Much as I'm fond of the occasional kamikaze can-I-solo-the-Whatever run, it's purest metagaming that I'm only doing it because reset/logoff time is impending and I know I'll not bite the respawn.
Going kamikaze is metagaming, but any action that has a 5% chance of death should be considered metagaming for all but extreme characters.
I've read a few times in this thread and have written it myself, that exploring by yourself because you don't find a partner is only fun if death is cheap. But hey, I enjoy reading "No, I won't go to B, I don't know it." from epic characters / epic forum members, so there really is no reason to go exploring on my own, right? Heck, I don't even know A well enough and it's much more welcoming to explorers.
And really, why do you care so much? Make it a rule; kill them if you spot it; let the servers log suspicious raising/swapping. Not all rules are hardcoded and people still are able to have fun playing.
Just don't touch my character when he's dead. That's inappropriate.
Sounds pretty good, Disco. My first instinct was to argue it, but I can't come up with anything better than that.
The only downside is that it'll make people hang around dead & afk more than they do now, which is a useless state and an unnecessarily filled server slot. But I guess that can't be helped.
Maybe someone has suggested this. I don't know, I might have missed it because my cookies are being all wierd and I can't keep track of posts since last visit. But...
How about making it so that if a character dies on one server, they can't be raised on the other? Scrolls and Spells wont work on misplaced bodies. Is that possible?
Joined: 06 Jan 2008 Location: ANU, behind the coffee mug (+10 GMT)
xordae wrote:
Sounds pretty good, Disco. My first instinct was to argue it, but I can't come up with anything better than that.
The only downside is that it'll make people hang around dead & afk more than they do now, which is a useless state and an unnecessarily filled server slot. But I guess that can't be helped.
Unfortunately that needs a DM to boot them. Or there could be a death timer - if you're dead for more than 30 minutes you get booted or something.
-Cloak-and-Dagger- wrote:
Maybe someone has suggested this. I don't know, I might have missed it because my cookies are being all wierd and I can't keep track of posts since last visit. But...
How about making it so that if a character dies on one server, they can't be raised on the other? Scrolls and Spells wont work on misplaced bodies. Is that possible?
Then you have problems if you die on A, change characters, and then want to play again later but A is full. I'm not particularly fond of the misplaced body check idea.
_________________ 2009's Second Most Overall Contributing Player
Tormy but what about in this scenario, you die on A or B, but there is an event for your character on the other server when you come back in 2 hours, and the server hasn't still reset? what then? are you for instance allowed to use a surface elf alt to represent your evil fanatical lolthlite yath because you can't raise one? and vice versa?
Joined: 06 Jan 2008 Location: ANU, behind the coffee mug (+10 GMT)
TormakSaber wrote:
I think it's a fine idea. If you died on A, you need to get ressed on A. Or etc.
Well, if the 'respawn' button is available on the other server it would be good ... I just don't want to spend 30 mins DCing into A just so I can go for some RP in ever-open B.
_________________ 2009's Second Most Overall Contributing Player
Tormy but what about in this scenario, you die on A or B, but there is an event for your character on the other server when you come back in 2 hours, and the server hasn't still reset? what then? are you for instance allowed to use a surface elf alt to represent your evil fanatical lolthlite yath because you can't raise one? and vice versa?
Uh, log on the correct server and respawn?
_________________ Davion Telemos - Monk of the Four Winds Korthan Isharnos - Dragon Shaman of Thunder Spirit Zamasham
Joined: 06 Jan 2008 Location: ANU, behind the coffee mug (+10 GMT)
TormakSaber wrote:
herkles wrote:
Tormy but what about in this scenario, you die on A or B, but there is an event for your character on the other server when you come back in 2 hours, and the server hasn't still reset? what then? are you for instance allowed to use a surface elf alt to represent your evil fanatical lolthlite yath because you can't raise one? and vice versa?
Uh, log on the correct server and respawn?
Good good.
So long as the respawn option works wherever I'm fine with scrolls/spells not working if you're not on the server where you died.
_________________ 2009's Second Most Overall Contributing Player
Joined: 06 Jan 2008 Location: ANU, behind the coffee mug (+10 GMT)
TormakSaber wrote:
You'll notice I said log on the correct server and respawn, correct server being the one you died on.
For varying definitions of 'correct' ...
That leaves the whole problem of spending half an hour spamming DC on A just to RP on B. I know I'd be willing to respawn immediately on entry to B, but if I had to wait half an hour to get on I'd be willing to wait the five minutes to get a free raise.
I think it is reasonable to use the 'respawn' button anywhere, but just to restrict scrolls and spells to the server you died on, or even the area.
_________________ 2009's Second Most Overall Contributing Player
Joined: 06 Jan 2008 Location: ANU, behind the coffee mug (+10 GMT)
Cori wrote:
Then don't log off while dead? Respawn as soon as you die, and you won't have this problem.
Well, if forced respawn is possible, I would say the best way would be if you log into the server you didn't die on you are automatically respawned. Much better than auto-booted.
_________________ 2009's Second Most Overall Contributing Player
Respawn would work the same way as it does now. The fiddle is to XP/GP drain; it'll happen at death rather then at respawn, and be refunded if there's a Raise in the same area.
The worst thing about the current setup is that I never know whether I'm raising a legitimate guy who died ages ago or a twunt from the other server who's not even cold yet. There's something about the way it makes other people unknowingly complicit that's extra annoying.
Disco's fiddle would clear that up, so I approve with a hearty heart.
Bias note: I respawn freely already so this doesn't affect me directly apart from the above. The maths of levelling when you're a mucky powergamer like me are such that respawning is always worth it unless there's less than X minutes till reset/logoff. Depending on how good a soloist I'm driving, X can be as little as 15 minutes or as much as 40, and that assumes I don't find a party in that time.
If you die, you are instantly hit with the gp/xp penalty (same one as now) and are only refunded if you are raised in the same area in which you died.
If you deliberately respawn, of course, you've already paid, wherever you decide to come back.
It's the other possibilities that I'm not sure on, but let me guess.
If you log out and log back in, you respawn in the entry (or perhaps your home area). If you log out and log back in to the other server, you respawn in that server's entry area (or your home area on that server). Being booted by reset would count as logging out. At its most basic, then, logging in (to either A or B) forces an auto-respawn for dead PCs.
I like Yurell's solutions of an auto-boot (or auto-respawn to the entry) in order to prevent people from going afk and just waiting for someone to happen by. I'd make it 15 rather than 30 minutes though.
I personally dont like respawn penalties. On the rare occasion that I do die, I usually log in as a different PC and wait for a raise in the entry at reset for the dead one. But I do that because I have the option to do it (and assuming that I dont need to get back in on my dead PC for some reason). I will, however, fully support this proposal, assuming that I've understood it properly. I think that at least some penalty should be levied for dying, and while I may be too chicken to impose it on myself, I'll agree to let the Chicken do it for me.
_________________ ~Sharess on AmiaWiki~ Priestess, politician, prostitute "[They] were moving in on me like Sharessans on a new broad in the bath house" - Tracer Bolt AmiaWiki mod (mostly inactive)
I like Yurell's solutions of an auto-boot (or auto-respawn to the entry) in order to prevent people from going afk and just waiting for someone to happen by. I'd make it 15 rather than 30 minutes though.
The only problem I see with this is if someone managed to survive and is on their way back with a rescue party to raise you. It may take longer than 15 minutes to Find people to help and make your way back to the fallen person.
_________________ Chiania Windleaf-nervous druid/shifter who's happily in love and married to her Seabird, with three "cubs". Darby Mirth-troubled half-elf with an interest in the sea. Kaci- short...moody... faithful of Lord Firemane.
Joined: 06 Jan 2008 Location: ANU, behind the coffee mug (+10 GMT)
Nakomis Wolfen wrote:
Xaviera wrote:
I like Yurell's solutions of an auto-boot (or auto-respawn to the entry) in order to prevent people from going afk and just waiting for someone to happen by. I'd make it 15 rather than 30 minutes though.
The only problem I see with this is if someone managed to survive and is on their way back with a rescue party to raise you. It may take longer than 15 minutes to Find people to help and make your way back to the fallen person.
Which is why I suggested half an hour. After being dead for half an hour you have used up the slot for long enough - you should either be made to respawn or booted.
_________________ 2009's Second Most Overall Contributing Player
Joined: 10 Aug 2005 Location: Ottawa, Ontario, Canada
Timers like that require a heartbeat script, which = LAG, which means it isn't happening, as it's been discussed for afk'ers many many times in the past.
Personally, I do not like the idea of implementing a penalty-on-death, instead of penalty-on-respawn. It feels like honest players are getting punished because of what a handful of friggin' cheating scumbags do. And when the cheating scumbags already get away with things they shouldn't, with DM team knowledge (usually because of badly designed rules allowing for loopholes), it makes it feel all the more like being honest maybe isn't the best way to do things on Amia.
I don't like that feeling.
_________________ Role with the Punches...
Elan: A 10% chance is pretty unlikely, but everyone knows that a one-in-a-million chance is a sure thing!
Joined: 06 Jan 2008 Location: ANU, behind the coffee mug (+10 GMT)
Cori wrote:
Timers like that require a heartbeat script, which = LAG, which means it isn't happening, as it's been discussed for afk'ers many many times in the past.
Personally, I do not like the idea of implementing a penalty-on-death, instead of penalty-on-respawn. It feels like honest players are getting punished because of what a handful of friggin' cheating scumbags do. And when the cheating scumbags already get away with things they shouldn't, with DM team knowledge (usually because of badly designed rules allowing for loopholes), it makes it feel all the more like being honest maybe isn't the best way to do things on Amia.
I don't like that feeling.
How about this - respawn penalty on death, no raising in the entrance way? That stops the server-swapping.
_________________ 2009's Second Most Overall Contributing Player
Timers like that require a heartbeat script, which = LAG, which means it isn't happening, as it's been discussed for afk'ers many many times in the past.
Personally, I do not like the idea of implementing a penalty-on-death, instead of penalty-on-respawn. It feels like honest players are getting punished because of what a handful of friggin' cheating scumbags do. And when the cheating scumbags already get away with things they shouldn't, with DM team knowledge (usually because of badly designed rules allowing for loopholes), it makes it feel all the more like being honest maybe isn't the best way to do things on Amia.
I don't like that feeling.
How about this - respawn penalty on death, no raising in the entrance way? That stops the server-swapping.
Joined: 06 Jan 2008 Location: ANU, behind the coffee mug (+10 GMT)
WonWon wrote:
Yurell wrote:
Cori wrote:
Timers like that require a heartbeat script, which = LAG, which means it isn't happening, as it's been discussed for afk'ers many many times in the past.
Personally, I do not like the idea of implementing a penalty-on-death, instead of penalty-on-respawn. It feels like honest players are getting punished because of what a handful of friggin' cheating scumbags do. And when the cheating scumbags already get away with things they shouldn't, with DM team knowledge (usually because of badly designed rules allowing for loopholes), it makes it feel all the more like being honest maybe isn't the best way to do things on Amia.
I don't like that feeling.
How about this - respawn penalty on death, no raising in the entrance way? That stops the server-swapping.
*Dies just before reset with party*
Someone is going to lose no matter what it is changed to.
_________________ 2009's Second Most Overall Contributing Player
Joined: 06 Jan 2008 Location: ANU, behind the coffee mug (+10 GMT)
Uberuce wrote:
I suspect the ratio of unfortunate deaths one minute before reset is somewhat lower than the number of serverhopped raises.
I would think that too ... I would imagine a lot of last minute deaths are also because people decide to take on something too big knowing that there will be no penalty if they fail and big rewards if they succeed, rather than simple and honest bad luck.
_________________ 2009's Second Most Overall Contributing Player
Joined: 10 Aug 2005 Location: Ottawa, Ontario, Canada
If someone is going to lose no matter hwat it's changed to, then don't change it.
I hate the usually-lame "If it ain't broke, don't fix it" line....but in this case, I really think it fitting.
Shouldn't be too hard to script up some sort of database in the DM admintools, showing where a person died, and where they got raised. There's already such a tracker for pvp kills.
So add a tracker like that, and then DM's smite to holy hell and back anyone who cheats by server swapping.
If the punishment is something extraordinarily harsh, like a 2 level loss, and half their gold, then I suspect that'll lower the number of cheaters quite a lot. And those who don't stop, can suffer the punishment for it.
But don't make a change that amounts to punishing people who don't cheat.
_________________ Role with the Punches...
Elan: A 10% chance is pretty unlikely, but everyone knows that a one-in-a-million chance is a sure thing!
Joined: 06 Jan 2008 Location: ANU, behind the coffee mug (+10 GMT)
Cori wrote:
If someone is going to lose no matter hwat it's changed to, then don't change it.
I hate the usually-lame "If it ain't broke, don't fix it" line....but in this case, I really think it fitting.
Shouldn't be too hard to script up some sort of database in the DM admintools, showing where a person died, and where they got raised. There's already such a tracker for pvp kills.
So add a tracker like that, and then DM's smite to holy hell and back anyone who cheats by server swapping.
If the punishment is something extraordinarily harsh, like a 2 level loss, and half their gold, then I suspect that'll lower the number of cheaters quite a lot. And those who don't stop, can suffer the punishment for it.
But don't make a change that amounts to punishing people who don't cheat.
But that also tracks down people who log and then log in later on the other server for RP, or form simply not wanting to DC into A for so long ... you would need to track each individual case as to where and when they died, where and when they got raised and where and when they went after that. It seems like a lot more work and just as much collateral damage as no raising in entryway.
_________________ 2009's Second Most Overall Contributing Player
Timers like that require a heartbeat script, which = LAG, which means it isn't happening, as it's been discussed for afk'ers many many times in the past.
Personally, I do not like the idea of implementing a penalty-on-death, instead of penalty-on-respawn. It feels like honest players are getting punished because of what a handful of friggin' cheating scumbags do. And when the cheating scumbags already get away with things they shouldn't, with DM team knowledge (usually because of badly designed rules allowing for loopholes), it makes it feel all the more like being honest maybe isn't the best way to do things on Amia.
I don't like that feeling.
It was said that the XP and Gold lost on death will be returned when raised, so I doubt it'll be that much of an issue for honest players.
Joined: 10 Aug 2005 Location: Ottawa, Ontario, Canada
Well, they made a dm widget that shows a history of your items, tracking each thing from dropped->(picked up by) Bob->merchant (that Bob sold it to) -> Jimmy (who bought it from the merchant) -> Suzy Q (who obviously got it from Jimmy somehow).
So if the database can handle numerous transfers like that, and store them, I think it's much LESS difficult to make a nice simple Bob died on B @ 23:00, raised on A at 23:01 table. It wouldn't need to be fancy, and WE don't even need to know what it actually shows, as players. It'd be a tool, not a be-all and end-all, for the DM's.
I'd rather Disco make a tool to catch cheaters, than script in a penalty that affects non-cheaters just as much or moreso, than cheaters. After all, the cheaters are just as likely to ask for a metagamed raise from a friend, which means they'd still NOT get penalised, where the non-cheaters wouldn't do that, because it'd be cheating, and so they'd be the ones getting shafted the most out of the change.
The bottom line is, nothing is ever going to outright put an end to cheaters, just like nothing is ever going to put an end to pvp griefers. There's no point putting things in that will hurt NON cheaters, because the cheaters will just find another way to cheat. Best thing that can be done, is for the DM's to be extremely harsh to cheaters, and add in tools that will help them do their jobs more easily.
Punishing honest people is only going to push them away to other games or servers.
_________________ Role with the Punches...
Elan: A 10% chance is pretty unlikely, but everyone knows that a one-in-a-million chance is a sure thing!
Minor flaw in your logic: I don't use the database for item tracking.
Anyway, what would happen we simply disable resting in the Entry and don't allow you to jump back to your point of dying once you go through the mirror? I guess that both counters the rest/buff exploit, and the solo death cheat.
At least: I wouldn't fancy to jump into a group of critters that just killed me with 1 HP.
I say we shouldn't just leave it as it is. It happens too often. A lot of newbs do it. People don't all bother to read the rules and the DMs can't be everywhere.
While I think an XP dock isn't the best solution (they will have to hunt more & die more which just creates more of this problem), there should be a script that alerts the DMs to these transgressions.
There should be a penalty for death. And, as I pointed out previously, people dont like penalties and will avoid them if possible. I would prefer to be forced to bear the penalty because I will only rarely accept it voluntarily. Yes, the game will glitch occasionally, but **** happens.
As well, it may address some of the beefs about Amia that people have, such as slowing levelling (only by a small amount, admittedly). I also see the point about a 30 minute boot-timer, but if it takes a heartbeat script, forget it. There is still the metagamed rescue of dead folk, but that's a different issue.
_________________ ~Sharess on AmiaWiki~ Priestess, politician, prostitute "[They] were moving in on me like Sharessans on a new broad in the bath house" - Tracer Bolt AmiaWiki mod (mostly inactive)
Joined: 10 Aug 2005 Location: Ottawa, Ontario, Canada
Dev Disco wrote:
Minor flaw in your logic: I don't use the database for item tracking.
Anyway, what would happen we simply disable resting in the Entry and don't allow you to jump back to your point of dying once you go through the mirror? I guess that both counters the rest/buff exploit, and the solo death cheat.
At least: I wouldn't fancy to jump into a group of critters that just killed me with 1 HP.
Okay, assumed that was database related. There is however the pk tracker, which is in Admintools (or used to be...I assume it's still there). Surely a "Death Tracker" could be made that works in a similar fashion, showing what server a person dies on and is ressed on?
Either way, disabling magic and resting would only marginally help, because the fugue plane already has both disabled, but heal kits are an easy way around that. They don't register as magic, so you can heal kit yourself to full, then continue on your way.
As to penalties, yeah, I very much don't like them, because with limited time, it *ISN'T* easy as pie to make up for them. And really, it's not an IC penalty to lose a handful of gold and some xp. It's very much an ooc penalty. It's IC penalties, that people generally want to see from death. Trauma, fear, physical weakness, memory loss. That sort of thing.
And since death by spawns happens so damned frequently, and for so many reasons (ill-prepared, bad luck with 1's or 20's, lag), I don't even consider or rp those as death, but rather as being knocked out in battle, or defeated and left to suffer in humiliation, whatever. PvP death I rp as being death (assuming it's supposed to be death), and dependant on the circumstances, I choose to rp weaknesses or trauma, or fear, or whatever. THAT is generally what most people who complain about no death penalty are referring to.
Losing xp and gold for a simple death to a spawn, is nothing more than an inconvenience of varying degree based on individual play times, and individual skill with building and such. Personally, I don't even see much point in having it, and don't think anything would change if it were completely removed altogether, except for some people being a lot happier. After all, in PvP, when it actually should matter, you don't suffer the penalty anyway.
_________________ Role with the Punches...
Elan: A 10% chance is pretty unlikely, but everyone knows that a one-in-a-million chance is a sure thing!
As to penalties, yeah, I very much don't like them, because with limited time, it *ISN'T* easy as pie to make up for them. And really, it's not an IC penalty to lose a handful of gold and some xp. It's very much an ooc penalty. It's IC penalties, that people generally want to see from death. Trauma, fear, physical weakness, memory loss. That sort of thing.
I remember a module I played in that when you died, you'll be smacked with temporary negative status modifiers for a reasonable amount of time. I think that may be the closest to the IC penalties you describe.
If a way can be done for such effects to remain on server swap, I suppose that can stop people who were just ressed from rushing straight back into battle...
O.o I done that.. meh, I done that many times. I am sorry for it, but it is kind, grrrrrrrrr now I need to log another character and wait until reset so I can level this one. I took the easy road out. Sorry, wont do it again.
I remember a module I played in that when you died, you'll be smacked with temporary negative status modifiers for a reasonable amount of time. I think that may be the closest to the IC penalties you describe.
If a way can be done for such effects to remain on server swap, I suppose that can stop people who were just ressed from rushing straight back into battle...
Or would it?
Unfortunately, status effects don't carry over in server swaps. They would need to be re-applied when you log in to the other server. That is, if you swap before the effects (and the associated 'is recently recovered' flag) expire, you would have to get the full timer's worth of negative status on the other server as well. If you wait the requisite time for the effects to expire and then go back, you don't get them again.
In LOTRO (just for example) you are always 'defeated' not killed because hitpoints are represented by morale. When you're out of morale, you have to retreat (it's respawn by another name) within ten minutes or wait for someone to rally/revive you.
As to penalties, yeah, I very much don't like them, because with limited time, it *ISN'T* easy as pie to make up for them. And really, it's not an IC penalty to lose a handful of gold and some xp. It's very much an ooc penalty. It's IC penalties, that people generally want to see from death. Trauma, fear, physical weakness, memory loss. That sort of thing.
I remember a module I played in that when you died, you'll be smacked with temporary negative status modifiers for a reasonable amount of time. I think that may be the closest to the IC penalties you describe.
If a way can be done for such effects to remain on server swap, I suppose that can stop people who were just ressed from rushing straight back into battle...
Or would it?
Ressurection Sickness like in WoW, their version of respawnign without being revived [well, or being a ghost and running back to your body]. [[World of Warcraft]]
_________________ Weston Carter ~Salandran~ : Retired Carters Leave Amia
I remember a module I played in that when you died, you'll be smacked with temporary negative status modifiers for a reasonable amount of time. I think that may be the closest to the IC penalties you describe.
If a way can be done for such effects to remain on server swap, I suppose that can stop people who were just ressed from rushing straight back into battle...
Or would it?
Unfortunately, status effects don't carry over in server swaps. They would need to be re-applied when you log in to the other server. That is, if you swap before the effects (and the associated 'is recently recovered' flag) expire, you would have to get the full timer's worth of negative status on the other server as well. If you wait the requisite time for the effects to expire and then go back, you don't get them again.
In LOTRO (just for example) you are always 'defeated' not killed because hitpoints are represented by morale. When you're out of morale, you have to retreat (it's respawn by another name) within ten minutes or wait for someone to rally/revive you.
Hmm.. Yes, that would be quite harsh, but quite plausible. How about giving it a reasonable enough time to wear off? Just enough so that you cannot rush head on instantly, while also not being too long for it to be a drag. 3-5 RL mins?
I was thinking not just respawn, but the penalty should apply to all forms of revival, whether respawn or resurrection.
Didn't Amia have this a long time ago? I remember not being able to walk very fast and I think haveing some stats decreased after getting defeated in pvp.
_________________ Chiania Windleaf-nervous druid/shifter who's happily in love and married to her Seabird, with three "cubs". Darby Mirth-troubled half-elf with an interest in the sea. Kaci- short...moody... faithful of Lord Firemane.
Yeah in NWN daze for any length of time isn't much fun. You'd be better off with a -20% STR and CON debuff. That is, if you have 18 STR and 12 CON, you lose 3 STR (3.6 rounded down) and 2 CON until you've recovered. It should be taken from your base stats however, not base + equipment stats. Otherwise your equipment also suffers a debuff when you come back from the brink, and that doesn't necessarily make any sense.
Joined: 09 Nov 2006 Location: The Hive Ward, Sigil
Unfortunately, it's countered by Restoration, I think. Probably exploit-o-licious.
_________________ Morgan Blancrest: The Rage from The Cage Lucas Baker: Humble Swordsman Wesley Fletcher: Greasemonkey Extraordonaire Also known as: EmoPinata
Joined: 10 Aug 2005 Location: Ottawa, Ontario, Canada
How about, people choose to rp whatever weakness/penalty/etc they feel is appropriate, ratehr than forcing something mechanical on people?
Yeah, a lot of people won't do this without encouragement. Yeah, some won't do it even *with* encouragement.
Work with people, talk to people, and see if they'll maybe acede to rping a penalty/weakness/whatever. If they refuse, then you decide how to handle that fact. If it's too annoying to you that they refuse to rp any sort of weakness, then YOU choose how you'll interact with that person.
Penalties come across as a punishment to some people. Others may enjoy penalties, and feel it brings more realism to the game. Amia is not about being hardcore rp/realism. It's about the FREEDOM TO CHOOSE how hardcore you wish to rp.
Do what you find enjoyable. Allow others to do what THEY find enjoyable, and don't worry about whether it's as hardcore as you like, because THEY are not YOU.
_________________ Role with the Punches...
Elan: A 10% chance is pretty unlikely, but everyone knows that a one-in-a-million chance is a sure thing!
Unfortunately, it's countered by Restoration, I think. Probably exploit-o-licious.
Restoration by default doesn't remove any Supernatural-type effects. As long as the effects have a temporary duration though, they'll expire when the time runs out.
That's not to say you can't offset the effects by (getting a) casting (of) Bulls Strength and Endurance, or swigging a potion of each. But you'll have less stats than if you hadn't got killed.
Cori wrote:
How about, people choose to rp whatever weakness/penalty/etc they feel is appropriate, rather than forcing something mechanical on people?
They already get a mechanical Vulcan dopeslap. I think after ten or more of those, they might want something that is, you know, a little more liveable.
Why reward players at all for killing monsters? Is it to give them an incentive to kill the monsters in the first place? Or is it simply to reward them for the time they've spent on this server rather than another one?
Why then penalise them when they get killed by monsters? Is it a form of balance or is it motivational?
There are no wrong answers to these questions, but to be honest I don't think anyone stops to think about them because they either accept what comes about when someone else answers those questions and creates a rule for this game based on it, or they don't accept it and try to reason out a new rule that doesn't cause mass dissatisfaction.
Maybe i'm just being a hard ass, but why not just make it harder to get raises so people think twice about running into the spires solo as a -20 lvl and then are like "CRAP". I think people maybe more inclinded to form proper hunting parties and not be so cavalier while soloing. Why not also raise the price of scrolls and attach deities to raises, isn't the actual raise spell suppose to be soemthing that requires a bit of time and energy and would not be accepted from opposing deities?
Another thought, give a raise spell an ambush roll, that there is a chance of being ambushed since raising someone isnt like snapping your fingers. Personally i don't think raises should be some matter of fact... with so many other spells like GS being nerfed because its just to powerful to run around with an epic summon and buff with no consequenses... why not raise or ressurect? require spell components like timestop. I mean, lets be honest, raise and ressurect ARE the single most powerful spells in all of D&D and/or AMIA. What's more powerful that givng a someone back the gift of life?
Here's yet another thought, you die and lose gold % but not xp, but when you respawn you respawn to the fugue plan, and the only option is to return to your home bind?
And lets not ignore our portal rods, if we didnt have portal rods we would tend to be more careful running around a "RP" server hunitng. Can someone tell me how a simple fighter can use a "magical" rod of porting and read a raise scrolls.
I love Amia don't get me wrong, but lets stop calling it a RP server when it cleary is set-up to be a "best-of-both-worlds" RP and Action/PvP server. IMO the best senario and marriage that i have yet to see.
Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 20 guests
You cannot post new topics in this forum You cannot reply to topics in this forum You cannot edit your posts in this forum You cannot delete your posts in this forum