|
|
|
OpenTheRift
|
Posted: Fri, Jan 16 2015, 2:39 AM |
|
|

Player
Joined: 17 Feb 2014
|
LetumLux wrote: Our PvP rules are in place primarily to protect people from griefers... Every time a DM is looking into a PvP event I think this should be chiefly in mind, and given their position of authority, and responsibility to the server's growth and well-being should holistically examine the situation and possible outcomes, rp created versus rp stifled. Rules that hinder progress are no longer serving their function, but dragging down the community. The elephant in the room is that we all know there's a problem with the rules, and we also know that without evil people causing a ruckus somewhere we're going to casually sink into a socialite (campfire) scene day-in-day-out. Given a holistic mindset it would also behoove the server if DMs actively assisted evil groups in engaging in creative and less-limited forms of generating conflict. This limitation is a contributing factor as to why so many evil instances gravitate towards PvP, because it's one of the few things they can do without having a DM overseeing them. (which much to the chagrin of many does then have a DM jumping in, and issuing heavy-handed treatment to those who are only doing a service to the community) Despite many statements of mine pointing at DMs to help the situation I do ultimately lay in the park of player-empowerment, but let's be real; that's not the reality we have here. It could be though... Just need to have support, or more freedoms (or both, please!).
_________________ bad man
|
|
|
|
 |
|
LetumLux
|
Posted: Fri, Jan 16 2015, 3:01 AM |
|
|

Player
Joined: 31 May 2007 Location: Amia IKEA
|
|
I'm going to lock this thread in about 10 minutes, so if you're working on a reply, get it finished up, or save it as a draft or what not. This isn't a punishment, and I will be unlocking the thread in a few hours. Consider this an experimental intermission, time for everyone to go do other things, reflect, and read, digest and consider what has been posted thus far.
|
|
|
|
 |
|
LetumLux
|
Posted: Fri, Jan 16 2015, 3:14 AM |
|
|

Player
Joined: 31 May 2007 Location: Amia IKEA
|
[Intermission] If you were still typing up a reply and got stopped up by the lock, you should be able to use the back on your browser to grab and copy your post so it doesn't get lost.
|
|
|
|
 |
|
LetumLux
|
Posted: Fri, Jan 16 2015, 7:38 AM |
|
|

Player
Joined: 31 May 2007 Location: Amia IKEA
|
|
|
|
 |
|
Terallis
|
Posted: Fri, Jan 16 2015, 13:10 PM |
|
|

Player
Joined: 30 Oct 2014 Location: Ontario, Canada
|
kalcibone wrote: I would not be surprised if on the first day one of the 'evil' lvl 30 groups just slaughters everyone and you can't do shit to stop them from doing it, on the first day the 'rules' are gone. This is actually something that plagues pretty much all RP servers, and I've definitely noticed it happen here. Though, perhaps with a different description. What I mean by that is that I do tend to notice a lot of max level characters (on Amia or other servers) that just seek to lord their levels over weaker folks. I personally see this sort of attitude as something to be avoided and maybe even enforced against, somehow. Not exactly sure how it could really be enforced, but it does happen frequently. Whether it's someone intentionally trolling for a fight with low levels, where it would be IC (based on their character personality or otherwise) to retaliate, to stuff like expecting that they are able to do virtually everything imaginable on par with a god, to even just jumping on the tiniest occurance to "protect" someone, even if it's just an insult or similar. Now, I'm not saying that people should break character just to avoid conflict with lower levels, but at the same time it's good to keep a level of common courtesy. Having been on the receiving end of a lot of this in the past (not just on Amia), it does tend to get extremely irritating, and you develop a fear of even playing your character because one wrong move, accidental or not, could lead to you getting one-shotted by one or more max level characters in the vicinity. In any case, I'll cut myself off there before I end up going off more on a rant. Haha.
_________________ 
|
|
|
|
 |
|
Q't'ulu
|
Posted: Fri, Jan 16 2015, 13:43 PM |
|
|

Player
Joined: 20 Jun 2012 Location: Russia, St.Petersburg
|
Terallis, AFAIU, MMORPG is creating some sort of reality, where people may show theirs (suppressed by laws and society) 'True (inner?) Self'. So, it is philosophical question, how to prevent gang maxed PCs from bully anyone other. All human history shows inability to solve this problem -- there is constant wars and hatred around world, you know. IMHO, there is no good-for-all solution. With other side, logging on such server is immersion in the world, which is radically differs from live in pampered NATO states. 
_________________ Evolution by any means!
|
|
|
|
 |
|
Magma Kitten
|
Posted: Fri, Jan 16 2015, 14:15 PM |
|
|

Player
Joined: 04 Jan 2015
|
|
As a new player, the pvp rules are the one thing that were a real turnoff to Amia and lent the impression of a stagnant low conflict community. And it does seem very casual, even in my attempts to mix things up and actively cause friction. Monsters being treated as people seems like a side-effect. I'm not going to comment in this with ideas of imrpovement because I am as mentioned new but I am very interested in a revision. All I can say is my experiences. The massively magical setting and huge level gaps can be a problem though, of course. I've been told by many people that if I happen to get into any pvp at all, for any reason, to screenshot the hell out of it and expect the other person to complain to DMs about it every time and that is just not right. Especially when there is absolutely 0 consequence to being defeated in a pvp situation in the first place.
I come previously from a much lower level setting where even a canny person three or four levels lower than an opponent could stand a chance as either aggressor or defender where consequences could range from simple robbery to dismemberment or permament death if warranted. Very harsh potential consequences, but the community grew up with it and handles it with style and class. Without the threat of risk the value of life I feel is greatly reduced. Of course this was not Amia and its levels and setting were vastly different. One thing I personally would like to see is harsher treatment to monsters though.
Maybe subraces like planetouched and other monsters requiring a (easily passed I'm sure) quick app for quality control and some encouragement for PCs to go out there and kill them. Too many cuddly little carebare kobolds that act and talk like normal humans or, even worse, acting like dragonblooded monsters. All sorts of planetouched freaks and mutants out there and queer monsters that people would kill in a heartbeat if they gave xp or loot, but as a PC they become instant friendlymen in part because there just isn't anything you can do about it. I am particularly sad that my blatant drow necromancer was not instantly public enemy #1 when visiting the surface and hunted down by PC mobs with torches and pitchforks for example. Especially when showing off these wicked powers in front of paladins and providing them ample IC justification to raise a public awareness and begin formulating a campaign to protect people against this monster and its minions. A revision of pvp rules, especially in regard to monsters, might help bring some more realism and danger. Particularly in regard to monsters being treated like monsters.
Pvp isn't about winning or losing. It is about building story or the culmination of a long and heavily developed conflict, and however it ends up turning out it can be an enriching and enjoyable experience for all involved, even if it may result in a permanent death of your PC.
Last edited by Magma Kitten on Fri, Jan 16 2015, 14:30 PM, edited 1 time in total.
|
|
|
|
 |
|
666WaysToHell
|
Posted: Fri, Jan 16 2015, 14:29 PM |
|
|

Player
Joined: 22 Nov 2010 Location: Western Australia
|
|
It would piss off a lot more players to suddenly have extreme penalties than it would to keep the rules as they are now. Not to mention no one would then ever leave the safety of the cities, because some people build and create groups for the sole purpose of PvP as we've seen recently, if we're giving them the advantage then it's just not going to be fun.
_________________ Aoth Nathandem - Wizard of house Tholaunt and chosen of Ma'at.
|
|
|
|
 |
|
Q't'ulu
|
Posted: Fri, Jan 16 2015, 15:12 PM |
|
|

Player
Joined: 20 Jun 2012 Location: Russia, St.Petersburg
|
|
666WaysToHell, as community, we can personally vote for given set of rules (of PvP) or another. btw, It is faaar too often someone "speak for whole net". Let to the community decide. IMHO, putting arbitrary rules is much more damaging, then "dura lex sed lex".
Secondly, pinning and disabling rampaging parties will bring more action to the server. Such as aforementioned death squad(s) of paladins hunting down rogue drow party in Paladinobad's area of interests. And so on...
_________________ Evolution by any means!
|
|
|
|
 |
|
That Guy
|
Posted: Fri, Jan 16 2015, 15:43 PM |
|
|

Player
Joined: 13 Nov 2014
|
|
Clarification: When I stated that PvP sucks... perhaps I should add the caveat that that has been -my- experience with it. Again, in 4 years, only a handful of incidents, and nearly all were poorly played out IMHO, and did not add anything to the roleplay of the server. They were simply "I'm right, you're weak, I kill you.". I don't think I even lost any of them, but still felt awful afterward. Oh, I initiated maybe 4 or 5, mostly acting as a guard in Bendir. Now, I do recall there was one time that it was fine, it was all properly IC and roleplayed, and me and the opponent walked away thinking it was a decent bit of PvP RP. That's only like a 10% piece of my experiences though.
I agree, more rules means more room for "interpretation" of those rules. That's why we have so many lawyers in the real world. If we simplify the rules, and people simply suck it up and don't cry if they lose FAIRLY, I think we have a chance to grow as a community. After all, as has been said, there is absolutely ZERO consequence for losing in PvP, just a bruised ego, and, as I said before, maybe we need some more bruised egos on this server. No matter how big and bad you think you are, there's always someone who can take you down a notch. Showing a little fear, sympathy, compassion, trepidation, and any other emotion does not make your character weak, it makes them real.
|
|
|
|
 |
|
KingArthur129
|
Posted: Fri, Jan 16 2015, 17:14 PM |
|
|

Player
Joined: 29 Sep 2013
|
|
Personally I think the rules are more then fair, due to #3.
"3. You must give the other party a reasonable chance to back down from the PvP In Character."
This could mean, they flee from you in a way that makes sense. No one is really stopping 'PvP' from happening at any time, you just need to allow the player an escape route. Just because you are mechanically capable of crushing another character dosn't mean the person behind the other keyboard wants to see it, nor experience it. I personally have had to flee from a few 'PvP engagements', the aggressors still 'won' they just didn't need to smash me to pieces to prove it.
_________________ Silith Rithix- Shifting Coward Hesk Suhet- Lizardfolk, Red Tribe Shaman
|
|
|
|
 |
|
That Guy
|
Posted: Fri, Jan 16 2015, 17:19 PM |
|
|

Player
Joined: 13 Nov 2014
|
|
The downside to the rule allowing them to step back from conflict is when you have a character or group of characters openly taunting the other into a fight, then they abuse this rule to avoid it. Wash, rinse, repeat. I've seen it.
|
|
|
|
 |
|
Rigela
|
Posted: Fri, Jan 16 2015, 17:20 PM |
|
|

Player
Joined: 16 Sep 2010 Location: Grimy Old England
|
|
Keep in mind, that rule doesn't mean you can escape freely - it just means you don't have to actually PvP. 'Giving in' to their demands is legit and counts, so consequences can't be avoided, essentially.
_________________ Signature by Maryn! <3 I am also seen as DM Snuffles.
|
|
|
|
 |
|
Zykritch
|
Posted: Fri, Jan 16 2015, 18:13 PM |
|
|

Player
Joined: 15 Jan 2015
|
666WaysToHell wrote: It would piss off a lot more players to suddenly have extreme penalties than it would to keep the rules as they are now. Not to mention no one would then ever leave the safety of the cities, because some people build and create groups for the sole purpose of PvP as we've seen recently, if we're giving them the advantage then it's just not going to be fun. .. Uh, nothing that has been suggested so far would be giving either party the 'advantage'. I'm not sure where you're coming from, but the IC/OOC mechanics of the fight that determine who wins would remain the same in either case. Those involved are the -only- ones that determine who wins. Nothing and no one else. No overlying OOC rule of engagement is going to change that. 90% of this effects the requirements regarding roleplay BEFORE the PVP. The rest of it would do nothing to give either party involved an advantage, because the rest of it is just a set of rules that outlaw OOC exploits, glitches, or other mechanics that you normally wouldn't have in a real, IC world, and using such to win the fight unfairly. I find it odd that you're managing to hypothetically place yourself (in the future tense) as the victim here, when the rules that people are trying to set in place here would be implemented for the sole sake of retaining the 'right'-based protections players have while also giving them more freedom (and hence, encouraging more roleplay and more unique, in depth stories) .. in the process. -- It's as simple as this: If you want to avoid problems, don't be one. If you feel your opponent broke a rule, or didn't give you the 'out' you had hoped for, -talk- to them about it. Confront them, request that you start back from step 1 (if that's something you really want to do) .. and actually handle it like an adult before you try getting a DM involved and turning into a big dramatic situation that ends up leaving pretty much everyone unhappy, and often results in either bans -or- people quitting the server. If the players can learn to grow up and handle things like mature, intelligent, competent people, there should be no problems at all with PVP on Amia.I wish I wouldn't have to state why, but given the responses I've been getting thus far, I think it's likely necessary. The reason there shouldn't be a problem with PVP on Amia (Yes, a roleplay server): A) It -encourages- roleplay. It literally creates it. B) It brings life to the server, makes things more exciting, and gives pretty much everyone the incentive to join in the roleplay/(IC drama) and fun without leaving the server in a bland state of mediocrity where at most you'll see 3-4 people rp'ing together at a time in their own little 'clique'. Instead, this way, the server actually congregates and plays together as a whole. C) It would (naturally) have roleplay before it, roleplay that led up to it.. and roleplay that, in itself, even existing.. -distinguishes- Amia from a PVP server (which seems to be the great fear you all have) .. And having been someone that played the PVP servers exclusively a good 7 or so years before ever touching roleplay? Believe me, I know that Amia is FAR from being anything like the PVP servers were. So you have nothing to fear there. Letum's "Unreal Tournament" reference was a good example of what the PVP servers were like. You go in, you see your opponent, and you wordlessly begin to spill blood. That is NOT what this would be, that is not what this has ever been. D) No exploits would be involved, no OOC mechanics would be used to gain unfair, unrealistic advantages over other people IC'ly. E) Contrary to what a number of people are saying here, both sides would have an even chance at winning, and walking away from the fight.^ Now, with that in mind, please tell me.. what exactly is so horrible about PVP on Amia? If anything, it's a contribution to the server, when you really think about it. The ONLY thing that takes away from that is the immaturity and childish attitudes of 'adult' players, whom just can't seem to grow out of their babypants (Yes, diapers) .. and act their age. This includes: A) Acting butthurt, and raging about it. (Aka, harassing other players as opposed to talking to them civilly, or making false claims to dish out the wrath of the DMs in your stead, or just coming to the forums and being all like "I HATE PVP. IT'S ALL BAD AND DOES NO GOOD EVAR.") B) Allowing your bruised ego to be the motive for seeking unjust vengeance against other players OOC'ly. (Aka, inherently making things that should be exclusively IC, OOC.) C) Failing to accept the fair and reasonable consequences of what you chose to engage in. D) Failing to accept the consequence of a (very often temporary) death. E) Failing to follow PVP engagement rules (A scenario in which, yes.. you guys should actually TALK about what happened and handle it maturely.) F) Resorting to calling DMs in when they really aren't needed (AT THIS POINT) more often than not.Something tells me DMs probably don't like being pestered every 5 minutes by players that can't solve their own problems because they simply didn't try. And to be quite frank, I think that if they find out that you haven't tried handling it yourself, then they should ignore you until you have done so. Make it a rule, even. Because you're doing no more than griefing almost everyone involved [and even some not] OOC'ly, and just causing OOC drama all around when it really isn't necessary or justifiable at all. This, above all else, results in one major thing that this server CANNOT afford: Players (willingly or unwillingly) leaving the server.
_________________ Inkheart
Last edited by Zykritch on Fri, Jan 16 2015, 19:35 PM, edited 13 times in total.
|
|
|
|
 |
|
Zykritch
|
Posted: Fri, Jan 16 2015, 18:18 PM |
|
|

Player
Joined: 15 Jan 2015
|
That Guy wrote: Clarification: When I stated that PvP sucks... perhaps I should add the caveat that that has been -my- experience with it. Again, in 4 years, only a handful of incidents, and nearly all were poorly played out IMHO, and did not add anything to the roleplay of the server. They were simply "I'm right, you're weak, I kill you.". I don't think I even lost any of them, but still felt awful afterward. Oh, I initiated maybe 4 or 5, mostly acting as a guard in Bendir. Now, I do recall there was one time that it was fine, it was all properly IC and roleplayed, and me and the opponent walked away thinking it was a decent bit of PvP RP. That's only like a 10% piece of my experiences though.
I agree, more rules means more room for "interpretation" of those rules. That's why we have so many lawyers in the real world. If we simplify the rules, and people simply suck it up and don't cry if they lose FAIRLY, I think we have a chance to grow as a community. After all, as has been said, there is absolutely ZERO consequence for losing in PvP, just a bruised ego, and, as I said before, maybe we need some more bruised egos on this server. No matter how big and bad you think you are, there's always someone who can take you down a notch. Showing a little fear, sympathy, compassion, trepidation, and any other emotion does not make your character weak, it makes them real. .. We definitely don't need more bruised egos on the server. That it what -creates- the drama. Look at what you just said, AS IT IS .. there are little to no consequences for deaths in PVP, and people STILL get butthurt about it and find a way to cause OOC drama-based problems. Believe me, if there's anything this server needs, it's less bruised egos, more maturity, more humility, and more adult-behavior. People need to stray away from their long standing perspectives of "no pvp ever unless its in our favor" .. (as that HASN'T worked in the past) .. and they need to just learn to handle things themselves. To act their age, if you will. But if you define the rules clearly enough, there doesn't have to be a ton left to interpretation. It's not hard to pinpoint and ban specific exploits, or to avoid flawed interpretations, contrary to what you might believe. The transition rules are an example. LIST the cases in which it can be exploited/abused for OOC advantage, and there is no question about the meaning of the rule, or the word 'abuse' (as there is now) .. Specifics eliminate that fear you have. A lack of them culls it. .. And here, I'll clarify one last thing for you: More rules = less IC possibility, less freedom, and less potential for roleplay. Simplification of the rules = more room for interpretation, and hence more room for mistakes, confusion, and drama. You've got it entirely backwards. Fewer, more specific rules are how you achieve efficiency without the drama. Vague (aka simplified), more frequent ones are EXACTLY how you cause problems.
_________________ Inkheart
|
|
|
|
 |
|
That Guy
|
Posted: Fri, Jan 16 2015, 20:24 PM |
|
|

Player
Joined: 13 Nov 2014
|
|
Maybe you didn't read what I said.... I am actually agreeing with you. My bruised ego comment means to have a bit of humility rather than being pig headed.
And, I think clearly defined rules are good....
Wow... you seem to REALLY want to disagree with me for some reason. No offense intended, I'm stating my thoughts, just as you are, but I'm not attacking you saying you're wrong.
Also, for the record, I've never had to get a DM involved over PvP.
|
|
|
|
 |
|
Murex
|
Posted: Fri, Jan 16 2015, 21:07 PM |
|
|

Player
Joined: 01 Dec 2009
|
Zykritch wrote: Something tells me DMs probably don't like being pestered every 5 minutes by players that can't solve their own problems because they simply didn't try. And to be quite frank, I think that if they find out that you haven't tried handling it yourself, then they should ignore you until you have done so. Make it a rule, even. Because you're doing no more than griefing almost everyone involved [and even some not] OOC'ly, and just causing OOC drama all around when it really isn't necessary or justifiable at all. This, above all else, results in one major thing that this server CANNOT afford: Players (willingly or unwillingly) leaving the server. This is totally right-on! I really really hate it when I get a DM tapping me on the shoulder after something I thought went smoothly in-game. No player to player discussion before grabbing a DM is just not a good thing to be doing in my opinion. It wastes time, causes players to get pissed off, and is just all-around not good. It's like calling the cops on your neighbor after seeing their dog poop on your lawn in the morning while you were waving to them on your way to the mailbox. Solve the problem before you involve the higher-ups!
|
|
|
|
 |
|
Lutra
|
Posted: Fri, Jan 16 2015, 23:56 PM |
|
|

Player
Joined: 12 Feb 2008
|
Zykritch wrote: A) It -encourages- roleplay. It literally creates it.
I think this is the most important sentence in this thread. PVP is part of the rp, and should be treated accordingly.
|
|
|
|
 |
|
Murex
|
Posted: Sat, Jan 17 2015, 0:20 AM |
|
|

Player
Joined: 01 Dec 2009
|
|
One consistent problem that breaks the rp prior to PvP is casting of spells while the rp phase is going on- this causes the rp to come to a screeching halt, and battle to ensue.
|
|
|
|
 |
|
666WaysToHell
|
Posted: Sat, Jan 17 2015, 1:47 AM |
|
|

Player
Joined: 22 Nov 2010 Location: Western Australia
|
|
It's perfectly fine to attack someone who starts casting spells because that then means they are prepare for the definite chance of battle. And PvP isn't RP, it's a comparison of mechanics between PCs to see who's a better builder.
Red is cruise control for cool, obviously!
_________________ Aoth Nathandem - Wizard of house Tholaunt and chosen of Ma'at.
|
|
|
|
 |
|
LetumLux
|
Posted: Sat, Jan 17 2015, 2:20 AM |
|
|

Player
Joined: 31 May 2007 Location: Amia IKEA
|
|
I honestly don't mind people using colors to make the core of a point stand out more. It's actually rather convenient for me while I'm taking notes on the vocalized thoughts and opinions.
That said, just remember to keep it all calm and don't get personal. If you (used in the general sense) find yourselves arguing with one person, or one point to the exclusion of contributions or debate with the rest of the topic, please moderate yourself; take a step back to take a breather, and get a broader view again before returning to the topic.
|
|
|
|
 |
|
Kawaiian
|
Posted: Sat, Jan 17 2015, 2:29 AM |
|
|

Player
Joined: 28 Dec 2014
|
666WaysToHell wrote: And PvP isn't RP, it's a comparison of mechanics between PCs to see who's a better builder. Someone sounds bitter. You can't just brush off people like that, who make an effort to understand the game and wish to be successful in all aspects of it. Or, suppose you can. But again, bitter, and is in no way accurate. I think the PvP that started this topic is proof of that.
|
|
|
|
 |
|
Zykritch
|
Posted: Sat, Jan 17 2015, 2:48 AM |
|
|

Player
Joined: 15 Jan 2015
|
666WaysToHell wrote: It's perfectly fine to attack someone who starts casting spells because that then means they are prepare for the definite chance of battle. And PvP isn't RP, it's a comparison of mechanics between PCs to see who's a better builder.
Red is cruise control for cool, obviously! I think you're missing one of the most simple, and easy to understand logical points in this thread (one that has been restated multiple times before) .. PVP on Amia will -never- (except in very rare, agreed upon terms and circumstances: aka, kill on sight statuses between individual players) .. be PVP without RP. There is RP beforehand, and there is almost -always- RP afterwards. It's never 'just' PVP. It's never 'just a comparison of mechanics'. Believe me, I played the PVP servers for -years- .. I know what that's like, and it's nothing like what we have here, on Amia. The PVP servers were what you just described. Amia isn't, won't be, and never has been. To say that PVP (in the context of this server) is "just a comparison of mechanics" .. and involves no RP, is flat out, a completely incorrect and inaccurate statement. And in fact, anyone who engages in PVP without RP is (in general) breaking the rules. I think your fear is a little misplaced, and kind of imaginary, actually.
_________________ Inkheart
|
|
|
|
 |
|
The1Kobra
|
Posted: Sat, Jan 17 2015, 3:03 AM |
|
|

Player
Joined: 11 Oct 2009
|
You know, I oft hear the PvP rules are overly long and dizzyingly complex. So, I'm going to take the PvP rules one at a time, see which needs clarification, rewording, etc. I'll add some commentary and correlary to them where appropriate, to help clear up any misunderstandings or the like. Anyways, here they are: PaladinOfSune wrote: ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- PvP rules------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- The following are rules to be used when engaging in PvP (Player vs. Player) combat. These rules are not optional (unless stated otherwise) and are to be used by ALL parties in PvP situations. Principles:[list]1. Amia is a role-playing server, not a PvP arena server. Okay, this is pretty straightforward. The goal of PvP is to enhance and enrich the server experience. This means that PvP should be done when it makes sense and enhances the RP. PvP should not be done for it's own sake. Quote: 2. All PvP must have a role-playing reason. PvP without a sensible reason is not allowed. Your character's alignment is not a valid reason for PvP. Summons, such as undead, are a valid reason but do not excuse you from the below protocol. PvP indeed, must have an IC reason for why it is happening. See above. Motives for the PvP should be rooted in In Character reasons, not Out of Character ones. The bit about character's alignment is mostly for cases of "I'm CE, so it's alright for me to attack everyone and anyone around me." While I'm sure /some/ characters may be like that, it's better for there to be more involved reasons. The same goes the other way around as well. Being LG does not overrule the PvP rules in the case of facing evil PCs, you still need to RP first. Now they can demand that someone unsummon an undead/demon/angel, etc, but again, RP first. PvP if it comes after. I do wonder if this can be shortened to the first two sentences though. Quote: 3. You must give the other party a reasonable chance to back down from the PvP In Character. Take careful note of the wording in this one. All it requires is that they are given a chance to back down from the PvP. This does not mean they can back down from IC consequences. Kidnapping, interrogation, etc, so it doesn't have to IC be nice to the character, but you do have to give them an out in some form. Quote: 4. IC Actions lead to IC Consequences. If you initiate a conflict (by insults or thievery, for example), you can't expect to get away with it. You cannot ignore other players' RP or declare it null. This one is one to be kept in mind, especially in the loser's case. The PvP rules are not a complete immunity to IC consequences. I think it could be amended to have a clause where whining OOC in chat channel is unacceptable, though our rules about staying IC once in the game world cover that one. (And, I would hope, common sense) Quote: 5. You must give the other party clear IC indication of your intentions to attack, and make sure they have reasonable time to react and possibly back down IC. This one's pretty straightforward I think, though does have some overlap with rule 3. You must make it /clear/ to them that they have an out, and want to attack. Simply going "Hi", "Hi", then attacking isn't acceptable. My advice? Set hostile if this line is crossed. Quote: 6. You must set all members of the opposing party to Hostile before performing hostile actions. You can do this with the tool in your inventory or through the player list. This one is very simple and straightforward. I would also include that you should probably set hostile before buffing if you plan on joining the fight. Quote: 7. If you do not give the other party time to observe the usual protocol, you can't expect them to stick to the protocol. This means that by resting, buffing or other such preperations to hostility, you forfeit your right to a warning: The other party may attack you immediately to stop you. If you have not set them to Hostile before, you can't blame them for having to act without it. Both parties should strive to set eachother to Hostile after the immediate reaction, however.
8. The above goes for fleeing from hostile situations: If you turn tail and run without a word to avoid IC consequence, you can expect to be stopped by any means possible. Always give others reasonable time to react with RP! These ones I think can be condensed and rewritten some. But just to clarify: Buffing in a tense situation is like setting up your favorite machine gun. Someone who's hostily inclined towards you is likely going to attack first and stop you. I do think however, it is still a good idea to set hostile before buffing, to avoid this messy situation. Please note however, that this would only apply in situations where there is obvious hostility (see 3,5). For example, if PC 1 is walking along in stealth, and PC 2 is singing for a group of other PCs (and is unaware of PC 1), it's not legal for PC 1 to just attack PC 2 outright when he uses his bard song. Quote: Victor determines the downed PC's state. Pretty simple. Quote: 10. Assassinations: Assassins must inform a DM that they are about to perform a hit. If a DM is unavailable, the assassin must inform the target instead. Again, I think this one is simple and unambiguous. Quote: 11. If you clearly escape scene, you may not continue the ”same” PvP later, unless such behaviour is explicitly agreed by all involved parties. It is a new encounter with all the above rules. Parties may agree to a "mutual aggression" pact, where it is agreed that hostilities may commence whenever these parties interact. This must be supported by previous role-play, and is generally done when two factions (such as drow houses) have on going IC disputes that end in hostilities. It is the responsibility of the faction leaders to make sure everyone involved knows about the situation. Should this be the case, please inform the DMs about this in advance so that they know what is going on. This one is a little cluttery, I'll admit. What 'clearly escape the scene' counts as is a bit nebulous. I'll lay out some terms that I've seen, myself. For one, Resting (since IC it takes 8 hours) would count as a new scene. Of course, that one isn't written down anywhere, but I'd consider that if your PC has time to rest in the middle of PvP, it should count as a new scene. Chasing someone through a transition still counts as the same PvP. If someone gets to a safe area (with NPC guards, etc), then another confrontation counts as a new scene. Quote: 12. Traps are considered PvP. Do not set them down to damage random people: you are responsible for your traps and their victims. You can use the trap tool to have them not trigger for neutrals. This one is pretty simple. Don't trap areas randomly to kill unsuspecting PCs. Quote: 13. Portalling to party leader into a PvP situation is forbidden. This one would fall into the metagaming rules, I think. You're not allowed to join a PvP you know is in progress but your character doesn't know about IC. Quote: 14. Taunting someone with the Taunt-skill, using Turn Undead summons and casting spells such as Darkness is considered initiating PvP. You should set Hostile before doing that. Simple enough, though is more a clarification. Quote: 15. If robbed, you are not required to hand over items you do not wish to give away OOCly; emoting that they are transferred ICly is sufficient. Again, this rule is pretty straightforward. It's more a way to ensure that you don't have a L30 PC ganking low level PCs and removing all their gold/equipment, especially since Amia doesn't have much of a system for storing items. It is something of a detriment to bandit RP, though I have seen some bandits strike wealthy when taking captives. Quote: 16. If your character is captured, and the character who caught him/her wishes to keep your character locked away, they can do so for a period of 24 RL hours, without your OOC consent. However, roleplay with the captive must be provided for those 24 hours. If it is not, then you cannot force the captive character to remain "locked away", unless you come to an OOC agreement on the matter. Keeping a character captive for longer than 24 RL hours requires the OOC consent of the player of the captive PC. In certain instances a DM can enforce captivity, but this is rarely done. This is mostly to ensure that someone's PC isn't locked away without RP for an extended period of time, because that would be boring. However, it's pretty straightforward, I think. So there you have the PvP rules. I will add though that some of the rules that are enforced aren't directly referenced here but are rather subsections of different rules, such as PvP in front of guards in a settlement. That may not technically be a PvP rule infraction, however since it happens in front of NPC guards (and if there is no DM controlling them), then it counts as a metagaming rule infraction. So while simple, it's not directly referenced. The issue with transition abuse is similar (counts as exploiting). So there's a cursory analysis of the PvP rules. What could be changed for the better? Aside from what I mentioned above already, perhaps some of those 'corollary' rules that often come into PvP could be added. Thoughts?
_________________ I play: 
|
|
|
|
 |
|
666WaysToHell
|
Posted: Sat, Jan 17 2015, 3:15 AM |
|
|

Player
Joined: 22 Nov 2010 Location: Western Australia
|
Quote: 15. If robbed, you are not required to hand over items you do not wish to give away OOCly; emoting that they are transferred ICly is sufficient. Quote: Again, this rule is pretty straightforward. It's more a way to ensure that you don't have a L30 PC ganking low level PCs and removing all their gold/equipment, especially since Amia doesn't have much of a system for storing items. It is something of a detriment to bandit RP, though I have seen some bandits strike wealthy when taking captives. It should be stated that a PC can be forced to hand over their own gold in the case of fines or compensation. But only guards (Both NPC and PC) have this power.
_________________ Aoth Nathandem - Wizard of house Tholaunt and chosen of Ma'at.
|
|
|
|
 |
|
corypx
|
Posted: Sat, Jan 17 2015, 3:51 AM |
|
|

Player
Joined: 14 Oct 2006
|
The1Kobra wrote: Quote: 11. If you clearly escape scene, you may not continue the ”same” PvP later, unless such behaviour is explicitly agreed by all involved parties. It is a new encounter with all the above rules. Parties may agree to a "mutual aggression" pact, where it is agreed that hostilities may commence whenever these parties interact. This must be supported by previous role-play, and is generally done when two factions (such as drow houses) have on going IC disputes that end in hostilities. It is the responsibility of the faction leaders to make sure everyone involved knows about the situation. Should this be the case, please inform the DMs about this in advance so that they know what is going on. This one is a little cluttery, I'll admit. What 'clearly escape the scene' counts as is a bit nebulous. I'll lay out some terms that I've seen, myself. For one, Resting (since IC it takes 8 hours) would count as a new scene. Of course, that one isn't written down anywhere, but I'd consider that if your PC has time to rest in the middle of PvP, it should count as a new scene. Chasing someone through a transition still counts as the same PvP. If someone gets to a safe area (with NPC guards, etc), then another confrontation counts as a new scene. I will admit I skipped reading the thread but wanted to reply to this rule as we have had problems with it time and time again over the years. The problem, it's who ever is DMing at the time to over see the problem as in the past we had DMs who disagree your stand point, and you and Hackum(DM at the time) did found here I fully agree resting would end combat but we need a full DM ruling that all the team agrees on, so the players can follow it. As for escaping scene, yes you can follow through a transition point and its the same PVP. What was a toss up for DMs was if I don't chase you, can you renter the PVP... you ran away though a transition point, we could follow you but don't, is that not a new scene? ((At the time it was viewed as such because they can run away and rest, so the common stand point was if you leave the zone you cant come back because then no one can claim you rested))
_________________ ================-<Cory ShadowFlame>-================ Risenlord-Shifter(OMG a Non-Dragon Shifter that can hold his own in PvE) 
|
|
|
|
 |
|
5star
|
Posted: Sat, Jan 17 2015, 4:05 AM |
|
|

Player
Joined: 08 Jan 2015
|
corypx wrote: The1Kobra wrote: Quote: 11. If you clearly escape scene, you may not continue the ”same” PvP later, unless such behaviour is explicitly agreed by all involved parties. It is a new encounter with all the above rules. Parties may agree to a "mutual aggression" pact, where it is agreed that hostilities may commence whenever these parties interact. This must be supported by previous role-play, and is generally done when two factions (such as drow houses) have on going IC disputes that end in hostilities. It is the responsibility of the faction leaders to make sure everyone involved knows about the situation. Should this be the case, please inform the DMs about this in advance so that they know what is going on. This one is a little cluttery, I'll admit. What 'clearly escape the scene' counts as is a bit nebulous. I'll lay out some terms that I've seen, myself. For one, Resting (since IC it takes 8 hours) would count as a new scene. Of course, that one isn't written down anywhere, but I'd consider that if your PC has time to rest in the middle of PvP, it should count as a new scene. Chasing someone through a transition still counts as the same PvP. If someone gets to a safe area (with NPC guards, etc), then another confrontation counts as a new scene. I will admit I skipped reading the thread but wanted to reply to this rule as we have had problems with it time and time again over the years. The problem, it's who ever is DMing at the time to over see the problem as in the past we had DMs who disagree your stand point, and you and Hackum(DM at the time) did found here I fully agree resting would end combat but we need a full DM ruling that all the team agrees on, so the players can follow it. As for escaping scene, yes you can follow through a transition point and its the same PVP. What was a toss up for DMs was if I don't chase you, can you renter the PVP... you ran away though a transition point, we could follow you but don't, is that not a new scene? ((At the time it was viewed as such because they can run away and rest, so the common stand point was if you leave the zone you cant come back because then no one can claim you rested)) I agree with Kobra's opinion on this. Resting should be a new scene, as should fleeing to safety (NPC guards, etc). Going through a transition while PvPing should be the /same/ scene, unless no one chases -- I think there should be a time limit before it counts as a new scene. (I suggest 5 minutes, something reasonable.)
_________________ Saevel Irithyl
|
|
|
|
 |
|
Murex
|
Posted: Sat, Jan 17 2015, 5:20 AM |
|
|

Player
Joined: 01 Dec 2009
|
|
Also, setting to hostile does not mean start attacking. Too many trigger fingers around, and I don't like that.
|
|
|
|
 |
|
2star
|
Posted: Sat, Jan 17 2015, 5:29 AM |
|
|

Player
Joined: 23 Dec 2014
|
|
Resting should end the scene.
Going through a transition as a means of temporary retreat/strategic maneuver or anything else, provided combat resumes within short order, should be perfectly fine. The fact is, not all battlefields and or matchups are equal, sometimes withdrawing through transitions, albeit perhaps temporarily, just has to be done.
|
|
|
|
 |
|
corypx
|
Posted: Sat, Jan 17 2015, 9:20 AM |
|
|

Player
Joined: 14 Oct 2006
|
2star wrote: Resting should end the scene.
Going through a transition as a means of temporary retreat/strategic maneuver or anything else, provided combat resumes within short order, should be perfectly fine. The fact is, not all battlefields and or matchups are equal, sometimes withdrawing through transitions, albeit perhaps temporarily, just has to be done. Yeah but how many time have to followed someone into a transition and them not be there.... did they load before you and run ahead (so you run to try and catch up) or are they still loading (stand around and wait) or did they load in first and click to zone right back....(run back to where you were) just to find out the what ever you pick out of the three option was wrong... and the only reason why you lost them was the OOC effect of the transition point.
_________________ ================-<Cory ShadowFlame>-================ Risenlord-Shifter(OMG a Non-Dragon Shifter that can hold his own in PvE) 
|
|
|
|
 |
|
2star
|
Posted: Sat, Jan 17 2015, 9:48 AM |
|
|

Player
Joined: 23 Dec 2014
|
|
The difference between retreating and anything else should be obvious in the context of the situation. If someone moves through a transition, is chased and is then still running further and further away, it's very probable their aim is to escape. However, if they're simply pulling back a short way for breathing room or what have you, they're clearly not going to keep running any further then required. Moving through a transition repeatedly in a very short time (spamming it) shouldn't be allowed though, which is a totally different thing.
|
|
|
|
 |
|
Zykritch
|
Posted: Sat, Jan 17 2015, 9:54 AM |
|
|

Player
Joined: 15 Jan 2015
|
Regarding the rules, I feel that all of them are fine as they are, except: Quote: 5. You must give the other party clear IC indication of your intentions to attack, and make sure they have reasonable time to react and possibly back down IC. Unfortunately, the wording in this rule is particularly vague, which causes problems. "Clear IC indication of intentions to attack" is a phrase that is very much so left up to interpretation, and allows for people to be unfairly punished over a simple misinterpretation of such. I think specifics should be added to this rule, as well as examples, that way we have some kind of a 'format' basis for the 'indications' we give. Quote: 11. If you clearly escape scene, you may not continue the ”same” PvP later, unless such behaviour is explicitly agreed by all involved parties. It is a new encounter with all the above rules. Parties may agree to a "mutual aggression" pact, where it is agreed that hostilities may commence whenever these parties interact. This must be supported by previous role-play, and is generally done when two factions (such as drow houses) have on going IC disputes that end in hostilities. It is the responsibility of the faction leaders to make sure everyone involved knows about the situation. Should this be the case, please inform the DMs about this in advance so that they know what is going on. The definition of "clearly escaped the scene" needs to be clarified, and perhaps even modified. Because in reality, transitions do not exist IC'ly. They're there for OOC reasons (such as lag prevention, organization, and so on) .. and in a real battle they are not a factor. It's.. silly to limit PVP to a single map, merely because in a realistic situation there would be no such thing as map boundaries. To address Cory's concern, though.. in my honest opinion, if your opponent was just running for his life via transition and escaped, well *shrugs* .. there is no choice but to accept that. It can happen just as easily (in general) in an open area as well. Unless people are using the transitions to gain an offensive based advantage, I don't think there's a problem. Quote: 15. If robbed, you are not required to hand over items you do not wish to give away OOCly; emoting that they are transferred ICly is sufficient. It'd be cool if IC robbing would be rewarded with actual gold, perhaps by DMs, I don't know. That would be sketchy, and difficult to implement, I'd imagine, given it's potential for abuse, but, it'd be nice. -- Aside from that? I honestly don't think there's too much to do regarding PVP rules. I'm sure I've missed something (probably a lot) .. but in general, my own theoretical forte here is: Greater clarification, less vagueness, less over-generalizations, and less room for people to get banned (or to cause fights) over misunderstandings. If all of that can be achieved while increasing player freedom & RP potential? .. I think you guys have a winner rule-wise.
_________________ Inkheart
|
|
|
|
 |
|
Kudark
|
Posted: Sat, Jan 17 2015, 10:16 AM |
|
|

Player
Joined: 14 Dec 2009 Location: The Dark Side of the Moon
|
Zykritch wrote: It'd be cool if IC robbing would be rewarded with actual gold, perhaps by DMs, I don't know. That would be sketchy, and difficult to implement, I'd imagine, given it's potential for abuse, but, it'd be nice. Apparently you've never had a pickpocket gank your gold. It's not easy, but it can be done.
_________________ 
|
|
|
|
 |
|
Murex
|
Posted: Sat, Jan 17 2015, 10:23 AM |
|
|

Player
Joined: 01 Dec 2009
|
|
Can there be a rule that states something like there should be X number of minutes of role-play before PvP begins? There needs to be something that allows players to make sure everything is done right before PvP combat starts. This is the biggest problem I see with PvP- no time for the proper steps before combat.
Last edited by Murex on Sat, Jan 17 2015, 16:13 PM, edited 1 time in total.
|
|
|
|
 |
|
Shadowfiend
|
Posted: Sat, Jan 17 2015, 11:17 AM |
|
|

Player
Joined: 17 Oct 2011 Location: The Hall of the Mountain King
|
|
I am going to skim through all those lengthy walls of text at some point, but up till then: I am not going to reward players that engage in pvp just because they know their character is invincible with awesome death scenes or lasting consequences. But if one plays with an equal chance of winning and losing, I'd be very up for a rivalry, and allow consequences on my character. On the matter of people that hide behind the rules, I think equally much of those that hide behind their builds. For an interesting conflict there has to be room for both victories and defeats
_________________ I am not weird, I am limited edition
|
|
|
|
 |
|
Shadowfiend
|
Posted: Sat, Jan 17 2015, 11:29 AM |
|
|

Player
Joined: 17 Oct 2011 Location: The Hall of the Mountain King
|
Murex wrote: Can there be a rule that states something like there should be X number of minutes of role-play before PvP begins? There needs to be something to that allows players to make sure everything is done right before PvP combat starts. This is the biggest problem I see with PvP- no time for the proper steps before combat. . If you don't think enough time had passed to make sure everything was done properly, back out of it?
_________________ I am not weird, I am limited edition
|
|
|
|
 |
|
Grymia
|
Posted: Sat, Jan 17 2015, 15:46 PM |
|
|

Player
Joined: 14 Dec 2004 Location: Kohlingen, and a Basement in Canada
|
Shadowfiend wrote: I am going to skim through all those lengthy walls of text at some point, but up till then: I am not going to reward players that engage in pvp just because they know their character is invincible with awesome death scenes or lasting consequences. But if one plays with an equal chance of winning and losing, I'd be very up for a rivalry, and allow consequences on my character. On the matter of people that hide behind the rules, I think equally much of those that hide behind their builds. For an interesting conflict there has to be room for both victories and defeats I agree with Shadowfiend here.. Just because someone's managed to over powerbuild beyond others doesn't mean they should completely be able to dominate in roleplay.
|
|
|
|
 |
|
Murex
|
Posted: Sat, Jan 17 2015, 16:24 PM |
|
|

Player
Joined: 01 Dec 2009
|
Shadowfiend wrote: Murex wrote: If you don't think enough time had passed to make sure everything was done properly, back out of it? If you get enough time for that. Typing when the opposition starts buffing ruins the whole thing. Basically, combat starts before the role-play finishes far too often. I think this problem needs to be addressed somehow.
|
|
|
|
 |
|
Terallis
|
Posted: Sat, Jan 17 2015, 16:28 PM |
|
|

Player
Joined: 30 Oct 2014 Location: Ontario, Canada
|
Grymia wrote: Shadowfiend wrote: I am going to skim through all those lengthy walls of text at some point, but up till then: I am not going to reward players that engage in pvp just because they know their character is invincible with awesome death scenes or lasting consequences. But if one plays with an equal chance of winning and losing, I'd be very up for a rivalry, and allow consequences on my character. On the matter of people that hide behind the rules, I think equally much of those that hide behind their builds. For an interesting conflict there has to be room for both victories and defeats I agree with Shadowfiend here.. Just because someone's managed to over powerbuild beyond others doesn't mean they should completely be able to dominate in roleplay. I, too, agree with this. Very much so, in fact. I've gone through this more times than I can count. There was a server I once played where there was an entire group of players who were experts at Arena servers and knew how to build for heavy PvP. This just made things irritating for everyone else as they would built the character to gain every advantage possible, and avoid properly RPing their stats, even. Some of these guys were able to take on groups of five or more (of the same level) and still have no real issue. I'm not saying it's a bad thing to know how to build, but I never really see it as something that should be used as a method of having immense power. Especially when (despite being around for 12 years) most people on RP servers don't know/care about powerbuilding, so much as just building to have it make sense for the character you're playing. There should never be someone who's able to pull off everything. Strengths and weaknesses are there, represented by the mechanics as well. And I'm going off on a rant again. Gonna stop before it detracts from the topic. @_@
_________________ 
|
|
|
|
 |
|
Grymia
|
Posted: Sat, Jan 17 2015, 16:39 PM |
|
|

Player
Joined: 14 Dec 2004 Location: Kohlingen, and a Basement in Canada
|
There's some cases though where it really is hard to let roleplay finish out before combat begins.. especially if any of the individuals involved are either known to be dangerous combatants, or if there's cause to believe that they might try to sneak attack. There's actions in PnP which are hard to emulate save by players being ready and trying to declare them *Readying an action to do something if the person does X* I'll offer a scenario based on on an older Sierra Game, Police Quest II.. some of you might not have played it but it might help provide perspective (the link I'll attach is to the portion of the game.. if it doesn't autowind to about 7:30 in the video you'll want to manually wind it there.. spolier incidentally but this game's so old I doubt it wholly relevant) : http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=iJ1C7pFbhW0--- Detective Bonds (the main character) pursued his nemesis Jesse Bains into the sewers of a city where Bains had Bonds' girlfriend kidnapped. Bains has already in previous matters escaped jail, murdered a guard at the jail, killed several of his old associates who turned states evidence against him and then kidnapped Det. Bonds' girlfriend to lure him into a trap. Sonny finds his girlfriend in the sewers and if played properly, calms her down and manages to notice Bains coming back, getting her re-tied enough to appear as though nothing is wrong. Bains comes back after Sonny hides, and has come in with a weapon drawn. At that point, Sonny's forced to gun him down after Bains fires first. ---- Applying Amia's rules.. how would you folks see that scenario?
|
|
|
|
 |
|
Shadowfiend
|
Posted: Sat, Jan 17 2015, 17:02 PM |
|
|

Player
Joined: 17 Oct 2011 Location: The Hall of the Mountain King
|
|
When it comes to point 9 of the rules I feel this should be specified a bit, as it gives room for powergaming. I've been killed in pvp by mages before and had it emoted by the other guy that my character was evaporized by the greater ruin. Imho, to emote the greater ruin kill my character is alright, to say my character was evaporized? Uncool, let me write my own death scene.
_________________ I am not weird, I am limited edition
|
|
|
|
 |
|
Mr. Hackums
|
Posted: Sat, Jan 17 2015, 17:06 PM |
|
|

Player
Joined: 22 May 2008
|
Grymia wrote: Shadowfiend wrote: I am going to skim through all those lengthy walls of text at some point, but up till then: I am not going to reward players that engage in pvp just because they know their character is invincible with awesome death scenes or lasting consequences. But if one plays with an equal chance of winning and losing, I'd be very up for a rivalry, and allow consequences on my character. On the matter of people that hide behind the rules, I think equally much of those that hide behind their builds. For an interesting conflict there has to be room for both victories and defeats I agree with Shadowfiend here.. Just because someone's managed to over powerbuild beyond others doesn't mean they should completely be able to dominate in roleplay. This is silly. For one, how do you even qualify something as vague and situational as character strength? Are you doing a comparison? Because if you're comparing a well-built character to your own characters, and saying that these characters shouldn't be rewarded with good Rp because they are mechanically stronger than both of your own builds, that's really sketchy. I'll expand upon this with my own style of play: I have never made a single fighter or weaponmaster in all of my 100+ alts over the course of my time on Amia. Why? Because for me, the amount of chance that factors in is too great. Mitigating chance in fighting and war is how you better control the outcome. You can have an awesome weaponmaster character who is built and geared incredibly well-- but the nature of strength-based melee fighting is a matter of rolling the dice. With this in mind, I tend to play Rogues, Sorcerers, Clerics even. Character builds where I can be sneaky, and use my own player skill to be able to win a fight, rather than taking chances. What if I'm just a better PvPer than you? That's what I'm getting at. That's not to slam you by any means, please don't think that. But when someone gets beaten in PvP, they often attribute it to a better build, or even cheese. Most people, for example, think that Di'rien (My sorcerer) was really well built. When in actuality, he spent 30 points in Ride, had extremely low discipline, was Epicly Focused in Illusion with.. no DC spells for illusion in his arsenal. I'm just calm-headed and understand sorcerer mechanics. Quote: "I agree with Shadowfiend here.. Just because someone's managed to over powerbuild beyond others doesn't mean they should completely be able to dominate in roleplay." When people start saying things like this, I get personally scared. I have never, ever-- in my entire NWN career-- ever tried to grief players. But if suddenly my victories in PvP are going to be treated as such, then I'm stuck in a lose-lose situation. My hands become tied-- I no longer contribute to the climate of Amia. I can't create conflict, because it won't get received well. I can't sit idle, because then I'm not providing conflict and the server stagnates.
|
|
|
|
 |
|
Grymia
|
Posted: Sat, Jan 17 2015, 17:10 PM |
|
|

Player
Joined: 14 Dec 2004 Location: Kohlingen, and a Basement in Canada
|
|
Perhaps i've just been burned one too many times by people that solely focus on PvP or seem to.
|
|
|
|
 |
|
Mr. Hackums
|
Posted: Sat, Jan 17 2015, 17:16 PM |
|
|

Player
Joined: 22 May 2008
|
I'll take this one step further, even: Quote: "I agree with Shadowfiend here.. Just because someone's managed to over powerbuild beyond others doesn't mean they should completely be able to dominate in roleplay." That's exactly what it means. But it should be stated more like this: Quote: "I agree with Shadowfiend here.. Just because someone's managed to over powerbuild beyond others doesn't mean they should completely be able to dominate in all roleplay." If a character is mechanically stronger than yours, or the player is simply better at fighting, if the character so chooses (And not all do) to be domineering over those weaker because of his combative strength, it's earned! It's justified! This is the jungle, baby! Instead of saying OOCly, "Man, I wish that guy wasn't such a douche," let your characters feel afraid, or concerned. Say ICly, "Don't go out alone at night. If you see him, avoid him-- avoid confrontation." Why complain OOCly about an IC outcome? Let the IC outcome dictate IC results. There will always be people stronger than other people. Under no circumstances should every player feel entitled to be strong. BUT! There's also something important to note, as I had 'bolded' above. A mechanically strong character may be able to ICly bully others around, and flaunt their strength because they know they're more powerful than you-- but that's hardly the extent of roleplay. Gyrmia, for example-- your character is not very strong in PvP. But, you've got immense character influence, strong investigative talents, connections to the Celestia. There is so, so much more a character can offer than simply combat RP. And people, myself included, should avoid judging the entire quality of their character on a basis of combat strength.
|
|
|
|
 |
|
Shadowfiend
|
Posted: Sat, Jan 17 2015, 17:25 PM |
|
|

Player
Joined: 17 Oct 2011 Location: The Hall of the Mountain King
|
|
But what about when you lose? Because no matter how minmaxed your build is or how good you are with your build, it's not mechanically possible?
_________________ I am not weird, I am limited edition
|
|
|
|
 |
|
Mr. Hackums
|
Posted: Sat, Jan 17 2015, 17:31 PM |
|
|

Player
Joined: 22 May 2008
|
I think it's very telling if you look at the success and liveliness of our community in the "Character weaknesses" thread, and how it doesn't translate to combat or PvP. Why is it that someone being physically weaker isn't also awesome in the same way that other character flaws are? I will say, that I expect and desire evil to be stronger than good, but some of the best evil characters can also be physically crippled and entirely manipulative. The regrettable nature of evil-produced conflict is that it usually has to be backed by strength (Even if they prefer not to use it), because people will so often simply challenge it with strength. And if they challenge it and win with incredible ease, the quality of the conflict that the evil group can produce severely declines. Think about The Dark Knight movie, and imagine the Justice League coming in and kicking the shit out of Bane in the first 10 minutes.  Wooouldn't be a very compelling piece of fiction! Would be amusing, but it would end quickly. And if it dragged on, and if Bane didn't muster his strength and become a viable threat again to even the Justice League, there would have been no plot progress. I'm saying this because part of the changes Amia needs to see is in the mindset. Letum is doing a great thing here with taking another look at the rules, and I'll no longer sidetrack that. Try to consider things from this angle: What would produce the best story on Amia? Better story = larger satisfaction. Edit: Oh, I didn't answer this very well then. I didn't understand what it was asking! Quote: But what about when you lose? Because no matter how minmaxed your build is or how good you are with your build, it's not mechanically possible? When my characters lose, because they're not omnipotent by any stretch, they suffer large drawbacks. Especially if the loss was backed up by quality Rp. For instance, Haan had his entire criminal empire crumble in a matter of days. He was assassinated, and a ~35 person faction fell into complete disarray. Vassilis took to hiding and became a Thayan fugitive. I personally try to make it difficult for my characters to be killed, but I always endeavor to reward the rarer victory with quality consequences on my end. Every evil/conflict character I've ever produced is made to lose in the end. Haan was a fireball of chaos and sin, and the collapse was perfect. It couldn't have gone any better.
|
|
|
|
 |
|
Shadowfiend
|
Posted: Sat, Jan 17 2015, 18:30 PM |
|
|

Player
Joined: 17 Oct 2011 Location: The Hall of the Mountain King
|
|
But most of the time it's not a result of quality and ongoing rp, it's sketchy half-assed characters with well made builds that want to boast their powers. If it creates a story beyond that encounter I won't complain. Unless, on the other hand, the other character is so strong and so persistant that instead of bringing the story onwards it stagnates, and that has happened. My character becomes unable to do anything about the problem, at all
_________________ I am not weird, I am limited edition
|
|
|
|
 |
|
Terallis
|
Posted: Sat, Jan 17 2015, 18:53 PM |
|
|

Player
Joined: 30 Oct 2014 Location: Ontario, Canada
|
Shadowfiend wrote: But most of the time it's not a result of quality and ongoing rp, it's sketchy half-assed characters with well made builds that want to boast their powers. In these cases, it's often something called a "Mary Sue". Aren't those sorts of characters not allowed, anyways? I'm unsure if there's an actual rule about it, but I really do feel there should be, tbh. Mary Sues tend to be a plague on RP in general. I mean, the biggest issue with all that's being talked about is when characters powerbuild for PvP specifically, don't RP much (especially the ones who avoid RP like the plague UNTIL they're max level), and then have their characters be engines of destruction with no weaknesses. All of that easily falls into the category of "Mary Sue", really. I'm personally not against people who build well, and then RP well. It's the ones that build amazingly and don't have any real RP to back it up. I've known people who even magically just "gain" power due to levels, with no background training or otherwise. Something like "I was a peasant all my life and all I ever knew was farming. I never picked up a sword before now. But look! I can fight on-par with the most skilled swordsman in the world, and even overpower him!" Actually, a huge example comes from a Star Wars server I played where one of the biggest PvP builders on the server would powerlevel up to max as a Force User, and still be a padawan in all levels of RP, but somehow have the power to take on an entire council of masters without issue. Stuff like that, what I think, is what is being said with all this.
_________________ 
|
|
|
|
 |
|
PassionateShadow
|
Posted: Sat, Jan 17 2015, 20:17 PM |
|
|

Player
Joined: 06 Jun 2014
|
As some one who rolls both PVP builds and Roleplay Builds I would like To point out the problems I've had. I've walked in to an area full of pc corpses. In an attempt to role play finding out what was going on only to get murdered by other characters with no warning or roleplay attached. Just to get killed. As soon as you log in that's not fun to play out at all. In my opinion it seems players just for go their manners when they are wrapped up in PVP and I feel this is a big issue that should be remedied. It's not the first time I've been subjugated to PVP when I've wanted to do RP no one ever takes the RP course or even let's it be presented. I much prefer written out role play and roleplay that sows a character's feeling and how they deal with instances. Depending on what reason you've fairly come to pvp I believe dice roles role play and mechanics can all be put in to one rather easily... Here's an example where all three were used and well- http://www.amiaworld.net/phpBB3/viewtopic.php?f=3&t=80013things prospered from it. We started to use our mechanics to see if success or failure came of it and we broke apart after small bouts to type a bit about our reactions. I found this to be MUCH more enjoyable all together. Then again this was a much more friendly way of 'pvp' and was meant for 'rp training' then anything vicious between characters / Players. If pvp can be geared towards offering a bit more manners and some ooc communication before hand I think it would be a much more enjoyable aspect. Also everything I've seen from Hakkums thus far presents very thoroughly how I feel about this whole topic. For now I'd like to start at the bottom of things and deal with the issues of etiquette and manners firstly. I find if you fix the first problem usually other problems tends to get fixed as well.
_________________ ❤ Amia is Fun Again! ❤ #GreenisNotACreativeColour "It's easy to feel like a hero. It's a little harder to be one."
|
|
|
|
 |
|
Zykritch
|
Posted: Sat, Jan 17 2015, 20:23 PM |
|
|

Player
Joined: 15 Jan 2015
|
Shadowfiend wrote: I am going to skim through all those lengthy walls of text at some point, but up till then: I am not going to reward players that engage in pvp just because they know their character is invincible with awesome death scenes or lasting consequences. But if one plays with an equal chance of winning and losing, I'd be very up for a rivalry, and allow consequences on my character. On the matter of people that hide behind the rules, I think equally much of those that hide behind their builds. For an interesting conflict there has to be room for both victories and defeats Hackums basically slammed this with exactly almost every point I wanted to personally make. I'm not sure why you think you don't have the right to powerbuild too, but there is -always- (from the very beginning) an 'equal chance' of winning (and I'm talking about from character creation onwards, till 30) .. No one is sitting there preventing you from making a good build too, and no one is 'hiding' behind their own. What they accomplish, and how strong they get IC'ly -is- how strong they get IC'ly. You can't claim to just disregard and ignore that because you think "Oh well he's powerbuilt, he has an unfair advantage over me." .. Because in reality, it's not him having an 'advantage' (or even giving himself one) .. the fact that you chose to deliberately build something weak and mediocre while expecting to have no consequences for that is -your- fault, and it's -you- giving yourself a disadvantage. It's as simple as this: If you want to roleplay a big, tough macho guy, design a build that fits it. Don't get all angry and pouty because someone beats you, and you attribute it to powerbuilding. No one is stopping you from doing the very same thing. And no one is doing anything to gain an advantage over you, if in reality you're only putting 1/10th of the effort into building that you could have. Your own shortcomings aren't the fault of anyone else, and you can't hold it against them that they just built a better character than you and say "Oh, I'm going to ignore your roleplay and/or give shitty reciprocation on purpose." .. And for the record, there is -always- both victories and defeats, lol. You can't have victory without someone getting defeated, and nor someone defeated without a victor. Just saying.
_________________ Inkheart
|
|
|
|
 |
Who is online |
Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 15 guests |
|
You cannot post new topics in this forum You cannot reply to topics in this forum You cannot edit your posts in this forum You cannot delete your posts in this forum
|
|