View unanswered posts | View active topics * FAQ    * Search
* Login 




Forum locked This topic is locked, you cannot edit posts or make further replies.  [ 49 posts ] 
QPR
 
PostPosted: Mon, Feb 02 2009, 16:46 PM 

User avatar

Player

Joined: 21 Sep 2008
Location: Norway

I wish to hear the oppinion of people on just how one should understand the requirement of Lawfull Good for a paladin. Good is obvious enough, but what does lawfull really mean? Does it mean that you follow whatever laws are in the area you are? Does it mean that you only keep to the law of your patron deity? Does it mean that you stick to a Code, that might conflict with other Lawfull good characters and deities? or a combination of all?

reason im asking is that im wondering of the possibilites of making a paladin that is not really in line with most other paladins. Sort of a freedom paladin, who will free people from oppression, both from secular and divine laws. Can suh a paladin exist at all? and is there a deity who is abit rebellish who would allow paladins?

Im in doubt myself, but it would be fun if it was possible. Heated debates between paladins would be awesome.


 
      
belgianbonzai
 
PostPosted: Mon, Feb 02 2009, 16:56 PM 

User avatar

Player

Joined: 01 Jan 2006
Location: Budapest, Hungary

Law of your deity mostly.
If you're in a region with a law that really is different from it you're probably in a land slaying a cult of your deities arch nemesis, so that's no biggy ;)

_________________
Click here for the navis & lukavi portraitpacks preview & download.


 
      
QPR
 
PostPosted: Mon, Feb 02 2009, 16:57 PM 

User avatar

Player

Joined: 21 Sep 2008
Location: Norway

I was more thinking of a paladin that would oppose, say, the zeal and ruthlesseness in Torm and Tyr's teaching, to take an example.

edit: Chauntea and Mielikki could perhaps be such deities whose laws would differ quite a bit from torm and Tyr, but still allow paladins?

edit 2:
according to forgotten realms wiki, a paladin does not need to be lawfull good, only of the exact same aligment as his/her deity: http://forgottenrealms.wikia.com/wiki/Paladin

So, due to nwn limitations, would it be acceptable to make a paladin and RP him as neutral or chaotic good?


 
      
Shrewd
 
PostPosted: Mon, Feb 02 2009, 17:44 PM 

User avatar

Player

Joined: 01 May 2005
Location: Sydney

I'm pretty sure that's only in 4th edition. Paladins are Lawful Good, if you wanted something Neutral I'd go for a CoT and RP it to another Diety. And of course, for evil take Blackguard.

Paladins are holy. Holy is good.
Somewhere in the middle there are knights/holy men of other faiths, but they're not Paladins.
Blackguards are unholy. Unholy is evil.

_________________
Aravain, Champion of Song.
Anar, a dark elf.
Giovanni, Blood Knight.


 
      
StandingBehindYou
 
PostPosted: Mon, Feb 02 2009, 17:49 PM 

User avatar

Player

Joined: 24 Nov 2008

QPR wrote:
edit 2:
according to forgotten realms wiki, a paladin does not need to be lawfull good, only of the exact same aligment as his/her deity: http://forgottenrealms.wikia.com/wiki/Paladin


I believe that wiki is talking about D&D 4th edition.

In 3rd edition there were Neutral Good and Chaotic Good equivalents of paladins, but they had different names. I believe the Chaotic Good version was called the "Liberator" or something.

Quote:
So, due to nwn limitations, would it be acceptable to make a paladin and RP him as neutral or chaotic good?


I believe that if you have an unusual character request you are supposed to get approval from a DM before making the character.


 
      
Silvarus
 
PostPosted: Mon, Feb 02 2009, 17:51 PM 

User avatar

Player

Joined: 23 Sep 2005
Location: Jyväskylä, Finland, Europe

Variant paladins: Over my dead body.

_________________
Gagis Silvarna, the Robocop with wings who shoots lasers from his fingertips
Lily Havthorn, the Waukeenar
Silwe, the elf


 
      
Shrewd
 
PostPosted: Mon, Feb 02 2009, 17:52 PM 

User avatar

Player

Joined: 01 May 2005
Location: Sydney

If you wanna do a Neutral/Chaotic Good warrior of some diety, then the Champion of Torm is the best bet, and just RP'd as another diety.

_________________
Aravain, Champion of Song.
Anar, a dark elf.
Giovanni, Blood Knight.


 
      
Slig
 
PostPosted: Mon, Feb 02 2009, 18:24 PM 

User avatar

Player

Joined: 19 Sep 2008

Silvarus wrote:
Variant paladins: Over my dead body.


I hate agreeing with Silvarus, because I can't stand his hat, but here he is bang on the money. Variant paladins are just not cool.

_________________
"All progress comes when somebody says: 'Who gave him the right to do that to me?'" - Tony Benn
Image


 
      
Uncle-Opustus
 
PostPosted: Mon, Feb 02 2009, 18:29 PM 

User avatar

Player

Joined: 10 Jul 2007
Location: Finland

Top hats are the stuff, yo!

_________________
Image
UCE THIS, YOU COW.


 
      
Yossarin
 
PostPosted: Mon, Feb 02 2009, 18:41 PM 



Player

Joined: 23 Jan 2006

My Lathandran paladin might think that paladins of other faiths emphasize different aspects of the Paladin's Code more strongly than others, but as a paladin he believes that anyone who has pledged the oaths and has a good heart and the requisite nod from his/her deity to champion the faith is an ally, a person you stand shoulder to shoulder with to protect the innocent from the excesses of evil.

Yes, that Tormite or Tyrran might have an excess of zeal that is intimidating to the average innocent. They may have a ruthlessness in the pursuit of evil that causes them to be prone to distrusting people who could be their allies. But that doesn't change the fact that they are a paladin, dedicated to the same principles as I am, willing to cull wickedness from a good society, willing to do their utmost to do the right thing in spite of the odds, and to stubbornly oppose a fellow paladin over a minor disagreement in methodology is not only an act of arrogance that is contrary to the virtue of humility, but an opposition to the proliferation of goodness and light for all.


 
      
QPR
 
PostPosted: Mon, Feb 02 2009, 18:47 PM 

User avatar

Player

Joined: 21 Sep 2008
Location: Norway

variant paladins are bad, get it.

next question; does Deneir allow paladins?


 
      
Yossarin
 
PostPosted: Mon, Feb 02 2009, 19:17 PM 



Player

Joined: 23 Jan 2006

Keep your variant paladins if you want to. But be smart about what is meant by "variant".


 
      
QPR
 
PostPosted: Mon, Feb 02 2009, 19:20 PM 

User avatar

Player

Joined: 21 Sep 2008
Location: Norway

Næh, Co(put in deity here) seems like a much better way to go. The thought was a sort of divine warrior with a different code than Paladins, and i see that CoT suits that much better


 
      
A Majestic Dwarf
 
PostPosted: Mon, Feb 02 2009, 19:28 PM 

User avatar

Player

Joined: 09 Oct 2006
Location: Wales

Suné can have Paladins, and she is a chaotic God. This would mean that their code would be quite a bit looser in some respects than others. Well at least to me it does, perhaps she would be a helps

_________________
Avatar Picture from Brinawilliamson.com

Player of:
- Whurak Thunderhammer
King of Barak Runedar and all round Vengeful Dwarf
- Alvian Tegleiwalla
Nerdy Painter Elf with a Silly hat


 
      
xordae
 
PostPosted: Mon, Feb 02 2009, 19:41 PM 

User avatar

Player

Joined: 01 Jul 2005
Location: Germany

The God is not connected to the character by the umbilical cord. Therefore, it doesn't matter if a god is chaotic or not, because the character will regardless of that still have his personal code (or absence thereof). The more often I think about the Alignment Axis, the more awful it all sounds really. I'm glad there's roleplaying games out there that do without it. It does some nifty things and it enables funny stuff and there's the clear cut good guys and bad guys. But unsuspectingly, over all our heads has been lowered the giant, iron grimace of RP restriction. As much as Cowboys love the idea of "evil", at the end of the day it's mostly circumstantial. Hitler was belt-whipped as a toddler. George W. Bush chokes on pretzels.

Cutting this short.. Alinment Axis purely personal. Chaotic god can have lawful followers. There's no one saying Chaotic Paladins can't be possible except for Gygax and his cohorts.


 
      
A Majestic Dwarf
 
PostPosted: Mon, Feb 02 2009, 20:19 PM 

User avatar

Player

Joined: 09 Oct 2006
Location: Wales

Yes, Alignment is a personal thing. As I am sure it is personal to the god. Which is why he tells his followers to act in a certain manner as dictated by their personality. Those who don't follow his particular set of rules will on the whole be kicked out of the club. Which is why Followers which call on their powers have to be closely aligned with their gods viewpoint and hence we have the "One Step" Alignment rule for deities and clerics.

This said, Paladins are supposed to be these Holy Warriors, chosen for their devotion to their god to carry out their will on this earth. They have sworn to a code which by rights should be different for each god, and have sworn to effectively be an extent of the Gods Dogma on earth, or in this case Toril.

So yes, while I see your point that Alignment of the God isn't relevant for most of their followers I think it is for interpreting what code they will want their Paladins, their chosen holy warriors to fulfill.

For Example - Tyr, the Lord of Justice is going to want his Paladins to come down a helluva lot harder on criminals than Sune is going to want her paladins to come down on them. I think she would rather they are out protecting Beauty and such.

This brings me back to the point I was trying to make above, is that Sune, is a Chaotic God that by the rules and setting of FR, allows Paladins. This is a clear Exception to the above mentioned "One Step" Rule. And as she is Chaotic herself, I was simply pointing out that her rules are likely to be a little more lax than the authoritarian Tyr for example, and as QPR wanted a paladin that may have differences with the ruthlessness and Zeal of Tyr and Torm I thought it an ideal suggestion.

_________________
Avatar Picture from Brinawilliamson.com

Player of:
- Whurak Thunderhammer
King of Barak Runedar and all round Vengeful Dwarf
- Alvian Tegleiwalla
Nerdy Painter Elf with a Silly hat


 
      
xordae
 
PostPosted: Mon, Feb 02 2009, 20:44 PM 

User avatar

Player

Joined: 01 Jul 2005
Location: Germany

Your points are all right, the whole concept just sits wrong with me. Probably because it's based on absolutes, and there's no saying that a Chaotic character cannot follow orders. And who ever said that any sort of doctrine that comes from above, regardless if it's a doctrine to uphold order or a doctrine to electrocute villagers and call storms.. isn't inherently lawful? Because it requires fulfillment just like it was given?

Eh, I'm not too good at Alignments but it just feels like it's a subject that when discussed at some depth, it comes to a point where you find a slip of paper tucked to the construct that says "Alright, we did want a toy fantasy universe and not a realistic approach. Sue us."


 
      
Silvarus
 
PostPosted: Mon, Feb 02 2009, 21:09 PM 

User avatar

Player

Joined: 23 Sep 2005
Location: Jyväskylä, Finland, Europe

QPR wrote:
Næh, Co(put in deity here) seems like a much better way to go. The thought was a sort of divine warrior with a different code than Paladins, and i see that CoT suits that much better
Yeah. I usually do these ideas with a barbarian/cleric/CoT combo whith 2 levels of cleric only for divine might and divine shield, not for spellcasting.

It gets almost all paladin abilities(divine shield, might, turn undead, lay on hands, saves in a way, smite evil and so on) plus barbarian stuff to boot, and can mislead people to think you have taken the holy oaths, while the character can be quite far from a real paladin in truth. For example I have had an utterly insane barb/cleric/CoT character who thinks he is a Paladin and a chorus of angels sings divine commands and advice in his head. It was awesome but too challenging to play back at my more noobish days.

EDIT: Now I want to recreate the bastard. Damn it all.

_________________
Gagis Silvarna, the Robocop with wings who shoots lasers from his fingertips
Lily Havthorn, the Waukeenar
Silwe, the elf


 
      
QPR
 
PostPosted: Mon, Feb 02 2009, 21:37 PM 

User avatar

Player

Joined: 21 Sep 2008
Location: Norway

My question would then be; how would one make a character that wishes to challenge tradition, authority and dogmas that the usual paladins of Tyr/Torm have, and at the same time be paladin-ish himself, blessed by his deity, fierce enemy of undead etc? A sort of rebel-knight or chaos-champion comes to mind, but Im very unsure how to aproach that.

Meh.


 
      
Grymia
 
PostPosted: Mon, Feb 02 2009, 21:42 PM 

User avatar

Player

Joined: 14 Dec 2004
Location: Kohlingen, and a Basement in Canada

Been said multiple times, CoT is the best bet you're looking for here.


 
      
QPR
 
PostPosted: Mon, Feb 02 2009, 21:45 PM 

User avatar

Player

Joined: 21 Sep 2008
Location: Norway

The problem with CoT is that it lacks the divine feel over it. To me, its just fighter with better saving throws. Cleric could be another route, but that class does not have the knightly feel, so my wishes falls between two chairs.

*shakes fist at bioware for not giving the options of (un)holy warriors that are not LG or Ebul*


 
      
Sakkran
 
PostPosted: Mon, Feb 02 2009, 21:49 PM 

User avatar

Player

Joined: 09 Nov 2006
Location: The Hive Ward, Sigil

QPR wrote:
The problem with CoT is that it lacks the divine feel over it. To me, its just fighter with better saving throws. Cleric could be another route, but that class does not have the knightly feel, so my wishes falls between two chairs.

*shakes fist at bioware for not giving the options of (un)holy warriors that are not LG or Ebul*



Champion of (Insert Name Here) is what you make of it. It can be anything from someone who is unwittingly 'favored' somewhat by the deity in question, all the way up to a devoted warrior, completely dedicated to the service of his or her deity.

_________________
Morgan Blancrest: The Rage from The Cage
Lucas Baker: Humble Swordsman
Wesley Fletcher: Greasemonkey Extraordonaire
Also known as: EmoPinata


 
      
IronAngel
 
PostPosted: Mon, Feb 02 2009, 22:28 PM 

User avatar

Player

Joined: 29 Sep 2005
Location: Helsinki, Finland

There are as many Paladin Codes as there are paladins. It's not a universal code, it's not a church-wide code, and it's not always even an order-specific code. It's a spoken or unspoken agreement between the patron deity and the paladin, a promise to uphold certain ideals and further the patron's goals via certain means. Yes, of course it's usually a formal thing, generally shared by a whole knighthood (but probably very rarely, if ever, by the church as a whole; Calish[size=0].[/size]ite paladins of Tyr aren't the same as paladins of Tyr from Silverymoon), but that's not the "minimum requirement". Nowhere is it said that the paladin's code has to take some physical form, or any form in particular, a paladin just has to adhere by it. It can exist only in the paladin's mind, at least in theory.

There are some minimum requirements that a paladin's code must meet, notably Lawfulness, Goodness and honour. Then there are miscellaneous rules that I'd give less emphasis, and in fact seem to just specify the concept of honour (no lies, no poison etc.). This is not what a paladin is about, though. He's not about the minimum requirements, and I don't mean to suggest that. He should aspire to perform as best he can, going beyond the minimum requirements that all paladins face. However, how they do this, and what additional rules they hold themselves to, is highly individual.

And that, in short, is why you cannot answer whether paladins would/should respect legal authority or not. How does one define legal authority? In which situations is legitimate also justified? These are questions you can't find answers to in rulebooks. It's a game system, after all, not a study of political philosophy.


What I feel is the stereotypical order of priorities a paladin has, and what I believe the DM team has also more or less agreed to when we've discussed paladins, is the following:

1) To deity
2) To alignment (including fundamental ethical principles)
3) To church
4) To mundane authority - which can be further divided (though this is where it gets unclear):
4.1) to the cultural concept of honour/chivalry
4.2) to mundane promises made
4.3) to cultural values and tradition
4.4) to local legislation

That is to say, a paladin serves his deity first and foremost. If the primary interest of his patron god demands actions that are generally unlawful or not particularly good, the paladin will do it anyway. Certainly, he may Fall for this if the transgression is too great, but he'd certainly Fall if he failed to serve his deity and make the personal sacrifice of losing his paladinhood. A paladin shouldn't refrain from doing what his deity demands out of fear of losing favour, but willingly give up his paladinhood for a greater goal: that of his patron. This is where DM judgement comes into play: what will the deity, whom the paladin serves well, demand of the paladin? Will a plea for forgiveness suffice, or is a quest needed, perhaps the Atonement spell from a cleric? You can't generalize, because it's exactly where DM storytelling and individual fates get to shine.

However, serving your deity is not the same as surving your church. A paladin will always respect a ranking cleric, and strive to serve the pious clergy as best he can. However, there may be conflicts between mortals, and a paladin is generally more invested in his ethical principles (one could say "alignment", though I try to minimize its impact in game) than church authority, and therefore a paladin of Hoar will not take part in any evil deeds his clerical superior charges him to do, or partakes in. On the other hand, if said practice is approved by the god and the clergy, the paladin will not stop it either.

Mundane authority comes last, but that's what really makes paladins different and so interesting to play: there are a thousand ways to fill the minimum requirements of paladinhood, and two Lawful Good Paladins of Tyr can be very different. Perhaps one comes from a land where fencing duels are the honourable way to conduct battle (Tethyr), whereas the other comes from a culture where archery is an everyday part of life (the Dalelands), and therefore they will disagree on the requirements of chivalric conduct: one will accuse the other of dishonourable combat for using a longbow in a battle, but it's perfectly normal for the Dalesman. Furthermore, a Paladin of Tyr from Silverymoon will abhor slavery and promote the gentle laws of his home city, whereas a Paladin of Tyr from Calimshan is charged with upholding local laws which sanction both slavery and draconian punishments (such as chopping arms off). And yes, Calimshan is specifically mentioned as a center of Tyrran worship. These two Lawful Good Paladins of Tyr, both following the minimum requirements of a paladin's code, will never see eye to eye. Yet both are faithful servants of their god, and will not Fall for acting on the premises of their culture. However, if they switched roles and acted like the other would, they might both fall. (That is, the one from Silverymoon approving slavery, and the Calish[size=0].[/size]ite illegally setting slaves free in Calimport.)

An interesting question is the relation between church orders and personal promises. What if a paladin promises his party to join them on a quest to save the wife of one of the companions, but mid-way his church orders him to return immediately and drop the task at hand? I would say that typically, the paladin is sworn to the service of the church and any oaths he makes as an individual person mustn't get in the way of the greater duty. In that instance, a paladin actively serving a church (as a mundane organization) has to betray his promise to his party, because his loyalty is not his to give; he's already given it to his church. This would be the general attitude, I believe, but there are always exceptions: a paladin might be a wandering champion who has no ties to formal church hierarchy. He would respect clergymembers he meets on his travels, but there's no place for him in church hierarchy and no chain of command. On the other hand, a paladin might have sworn fealty to a realm or ruler rather than a church. A paladin of Mystra might swear fealty to Alustriel of Silverymoon, the Chosen of Mystra, and therefore owe greater allegiance to her than the church of Mystra. In that case, of course, an order from Silverymoon would overrule the paladin's personal promise to a party.


But anyway: there are many ways a paladin could act against local legislation, and even church policy. The latter is unlikely, the former should be quite common among some faiths. If, however, you truly want to play a rebel guided by nothing but his conscience and zeal, a divine champion is really the better choice. And yes, I too bemoan the inclusion of the horrible paladin base class, and wish there was a more viable general divine champion base class, with paladin as either a prestige class or a special option for the general divine champion base class. I don't mind paladins, but I do mind their unjustified positions as the only knightly, divine base class.

_________________
On Joon, Kjetta wrote:
The guy that probably has sexual fantasies about masturbation. I mean, Iron, you're a bookworm nerd that even in your wildest escapism fantasies flee to the internet to play the role of another bookworm nerd? Come on!


 
      
soundofastream
 
PostPosted: Mon, Feb 02 2009, 22:41 PM 

User avatar

Player

Joined: 21 Sep 2007

Also remember that in many societies of feudal nature, Kings and Queens and Nobles have Divine Rights. That is, their word is divine law. Most of the Northern and Western nations in Forgotten Realms tend to have Kings and Queens with Divine Righthood (Cormyr and Tethyr being good examples). Thus to break the mortal laws is actually a breaking of divine law too!

_________________
Illithira Frostmaiden (Snow Elf) Guardian of the Frostfell
Elithiel Issatheerin (Shadow Elf) She who Lurks
Isolia Oussea'lylth (Sun Elf) Apprentice Wizardess


 
      
IronAngel
 
PostPosted: Mon, Feb 02 2009, 22:50 PM 

User avatar

Player

Joined: 29 Sep 2005
Location: Helsinki, Finland

Not quite as true as it is in the real world, because the gods are real, and paladins/churches assume to know their divine will. If a paladin of Torm belives a king untruthfully claims to have his right to the throne bestowed by Torm himself, he might be even more motivated to act against the king after verifying his suspicion, no? And on the other hand, little would a paladin of Tempus care for the divine right of an Ilmatari king.

_________________
On Joon, Kjetta wrote:
The guy that probably has sexual fantasies about masturbation. I mean, Iron, you're a bookworm nerd that even in your wildest escapism fantasies flee to the internet to play the role of another bookworm nerd? Come on!


 
      
555444333
 
PostPosted: Mon, Feb 02 2009, 23:28 PM 

User avatar

Player

Joined: 08 Oct 2005
Location: Czechia

Aurora wrote:
Suné can have Paladins, and she is a chaotic God. This would mean that their code would be quite a bit looser in some respects than others.


Sorry, did anyone else laugh at this?

_________________
ImageJys'zyne Do'larn


Man, this account is over 10 years old. Where do I get my old man beard?


 
      
Galenson
 
PostPosted: Mon, Feb 02 2009, 23:28 PM 

User avatar

Player

Joined: 26 May 2006
Location: Down Under, calculating your demise with blunt expressions.

Aurora wrote:
Suné can have Paladins, and she is a chaotic God. This would mean that their code would be quite a bit looser in some respects than others. Well at least to me it does, perhaps she would be a helps


Get out there my children and shag anything that walks!


And to the Original poster, you're wasting your time by trying to make a chaotic paladin. If you're not lawful good you're a "Fallen Paladin" and you lose all the Paladin abilities such as the divine saves, turn undead, divine spellcasting and lay on hands etc.

_________________
Plays:

"I'll think of something once Amia:EE drops."


 
      
TormakSaber
 
PostPosted: Tue, Feb 03 2009, 1:09 AM 

User avatar

Player

Joined: 16 Dec 2004
Location: Somewhere

Unearthed Arcana should pretty much be turned to ash at mass burnings. What a terrible sourcebook, 95% of it.

DnD/FRWIki is also worthless these days as it's disgustingly enough, 4e lore. Ignore it.

_________________
Davion Telemos - Monk of the Four Winds
Korthan Isharnos - Dragon Shaman of Thunder Spirit Zamasham


 
      
Delarwyn
 
PostPosted: Tue, Feb 03 2009, 1:45 AM 

User avatar

Player

Joined: 09 Dec 2007
Location: Aligators land...

Galenson wrote:
Aurora wrote:
Suné can have Paladins, and she is a chaotic God. This would mean that their code would be quite a bit looser in some respects than others. Well at least to me it does, perhaps she would be a helps


Get out there my children and shag anything that walks!




That is not what he meant. He meant that a Paladin will follow the dogma and code of his divinity. He used Sune as example. If I am a Paladin of a chaotic deity, in her name I would be a bit chaotic, but also lawful because I am chaotic because I obey my God.

So, Aurora point about Paladins is that you have to follow the dogma of your God and build the paladin believes and behavior on these dogma.

Sometimes a Tormite will be quite harsh on the application of justice. So harsh it may even be chaotic, but it will still be lawful, since this action followed the law of his God.

_________________
Image
Signature by Qualiz

Del's Characters Entry - Amiawiki.


 
      
FA_Frey_XC
 
PostPosted: Tue, Feb 03 2009, 2:16 AM 

User avatar

Player

Joined: 18 May 2005
Location: XC HQ Alpha, Sol System, Sirius Sector.

xordae wrote:
Your points are all right, the whole concept just sits wrong with me. Probably because it's based on absolutes, and there's no saying that a Chaotic character cannot follow orders. And who ever said that any sort of doctrine that comes from above, regardless if it's a doctrine to uphold order or a doctrine to electrocute villagers and call storms.. isn't inherently lawful? Because it requires fulfillment just like it was given?

Eh, I'm not too good at Alignments but it just feels like it's a subject that when discussed at some depth, it comes to a point where you find a slip of paper tucked to the construct that says "Alright, we did want a toy fantasy universe and not a realistic approach. Sue us."


I've said it once, and I'll say it again - this talk of RP restriction is ridiculous and simply player (and DM in some cases) justification to do whatever one wants without having to deal with perceived "negatives" of taking the class.

So are rules RP restrictions too? How about class restrictions! Pffft RP RESTRICTIONS! Why shouldn't my Mage be able to cast clerical spells? RP Restriction!

If that's the case, why use D&D at all?

Make your own game, roll up your characters according to your own "guidelines" (notice I didn't say rules, because gods forbid we have those, that would mean RP Restriction!) and then go ahead and play with the friends you can get to play it with you.

Myself? I view Alignment as a RP AID, and a RP Challenge. The ENTIRE POINT of Role Playing isn't just acting like your a god among men. It's playing another role, and by that manner it's suppose to open your eyes to a different way of being and doing things. It's about widening your perspective, not limiting it.

You don't want an absolute alignment system?

Be sure to take away everything else that is dependant upon it.

How about:

Smite Evil
Smite Good
Protection from Evil
Protection from Good
Detect Evil
Detect Good
Holy Swords
Turning of undead

just to start a few. I can go on but I think you get the point. It's also protection, from what you say?

From every controntation in D&D turning into a philosophical discussion on who's right and wrong.

Alignment is a definer of your character, just as Class is. You don't want to be bound by Lawful Good tenents? Don't play a Lawful Good alignment. But don't expect to be able to RP a Paladin without being held to that standard by the DM because it goes hand in hand with the class. That's just a given, and the fact that DMs here say that it shouldn't matter is just wrong. The real problem is coverage. The DM's don't want to have to actually watch Paladins, because this would take a huge time investment. It's NOT a problem with PnP games, because the DM is right there. So instead of dealing with the issue straightforwardly, we've come up with "reasons" to justify Paladins of other alignments, (just take this class and RP your a paladin), Paladins who break their tenets but never fall.

The Alignment axis is the foundation for the very premise of the game, which is to play fantasy characters who can wield incredible powers against evil. Stop trying to justify your desire to do whatever you want, accept the framework of the multiverse your playing in, and just get past the absolute alignment thing.

There is a REASON RP games have RULES, and it's NOT so they can be broken. I'm not opposed to change, because change is needed for growth - but there are certain things that remain absolutes, and the need for an absolute alignment system in fantasy RP games is one of those.

You *have* to be able to define good, as well as evil.

Regards,

_________________
Image
"Come under the flag of truce, and brook no treason... for mineself is Death, and care not whom knows mine touch."
- Frey Asaid'De Majere


 
      
TormakSaber
 
PostPosted: Tue, Feb 03 2009, 2:57 AM 

User avatar

Player

Joined: 16 Dec 2004
Location: Somewhere

This DM would like to note that as a generality, Iron is fairly loudmouthed about Paladins and how he feels about them and it in no way is the opinion of the team as a whole.

_________________
Davion Telemos - Monk of the Four Winds
Korthan Isharnos - Dragon Shaman of Thunder Spirit Zamasham


 
      
Delarwyn
 
PostPosted: Tue, Feb 03 2009, 3:04 AM 

User avatar

Player

Joined: 09 Dec 2007
Location: Aligators land...

I kind took notes of some of what Iron wrote though... With a DM disagreeing with the another, how one will know that they are safe to RP something and not fall as a Paladin?

_________________
Image
Signature by Qualiz

Del's Characters Entry - Amiawiki.


 
      
Selvec Darkon
 
PostPosted: Tue, Feb 03 2009, 3:41 AM 

User avatar

Player

Joined: 12 Oct 2005
Location: On a Disk, carried by four elephants, which stand on a gigantic turtle.

Think this has been talked about before. It's a DnD thing, a rule of the class. Kinda something that needs to be taken up with Wizards of the Coast and Ed Greenwood.

_________________
I keels u with my axe!

"Do ye know where the Holy-Flamin' Frost-brand Gronk-slayin' Vorpal Hammer o' woundin' an' returnin' an' Shootin'-Lightnin'-out-yer-bum is?"


 
      
soundofastream
 
PostPosted: Tue, Feb 03 2009, 4:11 AM 

User avatar

Player

Joined: 21 Sep 2007

I am 100% with Frey on this. Don't play your alignment, get it changed 5 to 15 pts each time. With a Paladin, once its gone over that 50 mark...you fall...its really not hard. Lawful means obeys rules and order. Chaotic means, breaks rules, bends them and lives your life freely.

Would a Paladin front a revolution against a tyrannical regime? Sure they would, but they'd do it by established rules of warfare and diplomacy. Orderly is the key to all actions.

_________________
Illithira Frostmaiden (Snow Elf) Guardian of the Frostfell
Elithiel Issatheerin (Shadow Elf) She who Lurks
Isolia Oussea'lylth (Sun Elf) Apprentice Wizardess


 
      
FA_Frey_XC
 
PostPosted: Tue, Feb 03 2009, 5:50 AM 

User avatar

Player

Joined: 18 May 2005
Location: XC HQ Alpha, Sol System, Sirius Sector.

Selvec Darkon wrote:
Think this has been talked about before. It's a DnD thing, a rule of the class. Kinda something that needs to be taken up with Wizards of the Coast and Ed Greenwood.


Yes, and some of the things said are confusing, and are opposing to the very concept of the Paladin as a class.

In my opinion, the Paladin class should be Platinum coined, and should only be given to those people who constantly, and consistantly RP a Lawful Good character.

Of course this won't happen, because it's RP restricting!

:roll:

One of these days we're going to go back to realizing that when everything is available to everyone, nothing means anything or has any worth.

Worth in something is directly proportionate to how hard I had to work to get it.

So, everyone that is screaming about RP restrictions, just realize that when your done, everyone will have everything, be able to do everything, and NO ONE WILL BE UNIQUE or DIFFERENT.

Wow, that's a place I don't want to be. I like challenges, I like to earn the things I value. Makes me feel like I accomplished something, instead of just taking it for granted and assuming I've been born with the right to have it.

Take for example Frey's lichdom... it took three years of constant and consistant RP before it was approved. Three YEARS! I didn't quit, I just kept on playing him as he is... and now? I'm very proud that my character is the only one in years that has been approved for lichdom, because I *earned* it, and the DM's validated that by approving the request.

Regards,

_________________
Image
"Come under the flag of truce, and brook no treason... for mineself is Death, and care not whom knows mine touch."
- Frey Asaid'De Majere


 
      
Selvec Darkon
 
PostPosted: Tue, Feb 03 2009, 6:01 AM 

User avatar

Player

Joined: 12 Oct 2005
Location: On a Disk, carried by four elephants, which stand on a gigantic turtle.

I honesty, I think back and last time this topic came up Tormak brought up the class known as "Anti-Paladin", which is basically the evil version of a paladin. If this class exists in 3.0 and 3.5, it then gives plenty of reasoning as to why paladins exist as Lawful good only.

That means the short coming of paladins on Amia is due to the lack of the base class being included in NWN. Which makes it another bioware thing.

But hell, if NWN was FR online, it would be a frag load bigger anyway.

_________________
I keels u with my axe!

"Do ye know where the Holy-Flamin' Frost-brand Gronk-slayin' Vorpal Hammer o' woundin' an' returnin' an' Shootin'-Lightnin'-out-yer-bum is?"


 
      
soundofastream
 
PostPosted: Tue, Feb 03 2009, 6:19 AM 

User avatar

Player

Joined: 21 Sep 2007

I've had stuff knocked back multiple times. Sometimes I think it was because I just didn't put enough effort in. I usually don't complain if I get a request rejected (which, is nearly 85% of the time) because, I go back and think to myself, "how much do I -really- want this?".

I then say to myself, "If I'm not prepared to fight the DM team to get it, argue a stronger case, whatever, I probably didn't want it that badly in the first place."

Playing a Paladin right is a tough RP challenge. If you're not prepared to live by a code, ask yourself, "Should I really be playing this class"? My own answer to it was "no" and I dumped the character.

Some people who play a Paladin, need to ask themselves the same question.

_________________
Illithira Frostmaiden (Snow Elf) Guardian of the Frostfell
Elithiel Issatheerin (Shadow Elf) She who Lurks
Isolia Oussea'lylth (Sun Elf) Apprentice Wizardess


 
      
QPR
 
PostPosted: Tue, Feb 03 2009, 7:40 AM 

User avatar

Player

Joined: 21 Sep 2008
Location: Norway

Sheesh, do calm down folks. This thread was started as a "I have ideas for a character, but I am not sure if it fits Amia, therefor I would like to hear oppinions and discuss them before I attempt to do anything", not a "I want to play a chaotic neutral paladin because I hate RP restrictions"

To clarify a few points: A paladin would ofcourse be good. No question about it, never said so either.

second: I was asking just what "lawfull means", and got that answered by that the deity's dogma comes first, and mundane law last.

Third; if the deity's dogma is law, would following a chaotic good deity's dogma of, say, challenging mundane authority be lawful?

fourth: Is there any restrictions on which -good- aligned gods that allow paladins?

Reason for all this? I like to challenge stereotypes, and because i believe it should be well possible to debate even constructed moral views like the aligment system in DnD, and have fun with it. The basic thought is not that extreme, just a paladin who questions the harsh methods often used by Tyr and Torm followers, and who denounces the rights of nobility in general because he believes no man has the right to command others just because of his parents.

Again, I started this to hear oppinions and have them discussed. If it does not fit Amia at all, then I will simply not make one. No need to get all screaming over it.


 
      
Kjetta
 
PostPosted: Tue, Feb 03 2009, 7:48 AM 

User avatar

Player

Joined: 11 Nov 2006
Location: A Clean, Well-Lighted Place

Join us Hoarites. We're quite lawful, but quite awful too.

http://www.amiaworld.net/phpBB2/viewtop ... highlight=

_________________
To err is human; to forgive divine, but VENGEANCE IS MINE!
Image


Last edited by Kjetta on Tue, Feb 03 2009, 7:52 AM, edited 1 time in total.

 
      
Guxx
 
PostPosted: Tue, Feb 03 2009, 7:48 AM 

User avatar

Player

Joined: 04 Dec 2007

I'm going to have to go with the few others who've suggested the Champion of (Choosen God Here). You get all the nifty divine granted abilities and are obviously a chosen of your god, well at the same time you're not strictly a paladin (though there's nothing stopping you from declaring yourself one ICly).

And now that that's out of the way... I really do like the idea of a chaotic good character challenging the stricter LG paladins, especially if you use the same argument they do (This is the will of a god).

_________________
Dran 'Brick' Do'ani - The Half-Drow

"Hey, who you calling un-chrasimatic?"


 
      
QPR
 
PostPosted: Tue, Feb 03 2009, 7:51 AM 

User avatar

Player

Joined: 21 Sep 2008
Location: Norway

Yes, I have prettyy much given up the idea of the char being a paladin, but I would still want it discussed, if nothing else to get more familiar with how aligments really work on Amia.


 
      
TormakSaber
 
PostPosted: Tue, Feb 03 2009, 7:55 AM 

User avatar

Player

Joined: 16 Dec 2004
Location: Somewhere

They work like the work in DnD. Not a hard concept.

_________________
Davion Telemos - Monk of the Four Winds
Korthan Isharnos - Dragon Shaman of Thunder Spirit Zamasham


 
      
xordae
 
PostPosted: Tue, Feb 03 2009, 9:09 AM 

User avatar

Player

Joined: 01 Jul 2005
Location: Germany

Fa_Frey_XC wrote:
A whole lotta text


I see you're a supporter of the Alignment system, that's all well and good. But fantasy RPGs don't need an absolute Alignment system to function. I've played at least one where there was no Alignment at all! It's called "The Black Eye". It just felt better to me. I didn't have to sit back and think "Whoa, can he really do that? After all, he's Lawful Good!".. he just went ahead and did it because it was a circumstantial decision. After all, we should assume that Roleplayers are flexible enough that they can make up an idea of what their character is, what he would do.. how well or how badly he can cope with dire situations.. in their mind without resorting to a system of 9 pieces of Alignment.

Why do I see it as a cumbersome restriction? Because in my mind it encourages to think along the wrong lines when reasoning and justifying what a character does. Of course it's up to the individual to be smart about it. But it encourages stereotyped thinking nonetheless. Mouthbreathing teenagers will get agitated over it because it means that they can whack the bad guys without much thought into motive and reason, they're simply evil and that's it, case closed.

I would gladly take away all this that is dependant upon Alignment. Going with a real-world approach, I find the idea of absolute evil preposterous, as well as spells and abilities that could differentiate between that and the good guys. Many, many things play into the upbringing, morals, reasoning of a character as well as one of us Humans. Trying to fit all these into the how and why of a character is in my opinion not any harder than going by 9 Alignments and having to cram the character and everything he does into a niche. Surely you can free yourself as good as possible from the Alignments and just go by what the character would do, anyways, but why then have Alignments in the first place?

The reason why we cannot do without it, is, you mentioned it.. it's hammered into all the aspects of the game and Good and Evil are to be had everywhere. Framework accepted. It's still something out of a children's book and I personally try to distance myself from it as much as is possible when playing D&D. It's a big honkin' RP restriction, and that is what I meant by it. Not powergaming.

Lastly since it was the biggest font, I assume the most important part is to define what's good and what's evil. "Evil is what does evil acts. Evil acts are those that go against an observer's morals. Morals are subjective."


 
      
Selvec Darkon
 
PostPosted: Tue, Feb 03 2009, 9:39 AM 

User avatar

Player

Joined: 12 Oct 2005
Location: On a Disk, carried by four elephants, which stand on a gigantic turtle.

You'll find all canon paladin groups of any diety are lawful good. Be it sune, selune, sharess, torm, tyr or mystra. All of the groups are lawful good. Most of the actions will be the dieties dogma, taken in a much more lawful way. Which is usually very easy to do when your diety isn't evil, since your just take the dogma in context to the current location. Such as hunting a man whom may be a werewolf in a city, in open broad daylight, would be against the law, the paladin would then wait until an innocent was in trouble, or the person leaves the jurastiction of the law.

Obviously if someone is evil enough to be attacked by a paladin, they will likely break the law at some point. Then the paladin steps in. You just use common sense and apply the dogma where sutiable. It's a mix.

Also take into context that on the mainland, a devil, demon, half breed or tiefling, would not be allowed to openly display themselves in a city. They would likely be taken in as a prisoner, or killed where they stand. So being a paladin on amia is extra hard, due to Cordor's weirdness. I suggest you simply take the Cordor law and give people the benefit of the doubt when in the jurastiction of the law. Also, paladin's wouldn't be prejudice anyway, they wouldn't judge someone based on opinion. Generally the racism associated with paladins is from previous experience in dealing with these "evil" races. As such it's more a personal choice to be racist and prejudiced as a paladin, then following the dogma of a diety. I don't believe any deities dogma says that all demons, devils drow, tieflings and monstourous races should be killed and judged simply on sight. Even the elven dieties which promote the killing of drow, state that all "evil drow" are to be killed, though not in those exact words. Which really doesn't matter since all Drow of evil are banned from most surface cities anyway.

_________________
I keels u with my axe!

"Do ye know where the Holy-Flamin' Frost-brand Gronk-slayin' Vorpal Hammer o' woundin' an' returnin' an' Shootin'-Lightnin'-out-yer-bum is?"


Last edited by Selvec Darkon on Tue, Feb 03 2009, 9:52 AM, edited 1 time in total.

 
      
555444333
 
PostPosted: Tue, Feb 03 2009, 9:50 AM 

User avatar

Player

Joined: 08 Oct 2005
Location: Czechia

Kjetta wrote:
Join us Hoarites. We're quite lawful, but quite awful too.


I'm afraid for that, I'm going to have to get revenge on you for the groan you made me issue.

_________________
ImageJys'zyne Do'larn


Man, this account is over 10 years old. Where do I get my old man beard?


 
      
FA_Frey_XC
 
PostPosted: Tue, Feb 03 2009, 11:38 AM 

User avatar

Player

Joined: 18 May 2005
Location: XC HQ Alpha, Sol System, Sirius Sector.

xordae wrote:
The reason why we cannot do without it, is, you mentioned it.. it's hammered into all the aspects of the game and Good and Evil are to be had everywhere. Framework accepted. It's still something out of a children's book and I personally try to distance myself from it as much as is possible when playing D&D. It's a big honkin' RP restriction, and that is what I meant by it. Not powergaming.

Lastly since it was the biggest font, I assume the most important part is to define what's good and what's evil. "Evil is what does evil acts. Evil acts are those that go against an observer's morals. Morals are subjective."


If you seriously are trying to bring in real-life concepts into a fantasy game, you've got a problem. You cannot compare the two, ever. Gary G said to me once when we got into a discussion on the very same topic lol, he said "You're using the wrong word. It's fantasy, not philosohy." D&D cannot be like real life, and vice versa because it's FANTASY. To compare the two is like comparing apples and a Sasquatch. Not only does it not work, but it's not even remotely possible.

Yet Iron will steadfastly defend his right to philosophize on the Paladin Code of Conduct, as well as the class itself, as he did in his entire "long bit of text" up there *points upwards*.

Morals are subjective? I'm sorry, let me explain something to you.

I don't believe in God.
I don't believe in Good / evil entities.

Hence, I don't believe in being punished in some nebulous afterlife for not adhering to some self-rightous code of conduct. I don't believe that anything I do will carry any repercussions, except if I'm caught.

So, you see, I have NO reason to accept good and evil as anything but two descriptors of a multitude describing human behavior. Should I take your perspective and apply it, considering morality is "subjective" (meaning it's determined by each person)...and then act as such? If I did, I have a fair bet the first time I acted in a non-acceptable way, there would be thousands there to point out my mistake, regardless of my personal "perspective".

Yet I still agree to take another's life is wrong.
Yet I still agree to steal something from someone else is wrong.

I could go on but I think you get the picture.

Why?

Because it just IS. No amount of word twisting, philosophizing will change that fact.

It is JUST WRONG.

But according to you, since my morality is subjective than it wouldn't be evil for me to kill you, because I believe you are satan and I am saving the world by destroying you. As well, if Aliens from the Planet discoteque shows up and their mentality is that we look good for slaves, you going to march on in there and accept your fate?

Truth isn't determined by religious doctrines, truth is determined by REAL life incidents in which people said "Dude, that would suck to have happen to me, you too?" "Uh HuH" "Well, then lets make sure everyone in agreement says something, so that next time it happens we'll do something about it." That's how laws came about.

Social trends = Laws when they are put down on paper and given a repercussion if the behavioural ruleset isn't followed.

My point is this : there will always be absolute good and absolute evil in the world, this very world we live in now! And I say that without any hint of a higher power scaring me into it.

I also want to say that just because I'm discussing this with you doesn't mean I'm belittling you. I appreciate your willingness to talk about how you believe in this, because it aids me in understanding your perspective.

Regards,

_________________
Image
"Come under the flag of truce, and brook no treason... for mineself is Death, and care not whom knows mine touch."
- Frey Asaid'De Majere


 
      
IronAngel
 
PostPosted: Tue, Feb 03 2009, 12:06 PM 

User avatar

Player

Joined: 29 Sep 2005
Location: Helsinki, Finland

TormakSaber wrote:
They work like the work in DnD. Not a hard concept.


And that, by definition, means "exactly how the DM wants them to."

It is true that there are many DMs on the team, and one might Fall you for something the other would praise you for. It's no big deal, really. If you think you've been unfairly judged in game, post your account for team review via PMs, I suppose.

(Though I am under the impression the DM team agrees with the view presented in my long post above, save for the part where I critisize the existance of the paladin base class. You will notice that much of it is included in the canonized Paladins of the Realms articles already.)

As for Frey's posts, you already know I will disagree. Don't even get me started on dogmatic phrases like "It's wrong because it just IS, no amount of philosophizing will change that." The value of such a statement is no different from saying "The earth is flat because it just IS, classical music is better than pop because it just IS, and the Bible is true because it just IS." Might very well be, might not, but "it just IS" is the worst enemy of civilization.

I guess the important point is: play D&D how you want, think whatever you will about alignments and paladins, but don't assume your opinion is the only one or somehow more correct. The game, by definition, isn't bound by the rules some game designer penned down, but open to DM and player interpretion (with the DM, of course, having the final say). DMs usually are encouraged to do whatever the hell they want with the rules in each book, in the very first pages of the books. To say, "You can't do this, because it's not how the game works" is sort of antithetical to the whole idea of role-playing. The only one who can say that is the DM of a given campaign.

_________________
On Joon, Kjetta wrote:
The guy that probably has sexual fantasies about masturbation. I mean, Iron, you're a bookworm nerd that even in your wildest escapism fantasies flee to the internet to play the role of another bookworm nerd? Come on!


 
      
xordae
 
PostPosted: Tue, Feb 03 2009, 12:12 PM 

User avatar

Player

Joined: 01 Jul 2005
Location: Germany

FA_Frey_XC wrote:
If you seriously are trying to bring in real-life concepts into a fantasy game, you've got a problem.


Maybe that is true for some points, but I like to think that the process of reasoning within a living being always grows the same way. By that I mean that every living, sentient being able to speak, perceive, communicate.. will have certain tools at its disposal that lead it down a path where it is ultimately not bound to behave in a certain way. There are learned tendencies and preferences of course. Chopping this away and saying "He's Neutral Evil because of this and that, and he'll always have this at the very basis of his being" makes for a very two-dimensional experience. Again, I'm not saying it cannot be transcended with the proper use of a brain, but it is not encouraged in any way by the Alignment mechanic.

FA_Frey_XC wrote:
Because it just IS. No amount of word twisting, philosophizing will change that fact.

It is JUST WRONG.


I agree with "Killing is wrong", just like you. But that doesn't mean it stands as some kind of pillar of irrevocable reasoning since the beginning of time. It is actually a very new thing... except that to us, it is the only reasonable thing. There is subjectivity which we simply do not perceive to be.

If you asked an old Aztec whether killing another human was wrong or not, he would laugh straight in your face. Not only was human sacrifice a central part of their culture... the jungle around them lead them by example. In a world where life grows everywhere without restraint, always trying to suffocate itself soon again.. all of this plays into what they believed to be the right thing. Of course everyone who takes a life has the understanding inside of him that the guy who is killed will not like it in the least. He is going against another's will. That would be another fine descriptor to what you can call evil, but it doesn't always apply like that either.

Bottom line.. What you defend so valiantly - moral absolutes - are very real and solid for us all, but that is a part of how we've been brought up.. and they cannot apply universally.


 
      
IronAngel
 
PostPosted: Tue, Feb 03 2009, 12:21 PM 

User avatar

Player

Joined: 29 Sep 2005
Location: Helsinki, Finland

Selvec Darkon wrote:
You'll find all canon paladin groups of any diety are lawful good. Be it sune, selune, sharess, torm, tyr or mystra. All of the groups are lawful good. Most of the actions will be the dieties dogma, taken in a much more lawful way. Which is usually very easy to do when your diety isn't evil, since your just take the dogma in context to the current location. Such as hunting a man whom may be a werewolf in a city, in open broad daylight, would be against the law, the paladin would then wait until an innocent was in trouble, or the person leaves the jurastiction of the law.


You're starting from recognized canon facts, but you're ending up with personal intertepretation.

Yes, all paladin orders are lawful.

And this is pretty much where the canon ends. You proceed to say lawful means adherence to mundane legislation. Which it often does, no doubt, but it is not the definition or the abovementioned "minimum requirement" of lawfulness. The gist of the topic was what lawful meant, and the answer is: it means many things to different characters. Not because it's relative, but because it's a broad term. A guard, a monk, a paladin and an illithid are all lawful in different ways. You can be lawful without embracing and representing every single possible facet of lawfulness; in fact, no human or even god can do that. No being in the multiverse is purely Good, Evil, Law or Chaos. That's evident just by looking at the gods: there are many gods of Law and Lawfulness, for example, but they're all slightly different in outlook.

Then you say paladins wouldn't hunt werewolves through city streets in broad daylight. What is your source? I have opposite evidence, from the novel Thornhold, in which a paladin of Tyr was chasing a young girl through the streets of Waterdeep to return her to his order, but was imprisoned by guards for doing so. He did it, he didn't fall. He was scolded for failing to capture the girl, not for trying to do so on the street.


I find questions like "What would a paladin do in X situation", and answers to said question, painfully naive. It's like asking, in the real world, "is it wrong to betray my promise" with no background provided. Did you promise to go watch your friend's game, but you can't because your granny is dying? Or did you promise to help them with moving, but you just can't be arsed because there's a good show on TV? Two different situations. Yes, there is absloute Good and Evil in the Realms, but it is a naive and small-minded to assume it makes things simple. People who claim something is simple and there's no need to analyze it usually just don't see the very real complications, for whatever reason. Just because there is absolute Good and absolute Evil in our fantasy world doesn't mean it's known to anyone, or that anyone acts accordingly. In fact, it is logical impossibility: if the gods knew Good and Evil, they would by definition all be pure Good and agree on all things. It's the definition of good, and no one who truly understood the meaning of Good and Evil could rationally pursue anything but goodness. So yeah, while Good and Evil may be absolute, morals aren't. They are a human concept, not immediately related to Good and Evil. They're what guide human behaviour, and deity behaviour. Morals can be mistaken in their quest for goodness, but it doesn't lessen their impact on character behaviour in RP.

The point is, you cannot answer what a paladin would do in situation X. You don't know all the factors. You don't know the details of the situation, you don't know the standing orders from the paladin's ranking clergy, you don't know the paladin's order and faith, you don't know the paladin's cultural background. you don't know the paladin's personality, you don't know whether local legislation is just or unjust, you don't know if it's important to break laws to accomplish your greater duty. You frankly know nothing at all, aside from a broad definition like "breaking laws."

Feel free to generalize, and say "the stereotypical paladin would generally not do X." Don't fall into the trap of using a generalization as a rule, that's a simpleton's mistake. The whole point of making a generalization is to present the average, but that includes the assumption there are various reactions on both sides of the average. Just because a paladin would usually go to the officials to change an unjust law doesn't mean every paladin in every situation will do so every time. That's not opinion, that's not "free interpretation" of the rules, that's just irrefutable common sense.

_________________
On Joon, Kjetta wrote:
The guy that probably has sexual fantasies about masturbation. I mean, Iron, you're a bookworm nerd that even in your wildest escapism fantasies flee to the internet to play the role of another bookworm nerd? Come on!


 
      
Display posts from previous:  Sort by  
Forum locked This topic is locked, you cannot edit posts or make further replies.  [ 49 posts ] 


Who is online

Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 12 guests


You cannot post new topics in this forum
You cannot reply to topics in this forum
You cannot edit your posts in this forum
You cannot delete your posts in this forum

Search for:
Jump to:  
Powered by phpBB © 2000, 2002, 2005, 2007 phpBB Group