Joined: 17 Aug 2005 Location: Land of the Scorching Sun, Empowered by Global Warming
Yossarin wrote:
Quote:
If they should, in fact, be high or even epic level, that's - to be honest - a design decision very badly reflected in the game world. It makes little sense to have a city guarded by near-demigods besieged by orcs and goblins.
What in the world makes you think the city is under siege by goblins and orcs instead of lvl 30 adventurers?
He's assuming that because the guard by the gate asks the adventurers if they are up to go after the orc's chief and bring its head.
_________________ BlackDahlya
Once Upon A Time Played Adr'ael Ken'rahel, Auron Teken’ath, Aurora Mesodias, 'Daniel' Daoskinaxarijikkym, Eilin'ira, Helena Rios, Layla Faircurrent, May'Une Do'Ndar, Mellinda Tellus, Michael of Cliffside, Rizzen of Twilight, Valkirya d'Claddath
Also of note, DMs are the rules. That is, what the umpire says goes (unless explicitly against existing rules, in which case, what they say goes in that specific situation).
That is, DMs word is final. Don't like it? Talk to admins.
But on the whole, if a DM says my character isn't allowed in Cordor, etc without a DM present, then that's the rules.
_________________ Illithira Frostmaiden (Snow Elf) Guardian of the Frostfell Elithiel Issatheerin (Shadow Elf) She who Lurks Isolia Oussea'lylth (Sun Elf) Apprentice Wizardess
Joined: 15 Feb 2007 Location: Hiding somewhere in the shadows
soundofastream wrote:
Also of note, DMs are the rules. That is, what the umpire says goes (unless explicitly against existing rules, in which case, what they say goes in that specific situation).
That is, DMs word is final. Don't like it? Talk to admins.
But on the whole, if a DM says my character isn't allowed in Cordor, etc without a DM present, then that's the rules.
Rule 0 all the way.
_________________ Murio Aers ~ High Priest of Mask Keth Aers ~ Shadow Puppet Mage Mishi ~ Innocent Paladin of Bahamut
If you try to sneak/Go/Teleport/GS anywhere where you don't belong ask a DM because even if you are spotted by the NPC's will and can they not react because they are not programmed for it. No matter the skillset and what not.
_________________ "Most assume that all the followers of Lathander are great morning people. They're very wrong." "I think we are the only group where AD&D stands for Attention Deficit Disorder."
Joined: 06 Jan 2008 Location: ANU, behind the coffee mug (+10 GMT)
Evil-Wizard wrote:
Quote:
Cordorian Guards don't adhere to standard Forgotten Realms Level Spread. 'Nuff said.
If they should, in fact, be high or even epic level, that's - to be honest - a design decision very badly reflected in the game world. It makes little sense to have a city guarded by near-demigods besieged by orcs and goblins.
<Removed> If you want to be logical, look at it like this - basically all the level thirties in Cordor obey the law. Why? Because the guards can kick their arses. Wasn't there the Horde War (or whatever they were called ... before my time)? The guards are dealing with high level adventurers every day.
Or another way to look at it - if there is such a high concentration of powerful characters in the isle, why would any sane ruler not hire some of them to serve in the guard?
Try fighting the guards some time before just assuming they're lowbies.
And the rule is simple - DO NOT METAGAME.
_________________ 2009's Second Most Overall Contributing Player
يمكنني استخدام مترجم جوجل
Last edited by Yurell on Sun, Feb 22 2009, 11:57 AM, edited 1 time in total.
I wouldnt bother trying to argue about metagaming with "Evil-Wizard" Apparnetly shifting into a Balor in Wiltun is not metagaming but then shifting into one in Cordor is, Lulz.
But on the whole, if a DM says my character isn't allowed in Cordor, etc without a DM present, then that's the rules.
Nobody's questioning that. It's just that if a DM decides to put such a rule up, (s)he should tell the players about it, and best do it in a way so that everybody can see, not whisper it on a case to case basis. It's just un-economical and provokes arguements. Didn't ask for anything else.
ainjyll wrote:
If you're not a DM, don't assume to know what skill sets the guards have.
And relating normal FR guards or whatever to Amian guards is a completely ridiculous notion. That's like saying that the local mall security guards are the same as the guys that guard the Pope's chambers while he sleeps. They're both guards, yes. But the former is not most likely not nearly as adept at the job of guarding things as the latter.
Assuming that you're not a DM, there's a funny contradiction between the first and the following sentences.
Last edited by Evil-Wizard on Sun, Feb 22 2009, 11:56 AM, edited 1 time in total.
hence why it falls under the rulling of "USE COMMON SENSE" too bad many do not seem to have it. I wonder how much money I could make by selling bottles of common sense to people.
Joined: 06 Jan 2008 Location: ANU, behind the coffee mug (+10 GMT)
herkles wrote:
hence why it falls under the rulling of "USE COMMON SENSE" too bad many do not seem to have it. I wonder how much money I could make by selling bottles of common sense to people.
I'm sure the irony would be lost on the people you sell them to.
As for guard behaviour, it is safe to assume that they will try to prevent you from breaking the law unless stated otherwise (that wasn't directed at you herkles, just in general:D )
_________________ 2009's Second Most Overall Contributing Player
Asking the adventurers to kill the orcs is like a general sending his privates to build his tent. he has more important things to do.
When the mage guards can throw Disjunctions and utterly own a level 30 PC they have more important things to do than Wail of the Banshee a few uppity orcs.
The one thing that is a little iffy is Greater Sanctuary. Someone should be able to sneak in under that if they consider everyone in the city hostile right?
It's OK to assume a guard behaves in ways XYZ if you've heard a DM state a guard behaves in ways XYZ, though.
I can only repeat: Please, put it in the rules section - it's just one sentence and clears up a lot. Several people here see/saw the behaviour as allowed, others don't (and feel invited to flame those of different opinion, for some reason), so there's apparently a need for clarification. Unclear points in the ruleset just provoke threads and flame fests like this one.
Edit: I apologize for even bringing the GS issue up, as this spells seems to cause even greater problems here than the thread topic. Invisibility, stealth, polymorphs etc., however, cause the same question (i. e. if it's allowed to enter a city/place without DM supervision your character wouldn't be allowed to enter).
Last edited by Evil-Wizard on Sun, Feb 22 2009, 12:50 PM, edited 1 time in total.
Not to the thread opener, obviously. Several other post(er)s were at least unsure if it worked / was forbidden or expressed a desire for a clarification.
The DMs themselves have said that, if the rules aren't transparent, then some people will take that as an excuse to sneak around them. I see this as a request for transparency, and "Don't go there without a DM" is no less an OOC issue than "Don't run ahead of hunting parties."
My suggestion: Let's put the level cap of Amia at 5. All problems solved.
Lets up it to 7 at least so people can chose some prestige classes.
_________________ "Most assume that all the followers of Lathander are great morning people. They're very wrong." "I think we are the only group where AD&D stands for Attention Deficit Disorder."
"Just take the safety labels off everything and let Darwinism take its course." - Unknown
If someone is the kind of twunt that needs a rulebook to stop him being an arse...why not just let them stick their head underneath the Ban Hammer?
Elegantly put, as always...
_________________ "Never ascribe to malice, that which can be explained by incompetence" ~ Napoleon Bonaparte. - Clearly, Napoleon never envisioned the Internet......where I'd judge it about 50/50.
"Just take the safety labels off everything and let Darwinism take its course." - Unknown
If someone is the kind of twunt that needs a rulebook to stop him being an arse...why not just let them stick their head underneath the Ban Hammer?
Elegantly put, as always...
I agree fully with him, though. I'm going to go out on the same limb I so frequently have gone out on in the past and say that Amia has a big enough player base that it can afford to lose some players. Most rules don't need clarification to be effective. They need the banning of people who work so diligently to get around them, and we sure as hell don't need players like that.
"Just take the safety labels off everything and let Darwinism take its course." - Unknown
If someone is the kind of twunt that needs a rulebook to stop him being an arse...why not just let them stick their head underneath the Ban Hammer?
Elegantly put, as always...
I agree fully with him, though. I'm going to go out on the same limb I so frequently have gone out on in the past and say that Amia has a big enough player base that it can afford to lose some players. Most rules don't need clarification to be effective. They need the banning of people who work so diligently to get around them, and we sure as hell don't need players like that.
D*mn right, Cartman.
_________________ "Never ascribe to malice, that which can be explained by incompetence" ~ Napoleon Bonaparte. - Clearly, Napoleon never envisioned the Internet......where I'd judge it about 50/50.
Likely the guards don't bother with the low level stuff because it:
A. Is out of their jourisdiction.
B. Also not worthy enough of a threat to martial militia/army to march outside to deal with it. Ergo, its 'Light work' that they pass off to the plethora of adventurors
Also IIRC the reason some npc's are such high levels is they are symbolic/representative of larger squads from a previous discussion on Cordor's Lawknights yielded from a dm.
_________________ Dwagin [Duh-wa-GIN] N. - 1a. Small and cute thingum, particularly fond of four legged scaled creatures of the metalic and chromatic varieties.
Joined: 03 Jun 2007 Location: [st]Ultrinnan[/st] [st]Edonil[/st] Nec'perya
BloodNAshes wrote:
Quote:
Ainjyll:...That's like saying that the local mall security guards are the same as the guys that guard the Pope's chambers while he sleeps.
You mean these guys?:
image = snip
Most fearsome indeed.
If you only knew. Besides their polearms, they carry heavy automatic weapons at all times, and I believe they have a 2 minute maximum response time for anywhere in vatican city. They are also one of the most highly trained army in the world, handpicked from the best of the best. They may not look imposing, but give them a reason to act and you might be dead before you say 'im sorry!'
_________________ Slander [Zanthair Akarupa of the Horsemen of the Apcalypse] - Sorcerer 'Mediocreare' Isendu't'tar Ussen'd'Vhid d'My'ana'd'Xull'd'Vharcan - possibly the longest name in Amia Tiffany Seagrass - weak and fragile weaver of words
_________________ "Prepare to embrace your creators in the stygian haunts of hell, barbarian", gasped the first soldier. "Only after you have kissed the fleeting stead of death, wretch!" returned Grignr.
The enthused barbarian swivelled about.
Joined: 10 Aug 2005 Location: Ottawa, Ontario, Canada
Are you people crazy?
Gays tend to have significantly better fashion sense than that.
Now maybe a drag queen....
On topic though:
Evil-Wiz, this bit right below, is where you fall short - you are using ooc knowledge that isn't even from Amia, and applying it to this scenario.
Quote:
If a 30th level, sneak oriented rogue character knows that a certain city guard is a typical, run of the mill city guard
As has been pointed out, you obviously haven't fought the guards, or you'd know that they are in fact, NOT typical FR run of the mill city guards. They are however, not from some FR pre-designed city. They are Amian guards, of the main starter city in the Mod. The other main starter city - Ultrinnan - also has some mighty uber guards.
Quote:
If you, as a player, use the game's mechanics to actually do that, mechanics, character and player knowledge are in complete concordance. There is no metagaming here.
And this you are just 100% completely incorrect in saying, because Amian npc's have no scripting. They cannot respond to you on their own, even if you were a level 1 who ran up and started smacking them with a shortsword. So in fact, you are not using game mechanics to do anything. Mechanically, you could walk on in with no invis or GS or anything at all. THAT is why a DM is needed - to control the guards, so they *do* have some chance to react. Whether they catch you or not, is up to the DM whom controls them.
To not give them that chance, to assume they are low level, and therefor ignore them, IS metagaming. It's also a bit of god gaming, to declare what or how the npc's will react to you.
You may think that it's bad design to have high level guards. You are welcome to think that. And if you'd been around Amia for the past several years, or bothered to ask instead of assuming, you'd find out that there's good reason for the guards to be high level. But, if you think it's really that bad, well, nobody is forcing you to play here. Hopefully you wouldn't let a minor fact like high level city guards be enough to make you quit a server....but that's your choice.
_________________ Role with the Punches...
Elan: A 10% chance is pretty unlikely, but everyone knows that a one-in-a-million chance is a sure thing!
Joined: 06 Jan 2008 Location: ANU, behind the coffee mug (+10 GMT)
BloodNAshes wrote:
Quote:
Ainjyll:...That's like saying that the local mall security guards are the same as the guys that guard the Pope's chambers while he sleeps.
You mean these guys?:
*People in silly costumes*
Most fearsome indeed.
Bad person, you stretched the page.
Now on a separate note - if you are assuming that these guys are normal, that means you're assuming that the people around them are normal too - the example of the shopping centre night-watch and the Pope come to mind.
Would you mind looking through some third ed book and pointing out every level 30 character?
In FR the average citizen is a lvl 1 commoner, the average guard a lvl 1-3 warrior, and adventurers don't cluster in massive groups of superpowers that can keep coming back to life.
_________________ 2009's Second Most Overall Contributing Player
Would you mind looking through some third ed book and pointing out every level 30 character?
Elminster.
The Seven Chosen of Mystra
Khelban Blackstaff
Halaster
(Yes I know some of them aren't technically level 30 but they're stupidly powerful and/or immortal)
If there's one thing the Forgotten Realms doesn't lack it's power creep.
I'd rather have most of the PC's on Amia become official FR Canon then anything written by Ed Greenwood or that Drizzt guy.
_________________ "Prepare to embrace your creators in the stygian haunts of hell, barbarian", gasped the first soldier. "Only after you have kissed the fleeting stead of death, wretch!" returned Grignr.
The enthused barbarian swivelled about.
Joined: 06 Jan 2008 Location: ANU, behind the coffee mug (+10 GMT)
Xavier wrote:
Yurell wrote:
Would you mind looking through some third ed book and pointing out every level 30 character?
Elminster. The Seven Chosen of Mystra Khelban Blackstaff Halaster
(Yes I know some of them aren't technically level 30 but they're stupidly powerful and/or immortal)
If there's one thing the Forgotten Realms doesn't lack it's power creep. I'd rather have most of the PC's on Amia become official FR Canon then anything written by Ed Greenwood or that Drizzt guy.
Now compare the extent of this list to the number of lvl 30 characters (or ECL 30) in Amia. By working the law of 'averages' or looking for normalcy, by both land area and population Amia should have 0.
Since the number of ECL 30 characters (not monsters) in Amia is higher than everywhere else in Faerun, is it a sane argument to say that Amia is normal?
_________________ 2009's Second Most Overall Contributing Player
Joined: 11 Nov 2006 Location: A Clean, Well-Lighted Place
Without reading all of this, I will agree with the notion that the culture of Amia can be hard to get. There's a lot of premises that we take for granted that you really need to discover as a newbie to our community. I am not sure it's even possible to pen them all down, though. Anyways, please, be cool towards these new players. They are our future. *Forlorn sigh.*
_________________ To err is human; to forgive divine, but VENGEANCE IS MINE!
Now compare the extent of this list to the number of lvl 30 characters (or ECL 30) in Amia. By working the law of 'averages' or looking for normalcy, by both land area and population Amia should have 0. Since the number of ECL 30 characters (not monsters) in Amia is higher than everywhere else in Faerun, is it a sane argument to say that Amia is normal?
So what's your point? That we should stop hunting once we hit level 20 because only random monsters and the various author self-insertions of the realms should be powerful?
God forbid anyone actually use those ten extra levels!
_________________ "Prepare to embrace your creators in the stygian haunts of hell, barbarian", gasped the first soldier. "Only after you have kissed the fleeting stead of death, wretch!" returned Grignr.
The enthused barbarian swivelled about.
Joined: 30 Aug 2008 Location: Some planet known as Earth
Gawds forbid that the epic level characters be able to slay/stop/get around the guards using IC power of their character. *gasp* <--sarcasm
Saying there is 'absolutely no way to get past any guard in any town' is just plain ooc'ness, and doesn't belong on any roleplay server.
So the remedy is to alert a dm to play the part and hope they don't pull out the dm kill button/cast greater ruin 5 times.
So it comes down to how fair in playing the part of the guards a dm feels like being, there's not much of an alternative until the NPC"s suddenly get a complicated AI that can respond to IC actions...which is nearly impossible for us to begin with, the lag involved in such a system would be up there as well.
...so the best we can do is to trust the dm's to not be (censoreds) and let them know when we're planning to invade cities with guards. (which is almost if not all of them)
The issue then transforms to 'do we have enough dm's to play the parts of guards for the players when they invade 'x' town(s)' Which then becomes the debate for a degree of fairness with this 'invisible rule'.
Do we have enough DM's to do this? <--there's ur main question.
An extended question is 'How much power should the DM's say the NPC guard's actually have?' Sure one or two of them may be epic...not 'all' of them, I'm guessing that there are squires and knights in training as well as a few 'epic' commanders. The ranks should be about as varied as the amian player-base.
...after all the PC factions usually are.
p.s. given above is generally true, amian player-base is seemingly on the side of epic characters if we count the characters in the vault, meaning epic npc's aren't 'that' rare. Epic may as well = very strong/formidable opponent in this case.
Do we have enough DM's to do this? <--there's ur main question.
Yes.
Azrael wrote:
An extended question is 'How much power should the DM's say the NPC guard's actually have?' Sure one or two of them may be epic...not 'all' of them, I'm guessing that there are squires and knights in training as well as a few 'epic' commanders. The ranks should be about as varied as the amian player-base.
...after all the PC factions usually are.
The DM's at the time decide whether or not this guards lucky enough to catch one of you sneekys breaking IC laws, Whether it be through Dice Roles or whether it be through your Given RP to said DM and as reward they may or may not let you in.
Joined: 06 Jan 2008 Location: ANU, behind the coffee mug (+10 GMT)
Xavier wrote:
Yurell wrote:
Now compare the extent of this list to the number of lvl 30 characters (or ECL 30) in Amia. By working the law of 'averages' or looking for normalcy, by both land area and population Amia should have 0. Since the number of ECL 30 characters (not monsters) in Amia is higher than everywhere else in Faerun, is it a sane argument to say that Amia is normal?
So what's your point? That we should stop hunting once we hit level 20 because only random monsters and the various author self-insertions of the realms should be powerful?
God forbid anyone actually use those ten extra levels!
My point is you can't assume that the guards are average level one-three warrior guards because Amia is not an average place.
My argument was against "Awww guards should only be level three its stupid to assume they can catch my uber 20-something" (i.e. Evil-Wizard's argument) by demonstrating that this argument is entirely invalid when applied in game. A level 20-something is only special everywhere else, in Amia it isn't. The reason you were quoted is because you were the one who responded.
_________________ 2009's Second Most Overall Contributing Player
(I don't want to start a new thread about city rules ...)
Is it okay if I bring my raven* familiar into Wiltun? Or does Wiltun have the same "no anything" rule as Cordor? If not, where's the line? Common sense helps a little, but not always.
Thanks!
Ts
*) or badger, wolf, panther, pixie, mini dragon, mephit, eyeball, EDK, ...
Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 6 guests
You cannot post new topics in this forum You cannot reply to topics in this forum You cannot edit your posts in this forum You cannot delete your posts in this forum