View unanswered posts | View active topics * FAQ    * Search
* Login 




Forum locked This topic is locked, you cannot edit posts or make further replies.  [ 163 posts ]  Go to page Previous  1, 2, 3, 4  Next
Zante
 
PostPosted: Mon, Feb 23 2009, 18:19 PM 

User avatar

Player

Joined: 06 Jan 2006

Azrael wrote:
Saying there is 'absolutely no way to get past any guard in any town' is just plain ooc'ness, and doesn't belong on any roleplay server.


None says this. (Well, the rules and dm's don't) What they are saying is to get a dm to determine if you get past or not. I sneaked into various places my character was not allowed into by getting a dm to observe the rp, it's possible.

_________________
Image


 
      
Dwagin
 
PostPosted: Mon, Feb 23 2009, 18:38 PM 

User avatar

Player

Joined: 08 Aug 2006
Location: The Land of Nod

I'm sure the people would still be freaked out.

xD

_________________
Dwagin [Duh-wa-GIN] N. - 1a. Small and cute thingum, particularly fond of four legged scaled creatures of the metalic and chromatic varieties.

-Extraordinarily ordinary in the mostest of ways.


 
      
Yurell
 
PostPosted: Mon, Feb 23 2009, 20:27 PM 

User avatar

Player

Joined: 06 Jan 2008
Location: ANU, behind the coffee mug (+10 GMT)

Zante wrote:
Azrael wrote:
Saying there is 'absolutely no way to get past any guard in any town' is just plain ooc'ness, and doesn't belong on any roleplay server.


None says this. (Well, the rules and dm's don't) What they are saying is to get a dm to determine if you get past or not. I sneaked into various places my character was not allowed into by getting a dm to observe the rp, it's possible.


That. They're saying that you as the player has no right to determine if ou succeed or not - you can try but ultimate a DM must decide whether it works or not.

_________________
2009's Second Most Overall Contributing Player

يمكنني استخدام مترجم جوجل


 
      
Azrael
 
PostPosted: Mon, Feb 23 2009, 20:47 PM 

User avatar

Player

Joined: 30 Aug 2008
Location: Some planet known as Earth

Yurell wrote:
Zante wrote:
Azrael wrote:
Saying there is 'absolutely no way to get past any guard in any town' is just plain ooc'ness, and doesn't belong on any roleplay server.


None says this. (Well, the rules and dm's don't) What they are saying is to get a dm to determine if you get past or not. I sneaked into various places my character was not allowed into by getting a dm to observe the rp, it's possible.


That. They're saying that you as the player has no right to determine if ou succeed or not - you can try but ultimate a DM must decide whether it works or not.


I'm ..glad you agree with me? ..not much else to say. ;)

The statement means: If someone were to say this, I'm letting them know it's not for the better of a rp server. OOCly it might be viewed as if there is no dm on then that statement becomes true temporarily until the counter measure (aka a dm) logs on to fufill the role.

_________________
Lalelilolu wrote:
*Po-tee-weet?*
Night is just another day without light.


 
      
Zante
 
PostPosted: Mon, Feb 23 2009, 20:51 PM 

User avatar

Player

Joined: 06 Jan 2006

Was not aimed at you, just used your quote to sum up my/your point. :)

_________________
Image


 
      
Evil-Wizard
 
PostPosted: Mon, Feb 23 2009, 21:40 PM 

User avatar

Player

Joined: 28 Jan 2009

Kjetta wrote:
Without reading all of this, I will agree with the notion that the culture of Amia can be hard to get. There's a lot of premises that we take for granted that you really need to discover as a newbie to our community.


Good lord, somebody understood the problem.

If the energy spent in this thread to flame was used to copy and paste the one, f'ing little sentence I posted two pages ago, the issue would be solved for good.

Some people might think about wether the "culture of Amia" is to behave like arrogant idiots or about building and maintaining a friendly community.


 
      
555444333
 
PostPosted: Mon, Feb 23 2009, 22:00 PM 

User avatar

Player

Joined: 08 Oct 2005
Location: Czechia

I'll be perfectly friendly but I refuse to answer stupid questions. Maybe if you spent more time immersing yourself in the culture rather than walking in and expecting everyone to fall over themselves explaining every cultural nuance as you enter?

I mean honestly most of us who have been here for awhile don't even realise we are part of this distinct culture, it's just how Amia is you see?

Its the same with real life cultures to. Like Kjetta said, we cant explain most of our culture to you because we can't think of it from outside?

_________________
ImageJys'zyne Do'larn


Man, this account is over 10 years old. Where do I get my old man beard?


 
      
Eighty-One
 
PostPosted: Tue, Feb 24 2009, 0:32 AM 



Player

Joined: 18 Jan 2009
Location: Bangalore, India

Evil-Wizard wrote:
Kjetta wrote:
Without reading all of this, I will agree with the notion that the culture of Amia can be hard to get. There's a lot of premises that we take for granted that you really need to discover as a newbie to our community.


Good lord, somebody understood the problem.

If the energy spent in this thread to flame was used to copy and paste the one, f'ing little sentence I posted two pages ago, the issue would be solved for good.

Some people might think about wether the "culture of Amia" is to behave like arrogant idiots or about building and maintaining a friendly community.


I believe what most people are saying is there's no necessity really to post that "one f'ing sentence" seeing as it is basically covered in the other two rules of "No Metagaming" and "Common Sense". One of the principles of the Amian Rules is that they aren't too specific so as to give off the impression of being constricting and detracting from the free RP environment that's the aim of the server. The worry is the effect might snowball into specifying every little thing that can go wrong, and result in groan-worthy statements like "You have been booked under item #247.3 of the Amian Law. You have the right to put your head between your legs and kiss your a** goodbye.".

All this said, Evil-Wizard kind of has a point about how harshly we came down on the OP and anyone who supported "the other side". In those very rules we are debating, there is a simple sentence like this which should be just as respected:

Quote:
If you have questions please don’t be afraid to ask a DM or post on the forums


Which would imply that we the established community shouldn't do/say anything (like what's been demonstrated in this thread) that might cause the newbies to have any fear of asking questions or educating themselves about the new culture they're about to get into.

_________________
~ Alexandria Do'Maetri, Champion of Tyr
~ Glam Snowfell, of mysticism and magery


 
      
555444333
 
PostPosted: Tue, Feb 24 2009, 1:58 AM 

User avatar

Player

Joined: 08 Oct 2005
Location: Czechia

Hypothetical Player wrote:
ha but I've gone native. I don't find the questions make sense anymore. It's just the way things are? Why are you asking questions? You are upsetting the order of things. Why are you doing that? What's wrong with you?


End result: This

_________________
ImageJys'zyne Do'larn


Man, this account is over 10 years old. Where do I get my old man beard?


 
      
Evil-Wizard
 
PostPosted: Tue, Feb 24 2009, 5:29 AM 

User avatar

Player

Joined: 28 Jan 2009

You prefer flaming people?


 
      
Yurell
 
PostPosted: Tue, Feb 24 2009, 5:38 AM 

User avatar

Player

Joined: 06 Jan 2008
Location: ANU, behind the coffee mug (+10 GMT)

Evil-Wizard wrote:
You prefer flaming people?


I believe he was being facetious.

It is fine to ask questions, but I believe most of the 'flaming' in this thread came up because of people arguing that the way things are on Amia are wrong, and then comparing to normal FR, which is 'right'.
I used to hold this opinion too, until I realised normal FR isn't crawling with lvl 30's, so why would the guard be the same as the normal FR guard?

The definition of metagaming is assuming the reaction of the NPCs: even if they have no hope of catching you, you don't know that, and they need their chance to react (please note, the 'you' here isn't referring to you, evil-wizard, but as a replacement for 'one' which looks horrid).

People may have come on harshly because they believed that you were saying "the NPCs shouldn't be able to do this anyway so I'll ignore that they may be able to". It could be a misinterpretation, but that's how it read to me, and if it is a misinterpretation (referring to our statement on page one, of course) I do apologise.

_________________
2009's Second Most Overall Contributing Player

يمكنني استخدام مترجم جوجل


 
      
Talon
 
PostPosted: Tue, Feb 24 2009, 5:45 AM 

User avatar

Player

Joined: 18 Feb 2006
Location: Texas, where else?

Xavier wrote:
I'd rather have most of the PC's on Amia become official FR Canon then anything written by Ed Greenwood or that Drizzt guy.


You do realize without either of those authors we wouldn't have an FR as we know it? Before Ed Greenwood there wasn't FR, and before Salvatore there wasn't an Underdark culture, there was simply a paragraph of text about Dark Elves and I think 2 modules that had evil Dark Elves in them.

_________________
Image


 
      
Nourm
 
PostPosted: Tue, Feb 24 2009, 6:40 AM 

User avatar

Player

Joined: 11 Feb 2009

I wanted to mention that although some people here are stating that unwritten rules such as "no Drow in Cordor" are braindead obvious, it took me a *very* long time before I ever found out of that rule. I mean, I actually never knew it was illegal to run into a city you're not allowed in even if you're stealthed/invised/GS'd/whatever.

The whole guard thing; it's logical, yes, certainly. But it takes a certain kind of imagination and understanding of the Amian metagaming mentality to comprehend. So I wouldn't be outright raging at a player who maybe isn't even new, but perphaps new to playing a Drow, for stealthing into Cordor and assuming it makes sense that he can stealth there.

I believe that calling that rule "common sense" is really a pretty vast exaggeration.


 
      
Yurell
 
PostPosted: Tue, Feb 24 2009, 6:42 AM 

User avatar

Player

Joined: 06 Jan 2008
Location: ANU, behind the coffee mug (+10 GMT)

Nourm wrote:
I wanted to mention that although some people here are stating that unwritten rules such as "no Drow in Cordor" are braindead obvious, it took me a *very* long time before I ever found out of that rule. I mean, I actually never knew it was illegal to run into a city you're not allowed in even if you're stealthed/invised/GS'd/whatever.

The whole guard thing; it's logical, yes, certainly. But it takes a certain kind of imagination and understanding of the Amian metagaming mentality to comprehend. So I wouldn't be outright raging at a player who maybe isn't even new, but perphaps new to playing a Drow, for stealthing into Cordor and assuming it makes sense that he can stealth there.

I believe that calling that rule "common sense" is really a pretty vast exaggeration.


When I first started I walked up to the gates and the guards told me to pike of. That was my hint that I wouldn't be allowed in there.

_________________
2009's Second Most Overall Contributing Player

يمكنني استخدام مترجم جوجل


 
      
Nourm
 
PostPosted: Tue, Feb 24 2009, 6:46 AM 

User avatar

Player

Joined: 11 Feb 2009

Yurell wrote:
Nourm wrote:
I wanted to mention that although some people here are stating that unwritten rules such as "no Drow in Cordor" are braindead obvious, it took me a *very* long time before I ever found out of that rule. I mean, I actually never knew it was illegal to run into a city you're not allowed in even if you're stealthed/invised/GS'd/whatever.

The whole guard thing; it's logical, yes, certainly. But it takes a certain kind of imagination and understanding of the Amian metagaming mentality to comprehend. So I wouldn't be outright raging at a player who maybe isn't even new, but perphaps new to playing a Drow, for stealthing into Cordor and assuming it makes sense that he can stealth there.

I believe that calling that rule "common sense" is really a pretty vast exaggeration.


When I first started I walked up to the gates and the guards told me to pike of. That was my hint that I wouldn't be allowed in there.


Again, you are missing my point. Yes, it was an indication that the NPC guard would not open the gate for you. It is not an indication that the guards are all-powerful and cannot be sneaked past under any circumstance. You are taking your comprehension of Amia's metagaming mentality for granted.

Many people like myself are a bit new to the concept. A lot of us are used to having the game function technically. That would mean that the guards would actually have to become hostile, see you, and kill you/kick you out. However, as I have already found out, on Amia (and I'm sure other RP servers) you often have to use your imagination and act as if the guards would do so. It's not so obvious if you try and look at it from my perspective.


 
      
Yurell
 
PostPosted: Tue, Feb 24 2009, 6:53 AM 

User avatar

Player

Joined: 06 Jan 2008
Location: ANU, behind the coffee mug (+10 GMT)

Nourm wrote:
Yurell wrote:
<snip>


When I first started I walked up to the gates and the guards told me to pike of. That was my hint that I wouldn't be allowed in there.


Again, you are missing my point. Yes, it was an indication that the NPC guard would not open the gate for you. It is not an indication that the guards are all-powerful and cannot be sneaked past under any circumstance. You are taking your comprehension of Amia's metagaming mentality for granted.

Many people like myself are a bit new to the concept. A lot of us are used to having the game function technically. That would mean that the guards would actually have to become hostile, see you, and kill you/kick you out. However, as I have already found out, on Amia (and I'm sure other RP servers) you often have to use your imagination and act as if the guards would do so. It's not so obvious if you try and look at it from my perspective.[/quote]

That's why the "don't metagame" rule is there - you don't know that they can't see you. With that rule, combined by the guard's evident dislike for me, I believe it was quite a logical progression to realise that I was not allowed in there.
Of course, it wasn't until months later I realised I could go into Cordor South but that's another story.

To be fair, the definition of metagaming provided in the sidebar doesn't state that this includes assuming what NPCs do, but I think it is a reasonable enough assumption.

_________________
2009's Second Most Overall Contributing Player

يمكنني استخدام مترجم جوجل


 
      
Evil-Wizard
 
PostPosted: Tue, Feb 24 2009, 7:22 AM 

User avatar

Player

Joined: 28 Jan 2009

Yurell wrote:
That's why the "don't metagame" rule is there - you don't know that they can't see you.


Aaaaactually, this is, funnily, metagaming.

In the game, the guards don't see you. It's possible to sneak into Cordor as an invisible drow (so I assume - didn't try so far) without the guards noticing/attacking you.

But as it turns out, we, the players, are expected to assume they (maybe) do. This is on the outgame, player basis. This outgame/player knowledge/rule is expected to be acted upon, changing how your character acts and perceives the game world.

It's fine and all... but it's just not in the rules as they read to a newcomer.

---

I suspect the term metagaming is used slightly differently on Amia compared to P&P gamers, or under vastly different circumstances.

Metagaming in the traditional meaning of the word is, though I expect violent protest against this, perfectly okay in many cases.

If, e. g., your characters are just about to start a journey to some faraway place, but you as players know that there's a reset in five minutes, you might make your characters wait/prepare a little while so as not to be thrown back to your starting place by the reset. This is a clear case of metagaming - player knowledge changes character behaviour.

Players apparently ask about character levels here before partying to avoid the 5-level-gap-XP-penalty-mechanism, and their characters act accordingly. Again a case of metagaming - the characters have no concept of levels, XP or being in a party or not.

Sticking to certain rules or expected behaviours here requires a certain amount of metagaming in the traditional use of the word.

---

To me, it seems "don't metagame" means "don't do something I don't like" in Amia-speak. Fine and all - each community has its own language. It's not a good basis to formulate rules on, though, as it may be ambigious, even contradictory to whatever you're trying to say.

As I said before: Making my character behave AS IF the guards reacted to him is a definite case of metagaming in my (P&P) understanding; citing a "don't metagame" rule to state this point sounds just... absurd.

Again, before somebody gets it wrong (again): I don't question the rule. I'd just think it wise to put it in the rules section in a way understandable to those who don't already know what it's supposed to mean.

The TE broke a rule without knowing it, I would have done the same in his case (in fact, I already had a GS expedition into the drow city on my to do list), and frankly, there was little chance to know about this (except asking, which is, as 55whatever pointed out, isn't proper behaviour on Amia, as asking questions upsets the holy order of things).

Some people stated it was too much effort to put everything into rules. That may or not be true - the effort used to shout down the question asked here, however, shows that there's much energy to be used for something constructive here, e. g. for clearing up the rules section.


Last edited by Evil-Wizard on Tue, Feb 24 2009, 7:31 AM, edited 2 times in total.

 
      
xordae
 
PostPosted: Tue, Feb 24 2009, 7:25 AM 

User avatar

Player

Joined: 01 Jul 2005
Location: Germany

Well put, Evil-Wizard.. and this is why it feels arrogant to hear people talk about "how everyone knows how it's supposed to be".


 
      
Yossarin
 
PostPosted: Tue, Feb 24 2009, 7:52 AM 



Player

Joined: 23 Jan 2006

I'm just waiting, Evil, to see if it takes more than three pages for you to convince everyone that people who were like me when I came to this server, a total n00b to NWN and pretty much the DnD setting in general, often require things to be spelled out. Not because we're dense, but because we have the genuine defense of not knowing any better.


 
      
Yurell
 
PostPosted: Tue, Feb 24 2009, 8:00 AM 

User avatar

Player

Joined: 06 Jan 2008
Location: ANU, behind the coffee mug (+10 GMT)

Evil-Wizard wrote:
Yurell wrote:
That's why the "don't metagame" rule is there - you don't know that they can't see you.


Aaaaactually, this is, funnily, metagaming.

In the game, the guards don't see you. It's possible to sneak into Cordor as an invisible drow (so I assume - didn't try so far) without the guards noticing/attacking you.

But as it turns out, we, the players, are expected to assume they (maybe) do. This is on the outgame, player basis. This outgame/player knowledge/rule is expected to be acted upon, changing how your character acts and perceives the game world.

It's fine and all... but it's just not in the rules as they read to a newcomer.


It's not so much as assuming they can detect you as not assuming they can't, but I do see where you are coming from.

Some rules are difficult to arrive at logically (see Numbers' 'immersion' argument), but all in al people are pretty willing to accept "sorry I'm new" or "sorry I didn't know" as a reasonable excuse (or at least, I am and most people I know / DMs I've interacted with are).

_________________
2009's Second Most Overall Contributing Player

يمكنني استخدام مترجم جوجل


 
      
Nourm
 
PostPosted: Tue, Feb 24 2009, 8:18 AM 

User avatar

Player

Joined: 11 Feb 2009

Evil Wizard has a good explanation, though when I was talking I was mainly talking from personal experience. When I was a complete noob here (I am now just a standard noob), I would have never guessed that "Don't metagame!" = "Don't stealth past the guards in a city you're not allowed in because the guards actually can see you and theoretically would throw you out even though they never show any signs of spotting you or do anything at all".

Just like Evil Wizard, I am not arguing the rule itself. I (now) understand the rule and the idea. However, as previously mentioned, if someone (like Yurell I guess) figured the above all out by themselves, by all means power to them. I certainly didn't.


 
      
BlackDahlya
 
PostPosted: Tue, Feb 24 2009, 8:32 AM 

User avatar

Player

Joined: 17 Aug 2005
Location: Land of the Scorching Sun, Empowered by Global Warming

Just in case.

http://www.amiaworld.net/about/rules.html

_________________
BlackDahlya

Once Upon A Time Played
Adr'ael Ken'rahel, Auron Teken’ath, Aurora Mesodias, 'Daniel' Daoskinaxarijikkym, Eilin'ira, Helena Rios, Layla Faircurrent, May'Une Do'Ndar, Mellinda Tellus, Michael of Cliffside, Rizzen of Twilight, Valkirya d'Claddath


 
      
Yurell
 
PostPosted: Tue, Feb 24 2009, 8:36 AM 

User avatar

Player

Joined: 06 Jan 2008
Location: ANU, behind the coffee mug (+10 GMT)

Yes, but once more, to be fair
Quote:
Do not metagame. Metagaming includes asking for a raise OOC, sending tells for help, and having a player port directly to your dead character with the purpose of raising it. Players caught doing this will be docked one level, and have half their gold taken. Multiple offenses will result in a ban from the game.

doesn't really tell people who are new to RP that they can't just assume that the guards don't see them ... there's nothing there about NPCs at all.

We may say it is obvious and unnecessary, but I suppose I will shift my contention - it wouldn't hurt to have a 'do not assume the guards' reactions' in there.

_________________
2009's Second Most Overall Contributing Player

يمكنني استخدام مترجم جوجل


 
      
BlackDahlya
 
PostPosted: Tue, Feb 24 2009, 8:41 AM 

User avatar

Player

Joined: 17 Aug 2005
Location: Land of the Scorching Sun, Empowered by Global Warming

Yurell wrote:
Yes, but once more, to be fair
Quote:
Do not metagame. Metagaming includes asking for a raise OOC, sending tells for help, and having a player port directly to your dead character with the purpose of raising it. Players caught doing this will be docked one level, and have half their gold taken. Multiple offenses will result in a ban from the game.

doesn't really tell people who are new to RP that they can't just assume that the guards don't see them ... there's nothing there about NPCs at all.

We may say it is obvious and unnecessary, but I suppose I will shift my contention - it wouldn't hurt to have a 'do not assume the guards' reactions' in there.


Quoted from the link I put up above.

Quote:
The gameworld
Only DMs hold the right to decide the actions of NPCs (Non-Player Characters), deities, or any other entities active and present in the world of Amia. This includes stories posted in the PC Story forum. The use of non-NwN material in game is not mandatory, nor is knowledge of D&D lore a requirement to play on Amia. No player can be forced to play by any other rules than those included in NwN game and Amia module, or those set by the DM staff.

_________________
BlackDahlya

Once Upon A Time Played
Adr'ael Ken'rahel, Auron Teken’ath, Aurora Mesodias, 'Daniel' Daoskinaxarijikkym, Eilin'ira, Helena Rios, Layla Faircurrent, May'Une Do'Ndar, Mellinda Tellus, Michael of Cliffside, Rizzen of Twilight, Valkirya d'Claddath


 
      
Yurell
 
PostPosted: Tue, Feb 24 2009, 8:44 AM 

User avatar

Player

Joined: 06 Jan 2008
Location: ANU, behind the coffee mug (+10 GMT)

BlackDahlya wrote:
Yurell wrote:
Yes, but once more, to be fair
Quote:
Do not metagame. Metagaming includes asking for a raise OOC, sending tells for help, and having a player port directly to your dead character with the purpose of raising it. Players caught doing this will be docked one level, and have half their gold taken. Multiple offenses will result in a ban from the game.

doesn't really tell people who are new to RP that they can't just assume that the guards don't see them ... there's nothing there about NPCs at all.

We may say it is obvious and unnecessary, but I suppose I will shift my contention - it wouldn't hurt to have a 'do not assume the guards' reactions' in there.


Quoted from the link I put up above.

Quote:
The gameworld
Only DMs hold the right to decide the actions of NPCs (Non-Player Characters), deities, or any other entities active and present in the world of Amia. This includes stories posted in the PC Story forum. The use of non-NwN material in game is not mandatory, nor is knowledge of D&D lore a requirement to play on Amia. No player can be forced to play by any other rules than those included in NwN game and Amia module, or those set by the DM staff.


Exactly, but lack of action? I connected it up pretty easily but there are several people here who have stated that the leap in logic is not as intuitive as it would appear to someone who has been 'immersed' in the game fora while.

_________________
2009's Second Most Overall Contributing Player

يمكنني استخدام مترجم جوجل


 
      
Cori
 
PostPosted: Tue, Feb 24 2009, 9:23 AM 

User avatar

Player

Joined: 10 Aug 2005
Location: Ottawa, Ontario, Canada

Evil-Wizard wrote:
(except asking, which is, as 55whatever pointed out, isn't proper behaviour on Amia, as asking questions upsets the holy order of things).


Utter nonsense. ASK all the questions you want. Amians can be astoundingly helpful, when ASKED a question.

To me, this:

Moridan_X wrote:
how about u guys update ur rules with more clearly defined rules, cuz i see a few rules that DMs are enforcing that aren't even on the rule topics

i find it stupid that people are getting busted over rules that aren't on the rules...


is not a question, it's a rather hostile and rude flame-bait post. Such things tend to get responded to in much the same way. A question, or a polite suggestion, often goes significantly further - though we do unfortunately also have a few people who'll post rudely and unhelpfully to polite suggestions as well. You'll learn to ignore them. Or flame their arses 'til their char-broiled.

And then things like this:

Evil-Wizard wrote:
If they should, in fact, be high or even epic level, that's - to be honest - a design decision very badly reflected in the game world


are again, to me at least, not a question, but rather an attack on the server, from someone who obviously has no idea WHY this might be the case. A question would perhaps be: "Is there a reason why the guards here are high level, and quite powerful?"

You don't have to like or agree with the answer. But to immediately jump to insulting the server (and therefore the dev's and DM's who are responsible for the guards being high level, by extension), well, it's not the best way to get a good reaction from people. And it's definitely not the way to get a suggestion noticed by those who might make the changes you want. Good way to get such suggestions ignored though.

_________________
Role with the Punches...
Elan: A 10% chance is pretty unlikely, but everyone knows that a one-in-a-million chance is a sure thing!


 
      
Lally
 
PostPosted: Tue, Feb 24 2009, 9:49 AM 

User avatar

Player

Joined: 16 Jun 2007
Location: Leather chair, USA. Tell me about your mother.

Yossarin wrote:
I'm just waiting, Evil, to see if it takes more than three pages for you to convince everyone that people who were like me when I came to this server, a total n00b to NWN and pretty much the DnD setting in general, often require things to be spelled out. Not because we're dense, but because we have the genuine defense of not knowing any better.


Yes.

I first came here 2 years ago. My knowledge of DnD came from teen years of tabletop sessions(long time ago folks..) and playing on a server 1/3rd the size of this one. I remember one of my charries having their pretty ghost out and being completely ganked by a bunch pf druids. I was upset, I was pissy...and I was told that druids don't like undead summons. I had -no- idea this was the case, but I got "duh'd" to hell and back.

Before portal wands were IC, I ported out of an area that was a bit dicey thinking..hah..I'm a genius! A very friendly player informed me this was bad form. Nicely, I might add.

I remember performing a bard song in Cordor, only having people ask me to roll a perform check afterward. I was like...huh? Didn't you like it? I rolled like a 7. I get a tell. "Shame, I thought that was really well done." I swore off di rolls after that, and some folks still swear BY it. Grey area.

Ya live, ya learn. Maybe the original poster didn't have the nicest way of putting it but frankly there are so many damn unwritten rules people go by it's impossible, time consuming and probably filled with grey areas. I don't envy anyone who wants to undertake it.

I think it's up to us as players when we see someone being a "LOL NOOB" to tell then what the dealio. I see people being helpful more often than not.

In my Amian experience, and even in this thread, people are more than happy to lend a hand, and only a small percentage of players roll their eyes when I have no idea what the counter to a di roll is.

_________________
We are all here on earth to help others; what on earth the others are here for I don't know.


 
      
Evil-Wizard
 
PostPosted: Tue, Feb 24 2009, 9:57 AM 

User avatar

Player

Joined: 28 Jan 2009

Cori wrote:
is not a question, it's a rather hostile and rude flame-bait post. Such things tend to get responded to in much the same way.


..., which is why it's better to prevent "rude flame-bait posts" by telling people what to do or not to do in the first place. The TE was angry because he was told he broke some rule not published. Ask yourself if you wouldn't be. The proper reaction would be to prevent misunderstandings like that in the first place.

Cori wrote:
A question would perhaps be: "Is there a reason why the guards here are high level, and quite powerful?"


Let me explain my (apparently wrong) assumtion:

In P&P games, the all-powerful NPC's (esp. city guards) are a common, and equally commonly known rookie DM's mistake. When PC's happen to run of the rail tracks and threaten to "ruin the adventure" or *gasp* use their powers, some DM's resort to the overpowering NPC's to make it all go away.
This usually backfires pretty soon, when the PC's/players start to ask why they should risk their arses hunting down some orc bandits when the NPC's that force them to are ten times as powerful.

You can struggle to rationalize the railroading, but "Elminster's got better things to do" gets worn down pretty quickly, especially if he'd be able to fix the problem faster than finding and instructing some PC's to do so.

If a DM didn't even introduce some Elminster character, but gives a run of the mill city guard demi god like powers, the "got better things to do" explanation requires some constant, epic threat as well, and as a consequence, the PC's powers, adventures and importance are dwarfed by the much more epic and important struggle of the NPC's.

This very problem has been an important design decision in the Eberron Campagin Setting ("Make the PC's the heroes."), has been a factor in Dark Sun before (although not spelled out this openly in the CS, it's perfectly accepted for the PC's to completely change the game world there) and has been a major arguement with the Forgotten Realms critics for years, if not decades by now.
I, naive as I am, assumed this mistake hadn't been made here, as most things seem thought through pretty well, esp. on the mechanical side. A wrong assumtion, as I've learnt in this thread, and I'm a bit disappointed to hear about it.

But well, maybe I'm completely wrong here and this isn't the pattern I've seen so many times before, so please tell me:

What IS, in your opinion, the reason are high level and quite powerful, yet let goblins and kobolds burn down farms while they stand around in the city? Waiting for the drow invasion? And why is there no hint in the game world about a threat like that?

I'll be very happy if there is a good reason.


 
      
xordae
 
PostPosted: Tue, Feb 24 2009, 10:16 AM 

User avatar

Player

Joined: 01 Jul 2005
Location: Germany

From my understanding, one city guard model = 10 or 20 actual guards. Just like there are no NPC traders and farmers and townspeople running around town if you don't imagine them, it makes sense that the guards represent a much larger guard force with the help of a couple of guard models across the area.

Although this gets a little dodgy as soon as a guard is possessed by a DM to apprehend some PC villain. The PC will then be in the situation of possibly getting shackled, dragged off, shown to the gates or even killed by a single or by very few guard NPCs. Now DMs could make it appear that there are usually a few more invisible guards around. Sometimes they do, sometimes they don't. So I don't know how much weight the explanation carries.

'Course, the OOC reason is that guards have to be able to put up a fight, be competitive with dice rolls against epic characters and all that jazz. Personally, I liked it more when Cordor was PC guard exclusive but I've ranted about that at length previous times.


 
      
Cori
 
PostPosted: Tue, Feb 24 2009, 10:51 AM 

User avatar

Player

Joined: 10 Aug 2005
Location: Ottawa, Ontario, Canada

Quote:
Ask yourself if you wouldn't be. The proper reaction would be to prevent misunderstandings like that in the first place.


I ask myself, and I answer myself that "No, I wouldn't be. I'd instead say: Okay, I didn't know that. Now I do. Thanks."

Because I can acknowledge that i'm not a god, nor an all knowing seer, and thus, such things as not knowing a rule are quite bound to happen.

As has been pointed out, it isn't possible to list every last possible eventuality.

That said, I'd be all for them changing the rules to include a specific mention of not breaking into a city without DM's involved, or something generic to that effect.

As to the blah blah about pnp....I didn't read it, nor shall I. Not to be rude, but it frankly, isn't relevant. This is not pnp. Gods, it isn't even D&D. It's NWN, a game based on D&D (and rather loosely so). It doesn't have craploads of things from pnp. It'd generally be wiser to approach an online NWN PW based on what you read about it, and can find out about it, not based on how it would be if it was pnp and dm'd by you.

As to the last bit, about why the guards are high level and powerful: It's because Amia has been around for many years now. It's had long periods of time where guards WERE just empty statues who did pretty much nothing, and were ignored. And Cordor was INSANE. Utter madness. Hellballs in the streets, a new PERSON (yes, person. Half the time it wasn't even a faction, or group of friends....just a single powerbuild) waltzing in and killing everyone and everything and declaring that they'd taken over.

Something needed done. Higher level guards, placed all over the place, and brought to life frequently, and made to DEAL with these people, was the less than perfect, but pretty much only possible, IC solution. And yes, a single guard is in fact supposed to represent many, just as a single random npc is supposed to represent many, and the small visible "Cordor" is supposed to represent an actual city, not a small collection of buildings smaller than my ridiculous little hometown.

As to why they don't run off and solve all the islands problems? Frankly, it a)isn't their job - they're hired to guard the town. And b)They're kept busy enough GUARDING THE TOWN. Since they're, y'know.....GUARDS. You're the adventurer - YOU can go risk your life and limb dealing with the many threats on the large island of Amia. Off note: I haven't seen any burned down farms, personally, within Cordor's immediate sphere of influence. If you have, it must have been a DM event. You are making a LOT more, it seems, of the MINOR ANNOYANCE the scattered goblins and kobolds *near* Cordor actually offer. The orc chosen head is a starter quest. It's given, not because the orcs are invading daily, but because a starter quest was deemed necessary, and thus, it's there. And the fact you get what? 1000 gold and a cheap raise scroll, for doing it? That, in a gameworld where pc's toss MILLIONS of gold around like pebbles in a stream, should show you that the guards don't really care much whether you do or do not kill the Chosen. It's more like "Meh, some annoying caravan driver complained to me for HOURS about the stupid orcs. Maybe I can make the guy shut up and leave me alone by suckering one of these dumb adventurers into killing the orc boss......Hey you, adventurer. Want a thousand *snicker* shiny gold coins? ooooh, shiny! Just go kill that orc, and they're all yours!"

Lastly, there's plenty of hint in the gameworld that there's threat of a drow invasion - though I've no idea why you decided to single that out. There's an underdark. There's Drow. You likely frequently see them on the surface. What more, precisely, do you need? A written precis detailing their next plot? Player driven world. There's nothing guaranteeing that the drow even PLAN to invade. It's up to the players.

This is not a campaign. It has no start (anymore), and it has no end (yet). It has no linear "storyline" to complete. It has thousands of players, who create their own storylines as they go. It has dm's who run events and plots, large and small. It has ongoing development, adding new places to explore, and modifying some places that already exist. It does not have a "map" of "Do task A, then go to point B, then slay uber-leet goblin lord to win".

If you want a single player campaign, complete with hints pointing you where to go and what to do next, with a start and an end, and a boss to kill to win, NWN conveniently comes with one, complete with 2 expansions and craploads of available downloadable campaigns. If you want a dynamic open gameworld in which you create the story, you plot, you plan, you decide what you should do today, or tomorrow, and whom you should view as a friend, and whom a foe, well, welcome to Amia. Amia is a setting. You make the campaign.

_________________
Role with the Punches...
Elan: A 10% chance is pretty unlikely, but everyone knows that a one-in-a-million chance is a sure thing!


 
      
Brown Blur
 
PostPosted: Tue, Feb 24 2009, 11:06 AM 

User avatar

Player

Joined: 27 Oct 2007
Location: Anywhere but Amia.

Awesome post Cori.

_________________
"Never ascribe to malice, that which can be explained by incompetence"
~ Napoleon Bonaparte.
- Clearly, Napoleon never envisioned the Internet......where I'd judge it about 50/50.


 
      
Yurell
 
PostPosted: Tue, Feb 24 2009, 11:11 AM 

User avatar

Player

Joined: 06 Jan 2008
Location: ANU, behind the coffee mug (+10 GMT)

Brown Blur wrote:
Awesome post Cori.


Seconded

_________________
2009's Second Most Overall Contributing Player

يمكنني استخدام مترجم جوجل


 
      
BlackDahlya
 
PostPosted: Tue, Feb 24 2009, 11:24 AM 

User avatar

Player

Joined: 17 Aug 2005
Location: Land of the Scorching Sun, Empowered by Global Warming

Marry me Cori! :shock:

_________________
BlackDahlya

Once Upon A Time Played
Adr'ael Ken'rahel, Auron Teken’ath, Aurora Mesodias, 'Daniel' Daoskinaxarijikkym, Eilin'ira, Helena Rios, Layla Faircurrent, May'Une Do'Ndar, Mellinda Tellus, Michael of Cliffside, Rizzen of Twilight, Valkirya d'Claddath


 
      
Evil-Wizard
 
PostPosted: Tue, Feb 24 2009, 11:28 AM 

User avatar

Player

Joined: 28 Jan 2009

Captain Capslock wrote:
As to the blah blah about pnp....I didn't read it, nor shall I.


You should have read the rest of the post, 'cause it showed why your rant is pretty much bullshit, but in the end...

Captain Capslock wrote:
That said, I'd be all for them changing the rules to include a specific mention of not breaking into a city without DM's involved, or something generic to that effect.


Awesome, another one convinced. Anybody still against the clarification?


 
      
Uberuce
 
PostPosted: Tue, Feb 24 2009, 11:41 AM 

User avatar

Player

Joined: 11 Nov 2005
Location: Near the bar.

Evil-Wizard wrote:
What IS, in your opinion, the reason [they]are high level and quite powerful, yet let goblins and kobolds burn down farms while they stand around in the city? Waiting for the drow invasion? And why is there no hint in the game world about a threat like that?

I'll be very happy if there is a good reason.
It's a server for levels 3-30 and sometimes you just have to turn a blind eye to the logical absurdities that the difference throws up.

The absurdity here isn't that the guards haven't killed the Frontier kobs and gobs; it's that the orcs haven't done it. They're much stronger. Then the absurdity would be that the Bloodmoons or trolls hadn't killed the orcs, then that the Mylocks hadn't killed the Bloodmoons and trolls, then that the Skull Crag Bugbears hadn't massacred them, and that the Yuan-Ti hadn't taken over the Trog caves and swamps, then that the Mindflayer Elderbrain or Khasay Everlast weren't sending their minions out into the island, and then they would be the big scary threat right outside the gates.

That's be a rather unfun server to level on, so I would tentatively suggest that our influx of new players and characters would rapidly decline.

It's not the end of the world to give up on finding IC explanations for everything and accept it's just a computer game played over the internet by lots of people. IC explanations are preferable, but recognising you're just banging your head against the wall trying to find one is a handy skill too.


 
      
Evil-Wizard
 
PostPosted: Tue, Feb 24 2009, 11:48 AM 

User avatar

Player

Joined: 28 Jan 2009

Uberuce wrote:
The absurdity here isn't that the guards haven't killed the Frontier kobs and gobs; it's that the orcs haven't done it.


Are the orcs and goblins enemies? And maybe the Yuan-ti like some other creatures driving the (demi)humans away - free guards to keep the rabble out. The Bloodmoon Orcs might actually be minions of the Illithids, or pay tribute to the Mylock tribe - we don't know, and thus, it doesn't really cause plausibility issues.
We do know, however, that the people of Cordor are at war with the orcs and kobolds. If the guards don't do anything about that, one has to ask why, leading to the train of thoughts posted earlier.

But more on the thread's topic: What do you think about adding the "Don't break into cities rule"? Yay or nay?


 
      
Uberuce
 
PostPosted: Tue, Feb 24 2009, 11:59 AM 

User avatar

Player

Joined: 11 Nov 2005
Location: Near the bar.

Evil-Wizard wrote:
Are the orcs and goblins enemies? And maybe the Yuan-ti like some other creatures driving the (demi)humans away - free guards to keep the rabble out. The Bloodmoon Orcs might actually be minions of the Illithids, or pay tribute to the Mylock tribe - we don't know, and thus, it doesn't really cause plausibility issues.
*winces and hands over the forehead lotion*

Quote:
But more on the thread's topic: What do you think about adding the "Don't break into cities rule"? Yay or nay?
Nay. It's not worth the HTML fiddling time.


 
      
hendrack
 
PostPosted: Tue, Feb 24 2009, 12:01 PM 

User avatar

Player

Joined: 24 Sep 2007
Location: Vienna

Quote:
We do know, however, that the people of Cordor are at war with the orcs and kobolds.


I didn't know that. Are you seeing posters around Cordor ordering a general mobilisation? As Cori said, guards are just that: guards, not the militia. A wise forum poster once said something like: "Don't try to change Amia to your ways, change yourself to fit Amia."


 
      
Nekhy
 
PostPosted: Tue, Feb 24 2009, 12:04 PM 



Player

We're not gonna add a rule for every little custom we have on Amia. Some of them you just have to learn by trial and error.

This is a matter of principle, mind. We aim for as few rules as possible, and as much relying on common sense as only possible.


 
      
xordae
 
PostPosted: Tue, Feb 24 2009, 12:09 PM 

User avatar

Player

Joined: 01 Jul 2005
Location: Germany

hendrack wrote:
"Don't try to change Amia to your ways, change yourself to fit Amia."


Amia has seen a very long line of improvements and changes that were partially inspired by players speaking out one way or the other. When you notice a deficiency, you don't think: "Wow, look at that. Now if I just twist my arm a little and make myself really small, I think I could totally fit in there." Not saying that it is so in this case, but by principle this piece of advice is pretty backwards and creates sheep.


 
      
Evil-Wizard
 
PostPosted: Tue, Feb 24 2009, 12:12 PM 

User avatar

Player

Joined: 28 Jan 2009

Nekhy wrote:
We aim for as few rules as possible, and as much relying on common sense as only possible.


Doesn't work very well in this case, obviously. But heck, it's your decision.


 
      
hendrack
 
PostPosted: Tue, Feb 24 2009, 12:13 PM 

User avatar

Player

Joined: 24 Sep 2007
Location: Vienna

To xordae: Whatever, but if you go to a new server, mouth about things you don't like, dont expect that the whole server bends for you.


 
      
Nekhy
 
PostPosted: Tue, Feb 24 2009, 13:05 PM 



Player

Evil-Wizard wrote:
Nekhy wrote:
We aim for as few rules as possible, and as much relying on common sense as only possible.


Doesn't work very well in this case, obviously. But heck, it's your decision.


It works just as intended. ;)


 
      
Lesquille
 
PostPosted: Tue, Feb 24 2009, 13:41 PM 

User avatar

Player

Joined: 14 Feb 2005
Location: Melbourne

In my experience, the DMs are pretty cool about dealing with rules being broken when it's clear there wasn't malicious intent on the part of the player. Provided the DMs are reasonable about dealing with "unwritten rules" being broken, it isn't a big problem.

It's not like the DMs go around saying, "Bzzzt, you broke an unwritten rule so now you're BANNED FOREVER!"

_________________
Born to a [wealth level] family, you spent your early years doing [early activity] in [town type]. Your father was [father status], while your mother was [mother status]. You left your homeland at the age of [chosen age], seeking [reason for leaving].


 
      
Talon
 
PostPosted: Tue, Feb 24 2009, 20:12 PM 

User avatar

Player

Joined: 18 Feb 2006
Location: Texas, where else?

Nekhy wrote:
We're not gonna add a rule for every little custom we have on Amia. Some of them you just have to learn by trial and error.

This is a matter of principle, mind. We aim for as few rules as possible, and as much relying on common sense as only possible.


If this is the case someone cannot be punished for breaking an unwritten rule they were uanware of, then.

_________________
Image


 
      
Yossarin
 
PostPosted: Tue, Feb 24 2009, 20:22 PM 



Player

Joined: 23 Jan 2006

Should not, I believe you mean to say.


 
      
Talon
 
PostPosted: Tue, Feb 24 2009, 20:29 PM 

User avatar

Player

Joined: 18 Feb 2006
Location: Texas, where else?

Yossarin wrote:
Should not, I believe you mean to say.


Sadly I suppose you right, they should not be punished for breaking an unwritten rule they were unaware of.

_________________
Image


 
      
Dev Disco
 
PostPosted: Tue, Feb 24 2009, 20:36 PM 

User avatar

HRM Chicken I of Amia

Joined: 02 Jun 2005
Location: Amsterdam

He isn't called 'Terror' for nothing, you know...

_________________
Say 'no' to JSBF!


 
      
Nourm
 
PostPosted: Tue, Feb 24 2009, 20:59 PM 

User avatar

Player

Joined: 11 Feb 2009

The only real danger arising from unwritten rules is the possibility of bad DM judgement. If a player breaks an unwritten rule with the innocence of unawareness, it would be very unfortunate for a DM to judge otherwise and punish the player for malicious intent. I am sure in most cases DMs make the right judgement on things, but we’re all human.

I do understand the idea behind as few rules as possible; honest players don’t need many rules while those with malicious intent find loopholes in the rules by playing pretend-lawyers.


 
      
Yossarin
 
PostPosted: Tue, Feb 24 2009, 21:03 PM 



Player

Joined: 23 Jan 2006

Nourm wrote:
I do understand the idea behind as few rules as possible; honest players don’t need many rules while those with malicious intent find loopholes in the rules by playing pretend-lawyers.


And shamelessly continue to exploit it until they are caught, and when they are, point to the loophole. Nothing entirely new, really.


 
      
Display posts from previous:  Sort by  
Forum locked This topic is locked, you cannot edit posts or make further replies.  [ 163 posts ]  Go to page Previous  1, 2, 3, 4  Next


Who is online

Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 5 guests


You cannot post new topics in this forum
You cannot reply to topics in this forum
You cannot edit your posts in this forum
You cannot delete your posts in this forum

Search for:
Jump to:  
Powered by phpBB © 2000, 2002, 2005, 2007 phpBB Group