PassionateShadow wrote:
Constructive Criticism on the DM Team...
I just want to note that this is a good idea. We had it back 6 months to a year ago with Mahtan starting the trend, but about specific DMs and plots. It was nice for people to hash out certain experiences with those who handled them, but I think in general it's a good thing to have the players review the Team. It's just like any other volunteer job, honestly, so it's not like volunteering means you shouldn't get reviewed. I certainly do! I think it'd help for us to have a template for reviewing the playerbase (as a whole), too. Anonymous, perhaps. Updated every half a year to accommodate possible changes. They don't have to be read until someone has the energy or the desire, but to sort of corroborate things with other input. It could be a good idea! Could not. Probably best if DMs take some thought about it, though.
Now, I'll do my own take!
1) What do you like Most about it?
What I like the most about the (current) DM Team is their obvious desire to learn from past mistakes. I know that the Team has really internalized a lot of their own experiences, a lot of the negative effects of certain plots and really taken an interest in turning a new leaf on public relations (and along with that, public image). There was a definitive break from the long-term style of many past DMs, a focus on settlement-arranged DMs and a lot of background organization into melding the different spots into a more cohesive workable mass.
I like that the DMs want to support each other and us all. I like that you all want to listen, and that the Requests are being handled with much more poise. I've seen DMs come to the defense of players many times. So many posts about keeping a positive vibe! And I like the spirit.
I really like seeing BoB's stance on DMs being where DMs feel good, where they enjoy the RP as much as players may. That DMs deserve enjoyment as much as we do- I firmly believe in that! I don't know how many other DMs support that stance. I think it's a good thing to advocate for on all levels. It can have dangerous consequences, but it's also a good thing in spirit.
I really like some of the new blood. Mercedes and SamTheGiantSlayer in particular have been killing it with activity and ideas, and while I've been involved in the fringes of their stuff, I'm MOSTLY impressed with the sheer amount of people they've been able to involve. I also really enjoy how they fall back upon the players as their inspiration, and really take the time to get to know certain players and plots and integrate themselves and the world into a dynamic interplay. It's not just up to players to do things. They fully take up that mantle of DMs to watch and react to things done (or not done), in a way that creates more avenues for others/people to be involved! (Even if that reaction is that the crypt the players go into is totally empty and has nothing in it.)
I really like the push of some DMs to hold others accountable, even in small ways. Making sure people answer topics, making sure RP is updated, etc.
I like the recent push for creativity and stories again. The Team got bogged down in a lot of drama, and Alanna really took the reins of trying to re-orient this as a storytelling-focused place. I've seen a renewed vigor in some old DMs returning, whether it's to make sure the players or the Team or the server itself maintain stability and reason. I think it's been extremely beneficial. Amarice, you have really taken it upon yourself to make helpful lists and communicate them with the players. Tormak, it's been nice to have you back without the old caustic candor.
I LIKE ALL THE DEV LOVE AND ALL THEIR DEDICATION. Might not be DMs, but THEY ARE AMAZING. All these crashes have reinforced for me how much we need them, and we need good ones. Msheeler, Terra, Faded, Eurgiga, Ana. Owning things. (I do miss Yossarin, though, on this level as well.)
2) Does it fulfill the assignment?
(?Assignment meaning purpose/server stability/plots? Unclear at this point-?)
While I think this question could be refined a little bit before providing any solid, specific feedback that's helpful for the Team and Teams to come... I would have to agree with PS that there are a lot of things that make me believe the Team is currently not fulfilling its "assignment."
The large, glaring things:
-- Lack of DM activity on many avenues: BoB saying she's on "Amia hiatus" but logging on B anyways; Rigela struggling to come back in spurts (for very understandable reasons, but it's still an undependable absence); Mahtan?; silkelock?; Gorgometh? .. Are you Wharftown's DM now?; Where did you go Manarethan?!
-- Lack of DM oversight/responsibility: Re: No one getting called out on lack of activity? Re: Lost plotlines that were supposed to be picked up by someone? (There's a topic on that somewhere. Maybe someone will find it for me.) Re: Is settlement-DMing even a thing anymore? It was Glim's little baby, but he's gone now and noone seems to be updating that sort of thing. Re: Are we ever going to have a larger discussion about all the big discussion before and mini discussions in all the cities about where people want things to go and where they have gone? Follow up on the one that we had a log printed and goals made? Whose job is that now? Gorgometh did it once? Is it the players to keep it up?
-- Lack of distinct bigger plotlines to follow as asked and advertised: Re: Sammy's attempt to get a greater plot. Is it still happening? Weren't there days being planned for events monthly or weekly? Did it get shut down? Re: Are we planning to wrap up the Truth plot ever? If noone ever does anything, shouldn't Truth like get up and follow his goals, or is it stagnation and static for forever? Confusing. Re: Why are there so many different Ruathym things all at once? Is it really necessary or could we spread the love?
-- Overall responses to OOC conflict. See below.
3) Name one thing you would do differently.
I've been advocating transparency as the biggest thing I would do differently lately, because I think communication is at such an all-time low... but if I were to be wholly serious? The biggest thing I would do differently is to stop giving so many fucks. Re: overall responses to OOC conflict. Right now the DM Team (and playerbase as a whole) are harboring so many resentments that it's weighing us all down. I mean, Tormak came back and seems to be mostly forgiven by folks. And he did change it seems! Why can't the rest go this route?
The OOC Banite drama. The permadeath dramas. The secret societies dramas. The resentment over the Arcanum plot. The shit talked about Amia and people here on other servers, on Skype, on other mediums. The Shrine. Sometimes I feel like we treat shit-talking here like America treats gun control. Let's just post viral videos of insane people who got guns way too easily and shot everyone up, but let's not actually change the laws or talk about the legitimate problem. It must be exhausting to read about another incident, yet another personal thing that got taken OOC and turned into a lasting fallout. I can't even imagine how the Team feels.
But..
it will all be fine. Because this isn't actually guns and real lives. For some of us it feels this way, but that's because it's escapism and some people's real lives actually do suck hard. We all deserve to feel safe, but safety doesn't have to be so fragile and dramatic for a whole community. It may not always seem like it, but I am mature enough to know that this is the internet. You are not in my house, you have no control over my real life. I am beyond your reach, I am better than your petty words. Most of that is true for all of us. (Except when you're dating that Amian and they really are there. Oops, sorry, some of you.)
Anyways, I wish more of us- and the leadership- took it all more to heart. I miss Disco and his no-nonsense style. I'll keep saying it.. and saying it. And saying it. Some of you can take this as another confusing/drama post from Estara. But, srsly, the community as a whole- you all need to get some thicker skin and stop playing into the bitchy attitudes of each other. This place has quickly approached a Mean Girls style gym seminar. I know that I come across as drama sometimes, but I've never said half the shit some of you say about each other (and me). Srs mode end.
PassionateShadow wrote:
Please understand I am not posting this out of spite or anything of the sort. I'm posting this as genuine care for the server and out of my personal observations and what I've come to understand as a whole. I hope that I did not offend any one and I hope that I have offered some insight to those who have been questioning such as of late.
As for this, I will say it was a good initiative, but it definitely looks a little presumptuous. That said, I often look the same way. (And probably do right now.)

So maybe it was intentional! Either way, it's an appreciated gesture, even if half of your message was ending your criticism by being unnecessarily thankful. Not that the Team doesn't deserve thanks- it just seems confusing in this sort of message. You have great ideas, PS! Send more people along to fill it out and help you buff the ideas up. Hope you didn't mind someone else jumping in.