|
|
|
LordSithaelon
|
Posted: Mon, Sep 02 2013, 23:51 PM |
|
|

Player
Joined: 17 Apr 2013 Location: Home
|
|
When I say Characters... I refer to the players behind the character. I just feel you are alienating some players... when it was not up to them that the dale was set up the way it was.
_________________ Years of Love are forgotten in the hatred of a minute - Edgar Allen Poe
|
|
|
|
 |
|
Gobbledygook
|
Posted: Mon, Sep 02 2013, 23:52 PM |
|
|

Player
Joined: 18 Sep 2011
|
Liz wrote: Sithaelon: Being reasonable to other players is certainly and universally a good suggestion. But, there's a difference between that and being reasonable to other *characters.* OOC, we're unquestionably obligated not to be assholes to each other. IC, though, we have no such obligation. As long as the roads and carts exist IC, they're appropriately governed IC. Which means, if your character has done something to get her/himself banned from the area... tough f***ing luck. The IC government of Bendir Dale has no interest in making sure that characters are able to travel around the island however they please. Their interest is in protecting the lives and commerce of the Dalers. If you're playing an aggressively evil character or a monster race, and a Dale ban makes travel problematic for you... good. Life *should* be a bit more difficult for those characters. Since there's no realistic threat of death or imprisonment on this server, inconvenience is really the only consequence that can have any meaning. Would you agree that someone who is IC angered by their ban, and seeks IC to take it out on Dalers, etc, is also covered by this? It'd be saying 'tough fucking luck' right back at all of the hin, regardless of whether they're involved. It isn't always someone being an asshole OOC when they come back to wreak a little havoc. ^ I hate to be the devil's advocate on this, but Lorna was an example of how this happened. Most of it was IC responses to actions that were happening, and whilst some people were getting frustrated OOCly about what was going on, it was just a character acting like the character should act.
_________________ Just lurking about!
|
|
|
|
 |
|
LordSithaelon
|
Posted: Mon, Sep 02 2013, 23:55 PM |
|
|

Player
Joined: 17 Apr 2013 Location: Home
|
|
Moving the carts is a good medium... because those banned individuals can still use the cart and go near the dale, without having to cause or deal with issues... and for those banned persons that make the choice to move into the dale , then they cant claim ignorance, and whatever happens happens.
_________________ Years of Love are forgotten in the hatred of a minute - Edgar Allen Poe
|
|
|
|
 |
|
Liz
|
Posted: Mon, Sep 02 2013, 23:58 PM |
|
|

Player
Joined: 28 May 2010 Location: Smallville
|
|
Gobbledy: I'd definitely agree with that, yes. But I'd also insist that regardless of whether a character has a legitimate IC gripe against their ban, the fact of their ban still exists, and should be governed just like any banishment from any other community on the server: i.e., if you're going to violate your ban for any reason, you need a DM watching, or else you've violated not just IC laws but also OOC server rules as well.
_________________ Winner of Amia's "Most Ethical Time Traveler" award 2026 Character Portraits!
|
|
|
|
 |
|
Zedrik
|
Posted: Tue, Sep 03 2013, 0:01 AM |
|
|

Player
Joined: 16 Aug 2011 Location: Silent Hill, Indiana
|
|
The issue, frankly, is not complicated in the least. There are no consequences for IC dickery, and there's no consequences for OOC dickery. People can pick on us at will. Bully the weak kid cause, haha, he can't do anything in return. And the teachers just let it happen. Over and over and over and over and over and over and over and over and over and over and over and over again. We're sick of it. So much so, many of the former Dale actives left the server. LEFT THE SERVER. Because people just will. Not. Leave. Us. Alone.
The solution is simple: There needs to be actual consequences. Right now the consequences are minimal at best and does nothing to curb disruptive behavior. Nothing. At all.
(Also, people are STILL misconstruing the bans. A ban does not mean "You cannot enter the Dale ever, period." It means, "If you enter, please be on your way." That means, no, you can't go inside the walls, but yes, you can use the roads. You can go from the frontier to the mylocks, from the crags to the forest or from the forest to the carts. Just don't linger about.)
|
|
|
|
 |
|
Gobbledygook
|
Posted: Tue, Sep 03 2013, 0:03 AM |
|
|

Player
Joined: 18 Sep 2011
|
MrHackums wrote: So a player who is banned can indeed linger outside of the walls without technically metagaming the guards there. And indeed, at present, they can even start violence without technically metagaming the guards outside of the walls. I'm not suggesting their ban doesn't exist, only that in most cases this is taking place outside the walls of the Dale, not inside the walls. As Hackums said earlier, this is not breaking server rules, because it is not technically metagaming. If it happens right in front of the guard, or inside the walls, then yeah it's definitely wrong. But around the corner and by the carts? That's ok.
_________________ Just lurking about!
|
|
|
|
 |
|
Liz
|
Posted: Tue, Sep 03 2013, 0:05 AM |
|
|

Player
Joined: 28 May 2010 Location: Smallville
|
|
I agree that what you're describing doesn't violate the rules as they currently stand. What I'm advocating is that the rules be changed, to include the situation you describe.
_________________ Winner of Amia's "Most Ethical Time Traveler" award 2026 Character Portraits!
|
|
|
|
 |
|
Gobbledygook
|
Posted: Tue, Sep 03 2013, 0:08 AM |
|
|

Player
Joined: 18 Sep 2011
|
Liz wrote: I agree that what you're describing doesn't violate the rules as they currently stand. What I'm advocating is that the rules be changed, to include the situation you describe. I'd be really supportive of that. If maybe we worked on growing the Militia IC, so that we could afford to have more guards in the surrounding area of the Dale? Even though it may not have a huge IC amount of strength (meaning that evil players with a DM can still do their thing), it will certainly change how people act OOCly in the area, since they would be metagaming if there were guards there watching without a DM.
_________________ Just lurking about!
|
|
|
|
 |
|
Mr. Hackums
|
Posted: Tue, Sep 03 2013, 0:11 AM |
|
|

Player
Joined: 22 May 2008
|
|
We can't police where we're not at. That was something NC was touching on at the very beginning. IC dickery-- well, that's not really our problem. That should and does fall on the players. Though I will say that an active Bendir Dale DM could also help with creating IC consequences from an NPC side. But unless its brought to our attention in an IC way, the DM team often likes to empower players to deal with IC conflict on their own.
OOC dickery you need to screenshot and report. Its the only way there will be consequences. And that again, falls on you players as well. The Dm's cannot be everywhere at once. And we follow through with fair procedure on every report we receive. If you don't get a response back from a DM, send it to a few more just to be safe. Sometimes, DM's are inactive on the forums for all kinds of reasons. Send it to a lot.
I'm not trying to be conflictual, or a dick, Zedrik. But if the problems were as easy as you seem to believe they are, the players would have already fixed it by now. Nay, in fact, simply stating 'Consequences' comes with a whole slew of complications. Are you asking for death penalties? Are you asking for changes in the module? Are you asking for increased DM time in Bendir? What should the consequences be? Have we taken into account Bendir's importance as a hub? How do we make changes without removing opportunities for conflict between players, without need of a DM to supervise. And if we change where the carts go, will we just be pushing this kind of conflict onto someone else's territory?
None of this is simple, mate.
|
|
|
|
 |
|
The Great Equalizer
|
Posted: Tue, Sep 03 2013, 0:43 AM |
|
|

Player
Joined: 29 Aug 2006 Location: Victoria, BC, Canada
|
|
Here is the thing the dale can't just expand to police the entire map, first of all the dale is small which means they have limited rescources and bodies to fill their militia, it also means that while they assuredly can defend the city itself thanks to fortifications and numbers going out to try to police the entire area thins the numbers and makes them vulnerable enough that a big bad PC could just whipe the ones they encouter out if the militia tried to stop them.
That is how it currently is with the roads, you can say "hey but we have guards!" but the militia is there to protect bendir and it seems unlikely that they would want to risk lives trying to enforce things that aren't a direct threat to the dale (aka the roads) which is a big issue here since many in Bendir claim that the laws extend to the entire area and so those outside the walls are metagaming only to have them go "but they wouldn't be enforcing it out here".
...Basically to get all that you seem to want you would need to have the dale law able to be ICly strongly enforced in the entire area, but that isn't realy a realistic option since a city doesn't just GET far more powerful and boom in population because you want it to.
|
|
|
|
 |
|
Scimiter
|
Posted: Tue, Sep 03 2013, 0:49 AM |
|
|

Player
Joined: 25 Apr 2009 Location: Canada
|
|
Arelith had a problem such as this in Cordor and mostly solved it by scripting the NPC Guards to react to PVP within thier range. Worked well enough the script was added to most of the NPCs watching over the given racial or faction area. Not a very hard script to build but take some time to deploy
Going back in the thread P's idea of moving the carts just out of Bendir lands wouldn't hurt.
I know I'm not touching on the real problem of people metaing in the first place buut that's more a DM thing to look at anyway. Screenies and chatlogs in hand they'll deal with it
_________________ Guys I play: Finng Meras Joshua Steel Daniel Makie Celub Elubmiire Tristan Len'ionel 
|
|
|
|
 |
|
Liz
|
Posted: Tue, Sep 03 2013, 0:55 AM |
|
|

Player
Joined: 28 May 2010 Location: Smallville
|
|
Moving the carts away from the Dale would be a problem IC, since Tomato is correct that the IC purpose of the carts is the commercial mass transportation of goods, not individual passengers. The cart stops at the Dale because that's where the business is.
_________________ Winner of Amia's "Most Ethical Time Traveler" award 2026 Character Portraits!
|
|
|
|
 |
|
LordSithaelon
|
Posted: Tue, Sep 03 2013, 1:11 AM |
|
|

Player
Joined: 17 Apr 2013 Location: Home
|
Liz wrote: Moving the carts away from the Dale would be a problem IC, since Tomato is correct that the IC purpose of the carts is the commercial mass transportation of goods, not individual passengers. The cart stops at the Dale because that's where the business is. Because of all the crap recently in the Dale, I have not seen much business. I like to set up shop to promote RP and to get people something they might need to further their adventures... but honestly, as the player, some of the stuff, like todays incident just pushes me off actually trying to do anything, and I really dont like it. But I would rather just avoid the area, rather than be drawn into something.
_________________ Years of Love are forgotten in the hatred of a minute - Edgar Allen Poe
|
|
|
|
 |
|
Mr. Hackums
|
Posted: Tue, Sep 03 2013, 1:14 AM |
|
|

Player
Joined: 22 May 2008
|
|
Another DM pointed out that if we script the NPC's to react to violence, we'd have to either upgrade the guards so they don't get slaughtered and the situation gets worse-- Or we'd make them uber powerful, and it might as well be a no PvP zone.
And I understand, LordSithaelon, that PC's don't often set up shop in Bendir. But the NPC business continues doing well, especially given the strained conditions of agriculture in the North due to Beastmen, and in the South due to goblinoids. Bendir, much like the Forest, is one of Amia's crossroads-- for business and travel. And for better or worse.
|
|
|
|
 |
|
Tomato Sword
|
Posted: Tue, Sep 03 2013, 3:17 AM |
|
|

Player
Joined: 18 Aug 2011
|
Mr. Hackums wrote: Another DM pointed out that if we script the NPC's to react to violence, we'd have to either upgrade the guards so they don't get slaughtered and the situation gets worse-- Or we'd make them uber powerful, and it might as well be a no PvP zone. Considering this is how it is on every other RP server but here, I really don't understand what the reservations are. Amia is the only one I've ever played in where it's on good faith system despite the fact players continue to violate it on daily basis for years on end. Yes, yes, we've all been told something will be done about it but until something actually does get done? That really falls on deaf ears. It is not our job to aggressively pursue rulebreakers as players (As in people who break server rules). We really can't. We don't have the time, the skill, the power, or the authority. We also know that Amian DMs also don't feel it's their job to do something about it. So it sounds like a fairly reasonable solution to take the problem out of both of our hands by just having the machine slaughter people who are blatant dickheads. Either way, a guard reacting to PC violence doesn't really equal to no PvP zone. No PvP zone you can't PvP at all in any capacity. NPC guards will only react to violence within a certain radius. The Dale is one of the biggest single map settlement there is in all of Amia, on both A and B. Especially considering how relatively sparse our NPC guards will be, I highly doubt it'd be the same thing as having a PvP ban on the entire area.
|
|
|
|
 |
|
Liz
|
Posted: Tue, Sep 03 2013, 3:25 AM |
|
|

Player
Joined: 28 May 2010 Location: Smallville
|
|
Just out of curiosity, since I've never played any other server for more than an hour or two... how exactly does an active NPC guard like you're describing determine who to attack? Is it just "pound whoever throws the first punch"? If so, I can agree that could be situationally problematic; Daisy has thrown the first punch in several fights, in response to people prepping themselves for a fight by casting non-offensive combat buffs. How do "smart" guards distinguish between legitimate preemptive defense like that, and someone just throwing punches for no reason?
_________________ Winner of Amia's "Most Ethical Time Traveler" award 2026 Character Portraits!
|
|
|
|
 |
|
LeathanKayne
|
Posted: Tue, Sep 03 2013, 3:46 AM |
|
|

Player
Joined: 03 Apr 2005 Location: Ontario, Canada
|
|
Honestly, I think the best solution here would be an announcement notice to remind people of the rules, and a DM or two enforcing it for a while with OOC consequences like a fine of gold or XP for metagaming.
Aside from that, we're just frustrating ourselves continuing this discussion right now as any other OOC actions like "smart" NPCs or no PvP will only make the situation worse.
We're only going to get our blood boiling by snapping at each other over this issue and it's not going to help anyone.
|
|
|
|
 |
|
Glyph
|
Posted: Tue, Sep 03 2013, 6:16 AM |
|
|

Player
Joined: 10 Jun 2010
|
|
I hate to find myself on the other side of this one in a way, recalling one time I got banned from the forest for 24 hours with an evil dude, you can't go the other ways by it when you are level 5, you die.
of course I know exactly what you're refering to and its not evil lowbies getting themselves in trouble for no reason and ignoring a guard to get somewhere quicker, I remember an SD abusing their powers to torment someone inside cordor a long long time ago, even stating they give not a single for the guards opinion. don't be that guy, it makes the world a shitty place.
ed: I would move the cart to bypass the main path, thats the only actual solution I can think of, dale gated with key items doesn't sound very hin-like to me though.
|
|
|
|
 |
|
LeathanKayne
|
Posted: Tue, Sep 03 2013, 7:04 AM |
|
|

Player
Joined: 03 Apr 2005 Location: Ontario, Canada
|
|
While I like the idea of the carts being elsewhere, they're typically supposed to be inside or by communities. That said, perhaps the carts should be moved from the south east area to the north east area. There's much more clear room there instead of crowding the footpath.
|
|
|
|
 |
|
Remal
|
Posted: Tue, Sep 03 2013, 7:58 AM |
|
|

Player
Joined: 12 Feb 2011 Location: Elsewhen
|
|
I don't understand why were carts moved back to original position from their place across the river in NE of the Dale. There they were close to the gates too (and to all craftsmen that are in the north side of the Dale). Returning them there and designating couple of NPC guards to keep eye on the carts and ensure banned folks don't linger much might help. But that really won't stop folks who are actively looking for trouble/PvP anyway.
Sincerely, if you want better control of the Dale, you must make place bigger and stronger. No one will take small peaceful hin village seriously anyway, to be honest. I've seen fair share of party chatter and comments like "5 Cordorian Law Knights could steamroll the place, with all PCs and NPCs together".
You firstly need to increase population. Dwarves in Barak sent call to help to dwarven citadels all around Faerun. While hin and gnomes don't have many standalone settlements, they do have their communities, and both races to have enough adventurous folks to actually come to Amia and help. I'm not sure if you still have those Guldorand refugees, but seeing Guldorand reconstruction hasn't moved a lot, maybe they can be persuaded to actually stay in Bendir? Pro-human propaganda in Cordor might be another way to get new hin and gnomes who might decide to change climate. Second, you need to increase military force - better gear, training, another watchtower or two to cover more land. Create small NPC force trained and equipped to deal with more powerful threats. While Malatril was still alive I offered such many times, but always got "we are peaceful village and don't want to make ourselves look more militaristic". Well, maybe a change of tactic is in order? Because as long as you appear weak, you will always be target of evil toons looking for their daily dose of feeling important and powerful (or just plain asshole), and it might be completely IC.
_________________ "A designer knows he has achieved perfection not when there is nothing left to add, but when there is nothing left to take away." - Antoine de Saint-Exupry
|
|
|
|
 |
|
Lord-Hadeis
|
Posted: Tue, Sep 03 2013, 8:35 AM |
|
|

Player
Joined: 02 Feb 2009 Location: Netherlands, Schoonhoven
|
|
Can't the roads be rerouted? The area is large enough to nudge them a bit further away from the actual village and raise some hills inbetween as a buffer, moving the carts again too would help. I think that could actually be a quick and easy solution though I'd have to mess a bit in the tool set to be sure. Maybe tunnel the road through a part of the eastern hills with a transition, that would skip players along through the area. Btw how many people live in BendirDale acording to the official lore? I've know then place as expanded atleast four times so far, so how much of a village is it still? Size has always been a bit decieving in Amia it seems to be atleast 10 times the people you'd expect countring houses and the size of them.
As for serious meta gamers. Take screen shots get the chat logger available in "Optional downloads" and build a case against them.
Yes I've recently dug through the dale forum and noted I've been a bit guilty too, though I have to say it is a tricky situation as the DM's say with the Dale on the main route through amai. Guess I'll be running invis through troll lands a lot for now. Though as long as the cart service is so close to the actual village some small short term introcision of some players are hard prevent.
|
|
|
|
 |
|
RuffTuff
|
Posted: Tue, Sep 03 2013, 9:08 AM |
|
|

Player
Joined: 20 Jul 2008 Location: Clock Town
|
Remal wrote: Create small NPC force trained and equipped to deal with more powerful threats. This idea is actually one I can get behind. A small group of Arvoreen's faithful dedicated to keeping the dale safe from bigger threats is a fantastic idea, and it keeps with our small village ways without overmilitarizing Bendir. While raising the walls, creating more military, gearing up and making ourselves a strong force may seem like a good idea, at the heart of it we're still playing Halflings, who are a very peaceful race. That isn't to say necessarily that all the hin in Amia are peaceful, because that simply isn't true. But generally speaking, halflings aren't warlike and aren't known for their battles. Arvoreen's faithful, however, are. A group of scary vanguard of Arvoreen's faithful could be a strong backbone for Bendir's protection, and it would make sense. Also, on the note of moving the carts. We've tried this before without much success. A lot of people just stopped showing up out of the inconvenience of being dumped in the middle of the area instead of the usual corner, and it didn't do much to chase off ban violators either. I'd also like to address a misconception I'm starting to see crop up here. The primary thing I'm trying to fix here is the rampant server rule breaking around Bendir Dale, in the form of ban ignorance, NPC guard metagaming, and the like. I'm not out to chase away every evil baddie who wants to show up and be.. y'know, evil. I understand that evil characters are important to the server, and I understand that conflict is what keeps areas alive. But just as a note on conflict, I'd like to point out good conflict versus griefing. Back when I still played Peter, another hin and I were informed by a disguised villain that they had downed party members in the Skull Crags. When we were led out there, the villain revealed himself to be a Cyrist and forced us to either bend our knee to his god or die. That was good conflict. It was meditated, well-executed, and led to a realistic non-metagamey fight. That is an example of good conflict RP. BAD conflict RP is repeatedly showing up at Bendir after you've started your fights, killed your scrubs and won your victories, and expecting that the guards won't care. Hackums did have a point that the outside guards can't constantly be checking to see who's on the ban list, but they're not blind either. There are guards stationed both in front of the dale gates with clear view of the cart corner, and guards stationed behind the carts near the entrance to the skull crags. If you show up and start a battle and kill a bunch of people, they're going to see it. And even if they can't react just at that moment, they're going to remember you. Because y'know, you're murdering people. So naturally, when you show back up to hang around the next day, they're going to remember you. Especially if your incident earned you a ban, and it more than likely would in that case. That's the kind of metagaming I'm talking about. I'm totally cool with evil doers being evil because that's what evil doers do. But evil doers who kill three dale citizens in broad daylight and then show up again the next day like nothing happened are GOING to be recognized, and are therefore metagaming. One important thing to keep in mind when you're making suggestions is that we have already tried a huge amount of things, and the people we have the most trouble with are the ones who are willing to metagame the NPC guards and ignore their bans simply because we have no way to enforce them. Posting more guards by the carts seems good in theory, but in practice it's only more cardboard cutouts for them to ignore. And we can just keep chat logging and taking screenshots, but like Tomato said, we've been doing that for ages with no success. The notion of building a case against a player makes sense here in the forums but you have to take into consideration that every day we have to spend chatlogging and taking more screenshots is a day that our enjoyment of the server is being muddied by that player who's breaking server rules. It may not seem like a long time in the forums, but in-game it feels like an eternity.
_________________ Characters I play: Kira Cottonfoot - Hin Bardess Kirby Cottonfoot - Arcane Trickster
|
|
|
|
 |
|
Kudark
|
Posted: Tue, Sep 03 2013, 9:47 AM |
|
|

Player
Joined: 14 Dec 2009 Location: The Dark Side of the Moon
|
Ruff's above post sums it all up on where most of the problems lie. In my opinion, as a continuous Bendir player for nearly 4 years, Bendir Dale requires a stronger DM presence. It 'is' really that simple. I have read through every single post so far, and have seen a whole lot of bullshit, and untruths, which I will not go into detail about. I'm not here to flame or blame, but those of you who have not really had the involvement that some of us continue to have in Bendir, do not understand the complete frustration we as players try to deal with on a continual basis. Literally, no other place on both servers, sees the amount of rule breaking going on, as it does in Bendir. I can truly say, I see metagaming infractions every day, and many of them I ignore, because I know the resulting arguments will will only cause more...it happens all the time. By the way...Private Tall Dragon does 'not' resemble this remark: Quote: Mr. Hackums wrote: [Pun incoming] and its that the Dale is simply short-staffed.  As stated before, by Mr. Hackums, Bendir Dale requires special attention. Personally, I think Bendir Dale, as small a community as it is, given its location and the traffic it receives, should have a dual DM team to supervise. This would not force one DM to be on, babysitting the little folk, but free them up for other things as well. This is one suggestion I have.
_________________ 
|
|
|
|
 |
|
The Great Equalizer
|
Posted: Tue, Sep 03 2013, 9:59 AM |
|
|

Player
Joined: 29 Aug 2006 Location: Victoria, BC, Canada
|
|
I think part of the issue is that the "guards" are actually militia members of a small town and while trained to defend against the trolls and stuff around the dale would likely not be very high level mechanically. So while it is true that it does suck that people ignore what they might do it is also good to note that what they would probably do is stay out of the fight with the really deadly and probably higher level PCs that or get killed trying to stop it.
The elite force thing is a good idea but I would still recommend backing off on the enforcement outside Bendir itself. You don't call in your big guns to chase someone away if they aren't really causing much of an actual issue. But if they try to strat killing people or attacking the town then would be a time to point out that the SUPER Militia team would jump on things, and then if they still continue screeny it all for the DMs. Because then they have context for the actual severity and scope of the meta gaming violation.
Someone being banned but not doing really anything bad while there and someone murdering or attacking the town are greatly different levels of meta gaming.
|
|
|
|
 |
|
Tomato Sword
|
Posted: Tue, Sep 03 2013, 10:05 AM |
|
|

Player
Joined: 18 Aug 2011
|
The Great Equalizer wrote: I think part of the issue is that the "guards" are actually militia members of a small town and while trained to defend against the trolls and stuff around the dale would likely not be very high level mechanically. There's really no basis to this claim. There are no areas on Amia A and B that have high level mobs in the immediate vicinity of a town, save for Zanshibon. And that's the goddamn Abyss. Everything is low to mid-level, with the highest concentration of low level mobs in the most powerful city-state in the entire server: Cordor. Unless the monsters around Cordor and INSIDE Cordor is somehow an indication Cordorian guards are level 3-4, this argument really holds no basis whatsoever. Even then, Skitt and Holl has been there for AGES. On a server with an average level of 29.9, I have hard time believing somehow these characters lack the experience that a week old level 30 character does for all that they've done to serve the Dale.
|
|
|
|
 |
|
The Great Equalizer
|
Posted: Tue, Sep 03 2013, 10:13 AM |
|
|

Player
Joined: 29 Aug 2006 Location: Victoria, BC, Canada
|
|
Not saying the dale doesn't have experienced skilled NPCs at all (Why I actually like the elite group idea) but they are a militia of a small town and so most of them are going to be pretty average. Cordor is not the same, they are a large city with a large population so they too might have a bunch of mediocre guards in their service but the ones who come to beat down adventurers and protect Cordor from large threats (AKA the ones you actually interact with) are the 1% of the guard that have rare skill and have had a lot of gold ad effort put into their training and equipping, there are only so many of them even though they are a small percentage because they have such a large population that a small percentage still means a lot of them. Bendir on the other hand would likely only have enough population with the talent to form a smaller group.
|
|
|
|
 |
|
Liz
|
Posted: Tue, Sep 03 2013, 10:26 AM |
|
|

Player
Joined: 28 May 2010 Location: Smallville
|
|
There's no inherently necessary correlation between the size of a town and the strength of its defenders. Their relative ability should be an IC concern. The Winya guards, for example, are elite soldiers from Evermeet; they're allegedly pretty badass regardless of Winya (like the Dale) only being a tiny fraction of the population of Cordor. Maybe Skit and Holl are retired adventurers, grizzled old hardcases who still have all their old high-level gear and haven't forgotten their old tricks?
_________________ Winner of Amia's "Most Ethical Time Traveler" award 2026 Character Portraits!
|
|
|
|
 |
|
Kudark
|
Posted: Tue, Sep 03 2013, 10:34 AM |
|
|

Player
Joined: 14 Dec 2009 Location: The Dark Side of the Moon
|
|
Sorry for this but, Great EQ? You have been saying the same thing over and over and over in this thread, just give it a rest for christ's sake. You have added nothing to help the situation. Bendir Dale has 'always' been based on militia, and the training of such has 'always' been of high priority. There has 'always' been a group of militia being trained behind the Town Hall. Remal's elite militia is a good idea, but does not solve the issue at hand. (see RuffTuff's last post).
_________________ 
|
|
|
|
 |
|
Kamina
|
Posted: Tue, Sep 03 2013, 10:36 AM |
|
|

DM
Joined: 05 Jul 2007 Location: Kent, England.
|
|
I think the Militia's "power" is an entirely DM matter and is pointless to debate it here.
_________________  "Operating in the border between light and darkness, shadowdancers are nimble artists of deception. They are mysterious and unknown, never completely trusted but always inducing wonder when met"
|
|
|
|
 |
|
Mr. Hackums
|
Posted: Tue, Sep 03 2013, 10:57 AM |
|
|

Player
Joined: 22 May 2008
|
|
Hrm. Well, let's try simple. I'll even try to help myself, busy as I've been, lately.
We'll try to increase our DM presence on Bendir, first and foremost. Whether idling there more often, or assigning a Dm to the area (I imagine this will happen regardless). But in honesty, I think that most metagaming like that happens when no DM's are online. Folks think they can get away with it because there's no one there to enforce the rules.
I understand its frustrating to have people consistently metagaming. Barak Runedar had similar cases as well. But the only way its going to stop is by making the stance very clear to the playerbase (Perhaps an announcement, of sorts), and enforcing that stance. And the only way we can mechanically enforce it is if the players and DM's work together to pounce on metagamers. You don't need to take what they're doing as a personal attack against you, you don't even need to have a whispered conversation with them. Just take a quick screenshot, send it our way. It really is the only way this is going to get any better.
Changing the carts, increasing guard presence, creating an NPC elite force-- this isn't going to stop people from metagaming, as Ruff said. The way to stop people from metagaming is by helping the DM team be aware of who's doing it. Tomato-- it /is/ our job to stop this. But we don't have the manpower to look at every character on both servers 24/7. We need your help in finding the issues.
|
|
|
|
 |
|
Liz
|
Posted: Tue, Sep 03 2013, 11:06 AM |
|
|

Player
Joined: 28 May 2010 Location: Smallville
|
|
I wonder if maybe it would help a little bit if the website didn't list the DM count online at any given moment. Would the assholes start hesitating before doing asshole things, if they had to be constantly wondering whether a DM was watching?
_________________ Winner of Amia's "Most Ethical Time Traveler" award 2026 Character Portraits!
|
|
|
|
 |
|
Tomato Sword
|
Posted: Tue, Sep 03 2013, 11:13 AM |
|
|

Player
Joined: 18 Aug 2011
|
RuffTuff wrote: One important thing to keep in mind when you're making suggestions is that we have already tried a huge amount of things... [W]e can just keep chat logging and taking screenshots, but like Tomato said, we've been doing that for ages with no success. The notion of building a case against a player makes sense here in the forums but you have to take into consideration that every day we have to spend chatlogging and taking more screenshots is a day that our enjoyment of the server is being muddied by that player who's breaking server rules. It may not seem like a long time in the forums, but in-game it feels like an eternity. I really don't know how much more we can make it clear or you, Hackums. I, along with many others, have said this repeatedly, not just here, but in many other previous discussion and threads. If you want us to spend hours upon hours doing something to help you, we really expect the same. We have been told so many times something will be done and nothing has. Until we actually see something is being done, I will be the first one to tell you it's highly unlikely we'll spend hours of our lives compiling screenshots just to be disappointed again.
|
|
|
|
 |
|
corypx
|
Posted: Tue, Sep 03 2013, 11:23 AM |
|
|

Player
Joined: 14 Oct 2006
|
Liz wrote: I wonder if maybe it would help a little bit if the website didn't list the DM count online at any given moment. Would the assholes start hesitating before doing asshole things, if they had to be constantly wondering whether a DM was watching? That would hinder people who are looking for DMs, because then they might not know if a DM is on or not, or if they missed the message. I know a lot of the time when people are looking for DM oversight in something they are looking for a select DM so we are already forced to ask over DM chat who the DMs are, if we had to ask every 10mins if any are on.... would just be a pain and even more so for the DMs if they were on A-mia because they could be seeing that every 10mins by a server of 40 people. Maybe what you guys need is a NPC reporting thread where you post screenshots of the most stupid metagame ever, I know on Caraigh I was granted permission in a single case where I got to post a what was a "IC report from a NPC guard to me and others" and it was a screen shot of a group of people who walked past a guard, to stand in front of another guard and ever closer to more guards.... to talk about how to destroy the location said guards were guarding..... They were temp banned but it also served as kind of deterrent because other plays saw how they were acting and could watch out for such actions from them and could also act to shame them a bit so they wise up.
_________________ ================-<Cory ShadowFlame>-================ Risenlord-Shifter(OMG a Non-Dragon Shifter that can hold his own in PvE) 
|
|
|
|
 |
|
The Great Equalizer
|
Posted: Tue, Sep 03 2013, 11:24 AM |
|
|

Player
Joined: 29 Aug 2006 Location: Victoria, BC, Canada
|
|
Kudark all you have done is complain about needing DMs and how the dale has is so much worse than everywhere else. And attacking me when I am attempting to actually be of help, regardless of if you actually like what I have to say is a dick move.
As for requiring more DM presence... too bad? and I don't mean that in a bad way but it is hard enough to get one DM really active as much as you guys seem to want and you seem to think the dale needs more than one. And the dale has a relatively minor metagaming issue, persistent and annoying but lots of players and groups on the server have dealt with as bad or worse. Hell at one time (although more than once) the drow RP was so insanely full of meta gaming, griefing, and OOC shit storms that I'm pretty sure it alienated a good chuck of the players and DMs from wanting to do anything with any drow for.. years in some cases.
And to those who say they've done this (for one of numerous reasons): DON'T IGNORE META GAMING, if you want something done about it report it. If you don't tell the DMs when it happens then you kind of lose your right to complain about how nothing is happening about it. hat the last I'll be adding here.
|
|
|
|
 |
|
Kamina
|
Posted: Tue, Sep 03 2013, 11:50 AM |
|
|

DM
Joined: 05 Jul 2007 Location: Kent, England.
|
The Great Equalizer wrote: And the dale has a relatively minor metagaming issue, persistent and annoying but lots of players and groups on the server have dealt with as bad or worse. Guess we should stop discussing these at-least-once-a-day issues because others have had it worse!
_________________  "Operating in the border between light and darkness, shadowdancers are nimble artists of deception. They are mysterious and unknown, never completely trusted but always inducing wonder when met"
|
|
|
|
 |
|
Gobbledygook
|
Posted: Tue, Sep 03 2013, 12:54 PM |
|
|

Player
Joined: 18 Sep 2011
|
|
He's not saying stop discussing it. He's just pointing out that some of these issues have happened in the past in other places, and they've been resolved. Everyone recognises that Bendir Dale is a bit different from the other situations. We just need to work together to come up with a decent solution here.
_________________ Just lurking about!
|
|
|
|
 |
|
Pony
|
Posted: Tue, Sep 03 2013, 14:53 PM |
|
|

Player
Joined: 07 May 2005
|
Bendir Dale is located in a great place. Mechanically it is the true center of the island with the knot of three cart service lanes. It is sorrounded by very popular and important low level hunting areas and it has very useful shops for low levels. On Amia A it is the only true alternative starting place for low level characters. It is home to one of the popular races. With the plot developments it is the neutral zone between Cordor and the Treaty States and with it's peaceful and merry theme it is a great place for people to socialize and get away from the more serious life of the island. The great benefit of that is that Bendir Dale is perhaps the settlement that will always have an easier time being active and sought out by people searching for roleplay. Places like Barak Runedar and Winya Ravena have it a lot harder in that respect. With being a place of great activity, especially one where different characters who would usually not be in the same spot meet, you will have clashes. Cordor was no different back in the days before it shrugged off it's motto of tolerance and started to go against the diversity with forcing people and groups out. The Cordor Guard faced exactly the same problems of troublemakers and verbal and physical arguements. Bendir Dale is the old Cordor Square. If you push the cart service back north and start enforcing laws to distance yourself from adventuring rp Bendir Dale will turn into Winya Ravena or Barak Runedar in many respects. You will have a very closed "fortress" of halfling players. Your activity will take a hit as you will no longer be the go to place for roleplay and you will need to put in a lot of rp to keep the resident players interrested and active in it. I think it is very much an ic matter that the Dale should address in the way they feel they should head. What I would do is not try to push away the adventuring rp, but embrace it and give it a better platform you can control. For instance you could undergo an contruction effort to build an amian version of the Friendly Arm Inn. The cart service, adventuring trading and rp takes place there in a controlled but tolerant envoirment. Bendir Dale keeps it's place of a popular place of resting for adventurers, it keeps the benefit of they being a deterrent to the savage wilds around the village, you also create a safer, more controlled, but also merry and adventerous atmosphere without doing a 'Cordor'.
|
|
|
|
 |
|
Zedrik
|
Posted: Tue, Sep 03 2013, 15:57 PM |
|
|

Player
Joined: 16 Aug 2011 Location: Silent Hill, Indiana
|
|
We don't want to push away the adventurers. We like the adventurers. Roseville is basically a low-level adventurer help center alongside a social gathering place. What we want to get rid of is not necessarily the conflicts, but the constant trolling. Like Ruff pointed out earlier, we OOCly aren't averse to evil characters. (Some of us also play evil characters.) It's the constantness of the juvenile behavior that eats at us. Basically, it's the e-peen waving that we don't like. The superbuilt uberPvP builds that come in at level 30 to harass the low level adventurers and non-grinder non-powerbuilder community that tends to play hins. People are just so... well, childish. They are told "no, you can't have your weapons out int he Dale, please" and they throw a fit, either by being overtly aggressive or trying to explain to us that there's nothing wrong with them having their weapons drawn. Or hoods/helmets... holy crap, you'd think we were asking people to undergo brutal castration. We're having issues with people, it's not unreasonable for us to want to see faces.
|
|
|
|
 |
|
bidocks
|
Posted: Tue, Sep 03 2013, 17:21 PM |
|
|

Player
Joined: 25 Jul 2011
|
|
Ok, I have read every single post on this.... whew. I'm a "relatively" new player, and only recently started having my characters hang out in the Dale. I'm going to throw out an idea that most will react negatively to, but please, think about it for a moment, and think about my IC explanation too.
What if.... Bendir Dale allowed any non-banned race to become a citizen? As far as I know, Bendir is one of the few racially-based Towns on Amia. I know it IS the hin town, but, it's not. It's Hin, Gnomes, and Dwarves, and Fey, but only the "little" fey. I've had a couple of characters now that would have helped out with the militia (and could have been good deterrents) that can't, simply because of their race. There is however a human citizen and militia member, so, the proverbial seal is already being broken. Over time, all areas evolve. In order to thrive, I would think Bendir Dale would allow, and even welcome other races that wished to live by their rules and enjoy the lifestyle they have created. Allowing other races to be citizens, and eventually militia, would greatly increase the population of the Dale, and the show of force for the militia.
I see a major problem with people not respecting the militia's authority. I see Crow (the one human member) there a lot. He tries, but, he's just one person, and..... I've seen people completely disregard he is EVEN A MEMBER OF THE MILITIA! Anything he says is retorted with, "I'll talk to the Mayor." and he's instantly done... Now, I'm also a firm believer of "get what you give", and a recent addition to the militia, who isn't around much lately had a wonderful tact to his rule enforcement. Instead of instantly threatening or trying to bully, instead, inform said rulebreaker politely first. You get more flies with honey, so the saying goes. Just a thought, and it's a minor one, at that.
Another issue I see is that anyone who spends a lot of time in the Dale suddenly thinks they can enforce the laws there. I recently watched a Silver Dragon chase down and kill a banned individual, usurping a Militia member's authority right in front of them. I'm not positive, but I don't believe the Silver Dragons have ANY authority in the Dale, nevermind OVER a Militia member's authority? Perhaps, adding a rule about vigilante-ism is necessary too. Though, more rules, more problems.
As much as I hate PVP, if the problem pvp'ers constantly arrive to face a superior force of militia (either NPC or PC or a combo of both), they will stop. I've played on enough servers to have seen this occur.
I know my idea of opening citizenship to other races is quite radical, but... drastic times... drastic measures? Just a thought, and not pointing fingers or laying blame (except to those who metagame, I hate that).
|
|
|
|
 |
|
RuffTuff
|
Posted: Tue, Sep 03 2013, 19:22 PM |
|
|

Player
Joined: 20 Jul 2008 Location: Clock Town
|
The Great Equalizer wrote: The elite force thing is a good idea but I would still recommend backing off on the enforcement outside Bendir itself. You don't call in your big guns to chase someone away if they aren't really causing much of an actual issue. But if they try to strat killing people or attacking the town then would be a time to point out that the SUPER Militia team would jump on things, and then if they still continue screeny it all for the DMs. Because then they have context for the actual severity and scope of the meta gaming violation. Equalizer actually has a decent point here. I honestly think we should quit enforcing things like the drawn weapon and helmet laws outside of the gates, because frankly, having weapons drawn or handy in a place that's surrounded not only by monsters, but monster PCs who like to kill people? Makes sense. I'm not blind. I can see that clearly a lot of the shenanigans around Bendir are a direct result of our increasingly frustrated and hostile efforts to keep people under control. Getting the third degree from a bunch of angry screaming halflings every time you so much as toe the line of a rule is not only unnecessary, but incredibly frustrating. Instead of tightening the deathgrip Bendir's militia have on the IC laws, I think we should take .38 Special's advice and hold on loosely, but don't let go, 'cause if you cling too tightly you're gonna lose control. bidocks wrote: Instead of instantly threatening or trying to bully, instead, inform said rulebreaker politely first. You get more flies with honey, so the saying goes. Just a thought, and it's a minor one, at that. We've tried this before. In fact, a lot of players start with this method. It only becomes conflict when dealing with two specific types of players. The ones who are there to troll, and the ones who have a stronger build than yours. As a player who once had a character with a semi-strong PvP build, I can tell you from personal experience that even when you're not playing evil, when somebody mechanically weaker than you starts pushing you around, you start seeing red. It's a blood in the water effect, because you know that it's about to come to blows, and your blows are harder. I feel this is a mentality that most people using powerbuilt or PvP-centric builds are subject to. Why should I take shit from a character I could kill without effort? Why should I intentionally lose a fight that I could win without breaking a sweat? And while that makes sense IC in a lot of ways, it starts to become a problem when that mentality leads them to do things like violate bans (breaking server rules) or hang around areas they've previously committed genocide in and metagaming the NPC guards (breaking server rules) etc. bidocks wrote: As much as I hate PVP, if the problem pvp'ers constantly arrive to face a superior force of militia (either NPC or PC or a combo of both), they will stop. I've played on enough servers to have seen this occur.
There is truth in this, and this is why I like the idea of an elite militia force who's actually trained and equipped to deal with the stronger, more dangerous PCs on the island. That way, we aren't immediately shutting down evil characters' avenues of roleplay, but we have an IC response to violence and immediate danger as well as an IC deterrent for repeat offenders. You can know that you can get away with stuff a time or two, but eventually you're gonna run into those stronger guards and things are going to get tough for you.
_________________ Characters I play: Kira Cottonfoot - Hin Bardess Kirby Cottonfoot - Arcane Trickster
|
|
|
|
 |
|
Gobbledygook
|
Posted: Tue, Sep 03 2013, 19:43 PM |
|
|

Player
Joined: 18 Sep 2011
|
Zedrik wrote: They are told "no, you can't have your weapons out int he Dale, please" and they throw a fit, either by being overtly aggressive or trying to explain to us that there's nothing wrong with them having their weapons drawn. Or hoods/helmets... holy crap, you'd think we were asking people to undergo brutal castration. We're having issues with people, it's not unreasonable for us to want to see faces. Are they throwing a fit IC or OOC? If that is their IC response, it's perfectly ok! Makes for a big difference. Jandar, for example, who I play, throws a fit about this IC. It's not that I'm trying to cause problems OOC, it's just how the character is. It's not because it's an unreasonable request, it's just because IC, it's a request he'd refuse. Given the things which came from that during the resulting RP, now there's a bunch of people he'll kill in retaliation to the aggression started against him over the whole weapon issue. Keep in mind, that's how he views it IC. He's a barbarian who has his own values that he'll stick by, and in his mind, he's not going to let other people push him around. bidocks wrote: I see a major problem with people not respecting the militia's authority. I see Crow (the one human member) there a lot. He tries, but, he's just one person, and..... I've seen people completely disregard he is EVEN A MEMBER OF THE MILITIA! Anything he says is retorted with, "I'll talk to the Mayor." and he's instantly done... Now, I'm also a firm believer of "get what you give", and a recent addition to the militia, who isn't around much lately had a wonderful tact to his rule enforcement. It sounds like people are disrespecting Militia IC, from the way you've said this. If so, there isn't a problem with that, rather it's an issue which should ultimately be addressed IC. RuffTuff wrote: As a player who once had a character with a semi-strong PvP build, I can tell you from personal experience that even when you're not playing evil, when somebody mechanically weaker than you starts pushing you around, you start seeing red. It's a blood in the water effect, because you know that it's about to come to blows, and your blows are harder. I feel this is a mentality that most people using powerbuilt or PvP-centric builds are subject to. Why should I take shit from a character I could kill without effort? Why should I intentionally lose a fight that I could win without breaking a sweat? And while that makes sense IC in a lot of ways, it starts to become a problem when that mentality leads them to do things like violate bans (breaking server rules) or hang around areas they've previously committed genocide in and metagaming the NPC guards (breaking server rules) etc. I totally agree with you here, but's really important to make sure you can determine between the people who are metagaming guards and the people who are responding IC. Like you said, it does make sense for a character to take action if they're able to and willing to. In the end it comes down to a level of OOC respect that players really should have for each other. If that's missing, then it makes everything a hell of a lot harder to keep on track.
_________________ Just lurking about!
|
|
|
|
 |
|
LordSithaelon
|
Posted: Tue, Sep 03 2013, 20:04 PM |
|
|

Player
Joined: 17 Apr 2013 Location: Home
|
|
"In the end it comes down to a level of OOC respect that players really should have for each other. If that's missing, then it makes everything a hell of a lot harder to keep on track." - Gobble
Judging by several of the posts so far in this thread.... We are looking at a 6 engine freight at full speed, and the tracks are out ahead...
_________________ Years of Love are forgotten in the hatred of a minute - Edgar Allen Poe
|
|
|
|
 |
|
Kamina
|
Posted: Tue, Sep 03 2013, 20:21 PM |
|
|

DM
Joined: 05 Jul 2007 Location: Kent, England.
|
RuffTuff wrote: We've tried this before. In fact, a lot of players start with this method. It only becomes conflict when dealing with two specific types of players. The ones who are there to troll, and the ones who have a stronger build than yours. As a player who once had a character with a semi-strong PvP build, I can tell you from personal experience that even when you're not playing evil, when somebody mechanically weaker than you starts pushing you around, you start seeing red. It's a blood in the water effect, because you know that it's about to come to blows, and your blows are harder. I feel this is a mentality that most people using powerbuilt or PvP-centric builds are subject to. Why should I take shit from a character I could kill without effort? Why should I intentionally lose a fight that I could win without breaking a sweat? And while that makes sense IC in a lot of ways, it starts to become a problem when that mentality leads them to do things like violate bans (breaking server rules) or hang around areas they've previously committed genocide in and metagaming the NPC guards (breaking server rules) etc. Pretty much this entire issue in a tl;dr.
_________________  "Operating in the border between light and darkness, shadowdancers are nimble artists of deception. They are mysterious and unknown, never completely trusted but always inducing wonder when met"
|
|
|
|
 |
|
bidocks
|
Posted: Tue, Sep 03 2013, 20:58 PM |
|
|

Player
Joined: 25 Jul 2011
|
Quote: bidocks wrote: I see a major problem with people not respecting the militia's authority. I see Crow (the one human member) there a lot. He tries, but, he's just one person, and..... I've seen people completely disregard he is EVEN A MEMBER OF THE MILITIA! Anything he says is retorted with, "I'll talk to the Mayor." and he's instantly done... Now, I'm also a firm believer of "get what you give", and a recent addition to the militia, who isn't around much lately had a wonderful tact to his rule enforcement. It sounds like people are disrespecting Militia IC, from the way you've said this. If so, there isn't a problem with that, rather it's an issue which should ultimately be addressed IC. Yes, you're right, they don't respect the militia IC because OOC they know nothing will happen to them. That, in and of itself is metagaming. If I walked into a town and within 30 seconds, saw a militiaman with a bow out, and two armed guards at a well built gate, I would likely not shoot my mouth off as some do. However, if I know that those two armed guards are more like mannequins, well..... Disclaimer: my saying "I" in this case represents a person, perhaps someone of ill repute, not necessarily me, my characters or anyone in particular.
|
|
|
|
 |
|
Mr. Hackums
|
Posted: Tue, Sep 03 2013, 21:15 PM |
|
|

Player
Joined: 22 May 2008
|
Tomato Sword wrote: I really don't know how much more we can make it clear or you, Hackums. I, along with many others, have said this repeatedly, not just here, but in many other previous discussion and threads.
If you want us to spend hours upon hours doing something to help you, we really expect the same. We have been told so many times something will be done and nothing has. Until we actually see something is being done, I will be the first one to tell you it's highly unlikely we'll spend hours of our lives compiling screenshots just to be disappointed again. What do you suggest we do? Please don't take this as a snide comment, I'm genuinely curious of the solutions you want to see. Its not my intention to make it seem like a broken record. And please be patient with me, as this is-- by my memory-- the first time I've worked with you guys on this. I was certain I was bound to suggest something you guys have tried plenty of times! Forgive me for bringing something up that was made clear in the thread itself. Alright-- apology made, returning to original question: What can we do? Where, realistically, is the change going to start? As it stands now, the DM team is unable to firsthand catch metagamers and trolls with 100% accuracy, due to personnel constraints. And the players involved are too frustrated with previous inactivity to report it. If nothing is done, this gap will only widen, no? More trolls will go unreported, Dm's won't be banning what we aren't aware of, and more players will be more upset. Its a vicious circle. I don't want it to be a situation where its "We break, or you break." I want to cooperate to see the best solution we can. As DM's, this is what we can do. We can increase presences idling in Bendir Dale, to catch metagamers. We can select a regional DM to more closely manage the Dale. This, I believe, will help in a number of ways: One, we'll have a reliably active DM who is kept up to date with Bendir affairs at all times. Two, he/she will build further trust with Dale folk, so that any incidents can be reported with confidence to this DM, and it will be in both DM and player interest to do so. Three, this DM can begin building repetitive NPC activity with Dale citizens, militia, and PC's, to help foster controlled and fun PC-on-PC conflict. Think about this: Very rarely the trolls you encounter are actually trying to hurt you guys. More often than not, its just a matter of their activity upsetting you, because it feels pointless, repetitive, or the good/evil conflict they might be trying to stir just doesn't connect. So it feels more like a distraction than an interaction, right? Isn't that how most cases are? With an active DM overwatching Bendir Dale, this DM can help make conflict -mean- something. He can provide IC consequences to the bad guy's actions-- By either having NPC civilians endangered, or by even holding/capturing said villain. He can provide consequences to the Citizens and Militia's initiatives. He can make the Dale militia an active group of NPC's, so that they aren't treated like mannequins. We can also take firmer stances with metagamers/trolls once we receive the reports. And, lastly, we can make an announcement on the forums and In-game to help stave metagaming NPC's. I think the biggest impact will be having an active DM with you guys. And from the sounds of it, it won't help only you-- it'll help the server as a whole. Bendir Dale, after all, is where the magic's happening. Its silly that its NPC's are as inactive as they are, given its where almost all the players are. ~~~~ Thanks for your patience, and for your ideas. Your feedback is valuable to us, it really is. Remember that everyone on the staff is a player just like you, at heart. We've been playing this game together for years upon years, and it really does mean something to us. It wouldn't be a game without its players, and I personally get really.. sad when I start seeing Amians up at each others throat or feeling helpless.
|
|
|
|
 |
|
bidocks
|
Posted: Tue, Sep 03 2013, 21:23 PM |
|
|

Player
Joined: 25 Jul 2011
|
|
Great way to start I think, Mr. Hackums.
Last edited by bidocks on Wed, Sep 04 2013, 0:05 AM, edited 1 time in total.
|
|
|
|
 |
|
Kamina
|
Posted: Tue, Sep 03 2013, 21:27 PM |
|
|

DM
Joined: 05 Jul 2007 Location: Kent, England.
|
Mr. Hackums wrote: As DM's, this is what we can do. We can increase presences idling in Bendir Dale, to catch metagamers. We can select a regional DM to more closely manage the Dale. This, I believe, will help in a number of ways: One, we'll have a reliably active DM who is kept up to date with Bendir affairs at all times. Two, he/she will build further trust with Dale folk, so that any incidents can be reported with confidence to this DM, and it will be in both DM and player interest to do so. Three, this DM can begin building repetitive NPC activity with Dale citizens, militia, and PC's, to help foster controlled and fun PC-on-PC conflict. Think about this: Very rarely the trolls you encounter are actually trying to hurt you guys. More often than not, its just a matter of their activity upsetting you, because it feels pointless, repetitive, or the good/evil conflict they might be trying to stir just doesn't connect. So it feels more like a distraction than an interaction, right? Isn't that how most cases are? With an active DM overwatching Bendir Dale, this DM can help make conflict -mean- something. He can provide IC consequences to the bad guy's actions-- By either having NPC civilians endangered, or by even holding/capturing said villain. He can provide consequences to the Citizens and Militia's initiatives. He can make the Dale militia an active group of NPC's, so that they aren't treated like mannequins.
We can also take firmer stances with metagamers/trolls once we receive the reports. And, lastly, we can make an announcement on the forums and In-game to help stave metagaming NPC's.
I think the biggest impact will be having an active DM with you guys. And from the sounds of it, it won't help only you-- it'll help the server as a whole. Bendir Dale, after all, is where the magic's happening. Its silly that its NPC's are as inactive as they are, given its where almost all the players are. A new DM and an announcement would be dandy, imo. This entire situation won't disappear overnight, but having official support will help a lot!
_________________  "Operating in the border between light and darkness, shadowdancers are nimble artists of deception. They are mysterious and unknown, never completely trusted but always inducing wonder when met"
|
|
|
|
 |
|
CTX
|
Posted: Tue, Sep 03 2013, 21:30 PM |
|
|

Player
Joined: 28 Oct 2008 Location: Installation 00
|
Mr. Hackums wrote: I think the biggest impact will be having an active DM with you guys... And this will only work if that person is truly interested in the faction. Not interested in helping. Not interested in helping players or friends. Bendir Dale. Because honestly, from what has been suggested thus far isn't promising at all. And I don't want another repetition of "Player/DM gets appointed/promoted to Bendir Dale 'supervisor,' stays for the first few months, gets tangled and involved in other dealings with dm fr3nz, and drops the faction upon realizing it's much more fun to him/her to host events or help other hosted events."
_________________ Serena Voi: An adorable little Halfling. Brizthara D'ulov: A spoiled, loud-mouthed priestess.
|
|
|
|
 |
|
Mr. Hackums
|
Posted: Tue, Sep 03 2013, 21:35 PM |
|
|

Player
Joined: 22 May 2008
|
|
Its definitely not something that will disappear overnight! But I'd rather we work to earn the players' confidence, rather than asking for it and getting upset when its not delivered, you know?
Let this be the first step. After this gets going, maybe we can help work on a better system for making metagaming reports, or develop alternative strategies to stop metagaming when a DM isn't there. ~~~~
Also, I agree wholeheartedly, CTX. I think what we'll do is ask for a volunteer from our staff. So its not a matter of putting someone there who doesn't hop on excited to be there, you know? I myself am excited about the Dale, and would love to see it flourish-- but I hold no illusion about how unreliable I am as a DM running a plot. But I'm pretty sure we could set someone up who would love to be working with the Dale. Honestly, it'd be a great opportunity for any DM. The Dale is so damn popular! As a DM, it'd be a great chance to get to put on regular mini-events for a wide variety of players. And help develop an already lore enriched settlement. I mean-- who doesn't love the Shire?
|
|
|
|
 |
|
Gobbledygook
|
Posted: Tue, Sep 03 2013, 21:47 PM |
|
|

Player
Joined: 18 Sep 2011
|
Thanks Hackums, this is a great start. Optimistic for what this brings. 
_________________ Just lurking about!
|
|
|
|
 |
Who is online |
Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 3 guests |
|
You cannot post new topics in this forum You cannot reply to topics in this forum You cannot edit your posts in this forum You cannot delete your posts in this forum
|
|