as a reward for this kind of RP, but we forget to. If you manage to request it, politely, and not demand it, you should be golden.
Of course, even if you catch me drunk on the client you will not be able to get more XP per hour this way compared to monkeystomping with Uce and Uncle-Opusuts, but still. It's a cool way of learning stuff.
Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 7 guests
You cannot post new topics in this forum You cannot reply to topics in this forum You cannot edit your posts in this forum You cannot delete your posts in this forum