|
|
|
Kamina
|
Posted: Fri, Jan 23 2015, 11:08 AM |
|
|

DM
Joined: 05 Jul 2007 Location: Kent, England.
|
|
I'm just trying to find a solution that isn't just saturating the server with more xp all the time. While I understand not everyone enjoys the current grind, the gap between now and the new quest system I feel doesn't warrant a drastic change like this.
_________________  "Operating in the border between light and darkness, shadowdancers are nimble artists of deception. They are mysterious and unknown, never completely trusted but always inducing wonder when met"
|
|
|
|
 |
|
Terallis
|
Posted: Fri, Jan 23 2015, 13:09 PM |
|
|

Player
Joined: 30 Oct 2014 Location: Ontario, Canada
|
|
Another thing to think of, and it may sound bad (and blunt), but some servers aren't for everyone. I mean, as a whole, a server shouldn't have to bend over backwards in order to cater to all the little things. I get that some people aren't enjoying the new player experience and that things are being changed over time. Some people join the server and enjoy things greatly. Some people find things tedious and feel like quitting. That's inevitable. Often times there isn't a middle ground, either.
As a whole, this is an RP server, afterall. Grinding/adventuring, just like D&D, is meant to be part of the experience. But it's also not the focus. The roleplay is the focus. That's why it's called a Roleplay server. I can perfectly understand the reasoning for people feeling like quitting. As well as you seeking a solution like this to prevent that. I've even had a couple friends that left for similar reasons (but mostly the ECL limitation). But I still stand by the fact that a server can't suddenly change to suit the needs of every person that joins. Again, it sounds a bit harsh to say, but it's generally how things are. Often times, I find it a good thing that a server evolves. However it's not evolution when it tries to cater to everything. Especially when it might clash with something else.
Now, don't get me wrong. Balancing XP and the like is fine, and is a more general thing to consider. But something like a "blanket solution" being needed just seems a bit too rushed. Yes, it'll take time to change things for a great number of reasons. But players need to be patient for such things to be implemented.
Additionally, everyone has differing play times and that would fall under the inability to cater to everyone. Focusing a system on people who have very short play times will honestly just make things worse for the people who play longer. It's not meant to sound like exclusion, but the truth of the matter is that, people who have less play time will usually not be able to progress as much as those with more time on their hands. It sucks, but finding a solution that benefits both sides AND keeps the server balanced is extremely difficult.
_________________ 
|
|
|
|
 |
|
Larsaan
|
Posted: Fri, Jan 23 2015, 13:36 PM |
|
|

Player
Joined: 26 Jun 2010
|
|
Personally, I think just increasing the experience gained per kill would go a long way to making things better. When one of my characters see someone who moves at the speed of sound, or summons incomprehensible things from the eldritch depths beyond, or is loaded down with enough magical weapons and armour that a dragon would want to put him in its hoard, it doesn't matter to them if they've killed 500 or 5000 frost giants.
In fact, most characters at level 30 haven't killed 5000 frost giants. Not really. If characters made IC claims on even a quarter of their kill counts, the server would have the atmosphere of being a bigger killing ground than most layers of the Abyss. As a roleplaying server where most epic characters lead relatively mundane lives, the sheer scale of the level grind is the single biggest immersion breaker around.
On the slightly different matter of early level difficulty for DEX-based characters, I would maybe add a few low-level summoning items without class restrictions to some of the shops around. Maybe make it so that one of the courier rewards is an almost-fizzled wand of Summon Creature II with two or three charges left.
_________________ Currently playing: Aven Brinyflask Safaya DalaiRiyitChsera Hile(Credits to Raua for the sprite, sauce -here-.)
|
|
|
|
 |
|
That Guy
|
Posted: Fri, Jan 23 2015, 14:56 PM |
|
|

Player
Joined: 13 Nov 2014
|
I've read every post in this thread. I've even added some of my own ideas. Here's my suggestion and summation, take it as you will. 1) Many people are upset at the "grind" on Amia. I'm getting the sense that the actual time needed to max level is not so much the issue as they actually feel the "grind" itself is either boring, or OOC. 2) Some people feel their particular character cannot be roleplayed properly until they get max level. IE, big bad types can't be the "Big Bad" without having their levels to stand on when they're trying to be "Da Ebul", or "Da Gudder". 3) Some people would prefer a slower leveling process, one that uses less grinding and more questing to get to max level. 4) Amia is not dead. We still pull in 40+ players on A every day. Could we use an infusion to get more? Of course, but we're far from dead. 5) There is a bunch of new stuff, in the form of quests and scripts coming from the team. We love this, but we don't know when they're coming. 6) We're all players, playing a game, and we're impatient, see #5. Suggestion: If overall, the XP was increased, by even 20-30% per kill (more if you feel like it), those that feel grinding is too slow, would need to do less, therefore, have more time to RP. Those that want to level slower, and feel hunting is OOC for them, will need to do much less of it, and can choose to do less but still have meaningful gains. Those who depend on max level can get there in a reasonable time. Those who just started here and need to "catch up" to the rest of the server can do so in a reasonable time. We would all be able to be patient a bit longer and wait for the new toys the team is creating that much easier. Suggestion #2: Increase the party cap to +/- 10 levels. Sure, there will be higher XP gains. That's essentially the point. Those that wish to get max level more quickly can, and those that want a slower progression don't have to hunt as much, which will inevitably lead to more RP and stronger social ties. People won't "stall" leveling to stay in range of their friends as much (which is a source of frustration), and others won't feel the need to rush leveling to catch up, as much. Summation: If we increase XP gains and adjust the Party cap, we can appease most, if not all the complaints presented. Also, if you feel that you DO NOT want to gain XP so quickly, you can either avoid hunting or turn off XP from hunting. Everyone is happy.
|
|
|
|
 |
|
Analog Kid
|
Posted: Fri, Jan 23 2015, 15:15 PM |
|
|

Player
Joined: 13 May 2010 Location: The Great White North Eh!!
|
Quote: 4) Amia is not dead. We still pull in 40+ players on A every day. Could we use an infusion to get more? Of course, but we're far from dead. Quality, not quantity. RP server. Our toons level should NEVER define or dictate our, or anyone else's rp. Full stop.
_________________ I Am: Derrin: 'Nothing to see here' Beck: Hard working dwarf paladin. Naela 'Widow': Wandering priestess. Celinor Triellian: Paladin of Corellon.
|
|
|
|
 |
|
Tequilus
|
Posted: Fri, Jan 23 2015, 15:16 PM |
|
|

Player
Joined: 27 May 2010
|
|
After reading through everything on here, I think that That Guy as hit on probably the best solution for now. I am sure that the new quest lines and everything the DM team is working on will be completely amazing, but it is also true the current state while those are being developed is still a problem. I am sure we all understand that it takes time to make high quality additions and nobody wants to make the DM team feel rushed or under appreciated at all.
That being said, for me at least the grind is a major drawback. I am a huge fan of NWN and have played on a few servers. So far, Amia has been the best and has the best community. However, largely due to the limitations of the game itself, leveling up can be incredibly boring and frustrating, especially for those of us in off-peak timezones.
Anyways, I just wanted to say that I think That Guy's summary and suggestions hits on a balanced way to address the issue, and give the DM team the time they need to make the high quality work they have proved capable of.
Thats just my 2 cents
_________________ Find me as: William Reave - Ranger James Talon - Veteran Mercenary
|
|
|
|
 |
|
Pony
|
Posted: Fri, Jan 23 2015, 16:19 PM |
|
|

Player
Joined: 07 May 2005
|
|
The leveling process on Amia is very fast, opposed to other servers. We can up the experience point income for spawns by twenty-percent, and it will be still too slow for some, and too fast for others. We can lower it by twenty-percent, and it will also be too fast for some, while even slower for others.
I think it is too fast, but I also think it is far more fun if your characters have a longer journey to the height of their power. So they have met fellow adventurers, have a few stories to tell, and it feels like it was earned and they had a rich adventuring career. When my character faces a frost giant the first time, I like there to have been an effort building up to him taking down such a powerful creature. But that is just me, and I understand others do not enjoy power-discrepancy and feel the need to be level 30 as quickly as possible.
What I feel is much more important than the rate of xp, and the speed characters can get to max-level, is to enhance the dungeon-crawling experience. I want to see dungeons that are more versatile in their challenges, have a greater atmosphere, have a narrative and quests. I would like to see a randomness with mini-bosses, wandering monsters, secret rooms to be discovered, etc. Little things that add more spice when revisiting them. Add to it lore objects that allow characters to discover mysteries, and opportunities for characters like rogues to shine more.
Much of that is exactly what is already being worked on. The quest system is a big part. Not only will the leveling-progression be easier for those who have not yet figured it out or are grand at mechanics, but it will add more enjoyable story and a little extra xp to be gained. You will know where to go, get items that help you, be guided to shops with important trinkets, etc. Simply make it easier for those who do not yet have the amian know-how.
Dungeons are also being improved in quality by having more background story, accurate lore, improved designs that yield a more interesting and immersive atmosphere, little secrets to discover, new challenges to deal with that are not only depend on your characters pvm capability.
That being said, I do not see why we cannot expand the party-range. I'd remove the hard cap it as a whole. The system I would suggest is the following; as soon as there is more than a 5-ecl difference between characters, the highest level character is taken as the point of reference. All characters more than 5-ecl lower, are given his level for xp caculation. All characters more than 5-ecl under the highest level character also get an xp cap. 10xp for 3-10, 15xp for 11-20, and 20xp for 21-30.
Gold income per kill would be handled similarly. Item drops for parties with more than 5ecl difference are reduced to what ever item tier that the lowest should get. So tier 1 for roughly levels 3-8, tier 2 for levels 8-12, tier 3 for levels 13-20, and tier 4 for levels 21+. With the precaution that the tier drop can not be higher than what is usually given by the spawns.
Party A: A level 22, 24, and 27 at the Fire Giants let a level 21 join. The party xp caculation is then 22,24,27 and 27 for xp income. This lowers the overall xp rate. The level 21, as he is more than 5-ecl levels under the highest level character (27) is hence capped at an xp income of 20xp per kill. The spawns then continue to drop tier 4 loot.
Party B: A level 28, 28, and 30 are joined by a level 3 in the abyss. The party calculation is 28, 28, 30 and 30 for xp income. Overall xp rate is lowered. The level 3 is more than 5-ecl levels under the highest level character (30), and hence is capped at an xp income of 10xp per kill. The spawns then drop tier 1 loot.
There is not really room for any exploitation here, but it makes it easier for people to level together. It also does not undermine the current plan for dungeons.
|
|
|
|
 |
|
That Guy
|
Posted: Fri, Jan 23 2015, 16:30 PM |
|
|

Player
Joined: 13 Nov 2014
|
Pony, I agree with you. Everything you said makes sense. Quote: Quote: 4) Amia is not dead. We still pull in 40+ players on A every day. Could we use an infusion to get more? Of course, but we're far from dead.
Quality, not quantity.
RP server.
Our toons level should NEVER define or dictate our, or anyone else's rp. Full stop. Analogkid, I respect you as a DM, a player and a friend, but this is a bit disheartening coming from a member of the team. I certainly cannot judge someone's "quality" as a player, and I hope we're not being judged this way. I've played on servers that had absolutely phenomenal roleplayers, all 6 of them. Was boring as hell. Amia has and I hope will continue to be a beautiful melting pot of Complete and Absolute Powergamers, Build Mavens, Casual Roleplayers, Boss Hunters, D&D Lore Junkies, Total Noobs, as well as the most strict by-the-book Roleplayers, and everything in between. That is what makes it work. To say any of that should be removed is to cut the heart out of Amia.
|
|
|
|
 |
|
Sleep Forever
|
Posted: Fri, Jan 23 2015, 16:35 PM |
|
|

Player
Joined: 10 Jan 2015
|
Pony wrote: The leveling process on Amia is very fast, opposed to other servers. We can up the experience point income for spawns by twenty-percent, and it will be still too slow for some, and too fast for others. We can lower it by twenty-percent, and it will also be too fast for some, while even slower for others. Which servers are you comparing to?
|
|
|
|
 |
|
OpenTheRift
|
Posted: Fri, Jan 23 2015, 16:38 PM |
|
|

Player
Joined: 17 Feb 2014
|
|
The quest system which has been in the works for well over a year will certainly add some spice, the first 1 or 2 times you do it. Just like there should be some spice the first 1 or 2 times you kill a mob for the first time. The quest system, much like the grind will lose it's appeal as you reach the 40th, or 60th run through, as is the case with dungeons. There's only so much replay value something can have.
The most populous server on NWN gives 600-800xp per kill on mobs that can be mopped up in seconds, it doesn't drag its players through the mud of grinding or gearing because it realizes the value of NWN is in the ability for it to facilitate RP.
We should ask ourselves why we play NWN? Do we play NWN because of the game, or because of the RP?
_________________ bad man
|
|
|
|
 |
|
That Guy
|
Posted: Fri, Jan 23 2015, 16:46 PM |
|
|

Player
Joined: 13 Nov 2014
|
|
Opentherift, I want to hug you right now.
While 600 xp per kill might sound stupid high, I see the point, and you are right. We don't play for NWN, we play for the RP. I've gone back and started up the Single Player NWN a few times, never lasted more than an hour or two. It's about the interaction with others, not the game. Also, still, people can opt to NOT hunt, that is still an option if they feel the leveling is too fast.
|
|
|
|
 |
|
Q't'ulu
|
Posted: Fri, Jan 23 2015, 16:50 PM |
|
|

Player
Joined: 20 Jun 2012 Location: Russia, St.Petersburg
|
|
As proof of concept, I currently use a PC with 'active block XP income (from kill)' (on login) and 'no gold from kill' (excess dumped or donated). I have no problems with levelup and worktime (8(+2)x5x4 per month). So, in my opinion, TS is moving his own problems on others. After all, Amia is RP server, as mentioned above.
_________________ Evolution by any means!
|
|
|
|
 |
|
Analog Kid
|
Posted: Fri, Jan 23 2015, 16:58 PM |
|
|

Player
Joined: 13 May 2010 Location: The Great White North Eh!!
|
That Guy wrote: Analogkid, I respect you as a DM, a player and a friend, but this is a bit disheartening coming from a member of the team. I certainly cannot judge someone's "quality" as a player, and I hope we're not being judged this way. I've played on servers that had absolutely phenomenal roleplayers, all 6 of them. Was boring as hell. Amia has and I hope will continue to be a beautiful melting pot of Complete and Absolute Powergamers, Build Mavens, Casual Roleplayers, Boss Hunters, D&D Lore Junkies, Total Noobs, as well as the most strict by-the-book Roleplayers, and everything in between. That is what makes it work. To say any of that should be removed is to cut the heart out of Amia. Remember that I am but one person on said team. This is MY opinion. The staff is the melting pot you mention. That is why Amia is successful. I'm not bring down the team, or the server with a comment like this, I'm just keeping the light on what /i/ think Amia is, first and foremost.... an RP server. game mechanics should never dictate rp.
_________________ I Am: Derrin: 'Nothing to see here' Beck: Hard working dwarf paladin. Naela 'Widow': Wandering priestess. Celinor Triellian: Paladin of Corellon.
|
|
|
|
 |
|
Pony
|
Posted: Fri, Jan 23 2015, 17:15 PM |
|
|

Player
Joined: 07 May 2005
|
|
@ Sleepy Forever: Baldur's Gate or PotM, for instance. I did not play on Arelith, so I am not sure what theirs is like.
@ OpenTheRift:
Adventuring is a part of roleplay. I disagree that dungeon crawling and roleplaying are exclusive of one another. I make a point to roleplay a great deal when hunting. Now, Amia has remained true to it's recipe for the past decade. We may tweak it, we may improve it, but we are not going to change steak to pancakes. That simply is not a reasonable expectation. It is also not very constructive feedback, just as me suggesting a concept you can at the most gain one level per month is not constructive for this server. It is not going to happen, and it does not make sense for Amia.
800 xp per kill on easily killed mobs equates to a lever in the entrance, you pull and get the xp to be max level. It may attract players. It may even make this server more popular. Will it make it better? Personal preference. For me, I think that is unlikely, and I believe it will alienate many of those who have been a part of this community for years. It sounds something that would basically turn Amia into a completely different server, and hence it may be more appropriate for it be done on a new server.
The most populous servers are the social cyber servers. I am certain on some there can be a great deal of wonderful roleplay. But that is not something we choose for this server. This is just to give a very easy example of saying what works elsewhere, is not always what we seek here. I also say this not in judgement of cybering, as I personally do not mind players doing the dirty in tells. Public cybering will never happen here however. Regardless if we would have 65+ day and night on Amia.
|
|
|
|
 |
|
Yossarin
|
Posted: Fri, Jan 23 2015, 17:35 PM |
|
|

Player
Joined: 23 Jan 2006
|
|
OTR's suggestion kinda puts me out of a "job", too, hehe. But whatever works for the overall experience for the players.
|
|
|
|
 |
|
Lutra
|
Posted: Fri, Jan 23 2015, 17:38 PM |
|
|

Player
Joined: 12 Feb 2008
|
|
A lowbie can do some adventuring with a higher level character. They can rp, thus they get DCs. The DCs are something that you can burn for XP and gold => problem solved, no need to change the already existing system
|
|
|
|
 |
|
That Guy
|
Posted: Fri, Jan 23 2015, 17:43 PM |
|
|

Player
Joined: 13 Nov 2014
|
|
Lutra, no offense, but... I'm not seeing enough DC's handed out to make that viable. Maybe I'm just an awful roleplayer, but in my 4+ years on Amia, I've received about 60 DC's, give or take. That's not enough to level 1 character to 30, in 4 years.
|
|
|
|
 |
|
Pony
|
Posted: Fri, Jan 23 2015, 17:44 PM |
|
|

Player
Joined: 07 May 2005
|
Lutra wrote: A lowbie can do some adventuring with a higher level character. They can rp, thus they get DCs. The DCs are something that you can burn for XP and gold => problem solved, no need to change the already existing system I do not think that really a working alternative or solution. The rate of dream coins earned, with needing 3-4dream coins for each level results in roughly 50dream coins required for just half of then needed levels. Dream coins can help when needed, but they are not a reliable source for xp. Especially as some players have the reasonable preference of using them for something fun, instead of burning them for xp. I think it is unfair to use that as an example of a reasonable alternative, and is not in anyway reaching out to those who voice a wish for (reasonable) improvement.
|
|
|
|
 |
|
That Guy
|
Posted: Fri, Jan 23 2015, 17:56 PM |
|
|

Player
Joined: 13 Nov 2014
|
|
I'm noticing a distinct trend, and this is not Amia specific. That trend is to separate XP gain from Roleplay. Roleplay simply (to me) means to take on a role, and play it out. This is D&D after all, that role is of some persona, a warrior, a scoundrel, a bard, what have you. The system of D&D is DESIGNED for you to advance in levels. Somewhere, on nearly every server I've played on there is an unwritten rule that if you advance your character, you're not a roleplayer. I just don't get it. There are soooo many ways to roleplay, soooo many options to slow your level progress, yet, only a few to advance it, grinding being the biggest. I say, if someone wants to fast forward their progression, what's the harm? Hells, I have done it, I've gotten 30 in days. This last time around, with Chance, I made a conscious decision to slow it down. I don't grind as much, I spend a lot of time socializing. It works for me. That said, I don't find anything really wrong with those that wish to hunt constantly either. It's a different kind of roleplay. It's not up to me, or anyone else to determine what style of roleplay is appropriate, as Amia has always been about "Have fun, do what you like, within reason.".
I'm also getting the feeling that no matter what is said here, by however many numbers of people who want a change, nothing will change. *insert windmill stabbing sound here*
I implore the Team to really look at this. Look at how many views and replies are on this thread in just 2 days. That should say something.
|
|
|
|
 |
|
Pony
|
Posted: Fri, Jan 23 2015, 19:28 PM |
|
|

Player
Joined: 07 May 2005
|
|
The hunting and questing system work consists of a lot of careful consideration, discussing and balancing by the dev team. It demands dozens of hours a week for months by those scripting it, balancing the creatures, designing the areas, etc. It is a very work intensive effort.
The whole work we are doing currently is very much inspired by player feedback. The team looks at feedback and suggestions. It goes through them carefully and debates them, once it moves to the dev forum. The team makes sure to do so carefully, because they do not want to ruin the experience of the playerbase by bad decisions or something ill-thought out. They then come up with a plan, and devote a massive amount of their personal free time to it. There is not going to be an impulsive decision making process, nor will we be doing massive overhauls of the Amia the community has loved for so many years.
That in addition to all of the other work being handled by the team. For those on the Dev Team who are DMs that is next to going through tons of topics on the forums, overseeing in game efforts of the playerbase, handling requests, disputes, events, and on and on. For me, it means working on the hak updates, custom content, area design, faction work, etc. That all next to the real life things such as university or your job. And you do want to squeeze in some other things besides Amia and work.
Realistically, after two days this topic will have very little effect. It will be read when they can get around to reading it. The suggestions and feedback will impact the work on the team as the project discussions continue. And then those things that will translate into our work, will be subject to a considerable delay until the mechanical work is done, tested and then added to the module.
Unless you kidnapp us and have us put to work as your personal slaves in a basement, I am afraid I do not see it changing. The effort and dedication to continue to make this sever enjoyable for the player base is there. Otherwise no one of us would be doing this. What the community discusses, has enormous weight on our decisions and work. But there is a component of needing to have realistic expectations. When the players understand and respect that, it also removes a stress factor from our shoulders.
|
|
|
|
 |
|
OpenTheRift
|
Posted: Fri, Jan 23 2015, 19:56 PM |
|
|

Player
Joined: 17 Feb 2014
|
|
not constructive.
_________________ bad man
Last edited by OpenTheRift on Fri, Jan 23 2015, 20:58 PM, edited 1 time in total.
|
|
|
|
 |
|
IronAngel
|
Posted: Fri, Jan 23 2015, 20:04 PM |
|
|

Player
Joined: 29 Sep 2005 Location: Helsinki, Finland
|
Pony wrote: That being said, I do not see why we cannot expand the party-range. I'd remove the hard cap it as a whole. The system I would suggest is the following; as soon as there is more than a 5-ecl difference between characters, the highest level character is taken as the point of reference. All characters more than 5-ecl lower, are given his level for xp caculation. All characters more than 5-ecl under the highest level character also get an xp cap. 10xp for 3-10, 15xp for 11-20, and 20xp for 21-30.
Gold income per kill would be handled similarly. Item drops for parties with more than 5ecl difference are reduced to what ever item tier that the lowest should get. So tier 1 for roughly levels 3-8, tier 2 for levels 8-12, tier 3 for levels 13-20, and tier 4 for levels 21+. With the precaution that the tier drop can not be higher than what is usually given by the spawns.
You pretty much just described my proposal (originally made by Didi in 2010) to the letter, with GreatPigeon's caveat of an XP cap for out-of-range PCs. Needless to say, I agree! There's a separate topic for it now, so get in there! I don't know about gold and loot drops; it was part of the original plan, but now that the twinking rules no longer limit the value of stuff you can give to lowbies, as long as there is valid IC motivation, it is simply unnecessary. I do not foresee drastic level differences becoming the norm anyway; problems currently arise primarily when somebody knows people both within 5 levels above and below themself, meaning a maximum difference of 10 levels. Or when you run into some 30 soloing giants in Brog (or is that no longer a thing?) on your party of 20s just taking first steps in the area.
_________________ On Joon, Kjetta wrote: The guy that probably has sexual fantasies about masturbation. I mean, Iron, you're a bookworm nerd that even in your wildest escapism fantasies flee to the internet to play the role of another bookworm nerd? Come on!
|
|
|
|
 |
|
Zykritch
|
Posted: Fri, Jan 23 2015, 22:16 PM |
|
|

Player
Joined: 15 Jan 2015
|
|
The number one set of problems I'm seeing with the majority of these solutions proposed is:
A) People are forgetting the fact that not everyone has the time to no-life it to get to max level. B) Not everyone -can- RP their character as what they were intended to be without max level. C) The perspective a single individual has about what RP 'should be' .. or 'how' it should be fun, is irrelevant when someone -else- has a differing perspective and cannot enjoy the server so long as we're here, restricting what they are able to do IC'ly. D) Amia -is- dead compared to what it used to be. As far as RP frequency and quality, it is a shadow of what it used to be. The grueling leveling rate is a large part of that problem. Hence why we need a solution now. E) Not everyone -enjoys- taking 2 months to a year to get to 30. Some of you are okay with that, but a large number of people are not. F) If this server is to be successful, we cannot flat out 'ignore' such a large quantity of our players preferences, wants, and desires, simply because a few are 'satisfied' with how things are. G) The leveling rate on Amia is NOT fast. At all. It is widely agreed upon that it is not only slow, but below average for most any server. (Yes, aside from no-lifer servers like Arelith.)
.. I'm sitting here every day coming home in college to a roommate whom I just got into this game, who is TRYING his butt off to really put the effort and time into this game, and to be resilient and steadfast despite the grueling, miserable experience that is leveling on Amia. And every day it's just obvious that he's getting sick of it, and losing the desire to play at all. Last night I was the witness to a rant on the fact that "I'm getting 15-20 xp a kill right now killing rats and goblins .. and every time I die I lose 500 xp. It's ridiculous. I've been leveling for 4-5 hours a day and I'm getting nowhere because I lose more xp when I die one time than I gain in an hour or more of play. And I'm too weak to go anywhere better to level." <-- And myself, a more experienced player and his roommate.. can do nothing about it. I don't always have the ability to sync my schedule with his and hold his hand through the leveling process. And even when I AM around, there's a ton of rules restricting what I am able to do to help him. And the level ranges undoubtedly make it difficult for me to be of significant aid. (Something needs to be done about this now. I'm aware that there's a quest system on the way, among a number of other changes. But they will take time that we do not have on this server right now, as a whole. People are leaving every day, and new players are saying "fuck it" after a week of play.)
Again I'll re-iterate, on a DAILY basis I am seeing new players talking about quitting this server because leveling is just too difficult when their friends are not allowed to help them (buffing rules, level range rules, 'gift-giving' rules, & babysitting rules), they do little to no damage, and they can't hardly survive leveling alone because Amia's leveling system is too party-based (and, as is.. people cannot find a party because no one wants to make new characters).
.. As much as there are people who are against just 'throwing xp at the problem' .. that DOES fix the problem. Think about it. Honestly. There are countless benefits to it, and I've yet to see one way in which it will hurt other people. It will create RP, it will give life to this server, it will make new players happy, old players will see more roleplay, and the endless, depressing cycle of "signing onto Amia, walking around for 30 min to an hour looking for RP and inevitably giving up" will come to an end.
_________________ Inkheart
|
|
|
|
 |
|
Mahtan
|
Posted: Fri, Jan 23 2015, 23:33 PM |
|
|

Player
Joined: 28 May 2006 Location: That place with the green grass and that blue sky.
|
|
I would like put this in a perspective I have. Majority of my time on Amia, as many here know, I served as a Wildland firefighter. That leaves me working 16 hour days 21 days straight with only one day off for much of my spring summer and fall. The slower days still leaves me working 10 hour days, Six days a week.
What I am getting at is I have next to no time to log in. I am also a long time staff member and have responsibilities to meet to maintain my position.
Yet I never have thought it's too hard to level here. Even solo. I certainly have felt that I do not want to level another PC, or that grinding bores me when I rather spend my limited time RPing and having fun. And certainly that being max level is enjoyable to me, since I am a math nerd and power gaming Cray Cray, I love my stats and builds to be ready for end game and everything that comes my way. But really always felt there is options for me to level one way or another, even with only averaging 4 hours a week.
I would either solo grind lower levels, or how system. Being a master in the job system is very useful for leveling, especially when there is no party to join or no RP. Some jobs even can be done as you RP with a group.
For an RP server as well, your PC will be under appreciated if they try to be max level or RP being a badass without ever establishing themselves. RPing the journey into seats of power or importance is what makes characters rooted into the community. If you can not RP your character until max level then you just need to work at playing a role that is not your immediate end goal. It does take time to get into the swing of such and establish yourself. Think of it this way as well since we both have such little time. Is it worth all the time to level this guy max, just to find out layer I hate RPing this character?
Amia certainly is not dead. It is not everything it once was back when the game was newer certainly. Gamespy and the hacking that took place indeed made the game a bit harder to bring in new people and when the old left or RL took over, not as many could come fill their shoes. Some indeed boycotted the server due to banning or rules or what not, and went to other servers. Which is fine, it's great there is other servers to keep this game surviving and meet the needs of others that still enjoy this game. But Amia certainly isn't dead, just matured as many of us been here 10 or more years and unfortunately real lives developed in the process.
Amia is successful, make no mistake with remarks like that. I also preach of giving players stuff they desire in content like clothing and features on the server to make what we have here even more enjoyable. But that does not mean I'll allow anything at all especially in regards to leveling faster than it already is. And to all the PCs you see saying they are quiting, I see many more on my own that love it here and want to stay and praise the quests and job system and the many areas to hunt in.
That's all I got on this really. If you learn the system and what is here, it's not hard. If you make quick impressions then yeah it may seem a bit hard since you haven't seen everything or learned how to use things as intended.
|
|
|
|
 |
|
Zykritch
|
Posted: Sat, Jan 24 2015, 0:01 AM |
|
|

Player
Joined: 15 Jan 2015
|
|
Your argument has it's points. But again, it's exclusive to people that are veterans here, have strong resilience & patience, and who have found their own niche. It doesn't apply to everyone. And that's exactly where the problem lies. This server caters to a very specific kind of person, and due to everyone's unwillingness to make changes (as they are afraid of change, they are too 'used' to the norm) .. we are left neglecting anyone new who comes here, and a fair number of others as well.
I'm aware Amia isn't 'dead' (as in, 0 players) .. But it -is- dead (comparatively) .. RP-wise and life-wise when contrasted with what it used to be. That cycle of signing on, searching for RP for an hour and giving up is very frequent and common here.
Like it or not, there -are- problems on Amia, and multiple people here have made testimonies to their agreement in that, especially regarding the leveling system. When problems like this arise, and we have an opportunity to solve them, the first step necessary in that is -acknowledging- the problems, not denying them. I'm not the only one who has admitted here that I've gotten all excited (repeatedly) about new character ideas, or new faction ideas and so on, only to find myself saying "Ugh, better not. It'd take ages to level it up and I just don't have the time."
I'm aware that what we're suggesting is scary. I'm aware that it's unique, it's 'different' .. and it's a big change. But that doesn't mean it won't work, and that doesn't mean it's bad either. It would solve.. SO much on this server. It would make it so much more successful than it already is, and it would ensure that we keep a hold on the few players that we still have (as well as really lure in and keep the new ones that show their faces and decide to give it a try here). Again, thus far, there has not been one irrevocable or preventable 'flaw' listed with increasing the XP rate on Amia. There has only been a recognition of benefits, across the board.
As it is, we currently have an easy to implement, effective, and rather con-less solution in front of us that will give this server a vibrance it hasn't had in a VERY long time. What are we waiting for? Why are we standing our ground, afraid to move, afraid to do anything? It -will- work. I can promise each and every one of you that.
_________________ Inkheart
Last edited by Zykritch on Sat, Jan 24 2015, 0:04 AM, edited 1 time in total.
|
|
|
|
 |
|
Eurgiga
|
Posted: Sat, Jan 24 2015, 0:04 AM |
|
|

Player
Joined: 12 Jun 2012
|
Mahtan Tasadur wrote: But that does not mean I'll allow anything at all especially in regards to leveling faster than it already is. And to all the PCs you see saying they are quiting, I see many more on my own that love it here and want to stay and praise the quests and job system and the many areas to hunt in. I'm sorry... what? Leveling here blows. If the overwhelming majority of opinions expressed don't convince you of that then, with all due respect, you're being willfully ignorant. I, and many others by the looks of it, have had countless concepts they've wanted to try, endless fun ideas they've wanted to explore, but the prospect of weeks or months of leveling simply makes them give up and give the entire process the finger. Perhaps you're fine with it, and perhaps you're a math nerd, but so am I and math alone can't justify months of grind just to get to an even playing field with 90%+ of the server- and that's really what it's about, an even playing field. To say "Well, you should compromise and do something else until you're level capped" flatly and unfairly dismisses a slew of concepts that simply don't comply to your viewpoint, and at that point you're making the RP call for other people- a role I yield to no DM in any medium. Yes, there are standout examples of why you don't have to be level capped to enjoy the server, but for every one of those there are ten "I got roflstomped for the sole reason that someone outleveled the crap out of me". Even the hard-RPing kobolds (who I love to no end) have bluntly stated that they get molested time and again for nothing other than the level gap. If you cannot recognize and appreciate that an OOC consideration is dictating the course of RP, then, again, with all due respect, I question your reasoning. If there are, as you claim, many people who praise the server's leveling process, then I ask you to produce them. So far, I see the scales tipping heavily if not irredeemably towards a position directly in contradiction of your own. Is it not a simple conclusion, a natural conclusion, frankly an unavoidable conclusion that OOC considerations in character interactions are a Bad Thing? Is it not also clear that the leveling process as it is now not only infuriates but discourages and turns away a great many players and concepts? Why, then, can you with any sense or reason argue against reducing this (freely admitted) pain in the butt system? Do you not believe the numerous and prolific testimonials that the leveling system turns people off from the server? Do you not think them "worthy" because they hate the boring, repetitious and stale grind? I really don't get it- and not just from you, but from a number of staff who seem to oppose this concept. You are, and forgive me for being so blunt, wrong. While I adore the effort you guys put in, I question how in-touch you are with the experiences of a new player. I'm glad you think things are fine. You have the patience of a saint, but to quote Solomon ben Judah, "The test of good manners is to be patient with the bad ones." You're remarkably patient, but that does not mean that what you're patient with is right, or in any sense fair to new players trying to break into the game. I have several 30s, but at the same time I still see that the leveling system is not only tedious but boring to the point that I want to bash my head on the desk after only a few levels. I cannot praise you enough for your endurance, your patience, or your thoughtful response, but at the same time I cannot disagree with it more. The job system is (again, begging your forgiveness) crap for XP. It's slated for overhaul for a number of reasons, and I can't help but feel that one is that its return on effort is more than a little lacking. If it wasn't abysmal, you would see it being used as a viable alternative to leveling. The fact that it's not is fairly self-evident as to the error of any proposition of adequacy. This is an RP server, and on that I agree with you- but at the same time this is, functionally, a "level 30" RP server. Again, while there are prime examples of not having to cap out to RP, there are far, far more counter-examples of PCs who have to alter their behavior because they simply can't be what they were intended to be without PvP viability. To discount this is unfair to players and a short-selling of your own understanding of the game.
_________________ ~Diana de Priondragas - Enigmatic druid, Arbiter, Counselor, Bear. ~Corinn Aldaine - Just a girl with a big heart... who can turn you into a newt. ~Vigdis Haldorsdottr - Walk softly and carry a big axe.
|
|
|
|
 |
|
Zykritch
|
Posted: Sat, Jan 24 2015, 0:13 AM |
|
|

Player
Joined: 15 Jan 2015
|
Eurgiga wrote: I, and many others by the looks of it, have had countless concepts they've wanted to try, endless fun ideas they've wanted to explore, but the prospect of weeks or months of leveling simply makes them give up and give the entire process the finger. Perhaps you're fine with it, and perhaps you're a math nerd, but so am I and math alone can't justify months of grind just to get to an even playing field with 90%+ of the server- and that's really what it's about, an even playing field. To say "Well, you should compromise and do something else until you're level capped" flatly and unfairly dismisses a slew of concepts that simply don't comply to your viewpoint, and at that point you're making the RP call for other people- a role I yield to no DM in any medium.
...
You are, and forgive me for being so blunt, wrong. While I adore the effort you guys put in, I question how in-touch you are with the experiences of a new player. I'm glad you think things are fine. You have the patience of a saint, but to quote Solomon ben Judah, "The test of good manners is to be patient with the bad ones." You're remarkably patient, but that does not mean that what you're patient with is right, or in any sense fair to new players trying to break into the game. I have several 30s, but at the same time I still see that the leveling system is not only tedious but boring to the point that I want to bash my head on the desk after only a few levels. ^ Please, read this and recognize it. We can't just ignore what so many people are unnerved by. Not when the solution before us not only satisfies the unhappy majority, but does nothing to harm the rest. There is nothing to lose here. And I'm sure we all would be happy to see new factions arising. New ideas coming into play, leveling parties running everywhere, RP thriving, and the playerbase showing more liveliness than it has in a very long time.
_________________ Inkheart
|
|
|
|
 |
|
Eurgiga
|
Posted: Sat, Jan 24 2015, 0:23 AM |
|
|

Player
Joined: 12 Jun 2012
|
Zykritch wrote: I'm sure we all would be happy to see new factions arising. New ideas coming into play, leveling parties running everywhere, RP thriving, and the playerbase showing more liveliness than it has in a very long time. Don't over-promise results. I concur that things will improve as characters become somewhat easier to create and as a result more disposable, but I feel your view somewhat shortchanges 'long-haul' character concepts that would, in fairness, be affected adversely by a change. I don't feel a lot of long-established players would like a 'monster of the week' popping up to try and kill them. There are some negatives to ramping up XP- to do so cheapens the value of a character and makes them more disposable. While I personally feel this is entirely a good thing (PnP thrives on new campaigns and concepts), in our present format it'll also aggravate a number of people. So please, when you argue your position keep in mind that while not all the points against your stance are that good, there are at least a few that hold water and you should give them a little credence when balancing the interests. And again, don't over-promise results you're mostly speculating on, even if they're backed by your prior experiences.
_________________ ~Diana de Priondragas - Enigmatic druid, Arbiter, Counselor, Bear. ~Corinn Aldaine - Just a girl with a big heart... who can turn you into a newt. ~Vigdis Haldorsdottr - Walk softly and carry a big axe.
|
|
|
|
 |
|
Zykritch
|
Posted: Sat, Jan 24 2015, 0:27 AM |
|
|

Player
Joined: 15 Jan 2015
|
|
You know, I've been talking to multiple players over the past few days who have been following this thread. And -all- of us find ourselves repeatedly saying "I really hope it works out. I really hope something good comes of this. That they actually do something about it." .. And -over- and over again I see people saying "It probably won't. It never does. I've seen this happen time and time again, people talk about it, they discuss it, the majority supports it and then it just gets dropped. Nothing ever happens."
Don't you want to draw away from that reputation? When you guys have a majority here agreeing that there is a problem, and that we want a solution to be implemented now, why can we not do something about it? Don't you want a better server? A better Amia?
Here is what we stand to gain:
A) New factions. B) New characters. C) New ideas. D) New roleplay (a lot of it). E) Increased activity & RP amongst larger groups of players. F) A better 'first taste' of Amia for new players. G) A happier playerbase overall.
What exactly are we waiting for? Is it fear that is stopping us? A necessity to hold the status quo, to avoid doing anything different? That's a very poor excuse to stand around and do nothing when we have so much potential ahead of us, and when it's implementation is nearly effortless.
_________________ Inkheart
Last edited by Zykritch on Sat, Jan 24 2015, 0:34 AM, edited 1 time in total.
|
|
|
|
 |
|
Zykritch
|
Posted: Sat, Jan 24 2015, 0:33 AM |
|
|

Player
Joined: 15 Jan 2015
|
|
For the record, to reference back something that OTF mentioned earlier, cheapening the value of a character isn't exactly a bad thing. (I'm aware that you said this, but I'm re-iterating it) .. It makes characters more disposable, which means evil RP has more of a risk, as people will likely be more willing to accept perma-deaths and longer disappearances. Deaths will mean more than they used to. And the rate at which new factions will rise (at which massive, history-making roleplay among different groups will occur) .. will increase dramatically.
I remember a few years ago before I quit I started a group of goblins. My character, the ringleader, was name Kayoz. There were literally 15-20 of us at one point and we'd run around in a pack, quite literally. It was probably one of the best experiences I've ever had on this server, and each and every one of us adored & loved it. But it didn't last. And the reason why wasn't just because of different schedules, but slow.. tedious leveling. There was such a variety of different 'free times' that people just got out of sync with each other level wise and the group split up naturally on it's own. The slow rate at which we could progress IC'ly left us very often split apart unless we chose to ditch leveling entirely.
_________________ Inkheart
|
|
|
|
 |
|
Mahtan
|
Posted: Sat, Jan 24 2015, 0:33 AM |
|
|

Player
Joined: 28 May 2006 Location: That place with the green grass and that blue sky.
|
|
I don't really care who is right or wrong. Don't get too excited over it. I also can't make people post or come out over the vocal rebellion on XP rates.
I've been here a long time and have many Max level characters and found how to manage time. Just sharing that and how I don't see the issue as gravely as some of you here do. Not saying that your issues are not real, but they may just be your issues. Much of the job system indeed sucks for xp unless you know the jobs to take. With that I have an advantage for certain. It indeed needs to be rebalanced and tuned to cater to more xp to a wider variety of jobs.
The rest of your post I didn't read entirely since I am in my phone. Probably not going to comment more on this as there is no point since I doubt I'll convince anyone here against how they interpret things. I only know changes are coming but apparently nothing posted satisfys at the moment short of a ten fold on xp rates.
|
|
|
|
 |
|
Zykritch
|
Posted: Sat, Jan 24 2015, 0:40 AM |
|
|

Player
Joined: 15 Jan 2015
|
|
Your resilience, endurance, patience and ability to adapt aren't traits shared by all, though. And the fact that you -need- those qualities to enjoy and endure this server is honestly pretty sad. Not everyone has that, and hence.. not everyone is really happy. Especially the new guys. Hence why they quit after a week of play.
_________________ Inkheart
|
|
|
|
 |
|
Pony
|
Posted: Sat, Jan 24 2015, 0:43 AM |
|
|

Player
Joined: 07 May 2005
|
|
About three months ago, I had someone check the activity logs of the server. It has been steady the past two years. While there numbers of the neverwinter nights community as a whole declined, ours remained steady. Some NWN 1 and NWN 2 servers went down, we continued on. This game will not last forever, but so far we have been doing a good job and hopefully will continue to do so. Amia dying hence does not have any factual backing, other than it sounds foreboding enough that it might frighten people to agree big changes are necessary.
I caution dramatizing this topic into doomsday prophecy too quickly or praising the suggestion for insta-levels it as the true solution to have Amia be back to 2008 activity.
There are also players who very much enjoy the hunting experience that Amia provides. Who enjoy coming up with new character concepts to test out against the spawns and bosses. There are also players who feel that the leveling process is far too quick. There are players who do not share the sentiment at all this is a server where rp starts at level 30.
There are also problems to this that might even cause a lot of negative situations that need to be considered. If leveling is close to "pull a lever" quick, people can visit this server without a desire to stay here and commit to the persistent world roleplay, but almost instantly start a big evil level 30 faction and start causing a lot of conflict rp. Without being more invested with their characters, or caring of consequences. Even without those type of people, if there is conflict between two factions, people can ask their buddies to quickly roll up power-build paladin to squash the dominating evil faction. We may see a lot more elements of an action server. It is not a simple matter that does not have other implications. I suspect we may see a lot more pvp, and pvp related drama as a result.
Take some time to consider what other people wrote. Give others a chance to read up and consider it. If this topic hits page eight in two hours, it will not quicken the process. It might even slow it down, as then you have tons of pages to sift through to find the posts that actually are useful.
Last edited by Pony on Sat, Jan 24 2015, 0:51 AM, edited 1 time in total.
|
|
|
|
 |
|
Eurgiga
|
Posted: Sat, Jan 24 2015, 0:51 AM |
|
|

Player
Joined: 12 Jun 2012
|
Mahtan Tasadur wrote: I don't really care who is right or wrong. Don't get too excited over it. I also can't make people post or come out over the vocal rebellion on XP rates.
I've been here a long time and have many Max level characters and found how to manage time. Just sharing that and how I don't see the issue as gravely as some of you here do. Not saying that your issues are not real, but they may just be your issues. Much of the job system indeed sucks for xp unless you know the jobs to take. With that I have an advantage for certain. It indeed needs to be rebalanced and tuned to cater to more xp to a wider variety of jobs.
The rest of your post I didn't read entirely since I am in my phone. Probably not going to comment more on this as there is no point since I doubt I'll convince anyone here against how they interpret things. I only know changes are coming but apparently nothing posted satisfys at the moment short of a ten fold on xp rates. Oh no, not discounting your opinion at all. I vehemently and vocally disagree with it, but I'm not so callow as to shortchange you as a person because of it. I wish I had the perseverance to put up with it like you do, and the optimism to see it as other than I see it. Tenfold is... somewhat of an exaggeration to what I'd hope for, though I can't fault you as to your take on the opinion of others. I think 3x would be quite sufficient, but that's me. I also understand your viewpoint and frankly could agree with it if I didn't have so much experience suggesting the opposite to my mind. I'd ask that you not characterize things as a 'vocal rebellion', however- a lot of the commentary is on behalf of others, or from people who already have a slew of 30s. That these people are weighing in should be somewhat telling. I hope our position implies (in your mind at the least) that we're not trying to break things nor gain some sort of advantage, but that we're being vocal about something we feel is hurting the server; in that light, I think we can all agree- we all want to help out and make things better rather than merely antagonize you because your opinion is different.
_________________ ~Diana de Priondragas - Enigmatic druid, Arbiter, Counselor, Bear. ~Corinn Aldaine - Just a girl with a big heart... who can turn you into a newt. ~Vigdis Haldorsdottr - Walk softly and carry a big axe.
|
|
|
|
 |
|
Zykritch
|
Posted: Sat, Jan 24 2015, 0:57 AM |
|
|

Player
Joined: 15 Jan 2015
|
Pony wrote: Amia dying hence does not have any factual backing, other than it sounds foreboding enough that it might frighten people to agree big changes are necessary.
I caution dramatizing this topic into doomsday prophecy too quickly or praising the suggestion for insta-levels it as the true solution to have Amia be back to 2008 activity.
There are also players who very much enjoy the hunting experience that Amia provides. Who enjoy coming up with new character concepts to test out against the spawns and bosses. There are also players who feel that the leveling process is far too quick. There are players who do not share the sentiment at all this is a server where rp starts at level 30.
Amia dying -does- have factual backing. We established already that the term isn't used exclusively to reference a numerical player count, but rather to reference a state of quality, liveliness, and so on. The cycle that I keep referencing (that others have testified of as well) .. is a perfect, 'factual' example of that. Your argument, like many others here is following a logical line that we've debunked numerous times already in this thread: "Well, some of us 10 year veterans are happy with the way things are. We're used to it. We've found a way to 'cope' with it" .. Coping shouldn't be a requirement for people to enjoy this server, at all. And that "Well us veterans are happy" attitude basically says "Screw the new guys. Who cares what they think, or want? I can cope with it. So, so can they." Except, they don't share your circumstances, your resilience, or your patience. Basically it's saying the solution to our problems is to make no solution and just 'deal with it'. That kind of an attitude will never make this server grow. Just as denying the flaws Amia has will never do anything to improve it.And as far as new evil factions rising (or good, as good factions will rise too) .. So what? If anything that's a good thing. There's an entire thread out there regarding how conflict breeds roleplay and makes it thrive on Amia: viewtopic.php?f=2&t=80279
_________________ Inkheart
Last edited by Zykritch on Sat, Jan 24 2015, 1:09 AM, edited 4 times in total.
|
|
|
|
 |
|
LetumLux
|
Posted: Sat, Jan 24 2015, 1:04 AM |
|
|

Player
Joined: 31 May 2007 Location: Amia IKEA
|
|
I'm going to do a lock intermission in 30 minutes to give everyone a chance to thoroughly read and comprehend what has already been posted without feeling like they have to skip that crucial part of a discussion to get their post in before the target has shifted again.
|
|
|
|
 |
|
Pony
|
Posted: Sat, Jan 24 2015, 1:05 AM |
|
|

Player
Joined: 07 May 2005
|
|
Do yourself a favor and calm down a little. You are hurting your own case and those who feel similarly to you with posts like this.
|
|
|
|
 |
|
LetumLux
|
Posted: Sat, Jan 24 2015, 1:29 AM |
|
|

Player
Joined: 31 May 2007 Location: Amia IKEA
|
If you were still typing up a reply and got stopped up by the lock, you should be able to use the back on your browser to grab and copy your post so it doesn't get lost.
|
|
|
|
 |
|
LetumLux
|
Posted: Sat, Jan 24 2015, 10:17 AM |
|
|

Player
Joined: 31 May 2007 Location: Amia IKEA
|
|
|
|
 |
|
Pony
|
Posted: Sat, Jan 24 2015, 12:33 PM |
|
|

Player
Joined: 07 May 2005
|
|
In response to a few things you wrote about...
@ Difficulty finding roleplay
Players having a hard time finding others to roleplay with is an issue primarily related to server spread. It bugs me incredibly. This remains the issue that I feel is the number one thing that Amia has to deal with, as it is also my opinion it is the single most damaging problem of the server. I do not think we have done or are doing enough on that front. A working solution would also the best fix to raise activity on this server imo. Not necessarily in a massive activity spike, but something that could be felt.
I personally felt and continue to feel strongly in favor of my proposal of a single server hub system for the server. Namely, Cordor being expanded in its roleplay possibilities and having a dominant presence of several DMs. Not the removal of other hubs, but simply a strong central presence in a single big city in which there would never be a problem to find a diverse amount of roleplay. The best chance to do so however has passed. To get it done now would be even harder to explain story wise and feel quite forced.
The problem is even the tri-hub solution we agreed on (which I believe could work) was then watered down, and we ignore what little we agreed on often enough, to the point it is not really accurate to call it a solution. I also think it is in no small part a player problem. If you want to be able to find steady rp, have lots of it concentrated in one place, make it easy for hunting parties to get together, we need to stop splitting our playerbase as we are doing now. It is not an easy feat, but we are really not trying properly.
@ Insta-levels helping rp be found
You are not wrong that insta-level 30 characters may help with the sever spread problem from another direction. I do not believe it is the right one however, because it would bloat the server with alt characters, and fad factions which simply fluctuate through the hubs.
@ All type of conflict equals fun for everyone
Conflict can be a great way to spice things up. It however needs to be focused on roleplay. In addition, it needs to have a quality and maturity to it. It is naïve and shortsighted to say that just upping the quantity of conflict encounters between players will contribute positively to the server. If it were the case, the last group of evil factions would not have been struggling. You can also just take a look in the latest pvp rule discussion topic and see for yourself how welcoming a good part of our players are to the idea of their characters getting a boo-boo from another player’s character.
Insta-level 30 characters invites conflict “rp” problems, and we do not need a lot of pvp-related disputes or grieving. Or worse, disputes between factions of people pointing out that the battle was only won as ten people made power-builds the day before on request of a pal, which results in bad blood. Dismissing the drawbacks of your proposal, by basically suggesting all type of conflict results in great activity-encouraging roleplay, is obviously not accurate. Else we would never had the banite or cultists of orcus factions dying because of players not being able to handle it.
I very much believe conflict rp is an important part of a server that I would like to see return to be more present. But I want it to work. It is not going to work this way.
@ The vets'hate'us-theory
You are wrong. I will leave it at that, as else I would be referring to a donkey's bum in my response.
|
|
|
|
 |
|
Tyrak
|
Posted: Sat, Jan 24 2015, 13:09 PM |
|
|

Player
Joined: 31 Oct 2014 Location: In Falsetto
|
Okay, so, before the post-intermission dialogue gets too deep into various things, I'd like to bring something to the forefront real quick. I'm not going to get very involved in the whole EXP-rate conversation, or the "is Amia dying" conversation, and all that jazz. At least, not now. Though I will say that, as Larsaan very aptly put it, it is rather insane that most characters on the server have higher killcounts than many international wartime skirmishes. So. Uh. Just some food for thought, there. But, regarding that issue, I'm just going to keep observing for the moment. Instead, I'd like to try and bring a specific topic to the centre of conversation for a post or two: The ECL Limit.Seriously, I've read the last two pages of responses, and it seems like most people are in agreement to expanding or even removing this thing entirely, just because it's an extremely-frustrating hindrance to RP, as I pointed out in my massive post earlier. I've yet to see any good arguments for leaving it as it is, except for "higher-level players will help our newcomers". To which I say: Yes, they probably will, and I don't see an issue with that. It's teamwork, it helps build connections, and in a server where I'd estimate 60-80% of the characters being played are already above level 20, it'd be kind of nice for newcomers to be able to play with them. This is one of the big reasons that people want to progress so rapidly: Because they can't play with their friends until they do. In contrast, there's some great arguments for changing it. Biggest one is that, well, yeah, it's a huge hindrance to RP. Like, the biggest hindrance to RP that I can think of on this server. It prevents you from playing with many people you know, playing with many people you don't know, and makes it significantly harder to do any kind of dungeoneering with a group. And having to do it solo is, I'm sorry, boring. Which makes the grind even less pleasant. Which makes it seem slower. Which makes it seem to last longer. It's this... awful progression of effects that build onto each other and just makes it a big pain in the neck. As a server that proudly proclaims that it puts RP first, I would hope that we'd want to seriously, seriously consider changing this for that reason alone. To put RP first. And even if we're more worried about mechanics or people going too fast, or whatever, there's still some great arguments for changing it. I'm gonna quote Analog Kid, who doesn't seem particularly enthusiastic about most of these ideas, but said something very useful: Analog Kid wrote: game mechanics should never dictate rp. I agree. Sincerely. As I think many people do. Which is the biggest reason I hate the ECL Limit, as it is. Over and over again it dictates how RP is supposed to be played out, and leads to countless awkward OOC conversations and backtracking when you realize that guy you just invited is out of your level range, or that you have to leave some of your friends behind to play with them. It sucks. So, then, could we please do something about the ECL Limit? Even if the grind is too slow, or too fast, or whatever you guys decide it is, it's always going to be better with friends. And anything that facilitates more interesting RP is a good thing. On, you know. An RP server. Changing the ECL Limit from its current system might even help solve some of these issues that keep coming up, as people are able to party together more, have more fun in dungeons on a regular basis, and new players are able to be assisted by more veterans. Also, as for how to change it, I enjoy Pony's idea. Seems like a good system. But no matter how we change it to be less restrictive, I strongly believe it needs to be. Somehow.
_________________ Currently Playing:
- Krel'xiekiv - Kobold Scout
- Aldriano Alode'tnen - Fabulous Bard

|
|
|
|
 |
|
errk
|
Posted: Sat, Jan 24 2015, 13:40 PM |
|
|

Player
Joined: 17 Mar 2014 Location: Sweden
|
|
Gah.. this thread took some time to read. I'll keep it short.
I agree with "Guy" and several others. Expand or remove the ECL cap!
I'll help anyone and everyone grind, and get really sad when not able to run with a new player just starting out. (true, I can create yet another alt.. but switching identity all the time is really annoying)
There will be babysitting, zero-RP grinds, and people who clearly want to reach lvl 30 within days.. But if they OOC chat or only want to lvl and don't spend time responding to IC chat, I usually end up IC leaving. I usually don't see these "powergamers" once they hit 30 anyway.. so don't mind someone rushing past me lvl-wise.
|
|
|
|
 |
|
Tyrak
|
Posted: Sat, Jan 24 2015, 13:50 PM |
|
|

Player
Joined: 31 Oct 2014 Location: In Falsetto
|
Oh, also, there was something I really felt the need to comment on, but I wanted to keep it separate from the textdump on the ECL Limit for ease of reading. So, here's another wall of text. Apologies in advance! Mahtan Tasadur wrote: I've been here a long time and have many Max level characters and found how to manage time. Just sharing that and how I don't see the issue as gravely as some of you here do. Not saying that your issues are not real, but they may just be your issues. Much of the job system indeed sucks for xp unless you know the jobs to take. Mahtan Tasadur wrote: That's all I got on this really. If you learn the system and what is here, it's not hard. If you make quick impressions then yeah it may seem a bit hard since you haven't seen everything or learned how to use things as intended. Mahtan Tasadur wrote: And to all the PCs you see saying they are quiting, I see many more on my own that love it here and want to stay and praise the quests and job system and the many areas to hunt in. I'm quoting Mahtan Tasadur not because I'm personally aiming this at him/her (though he/she is one of the people I'm addressing), but because these statements really exemplify an attitude that I'm seeing repeatedly, and it's kind of starting to bother me. In response to the argument that these issues "may just be our issues"... Er. Well, yeah. They are. They're just our issues. "Our" referring to the part of the community that hasn't been here for a long time. "Our" referring to the part of the community that doesn't know the ins and outs of all the server's dungeons, which ones to go to at what time, and how much EXP they'll give. "Our" being those who don't actually, as Mahtan put it, "know the jobs to take". "Our" being, yeah, new or inexperienced players. You are entirely right, Mahtan Tasadur. These are just our problems.The question is: Does that mean we should ignore them?I mean, I'd sincerely like to think that that isn't how Amia works. I've repeatedly stated - on the forums, even - that Amia's a really open and friendly server whose really tries to help you out when you get started, and whose staff and veterans really care. I do not believe in the so-called "vets'hate'us theory", as Pony quite adequately summed it up. I know some who do. Some who believe in it strongly. But I, personally, do not. But I'm starting to worry that, with some vets, yeah, this might be an issue. But there are some rather clear and impossible-to-ignore facts that have come to light in this thread. Three, in fact. - 1: Amia has some issues with its leveling/progression system that are causing significant problems and discouragement among a portion of the playerbase.
- 2: This portion of the playerbase is primarily made up of newer players and those who wish to support them.
- 3: These problems are issues that some people feel strongly enough about to speak out over it (quite a bit, in a very short period of time), while others have felt strongly enough that they've left the server due to lack of enjoyment.
This thread's very existence and the contents within are very solid, visible, and concrete evidence of these points. Enough so that we should acknowledge them. Yes, they are not issues that affect everyone, but they are, as it was said, "our issues". The burning, million-dollar question, however, is: Do we as a server actually care about this group's issues enough to try and help with them? I don't honestly know the answer. I mean, if we don't... Well. That's that, I guess. I'd be genuinely disappointed, myself, but. Not much to be done. But, I would like to think that we, as a collective, care enough about our playerbase as a whole to try and acknowledge that this is an issue that many people feel strongly and negatively about, and would want to change it despite there being "many more that love it here" just the way it is. It's clear that at least some people other than the ones experiencing "our issues" feel this way, and I'm very glad for people such as Eurgiga - people who don't experience these issues, and still want to see them fixed for us regardless. Again, I'm not particularly outspoken for any specific changes at the moment (except the ECL Limit being changed because man I dislike that thing), but I would just really like to hope that this is something that the staff, developers, and server as a whole are willing to care about, because we - another portion of the playerbase - care about it. I would really like to hope that with the knowledge that, with new people (including no less than three of my friends) frequently leaving the server over these things, we'd like to look into them for their sakes and for the sake of the server as a whole in the long-term. Even if they are "just our issues". Or, at the very least, give us the courtesy to "entire read" these things before weighing in or disregarding these ideas entirely. I can respect disagreeing opinions, but not if one is unwilling to actually listen to the issue they're talking about, first. So, let's all read each others' posts, try to see things from every perspective, and talk about this like people. Please. (Disclaimer: Mr./Ms. Mahtan Tasadur, I do not actually know you, nor have anything against you as a person. At all. Like, seriously. Your posts in this thread have just been very... Uh. Quotable, obviously. And serve to demonstrate a mindset that I hope isn't shared by the server as a whole.)(plus for all I know you might just be having a bad day)
_________________ Currently Playing:
- Krel'xiekiv - Kobold Scout
- Aldriano Alode'tnen - Fabulous Bard

|
|
|
|
 |
|
Kamina
|
Posted: Sat, Jan 24 2015, 14:24 PM |
|
|

DM
Joined: 05 Jul 2007 Location: Kent, England.
|
|
Without quoting Tyrak, the trend of expecting newbies to have the knowledge of older members isn't bad in itself: It's when a newbie turns to the older members asking "how do I do this" on the forums or what have you, and most of the time is greeted with "explore ICly". Yeah, it's great to have a spark of interaction of finding people that know where to find X or to complete X quest, but here's the problem:
Older members will rarely, if ever, roleplay new characters that don't have the same OOC knowledge of themselves after the first time.
When you make a new character after your first couple, you tend to have insight what gear's best, where to find the gear, what quests are worthwhile, what areas are best to grind. But how many of you genuinely roleplay your characters who haven't had that knowledge told ICly?
We shouldn't expect newbies to ask ICly when we're just as guilty of harbouring OOC knowledge without RP cause.
_________________  "Operating in the border between light and darkness, shadowdancers are nimble artists of deception. They are mysterious and unknown, never completely trusted but always inducing wonder when met"
|
|
|
|
 |
|
Broldi
|
Posted: Sat, Jan 24 2015, 14:32 PM |
|
|

Player
Joined: 06 Dec 2012
|
Kamina wrote: Without quoting Tyrak, the trend of expecting newbies to have the knowledge of older members isn't bad in itself: It's when a newbie turns to the older members asking "how do I do this" on the forums or what have you, and most of the time is greeted with "explore ICly". Yeah, it's great to have a spark of interaction of finding people that know where to find X or to complete X quest, but here's the problem:
Older members will rarely, if ever, roleplay new characters that don't have the same OOC knowledge of themselves after the first time.
When you make a new character after your first couple, you tend to have insight what gear's best, where to find the gear, what quests are worthwhile, what areas are best to grind. But how many of you genuinely roleplay your characters who haven't had that knowledge told ICly?
We shouldn't expect newbies to ask ICly when we're just as guilty of harbouring OOC knowledge without RP cause. Guilty as charged.
_________________ MAURICE "THE JUGGERNAUT" GRAFF
|
|
|
|
 |
|
The1Kobra
|
Posted: Sat, Jan 24 2015, 14:34 PM |
|
|

Player
Joined: 11 Oct 2009
|
|
Well, from my own take, it took me over a year to level my main PC to level 30, RPed and had a good time the whole way up. (His build was pretty bad too, heh). Anyways, I don't mind the slow climb myself. Compared to other RP servers I know, Arelith for example has a much slower rate of levelling (mobs give about 20/kill, and the death penalties are significantly more harsh), and Efu:A has a very slow rate of levelling coupled with that a PvE death costs 1/3 of a character's XP. Mind, we aren't that hardcore here in Amia.
I have noticed that you don't get the same "Must be L30 to RP" mentality, and it's not a mentality I agree with here myself. In fact, in the early stages of the Cordor out of Control plot, one of the main drivers behind that plot was level 12 to 15 for most of it. Sure, she ended up getting beaten up by one of the main corrupt guard NPCs, but she was really driving things and even as a relatively low level, kept things going for more PCs than just herself.
Similarly, for combat events, I do tend to look at player's levels and adjust monster difficulty accordingly.
I like when there's a sense of progress with them, as well. I think climbing the way up helps keep perspective as well.
That said, I do find the level cap for hunting kind of clunky. I know Arelith doesn't have it, instead the highest level PC in the group determines what XP the party gets per monster kill. Perhaps we could implement something like that, (ironically, might slow XP gain down a bit, but it would alleviate the level gap issue).
_________________ I play: 
|
|
|
|
 |
|
That Guy
|
Posted: Sat, Jan 24 2015, 14:37 PM |
|
|

Player
Joined: 13 Nov 2014
|
|
I stepped back from this thread for a bit because I was actually beginning to get angry. Ok, good night's sleep, and I'm back.
After reading, and thinking, then reading Tyrak's response, and Mahtan's. I came up with an idea.
I do not believe we need to change the XP gain on Amia. It's pretty good how it is.
I DO believe we need to change the way our characters interact, making the leveling process a journey worth taking rather than something to "get through". This means removal of the party ECL cap limit. There have already been suggestions that solve the issues. Pony and IronAngel have provided solutions.
Why just this?
Though Amia does not limit you to one character, if you put the time and effort into one character, you get results. I don't care if people have Alts, or a Main, or whatever. To me, they're just characters. However, if you try to actively play 5 or more characters, it's really, really hard. Hard to keep track, hard to level, just plain hard.
Our current system of limiting party ECL's promotes creating alternate characters, thereby removing "main" characters from the world, even temporarily and thereby watering down our roleplay. Watering down? Yes. How many veterans out there have made a character just to help a friend level up? How'd that work out? You made this character to help another character get to a level they can play with your initial character. You either dumped character #2 when your friend caught up, or, character #1 got left behind. Also, Character #1 knows less about your friend than #2 does, so, you get to start the friendship all over again. Oh, hold on a minute, isn't this technically metagaming? Stretch, I know, but... proving a point.
When any character gets put in the archives, the server loses all the connections that character made, thus, watering down roleplay. I'm speaking from personal experience here. I've made more characters than I care to admit, and in some cases, I regret not playing them anymore, but, I've learned that having one, that you really love makes a huge difference.
Now, if that one can do what comes natural, and help out someone new to the island (helping them get some xp) in a meaningful way, he built a new connection. Eventually, the value of each character we make will grow, thus, making the roleplay less watery. Thus making the community stronger.
But, having to find an OOC reason to NOT help someone is completely detrimental to a community, to new players, to roleplay, and to having fun with new characters.
Analog Kid said game mechanics should not determine your roleplay. That statement right there means the ECL party cap is wrong.
Mahtan said he won'd allow (which I find an interesting word for him to use) anything that makes xp gain higher. I don't really understand where Mahtan is coming from, if he has several 30's, but he didn't mention any new characters. Sure, lots of people love it here, that's why we're telling you this, rather than leaving.
In short! I'm against XP changes, but am 100% in favor of party cap removal. I would also add that this should be "pushed up" on the list rather than considered in a year or two. This is a real issue, as shown by this and the other thread and as a community of players who just want to see that community thrive, we're giving a pretty clear indication there's a problem and a solution is needed now. I know, the team have lives too. I know you're all busy working on all this new stuff that may or may not solve the problem. I've not idea since I haven't seen any of it save some new graphics for the Underdark. As many have said, this is a rather simple fix, easy enough to do. I don't know, never broke down the coding of NWN, so I could be totally wrong. Some have hinted though, that this won't take long to do. Then you can get back to all the other stuff, and we will wait patiently while all of our characters romp through dungeons together.
|
|
|
|
 |
|
fairdady
|
Posted: Sat, Jan 24 2015, 15:16 PM |
|
|

Player
Joined: 10 Apr 2011
|
Guess I"ll have to add my handful of coppers. I'm with the camp that feels the XP rates are decent here on Amia. It can't be THAT bad when you get brand new 30 lvl PCs in 3 to 5 days. Myself, it took me over a year to get Reddok to lvl 30. While I enjoy the hack and slash as much as the next guy, I really do seek out and engage in a lot of RP. That and I really don't enjoy the grind, but that's not because of the XP gains, but more of just doing the same stuff over and over. I also do not believe 20+ or 30 levels does it take to make and RP your character. As for the party mechanics, as someone that's faced this issue on both sides, I understand the thought and wants behind it. I think the rewards for folks that party up and RP while grinding need higher rewards than those that solo. Be it more XP, higher loot drop percentage, or whatever. But sometimes solo'ers have to solo cause of their PC or play times so those folks can't be crippled. Always tough choices to make as the Staff. We're all human, the vast majority are all decent folks, even if the PC is an ass the player behind it usually a nice person just having some fun. That means we want to help. We can't help but help. I used to be all for level range caps, and believe we still need kept from ourselves a bit. As a long term 30th level and faction/settlement leader PC player, I can honestly say the 5 level range cap impacts and hinders RP some. There's been countless times I've wanted to help out a fellow player while no one else was around for them to party with, and just couldn't for no real IC reasoning. We'd still hunt, RP, and loot, but it wasn't helping them gain XP to get to a level we could patrol the mountain together or train on the big isle. Maybe we try a 10 level range? See how that works for awhile. Everyone already should know my stance on Alts. Altitis is my bane, I feel it waters down the characterbase. But again, I understand the want and desire of a new character to do this with, or go there with, or play with these people with. I also wanted a 3 character limit for each CD Key, only way to clear up a spot would be to perma a character and pay a DC cost for dumping the PC for a new one. Could say the first two are free, or give a 36 hour buffer before the character is saved to your slot in case of mistakes. But something along those lines cause I'm a jerk like that. 
_________________ fairdady.. Loyal Dwarf of Barak RunedarSig by Jaydn- Dragon by Jes
|
|
|
|
 |
|
Ice
|
Posted: Sat, Jan 24 2015, 15:34 PM |
|
|

Player
Joined: 10 Feb 2013 Location: Usa
|
|
It has been said. I've said. Everybody has said it: The cap has to go or take a kick to the nuts.
Beyond formula calculation to prevent abuse and mechanical scripting, I can't think in any reasonable reason to not go down this path immediately.
We are in a community composed of a vast diverse kind of individuals that regard different issues in their own ways. The majority finds leveling to be painful. I find it painful. Let's alleviate the pain, and hope that the changes to come make it better for the entire community, and not just a "small bunch".
Do mind, I'm talking about the ECL cap - I don't really know what to think about boosting XP rates.
Last edited by Ice on Sat, Jan 24 2015, 18:53 PM, edited 1 time in total.
|
|
|
|
 |
|
Mahtan
|
Posted: Sat, Jan 24 2015, 17:26 PM |
|
|

Player
Joined: 28 May 2006 Location: That place with the green grass and that blue sky.
|
|
Yes I am directing things as I do not share or see much of the issues that keep being brought up. I do not support the idea of arguing or complaining things are too hard to work towards due to time or learning curve, others have it easier because they have no life, etc. So I shared a part of my busy life to explain that it is possible to level characters timely here and that if you can't, learn and ask the ways of leveling. Not because I want to brag or be better than you all, but to just say it can be done even with my schedule that I imagine is quite a bit more hectic than average. I have also acknowledged that because I do not see them as my issues, they indeed may be your issues and very real. That does not however change my stance on things with the current posts mostly just wanting things to be easier. Nothing hostile to you all for your opinions, but you come off as whining and wanting things easier because its too hard for you. That wont be helping you with changes actually happening here.
Yes I do indeed have a stance against exponentially Increasing the XP. If that makes me "having a bad day" because I oppose your stances, then people need to realize there will always be opposition and I am not worried to express that. I stand with games have learning, achievements, and ways to take forever and finish quick if you know what you are doing. There is already going to be ways coming for quests to give you entire levels, I am not against those, nor have I ever been against dumping XP on players that RP in hunting grounds, or at the end of events. I know not all DMs may do this, so this comment my be met with "I never got that" but perhaps it will influence other DMs to give XP rewards too. My being here, even I do not post publicly will indeed be opposed to many of the suggestions here. Its fair that you should know that.
Finally, if you think I am ignoring your problems by taking my time to post to you all and address them in a manner that is not giving you directly what you asked for, but rather directing you to ways that may solve them that are already available and sharing that changes are coming for questing and leveling structure that do not involve the "Exponential XP Increase" then please get out of your tunnel and look around, because you are not being ignored, rather you are being told things you do not want to hear.
To show I am not entirely a nay sayer on everything here too. I do support the ECL system being removed or redone, as that it does nothing but complicate things in more ways than I seen mentioned here. That is something I have expressed several times among my teammates. The carrying lowbies to "Leech XP" is already being done by either the vets that know the way of the game and can carry lower levels through an area that is 5 levels above them (The highest level), and by people that do indeed break the rules of babysitting out of party to heal and pre-damage spawns. The people that want to break things and do whatever always will because they will see no DMs are on, or the DM is busy in an event so they can get away with whatever. To all the rest getting put into a broken system being told deal with it because it stops abuse, is indeed wrong in my opinion. So also know I will be pushing for such a thing behind the scenes as well in a manner that still keeps a balance to the adventure and achievement of maxing a PC.
Disclaimer: I save good news for last as a present to those that read through it all. I am aware I am one of unpopular opinion. I am aware more people will be offended by sections of this post and take them personally, but please do not, this is a general post addressed to all and intended to be informative to my stance on the issue. I do not represent the whole of the team and could very well be made obsolete by the end of this.
|
|
|
|
 |
Who is online |
Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 26 guests |
|
You cannot post new topics in this forum You cannot reply to topics in this forum You cannot edit your posts in this forum You cannot delete your posts in this forum
|
|