I think there needs to be some clarification here about what is allowable to post about someone else's PC, specifically in a journal entry. Journal entries are generally written as first person and contain the character's OPINIONS. Opinions, even as to recorded wording of statements, does not need to be factual, or accurate. There are plenty of ways to get around this... just don't make identifying comments about the other PC, but still...
I weight this with Tormak's own recent ruling that he refused to ask someone to change a post where a blatant falsehood was written about a PC, he said because it was considered IC opinion/understanding, and IC opinions or understandings of a situation didn't have to be accurate. (even though it was used in an OOC request).
As for postings in faction forums, again IC is IC. If someone posts lies about a PC, well that's IC. When it's determined or found out to be inaccurate, they should have to deal with the IC consequences.
Does this really need to be directed & edited by the DMs?
As for the post that started all of this: It seems rather simple to me. The NPCs would have witnessed it - so therefore the screenshots should have been submitted to the DM team. IMO Posting them to the public IC forum only serves to "notify" other PCs/Players that weren't actually in attendance and shouldn't have an opinion on the matter unless they are told first-hand (yep, we call that meta-gaming).
The rule about IC postings which Lutra indicated is obviously meant for IC story posts which are written in a way that it makes it sound like the indisputable truth. I don't agree that journals fall into this category, since those are all opinions and characters can believe/lie about whatever they want. A journal detailing a run-in with a blue kin which paints the blue kin in a horrible light is not the same as a story post which details the encounter like a retelling of the event in narrative form which paints the blue kin in a horrible light.
Re: Post in question...
Aedan's emote included an OOC "because no other way to apparently remove it or whatever." It was obviously an OOC restriction which he handled IC in the best way possible. A lot of people instead choose to emote moving things and just OOC break them, but the result is the same. Stringing up a player and OOC publicly posting up the screenshots instead of sending them to a DM when they are obviously posted for the sake of proving something happened for the sake of NPC response is what is in contention. Screenshots are used as proof, not as story posts, and Commie's notes about the NPCs make it clear he only posted them so the DMs could have NPCs react.
Next time, we can avoid this kind of back-and-forth by just sending these sorts of things to DMs, and not vilifying someone because of obvious OOC mechanic restrictions.
_________________
Login: The Copper Queen Cromlech - The Best Copper This Side of Ruathym Zelly Cys'dina - The Wounded Soul, Also Merchant Aelynthi Nor'alei - The Bubbly Winged Elf
Joined: 07 Apr 2008 Location: That England place (Gmt+0)
Elven Paladins When looking at the list of deities, and over all the Elven pantheon, i couldn't see that any of them allowed Lawful good worshippers. Would that mean that Elven Paladins are no longer allowed, or is there a way around them to still worship the Seldarine, and have access to your divine powers?
Joined: 17 Dec 2013 Location: Just arrived from Korriban by Fury class Imperial Interceptor
Thank you Lutra for being thoughtful and sympathetic to those that are acting like spoiled brats and trying to verbally trap you.
If we can't lie about another character then the drow and every evil character is out of business. And that's just silly.
Hell, my characters have been lied about and it got them killed - More than once. You don't see me getting all whiny about the mean things PC's say. Eesh.
Personally if I include anything in my PC stories that another PC doesn't actually /say/ I ask them first. Otherwise, what your character says is fair game as is my characters take on it. I've apologized to players when their character is shown in a 'bad' light but if that's the way my character took it, no point in changing my PC's OPINION.
Jes is absolutely right this looked to me like a player purposefully attempting to make a character look bad for a NWN limitation. Which is NOT what Amia is about.
_________________
2015 Mr. AMIA with the Fabulous Estara ~ 2015 Best Developed SOB Character: Rith'tar
Elven Paladins When looking at the list of deities, and over all the Elven pantheon, i couldn't see that any of them allowed Lawful good worshippers. Would that mean that Elven Paladins are no longer allowed, or is there a way around them to still worship the Seldarine, and have access to your divine powers?
I think we are all smart enough to realize this isn't really about the event as it is the response. That said we can also see that the post in question is not for pc eyes because if you aren't there you aren't there. Npcs are though. And that is part of wharf life.
Additionally we are all good enough roleplayers to not let the post affect our perception of aedan
Joined: 22 Jul 2015 Location: Lincolnshire, United Kingdom
MazeOfThorns wrote:
Thank you Lutra for being thoughtful and sympathetic to those that are acting like spoiled brats and trying to verbally trap you.
If we can't lie about another character then the drow and every evil character is out of business. And that's just silly.
Hell, my characters have been lied about and it got them killed - More than once. You don't see me getting all whiny about the mean things PC's say. Eesh.
Personally if I include anything in my PC stories that another PC doesn't actually /say/ I ask them first. Otherwise, what your character says is fair game as is my characters take on it. I've apologized to players when their character is shown in a 'bad' light but if that's the way my character took it, no point in changing my PC's OPINION.
Jes is absolutely right this looked to me like a player purposefully attempting to make a character look bad for a NWN limitation. Which is NOT what Amia is about.
You write lovely stories and I for one enjoy reading... more so if I happen to end up in them somehow! heh
_________________ When it rains, look for rainbows. When it's dark, look for stars.
Just a 'so you know,' I have been in contact with Lutra since this post went in. This was one of the first things he told me.
Lutra wrote:
There is nothing wrong with the screenshots there. Screenshots can be made in IC posts.
I've yet to be given any instruction despite an hours long back and forth with Lutra, so I'm not doing anything to the post until I get an official word. I've offered to re-write the post a few times, including some samples, but he just isn't telling me what to do about it. Other DM's were notified as well at the time it happened.
The reason I used screens over a paragraph was to appear less bias, anything I wrote out would be bias, but a raw 'witness' of the event can't be, which is why I posted it as I did.
Lastly, altars can be IG destroyed, but, as I do when I run into one that shouldn't be there, "dissembled" or "moved" via emotes and then "OOC" destroyed so as not to be sacrilege.
As an aside, I did not mean to imply some malicious intent with the post.
Didn't there used to be a rule regarding placables, that you had to remove them when leaving an area? Another question is why place an alter of Selune on the roadway in Wharftown when there is a temple to Selune in the town? This reads to me as somebody doing something oocly, saying it was an IC thing and trying to put IC consequences on another players ooc actions.
I find it hard to believe that Commie did not mean to be malicious in his post when so many of his ooc post feel malicious.
_________________ ---------------------------------------------------- "Toss me...I cannot jump the distance. You will have to toss me." -Gimli
As an aside, I did not mean to imply some malicious intent with the post.
And yet that's exactly how it looked to me. Just saying.
Then I apologize for any confusion my comments caused. I used the "//" marks to establish what I felt was fair context for the screenshots and included a summary so people didn't need to read 5 full-screen pages of text.
Again, I offered to re-write the post with no summary and no comments outside of something like "This happened today :SCREENSHOTS:" but Lutra did not say I should or should not do that, other then telling me "There is nothing wrong with the screenshots there."
I didn't want to post or comment but now that the term 'metagamer' has been used over the use of posting screenshots, one of the first things I was DM told was acceptable, I felt I needed to post to clarify, as well as show that I am, in fact, actually in communication with the DM's.
beciv wrote:
Didn't there used to be a rule regarding placables, that you had to remove them when leaving an area? Another question is why place an alter of Selune on the roadway in Wharftown when there is a temple to Selune in the town? This reads to me as somebody doing something oocly, saying it was an IC thing and trying to put IC consequences on another players ooc actions.
I did not do these things (Altar was not mine believe it or not) so I can't comment.
beciv wrote:
I find it hard to believe that Commie did not mean to be malicious in his post when so many of his ooc post feel malicious.
Never include someone else’s character in a written story that didn’t actually happen exactly as you wrote it without letting that character’s player proofread and approve the story before you post it.
What if the character actually "believes" X character is a cleric of Cyric and posted it on reports and or IC stories? It's not technically lying if IC Y character thinks X character did something or might be a cleric of Cyric, when in actuality they might be a follower of Shiallia picking Daisy in the fields, but the character believes other wise.
Honestly, I think that rule is asinine and police-ish. IC is IC. Honestly if someone reported in a faction forum or wrote in their journal that my character is really an undead drow priestess of Orcus, then let them, be it an Intentional lie or an actual belief or opinion. Others can find out IC that's not actually the case, or maybe it is! Who knows.
If this is actually a thing do you realize on how people can abuse it or how much of a headache it will be to go through any and every character's posting about said character? And cry out they don't like the posts about their characters and want it changed/removed? What if someone complained they dont like a post someone made about their character, and complains about it being wrong or a lie, even though that is actually what happened? People have posted on reports and stories about other people's characters all the time, now you have to go through all of that, so the people complaining feel better about themselves.
Quote:
If we can't lie about another character then the drow and every evil character is out of business. And that's just silly.
Exactly this, hell even some non evil characters too.
I didn't want to post or comment but now that the term 'metagamer' has been used over the use of posting screenshots, one of the first things I was DM told was acceptable, I felt I needed to post to clarify, as well as show that I am, in fact, actually in communication with the DM's.
What I write often makes perfect sense in my head, but the meaning doesn't come across correctly.
Anatida wrote:
Posting them to the public IC forum only serves to "notify" other PCs/Players that weren't actually in attendance and shouldn't have an opinion on the matter unless they are told first-hand (yep, we call that meta-gaming).
That was meant to be the inferred subject of my meta-game quip.
Joined: 17 Dec 2013 Location: Just arrived from Korriban by Fury class Imperial Interceptor
They weren't screenies of the actual event. They were screenies of a conversation. And in my opinion they didn't need to be posted. If you look around the way a PC reacts to such an event is to post ICly. There are plenty examples of witnessed events that don't have screenies of conversations.
Since your character was there you could have posted what your character saw with their point of view. All I'm saying is that you might want to consider doing it that way next time to avoid confusion.
_________________
2015 Mr. AMIA with the Fabulous Estara ~ 2015 Best Developed SOB Character: Rith'tar
Since your character was there you could have posted what your character saw with their point of view. All I'm saying is that you might want to consider doing it that way next time to avoid confusion.
I was going to do this at first, however I felt I would be unable to post anything from my point of view without coming across as spiteful or bias, hence just the screenshots.
And yes I did not screen grab the actual altar destruction because I simply had absolutely no idea it was coming and the object destruction animation is less then a second long.
Why is a neutral report always taken as an attack?
Commie quoted Terralis. He added a bit where he asked for a DMs NPC reactions. Unless the post was altered, I do not see the malicious intent.
Keep in mind that I do not see a malicious intent in a metagaming report. And this, in my opinion, was an act ofminor rulebreaking by Terralis, in a certain way. Just the same way PvP is OOC not allowed in Cordor. People or guards would react. On the other hand, honestly, since all of this would not have happened with NPCs standing there, would it be so difficult to declare the RP void? It happened due to IG limitations, started a big argument, and is a break of character for Aedan, as far as I understand.
Just my opinion here, but it solves the problem nicely actually.
Joined: 11 Nov 2008 Location: In the land of liquid sunshine and coffee
Destruction of placeables when the Player is not present is usually an OOC action. Has the player logged off? Is it just another troll? Who remembers those fun times that certain factions would use placeables to actually block exits of areas so that no one could escape PvP or get in to an event area? If the player isn't there, who knows.
Using an OOC action to infer an IC action is just asinine. If it were the first time I've heard from another player that they felt like they were being stalked by Commie it might just be an innocent misunderstanding. But it's not the first time and to top it off a former DM swoops in to parse every dissenting opinion. I am so sorry that people like Lutra, who is the most understanding person on the server, even has to deal with this sort of bullshit drama.
Some people have actually been paying attention. Running around the server and trying to trap people with what they say to make them look bad is childish. I know that you probably think that it makes you seem intelligent, but it's not. And the only reason more people don't call you out on on it is the fear of Tormak's response if they disagree with you.
It is an injustice when people fear to voice an pinion out of fear, especially when they are being victimized by what is essentially an online bully.
_________________ Thine taste in horrid footwear not withstanding, I did not say that thou were in fact an idiot, I merely implied that such things were self evident.
Destruction of placeables when the Player is not present is usually an OOC action. Has the player logged off? Is it just another troll? Who remembers those fun times that certain factions would use placeables to actually block exits of areas so that no one could escape PvP or get in to an event area? If the player isn't there, who knows.
Using an OOC action to infer an IC action is just asinine. If it were the first time I've heard from another player that they felt like they were being stalked by Commie it might just be an innocent misunderstanding. But it's not the first time and to top it off a former DM swoops in to parse every dissenting opinion. I am so sorry that people like Lutra, who is the most understanding person on the server, even has to deal with this sort of bullshit drama.
Some people have actually been paying attention. Running around the server and trying to trap people with what they say to make them look bad is childish. I know that you probably think that it makes you seem intelligent, but it's not. And the only reason more people don't call you out on on it is the fear of Tormak's response if they disagree with you.
It is an injustice when people fear to voice an pinion out of fear, especially when they are being victimized by what is essentially an online bully.
After the public warning about insults from lutra I expect every instance of character assassination in this topic coming from frequent problem posters on the forum to be dealt with as they should be.
_________________ Davion Telemos - Monk of the Four Winds Korthan Isharnos - Dragon Shaman of Thunder Spirit Zamasham
Joined: 11 Nov 2008 Location: In the land of liquid sunshine and coffee
TormakSaber wrote:
After the public warning about insults from lutra I expect every instance of character assassination in this topic coming from frequent problem posters on the forum to be dealt with as they should be.
If I have to be reprimanded for what I've said, so be it. I will however stand by it, you don't change the behavior of a person that bullies others by pretending it doesn't happen. You can temporize and call it character assassination all you like, but there is a trend and I'm not the first person to have noticed it.
_________________ Thine taste in horrid footwear not withstanding, I did not say that thou were in fact an idiot, I merely implied that such things were self evident.
After the public warning about insults from lutra I expect every instance of character assassination in this topic coming from frequent problem posters on the forum to be dealt with as they should be.
If I have to be reprimanded for what I've said, so be it. I will however stand by it, you don't change the behavior of a person that bullies others by pretending it doesn't happen. You can temporize and call it character assassination all you like, but there is a trend and I'm not the first person to have noticed it.
Using an OOC action to infer an IC action is just asinine.
Why is everyone ignoring the fact that Adaen emoted destroying the altar, and even said that he did so to Commie's character?
I'm not saying he is a 'bad Selunite' for doing this, I am just tired of seeing people act like it was entirely OOC when it wasn't. He never said 'hey, doing this OOC' in which case yes it would have been OOC. I just get my jimmies rustled when facts are misrepresented anywhere, lol
TBH I think the most disturbing thing is that Kilmar apparently thinks he is a feline of some sort, though my suspicion is some breed of domesticated housecat:
_________________ Whomst've'll'd'mn't I play: Salema Nefahri::A penny for your thots Zrae'a'stra'fryn::That which nightmares are made of Khasir::From the East a storm is coming
Destruction of placeables when the Player is not present is usually an OOC action. Has the player logged off? Is it just another troll? Who remembers those fun times that certain factions would use placeables to actually block exits of areas so that no one could escape PvP or get in to an event area? If the player isn't there, who knows.
Using an OOC action to infer an IC action is just asinine. If it were the first time I've heard from another player that they felt like they were being stalked by Commie it might just be an innocent misunderstanding. But it's not the first time and to top it off a former DM swoops in to parse every dissenting opinion. I am so sorry that people like Lutra, who is the most understanding person on the server, even has to deal with this sort of bullshit drama.
Some people have actually been paying attention. Running around the server and trying to trap people with what they say to make them look bad is childish. I know that you probably think that it makes you seem intelligent, but it's not. And the only reason more people don't call you out on on it is the fear of Tormak's response if they disagree with you.
It is an injustice when people fear to voice an pinion out of fear, especially when they are being victimized by what is essentially an online bully.
Commie was not the person who made it an IC action. Terralis broke it. Breaking it might not have been an IC action, but emoting breaking it is.
Also, stalking others is not against the rules. If you don't like being stalked, make sure you can't, ie permanent True sight and spot at like 100. But complaints for that are like complaints about being talked to on an RP server.
I would also like to remind you that Tormak holds no official sway on the forums. So, if you fear Tormak's voice, send it to a DM via PM to have it evaluated. I would say the reason people don't call Commie out, or at least we have never heard of him being called out is for one of two reasons: 1. It was called out in a PM, and the DMs figured it was alright. 2. People don't actually feel it is a problem.
You don't like things your character does being called out? Be paranoid so that nobody can call it out. Information on people, and for that fact, important people, and Aedan certainly is important, gives you power over them. As soon as you accept a position in a guard, you accept the consequences, just like you get what you signed up for in the RL military or police. Can you be surprized if you get shot as one of those? No.
On Commie in particular, yes, he does have a habit of making posts where he voices his opinion. Loudly. But how do his past habits influence his reporting of a completely neutral happening? I simply find it ironic that you are calling Commie a bully, but at the same time insult his intelligence.
You are, yourself, with your post now, doing much the same Commie was, and is, by you, criticized for in his own posts.
It is an injustice when people fear to voice their pinion out of fear, especially when they are victimized by what is essentially the (possibly purposeful) misunderstanding of the meaning of a neutral post.
Commie did a neutral report of what happened. He did not add any opinion to this post. I do not see how this can be taken as "malicious".
Using an OOC action to infer an IC action is just asinine.
Why is everyone ignoring the fact that Adaen emoted destroying the altar, and even said that he did so to Commie's character?
I'm not saying he is a 'bad Selunite' for doing this, I am just tired of seeing people act like it was entirely OOC when it wasn't. He never said 'hey, doing this OOC' in which case yes it would have been OOC. I just get my jimmies rustled when facts are misrepresented anywhere, lol
TBH I think the most disturbing thing is that Kilmar apparently thinks he is a feline of some sort, though my suspicion is some breed of domesticated housecat:
Yeah that 'meow' is what the plc spawner (how I make my glowey stuff) says when you use it. It's funny.
Using an OOC action to infer an IC action is just asinine.
Why is everyone ignoring the fact that Adaen emoted destroying the altar, and even said that he did so to Commie's character?
I'm not saying he is a 'bad Selunite' for doing this, I am just tired of seeing people act like it was entirely OOC when it wasn't. He never said 'hey, doing this OOC' in which case yes it would have been OOC. I just get my jimmies rustled when facts are misrepresented anywhere, lol
TBH I think the most disturbing thing is that Kilmar apparently thinks he is a feline of some sort, though my suspicion is some breed of domesticated housecat:
Yeah that 'meow' is what the plc spawner (how I make my glowey stuff) says when you use it. It's funny.
Alright, PassionateShadow, that actually makes sense.
Proposal for a solution: 1. DMs remove the post and OOC posts after it. 2. Dms post an official notice about what happened. Not neccessesarily public, I think a notice to Commie and Aedan likely is enough. 2. alternative: DMs declare it void. 3. Players forget about what happened IC. 4. Players form complaints (if any) to be evaluated by DMs. 5. If neccessary, DMs formulate a rule/ruling about PLCs and destroying them.
Suddenly, OOC drama goes to the people who can and should deal with it (DMs) and the whole issue of Metagaming is resolved.
Alright, PassionateShadow, that actually makes sense.
Proposal for a solution: 1. DMs remove the post and OOC posts after it. 2. Dms post an official notice about what happened. Not neccessesarily public, I think a notice to Commie and Aedan likely is enough. 2. alternative: DMs declare it void. 3. Players forget about what happened IC. 4. Players form complaints (if any) to be evaluated by DMs. 5. If neccessary, DMs formulate a rule/ruling about PLCs and destroying them.
Suddenly, OOC drama goes to the people who can and should deal with it (DMs) and the whole issue of Metagaming is resolved.
+1 Stellar.
_________________
❤ Amia is Fun Again! ❤ #GreenisNotACreativeColour "It's easy to feel like a hero. It's a little harder to be one."
I don't see why you don't trust yourselves with OOC information. I for one think it's best if we put as few things into the DMs hands as possible. This is one of them.
I don't see why you don't trust yourselves with OOC information. I for one think it's best if we put as few things into the DMs hands as possible. This is one of them.
Because not every one is perfect.
_________________
❤ Amia is Fun Again! ❤ #GreenisNotACreativeColour "It's easy to feel like a hero. It's a little harder to be one."
Alright, PassionateShadow, that actually makes sense.
Proposal for a solution: 1. DMs remove the post and OOC posts after it. 2. Dms post an official notice about what happened. Not neccessesarily public, I think a notice to Commie and Aedan likely is enough. 2. alternative: DMs declare it void. 3. Players forget about what happened IC. 4. Players form complaints (if any) to be evaluated by DMs. 5. If neccessary, DMs formulate a rule/ruling about PLCs and destroying them.
Suddenly, OOC drama goes to the people who can and should deal with it (DMs) and the whole issue of Metagaming is resolved.
What am I getting a notice about? DM said IC screens are fine.
Have some faith in yourself, and the more cards on the table arms us the players with better bullshit detectors so that we can self-moderate metagame, saving DMs the headache.
What am I getting a notice about? DM said IC screens are fine.
What is to declare void?
Mostly the lack of NPC action. It depends. If a DM says Aedan never did this, it is void, otherwise a DM has to tell you what happened as a response.
I don't think I mentioned any npc action aside from noting npcs were in the area, in the same spots they always are, some visible in the screens, when it happened.
I see no reason to declare anything void as the actions clearly took place and the altar was destroyed. Not that it is my place to do so if the dms deem these actions did not happen as I witnessed them.
If the dms wish to do an npc reaction it is on them. I merely stated some people were present in their usual locations.
I think I understand what you mean. Especially im Wharftown, I doubt NPCs would have stood by idly if an altar of selune was desecrated like that.
For NPC actions, DMs have to play them.
So, either DMs state what happened, or, lets imagine a huge brawl would have broken out, which might have killed and then soulbound Aedan (I'm exaggerating to make my point) then it didn't happen because no DM was watching. In this case, declaring RP void would likely be easier than retconning it. That is why I bring up declaring it void. Ultimately, it is up to the DM who decides what to do about it.
I think I understand what you mean. Especially im Wharftown, I doubt NPCs would have stood by idly if an altar of selune was desecrated like that.
For NPC actions, DMs have to play them.
So, either DMs state what happened, or, lets imagine a huge brawl would have broken out, which might have killed and then soulbound Aedan (I'm exaggerating to make my point) then it didn't happen because no DM was watching. In this case, declaring RP void would likely be easier than retconning it. That is why I bring up declaring it void. Ultimately, it is up to the DM who decides what to do about it.
Oh yeah. Then we mean the same thing. Npcs didn't react to a holy altar being demolished because no dm was on and there. If they want to react 'later' that's the DM's choice.
I'm not stating anyone did or did anything the screenshots do not clearly show, just noting that npcs were present to bear witness to what was done to the altar of Selune.
I'm not going to touch the subject of this topic with a ten foot pole, but I'll say this:
61 posts later, are we really accomplishing anything anymore? I think everything's been said, a lot of good viewpoints expressed, but if we expect a DM to look over this in any reasonable amount of time while retaining their sanity, maybe we should let it rest for a while. I don't think another 20 to 30 posts is going to help matters at this point.
-SS
PS. This is not directed at any one person. I just think it's time to let things cool down.
_________________
Account moved to LeathanKayne. Delen and Fosco will see ya on that one! (If you PM me on this, I likely won't see it for a long time >.>)
Elven Paladins When looking at the list of deities, and over all the Elven pantheon, i couldn't see that any of them allowed Lawful good worshippers. Would that mean that Elven Paladins are no longer allowed, or is there a way around them to still worship the Seldarine, and have access to your divine powers?
As someone formerly affected by this, you can actually be a LG follower of the Seldarine (Corellon in the case of Snow). There are official sources that support there being LG Elves that worship and receive benefits from the Seldarine so just ask a DM to help set you up so that you either have no Deity or some random Diety in-game for mechanical reasons.
If I have to be reprimanded for what I've said, so be it. I will however stand by it, you don't change the behavior of a person that bullies others by pretending it doesn't happen. You can temporize and call it character assassination all you like, but there is a trend and I'm not the first person to have noticed it.
+1
The DMs will take care of it when they see it. No point in arguing the actual incidence to death, I think the more important thing to clarify now is the stance on PC journals because it's seeming to confuse a ton of people now.
Also re: Paladins of Chaotic Gods
It can happen. Corellon can have paladins, thus I assume Selune can have 'em. I assume it's acting and developing the Good side of the deity, not so much the Chaotic side.
Amarice-Elaraliel said they are discussing IC screens with the rest of the team, and as a personal preference (not as a DM instruction) would like to see the post edited to be more of a paragraph, so that's what I'm going to do with the post. Because there were a bunch of non ic posts that followed, I'm going to make a new post and essentially blank the old one so anyone looking for ic happenings can just skip over the back and forth.
Again, I wasn't trying to be malicious, I thought it was fine when I posted it as I posted it, and I didn't want to edit it until I got any kind of reply or instruction, Ama gave me her personal preference on it so I'm going with that.
edit; oh even if the team comes back agreeing with Lutra about screens being ok im not going to edit it back to have the screens.
The fact that there is even an argument to be had over whether or not screenshots of what happened IC are themselves IC is unbelievable. Especially when a bunch of npcs were in visibility of thr events and these screenshots allow both pc and npc to view an unbiased account of events, which is especially critical for a dm.
_________________ Davion Telemos - Monk of the Four Winds Korthan Isharnos - Dragon Shaman of Thunder Spirit Zamasham
Joined: 17 Dec 2013 Location: Just arrived from Korriban by Fury class Imperial Interceptor
TormakSaber wrote:
The fact that there is even an argument to be had over whether or not screenshots of what happened IC are themselves IC is unbelievable. Especially when a bunch of npcs were in visibility of thr events and these screenshots allow both pc and npc to view an unbiased account of events, which is especially critical for a dm.
Missing the point. Let me help you out. First the original post was posted as OOC. My attention to detail noticed that right off. You don't want your post taken OOC, don't use the universally accepted "//" in front of everything. If the poster didn't intend that then guess they know better for next time now.
Second, a conversation by two PC's is not unbiased. Screenied or not. The simple fact of the conversation being held by players as their characters precludes that. That's the fun thing about us humans. You get three in a room and you have six opinions. All those OOC qualifiers added by the poster certainly sent the unbias out the window.
Third, a kudo to you Tormak for defending your friend. However, you might consider less attacking everyone and more looking for a nice solution next time.
Finally, a kudo to Commie. You took a crappy situation and seemed to listen to the feedback. I really liked your redone post. Happy Holidays!!
_________________
2015 Mr. AMIA with the Fabulous Estara ~ 2015 Best Developed SOB Character: Rith'tar
The fact that there is even an argument to be had over whether or not screenshots of what happened IC are themselves IC is unbelievable. Especially when a bunch of npcs were in visibility of thr events and these screenshots allow both pc and npc to view an unbiased account of events, which is especially critical for a dm.
I agree here. Given how frequently screenshots are already used ic, and given that screens are the only way to show something actually happened, they need to be allowed to be posted.
Unlike irl theres never any signs something went down. Fireballs dont leave burned grass, there's no blood trail, people don't have to look like they just got in a fight. Showing someone did wrong or that you didn't do wrong (being forced to prove a negative is an extremely frustrating situation to be in and one I find myself in alot) is actually impossible.
Even spells like zone of truth or detect lies arnt believed for a myriad of ic reasons. Screens, ic screens, are the only way to show something actually happened. They should really only be considered by those who were there or would know, but if screens can't be ic as proof of truth or proof of a lie, there is really no truth at all.
It's a required concession for a functional ic society for screens to contiune to be able to be used ic.
And as an aside: Amarice-Elaraliel said she personally didn't like screenshots. Lutra, not as a matter of opinion, said the screenshots were allowed.
Until word changes, until a new ruling comes from the team, the screens are ic and able to be used.
However if you disagree, I encourage you to preen your own posts of screenshots. There are many in ic threads.
The fact that there is even an argument to be had over whether or not screenshots of what happened IC are themselves IC is unbelievable. Especially when a bunch of npcs were in visibility of thr events and these screenshots allow both pc and npc to view an unbiased account of events, which is especially critical for a dm.
Missing the point. Let me help you out. First the original post was posted as OOC. My attention to detail noticed that right off. You don't want your post taken OOC, don't use the universally accepted "//" in front of everything. If the poster didn't intend that then guess they know better for next time now.
Second, a conversation by two PC's is not unbiased. Screenied or not. The simple fact of the conversation being held by players as their characters precludes that. That's the fun thing about us humans. You get three in a room and you have six opinions. All those OOC qualifiers added by the poster certainly sent the unbias out the window.
Third, a kudo to you Tormak for defending your friend. However, you might consider less attacking everyone and more looking for a nice solution next time.
Finally, a kudo to Commie. You took a crappy situation and seemed to listen to the feedback. I really liked your redone post. Happy Holidays!!
It was posted as a happening with the ooc marks used as a summary. It was not ooc, people simply assumed it was.
Also, again, Amarice-Elaraliel didn't rule. She is going to discuss with the other dms if screens can be ic. As it stands Lutra already said it was fine.
An interesting event transpired in the center of Wharftown.
::screenshot links::
If you know it you know it. If you were there or live there and know it then you know it. Doesn't make it any different from any other post there.
Screenshots are just a way to show something factually happened and it's just just total bull; you need to be able to demonstrate that the words on the screen are an actual happening and not just some Bs you made up and threw in the topic.
The fact that there is even an argument to be had over whether or not screenshots of what happened IC are themselves IC is unbelievable. Especially when a bunch of npcs were in visibility of thr events and these screenshots allow both pc and npc to view an unbiased account of events, which is especially critical for a dm.
Missing the point. Let me help you out. First the original post was posted as OOC. My attention to detail noticed that right off. You don't want your post taken OOC, don't use the universally accepted "//" in front of everything. If the poster didn't intend that then guess they know better for next time now.
Second, a conversation by two PC's is not unbiased. Screenied or not. The simple fact of the conversation being held by players as their characters precludes that. That's the fun thing about us humans. You get three in a room and you have six opinions. All those OOC qualifiers added by the poster certainly sent the unbias out the window.
Third, a kudo to you Tormak for defending your friend. However, you might consider less attacking everyone and more looking for a nice solution next time.
Finally, a kudo to Commie. You took a crappy situation and seemed to listen to the feedback. I really liked your redone post. Happy Holidays!!
Saying the entire post is OOC because of two character that are clearly a denoter of context for an otherwise entirely IC set of pictures is the nitpickiest argument against this post being IC that has been posted in this topic. It's like going after someone for a clearly misspelled word, like saying they couldn't possibly have been talking about Selûne because they spelled it Selune. This is the definition of missing the forest for the tees and is absolutely a disingenuous argument.
A screenshot of two characters having a conversation with full overlap of text presented in front of several NPCs is as unbiased as it can possibly get: It is a word of word recreation of the events that recalled and is CRITICAL to the DM's evaluation of the situation, speaking as a years experienced DM who had to handle these situations and knows how these situations need to be handled. Screenshots are king, always have been, always will be. Both PCs and DMs know this, and especially any PC that's been involved in a situation where they need to prove whether or not something happened - and is speaking to DMs about it. PC opinion doesn't matter when it comes to providing the objective truth of an event that occurred in a public place in front of NPCs. Its has its place everywhere else in the world, but there is absolute need for objective fact and truth, especially when it comes to divine matters on divine characters in the seat of that divinity's power on the server when the altar was a consecrated altar placed by a paladin of that saidsame divinity.
I don't care who the player is. I'm not explicitly defending anyone because they're my "friend". I'm also not attacking anyone - and certainly not in the way some posters have in this topic after a DM warned people not to. I'm speaking out about a bad call made by a DM ("screenshots are not IC"), awful treatment from player to player because of a name and two slash marks in a post made by a player who is in good faith attempting to avoid the very thing he is being repetitively accused of, a horribly destructive ruling about player journals and consent made by a DM ("Consent required from all posts involving another player" - in case the subtext of these posts was missed, they were to show the destructive ends to which this ruling can be taken, which is forced policing of topics by DMs because of a lack of consent from one PC or Factino over IC issues. I made those posts knowing Korthan wasn't mentioned but anywhere - so I had no dog in the race except to show how destructive that ruling is to any haracter that makes its stake on information, true or otherwise. This was done instead of saying "this ruling is dumb", to show by example what that ruling meant. As a DM, making rulings means you need to be aware of all situations that are going to crop up - "Just use common sense" does not cut it.), personal character attacks, both passive and aggressive, levelled at someone for the name attached to their post, including such remarks as "i refuse to believe this isn't malicious, because of the name." All of these occuring after a public DM warning to cease insults and personal attacks.
There are two other posts on that page alone of that single topic that consist of a blurb and a screenshot. They are situations which no PC that wasn't there could know about, but in both cases are areas where NPCs are explicitly present and even present in the screenshots. No fuss was raised about either of these posts. There are a great deal more posts in the Wharftown forum alone, where screenshots with text, with no other PCs around, but NPCs are posted, situations where no other PC was present and could see this information or could be privy to it. This is exactly the same situation that occurred here. Why is this one being treated with such scrutiny and disrespect, both for the situation and for the player who posted it? There are even a bunch of topics in the Wharftown forums that aren't marked either IC or OOC, but deal with content that could be either IC or OOC, such as the levelling of bans and information contained therein.
Let's now all play a game. The game is called: "Is This Post IC Or OOC?" We look at posts, look at the formatting and context, and then try to determine if a post is IC or not, based on this, and, since these are past posts, based on how Amians in game and via the forum reacted to them.
// From the Memoirs of Reriam Zedelgel This is the first time arriving in Wharftown by ship. Rumors of bandits are still the talk of the town but my journey was without event. I have to say this is by far the best way to travel. I doubt I'll be riding in the back of those filthy carts with the boxes again any time soon.
I stop by to say hi to Zeke. We are on a first name basis now. I promise to drop him off a gator hide or two next time. Note to self: Kill some swamp gators and get Zeke some hides.
I slip down to the basement to talk to the engineering instructor there. He hasn't seen Willie in ages. I have yet to meet this mythical Willie. I am starting to think that the rumors in Bendir Dale of an engineer named Willie are just that... rumors.
I study the bird and one of the clockwork helpers in the basement. There are plenty of parts to play with here. It's a toy shop. I study the bird closely. I think I may be able to replicate one. Hopefully without the oil leak. It appears to be a faulty gasket design.
Is this post OOC? It has the exact same format as the one in question: Two slash marks, a brief context, and then IC content. If this post is IC, then why is the one in question not IC? If this post is OOC, then why was the situation not attended to when it occured? It displays private information that couldn't have been attended to by any PC present, and to prevent metagaming and accidental gain of information, shouldn't be in the topic.
This topic provides an OOC bump of a post but says IC events happened: That notices were refreshed. If the post is IC, we can assume the notices were refreshed, but if the post is OOC, how are we meant to take it? It's an OOC denoter of context to explain an event that happened with objective fact: Notices were replaced, but nothing else occured. If this is OK, then why isn't the post in question? And if it's not OK, how come nothing happened here?
This topic has the same "issue" as the above one - if we're to assume all of these are issues, for the sake of the ongoing argument and what's being presented here to examine the situation in light of the rulings being made.
// This has been postponed until Sunday, 7:30 PM Eastern due to the Flamboyant Appearance.
The last post of this topic is an OOC comment describing how an event has been moved, but in all likelihood was accepted as IC by the viewers of the topic, and information disseminated as such. If so - how did this information ever enter the IC consciousness? It was never put forth, never explained. The Djinn's arrival is ICly stated, and thus, so could the change of time. If this post is OOC, then, how did anyone know how to react? And, well, I mean, it's got the slashes at the beginning of the post so it has to be entirely 100% OOC with no context or entry into the IC consciousness whatsoever, by the current standards and the arguments being put forth in the topic.
One late eve, a cloaked figure briefly appears near the shrine, starring down on the scene below for a bit before disappearing promptly again, its steps determined.
// Would saturday UTC 7pm work for the people who'd currently hang around the shrine as per their posts? (for your convenience: http://time.is/UTC )
Towards the bottom of this page and the next, we find an entire DM event arranged entirely OOC outside of the DM's opening post. Yet, this was OOC context and discussion that allows in game events to occur as they normally would, since we don't all exist in this game 24/7. I don't need to quote how many more other examples of OOC context and discussion for the sake of events and IC happenings occur - we all even use Doodles for them, and I did ita as a DM as well to make sure things could happen. Yet, as alwyas, in these cases, the OOC is simply a thin veneer that all allows us to be in the same place at the same time, and often as if it were planned that way IC, even though it never was. So how does that knowledge enter the collective IC consciousness? It never actually did - we accept the OOC context as reasoning behind the IC, just like the post in question. And nothing's wrong with any of those other posts either. So why this one?
OOC context is used as a vector to deliver and clarify IC information through the entirety of this topic as well, by multiple users, but there was nothing wrong with that. If there was something wrong with it, why didn't anyone call it out or mention it? Everything was treated in character and the party went off without a hitch.
// This has been moved to the 11th of December at 3pm London time, an hour later than usual meeting time! Sorry for the inconvenience.
The date of the coin festival is changed OOCly - and only a vague mention that isn't denoted as IC or OOC about it being in an hour exists at the end - and I think it's fair to say we can assume that masses of flyers werenot distributed to all of those places in time for an hour before the Coin Festival, so it's probably safe to say it's OOC. However, this was used Icly and changed the time and date of the Coin Festival ICly - OOC context for an IC event, information that could never have been disseminated but was done so. If this was wrong, why was nothing done about it? If it's not wrong, then why is our original post in question, which uses a brief OOC marker to establish objectivity, not IC as well? It can't be the slashes at this point - we see plenty of them where they're used to explain IC actions. And this is only the ones that have slashes at the start of the post, not even counting the many more that have them at the middle of the end, but still contain information that was used IC, such as item stats, event times, PMs, messages to players, or etc - but we're primarily convinced withthe very first two character sof a post, so that's all we're examining here. That's fairness for the argument.
//A small flyer, written in a beautiful script, would find itself posted to the Kampos bulletin board.
//and a day later several copies of the above notice would find their way to the bulletin board in Tarkul and the Temple of Jergal there, Guldorand, the docks around Runedar but not in the city itself, L'obsul, Cordor, the orchard by Bendir Dale and the blood moon orcs, Wiltun, Nesek, and a final copy stuck to the leyline at the Brog Mountain Peak.
In fancy letters Greetings! News from the Holy City! Quite a sight in the Fey Lake today!
The long-thought-deceased Marie de Jerjes has been resurrected from the dead! Once an ashy corpse hidden in a magical coffin, she has been gloriously reanimated and breathes once again!
Thought to have been killed and cursed by her sister, Marie once had high aspirations; She was set to marry Justicar Tristam. Alas her older sister was jealous, and thus had her killed and sealed into a box. The coffin remaining cursed and haunted, locked away in an unassuming building in the Feylake district, mere feet from where children play and where hogs snort at the ground, and just a stones throw away from the portal to the dwarves!
What will this poor time-crossed would-be-widow do now that she once again breathes life? What will Kohlingen do with such a chronologically displaced noble Lady? And what of the property she once claimed as hers?
...and how long was she dead for?
//locations updated.
This post was responded to in character by players and treated as such by players and NPCs in both public and private forums despite there being two slashes at the start of the post. If this was wrong, why did players and DMs support this post, but not the current one? What's the difference? Is it truly the screenshot? But we've already established above that there's posts in the very same Wharftown topic, on that very page, that contain a screenshot with information that couldn't be seen by any other PC except NPCs, and was posted publically and was deemed "fair do's" by DMs and players alike, with no stink being raised. So why is this post the single difference?
User 1: // Was a new one put up in Kohlingen? User 2: //no
OOC information is sought then used ICly rather than an IC post being made - and the posts and followup information gained from the OOC posts were treated as IC on other forums, to boot. Why is this alright here, but the original psot in question is an absolute OOC? The slash marks clearly don't define, at this point, whether or not a post is IC or not - they merely, in many cases, seem to provide context or the situation through which the IC information is then translated. Sometimes, the IC isn't even written or shown, it's simply taken in game! If so - why is this situation alright, but the current situation in question isn't, to the point of being called "malicious" and "online bullying"? This post also demonstrates a conflict between PCs that is brough to the forums via posted happenings denoted with slashes at the beginning of their post, and yet garners no attention. How come the user in question didn't attempt to find out ICly, or contact a DM privately to see if more notices were posted? This probably involves IC help.
A note is left on the notice boards in the locations listed in the topic.
This one doesn't have any opening slashes, mea culpa, but is clearly OOC given the verbage of the post. It's a brief OOC context placer to show with absolute truth what event occurred at particular locations where both PCs and NPCs frequently travel. It's about displaying what happened for the sake of everyone who might live there, PC or NPC. The rest of the post is IC. While there are no replies to this post, I would surmise that any, if given, might be in PM form. While I do not se those posts, I also did not see any public outcry about the use of OOC context to denote IC events.
// These Guests are invited too... Look for your name here:
Gertrude Polaski, Kurchin, Rosary D. Ryker, Dicey Quickshanks, Torsten Eadgarsson, Ser Robert, Lord Marcus Valis, Lord Hector Sylgerand, Lord Tuomas Valo, Lord Avadon, Lady Rania Shadowflame, Lady Amalyth Le'Quella, Lady Las'Claianna Le'Quella, Tristen Swift, Techsmith Captor, Abernathy Hearthhart, Xaviera Xulder Xee, Nyacelil, Levexal, Andrew Fryar, Sanguinius Blake, Abdullah Fadir, Wulf Heimdahl, Silverstone, Sandrox, Emily Thatcher, Andre'us Larson, Crow Meltana, Elrith Meltana, Elwyn Sabel, Ania Viranirn, Jace Fenneril, Pylithien "Pie" Eriamyn, Tabitha Black, Lady Kathrynn Ardelyn and Nathaniel T. Antaeus.
// Anyone unsure about being able to attend at the given time. Be aware that festivities may run on long throughout the day. Planning on an unofficial afterparty at Setersborg too. That can benefit people like Kurchin who are not allowed in Barak Runedar and such.
OOC context is provided to show who receives invitations. In addition, the players respond to these invitations mentioned in an OOC remark as though they were delivered IC. And that's fine! Because they were delivered IC - the OOC denoter here is, again, simply context to show an objective event that occurred, the IC of which speaks for itself: Invitations were delivered to a great deal of people. There is even an OOC comment to say the party will likely run long, and that there will be an afterparty - at an entirely different location than the original Ic event is stated to attend at, and for the benefit of PCs who are banned from the original location. This information is taken IC, and was not disseminated IC (at least, via the forums, it was hopefully said in game). The takeaway here is that OOC context is being used to denote events that occurred IC, with no bias to either side. This one even includes markers of after events that are not available to party goers, who may be basing their attendance on whether or not they're banned from Barak runedar, not knowing Ic that there's an afterparty is Setersborg. And yet, all of this is taken Ic and the world moves on, with no issues. Why then does the original post in question so rankling?
OOC is even used within the IC picture to provide context for the event and give a time that can be used ICly and OOCly to allow players and characters both to figure out if they can attend. However, no issues arose with this post.
A topic where private IC correspondence, something PCs should not have access to, and information that could be metagamed purposefully or accidentally by PCs, is put on display. To boot, the topic begins with OOC marks that are context denoters, to explain the situation by which the rest of the very obviously IC topic is occuring. It has to be IC and is nothing but Ic, as we can see it responded to and treated ICly by both players, with, (presumably) it treated IC in game on the server as well. But there's nothing wrong with this topic. Why is there something wrong with the Wharftown post? It happened in a public area, was witnessed by people, but is otherwise the same situation: An IC post with a brief OOC denoter to show what occurred as an objective truth, including a great deal of information that PCs who are not reading these letters aren't privy to. This one even cuts out NPCs. No harm no foul here though - why is this situation different?
~~~~~~~~~~~
This is just a few posts, in a few forums, going back only a few months, save for the very first post, which was a few years ago, but still holds true to the situation being described. It's barely scratching the surface of the server and we already have this many examples. Why is this being treated so selectively, then, with personal attacks and accusations flying about the people who were involved on one side, based off of, "well, it's his name, so it must be malicious", and other such callouts.
_________________ Davion Telemos - Monk of the Four Winds Korthan Isharnos - Dragon Shaman of Thunder Spirit Zamasham
Joined: 23 Sep 2012 Location: Western Australia (+8 GMT)
This back-and-forth no longer really serves any purpose but to further aggravate. Remember this is the General Questions thread, any discussion should be taken to its own thread or discussed in PMs.
_________________ Elwyn Sabel - Laura Jarshall - Mordoc Ebonhand
On this page alone, I've been called a bully, stalker, metagamer, and belittled, there was even someone saying they didn't care if they got banned as long as they got to smear some shit around about me first... only to see the things I'm being 'called out' over are ultra common-place.
I don't know exactly what it was I did to be treated so differently, where I cannot even communicate the most base of context or post a screenshot without getting jumped on like everyone else can, but I really wish it would stop.
Some people are saying things about me and I don't even know if I've ever actually interacted with them, and I don't even know what it was I did to cause this pattern of mistreatment in the first place. I just really wish it would stop.
After seeing that post I don't even know what else I could say that wouldn't be instantly used to attack me.
If a DM reads this and wants to talk shoot me a PM.
tormak, this sort of post does absolutely NOTHING but inflame people if i did not have the respect for you and your work on the dm team id ask you to leave instead, ill just ask you to take a few days break to settle down
Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 6 guests
You cannot post new topics in this forum You cannot reply to topics in this forum You cannot edit your posts in this forum You cannot delete your posts in this forum