TormakSaber wrote:
Two wrongs don't make a right. If you get hit, don't HIPS. don't drag it into a "you need to give to me before you recieve" because both sides will do it all the time and no one gets anywhere. Start by doing it yourself first.
Besides, you are a PvP vet, Mr. Jyro. You know the odds of getting said roll off in combat or any hostile situation are about zero. Take what you get, and dont get hit, or if you do, learn to cornersneak, because there are non SD cornersneaks out there that do their job better than an SD, and if they're lit?
They can still hide. And so can you, if you learn the lost, forbidden art of Cornersneak.
I'm not trying to insinuate doing anything wrong. And by all means, in the middle of battle, if you get hit with Light and the mage was set to hostile before casting it, fair game without a roll. You were given opportunity to avoid it and warning of the mage being hostile.
I'm talking about in RP situations where you're just sitting there talking to someone and someone all of a sudden comes up and goes "*casts Light on you*" and then goes "Ha! Now you can't get away!", that's borderline god-gaming without giving the SD a chance to avoid the TOUCH ATTACK, when there was no hostile flags up or anything. In level of severity to a shadow dancer, I would count that as the same thing as someone coming up to you as neutral and just dev-critting you without even so much as a spell-cast or hostile flag warning.
In a situation where you're not in active combat, I see no reason why you can't cast the spell, roll your touch attack roll and then roll with the punches from that point on (assuming the SD you're RP'g with is responsible and mature enough to honor the terms and conditions).