This topic is for people's opinions on the title, and how they play it themselves. my character has fallen twice to other player's chars by dev crit. Now ive seen many people play their character as just unconscious after a dev crit, even seen some of the dev critters say to do that.. but to me, that goes against the description of the feat. Both times I've played a few days recovery time after getting resurrected.. I'd like to hear other peoples thoughts
_________________ If a man who cannot count finds a four-leaf clover, is he lucky?
havent been killed by it due to getting bored with chars around 20 and not much pvp...but i would play it as they just that the person who dev crited you landed a extremely unbelievably uberly hit e.g cutting you in half (horizontally or maybe vertically), if unarmed just ripped your heart out or did that crazy move from kill bill. or basically just like any other death except that they got passed your defence and killed you with one perfectly executed slash/move/throw/shot.
Generally, I just emote something nonchalant. (If that's the right word.) *Prepared for an epic duel that will shake the planes, the warrior storms into the fray. Fortunately for the planes, it's just the apple basket nearby that shakes as his severed head tumbles into it before his body has fully realized the loss* or something.
There are few things in PvP that offer as much ironic value as being Dev.Critted the first round of combat. Don't let it go to waste!
_________________
On Joon, Kjetta wrote:
The guy that probably has sexual fantasies about masturbation. I mean, Iron, you're a bookworm nerd that even in your wildest escapism fantasies flee to the internet to play the role of another bookworm nerd? Come on!
This topic is for people's opinions on the title, and how they play it themselves. my character has fallen twice to other player's chars by dev crit. Now ive seen many people play their character as just unconscious after a dev crit, even seen some of the dev critters say to do that.. but to me, that goes against the description of the feat. Both times I've played a few days recovery time after getting resurrected.. I'd like to hear other peoples thoughts
My default mental image of a devastating critical hit is that the character was decapitated or cut in half, or something instantly lethal along those lines. It seems to me though that it's up to however the person who struck the blow decides to portray it.
I would agre that this is in the realm of the swinger of how grievous they are. Dev Crit from a throwing axe? He cleaved your brain in twain. Dev Crit from a dart? He penetrated your eyeball and impacted your brain. Dev Crit from a dagger? Throatslit! Dev Crit from a Rapier? He pulled a Tybalt on you!
_________________
Man, this account is over 10 years old. Where do I get my old man beard?
I would agre that this is in the realm of the swinger of how grievous they are. Dev Crit from a throwing axe? He cleaved your brain in twain. Dev Crit from a dart? He penetrated your eyeball and impacted your brain. Dev Crit from a dagger? Throatslit! Dev Crit from a Rapier? He pulled a Tybalt on you!
I'd agree with this. It really does seem like the weapon of the critter would determine how you would react or emote to it. For instance if they dev critted you with a club...maybe they smashed your head like a fruit in one shot.
I always thought it was funny to be with a hunting group and rp dev critting the fire giants by slicing at their legs like tree trunks until they were my height with nothing but their severed torso upright on the ground. ^^;
Yep, pretty much what everyone else has already said. If one of my characters gets dev crit'd then I take it as some sort of insanely powerful instant kill blow gets landed. The kind of blow is completely dependent on the type of weapon the dev crit'er is using. A two-handed sword will likely cut some part of you off or cut you in twain. I'm working a dev crit'ing character right now that will be using a whip. My personal question is this:
What kind of uber-powerful blow that instantly kills can be performed by a whip?
I've been thinking about it and can't seem to come up with anything, so I turn to you... yes, you... reading this right now. You know who you are! I need some help coming up with some ideas!
_________________
"I once took the high road and it took me straight to hell and I stood there all by myself." -Hank III
Get a lot of Fort gear, so you have at least 40, also pack a lot of AC so they can't hit you (Being a cleric/BG/rogue helps with this)
Laugh as they crit you, on a luck shot, and you shrug it off, only to chop their head off slowly.
(I do believe I emoted *The wound struck deep, nearly cleaving her in half, but alas, it seems you have run into a monster, as she pulls the blade deeper, laughing like a maniac, as she cuts you down when you were certain your victory was assured* Insert either Rot Maggot, Worthless, then proceed to cast greater restoration to heal the wound.)
Pure Wizard Tactics:
in 5 feet of weaponmaster dev critter range
Run or Time Stop. Emote *Screams* Ahhhh!!!!, come back later, emote *Boom* and blow em up
_________________ I sleep with the Libris Mortis under my pillow.
---Carstina Blackweave--- Speaker of Tarkuul Headmistress of the Magisterium Mortis
Run or Time Stop. Emote *Screams* Ahhhh!!!!, come back later, emote *Boom* and blow em up
Ah yes, the Rincewind tactic. It keeps you alive and away from death and there is no shame.
_________________ "Most assume that all the followers of Lathander are great morning people. They're very wrong." "I think we are the only group where AD&D stands for Attention Deficit Disorder."
What kind of uber-powerful blow that instantly kills can be performed by a whip?
I've been thinking about it and can't seem to come up with anything, so I turn to you... yes, you... reading this right now. You know who you are! I need some help coming up with some ideas!
I was talking about this exact same thing with my room mate last night because he too wants to make a whip dev critter. His character in concept will be using a chain and we were talking about what would happen if he used, for instance, a sharpened chain. Could he not also emote that he just sliced a limb off with a single flick of his wrist?
I view dev-crits as 'turning out the lights'. Instant kills.
Cutting people in half with big weapons, heads comming off.
The smaller ones are more hitting 'important places' .. like brainstem, brain, etc.
_________________ Dwagin [Duh-wa-GIN] N. - 1a. Small and cute thingum, particularly fond of four legged scaled creatures of the metalic and chromatic varieties.
In a party in the frozen wastes once, someone dev-critted a pixie-thinger. I laughed and asked what that would be, such a precise strike on something so small. He laughed and replied he figured it was like swatting the pixie out of the air with the flat of the blade on a full swing.
funny story, but the bottom line is that it can be whatever you want. but i always picture it as killing, not knocking them out.
_________________ "Earnest Hemingway once wrote, 'The world is a fine place, and worth fighting for.' I agree with the second part."
Joined: 10 Aug 2005 Location: Ottawa, Ontario, Canada
If it's pvp, there's no reason it can't be a K.O.
Could be flat of the blade/pummel/crossguard/hilt slammed their temple so hard it dropped them instantly, only to awaken some hours later with a headache the likes of which only a human trying to outdrink a dwarf might suffer.
Or if the critted person happens to be someone who accepts that they're character might have a weakness, perhaps they'ev just learned it's a glass jaw.
It only has to mean death if you want it to mean death.
Whip could also be "crushed their windpipe", but there's not a lot else I can think of. Again, hit to the temple if it's to be a knockout blow, works. And if yer fighting a fey, swatting it from the sky works too, even with a whip, I'd suppose.
_________________ Role with the Punches...
Elan: A 10% chance is pretty unlikely, but everyone knows that a one-in-a-million chance is a sure thing!
Joined: 20 Apr 2008 Location: The downeaster "Alexa"
I agree with most of it. The devver usually is left to decide what happens to the unfortunate devvee.
That's why I -love- my monk with dev crit. Ripping off heads, chopping people in half, tearing people in twain at the middle....ah...good old Devver RP. Of course, I usually ask before I do such things, and if people really have a problem with it, I just say he decked them with a punch to the face.
Edit:
Just would like to add, that Dev crits aren't the -only- justification for devastating carnage. If you're a Greataxe WM without dev and score a 150 or so crit to kill something, I think that's plenty liscense to say you cut he/she/it in half.
Joined: 17 Aug 2005 Location: Land of the Scorching Sun, Empowered by Global Warming
When I am sparring and deal a Dev Crit, I never say I killed the PC, only that I tried to KD him or her and miscalculated the force of the blow, making them unconscious.
If I am the one hit with a Dev Crit, I tend to ask (if the other player didn't emote) if it was death or KD, and to describe what exactly was done.
_________________ BlackDahlya
Once Upon A Time Played Adr'ael Ken'rahel, Auron Teken’ath, Aurora Mesodias, 'Daniel' Daoskinaxarijikkym, Eilin'ira, Helena Rios, Layla Faircurrent, May'Une Do'Ndar, Mellinda Tellus, Michael of Cliffside, Rizzen of Twilight, Valkirya d'Claddath
Joined: 06 Jan 2008 Location: ANU, behind the coffee mug (+10 GMT)
Well, I'd imagine it's an impossibly good shot ....
*She channels her Ki through her bastard sword and slice you in twain, blade splitting through plate and mail like a hot knife through butter*
That'd be for a WM or a monk, though, since both use Ki. Anyone else, guess it could be a good shot e.g. Dev-crit dagger: straight in the eye.
_________________ 2009's Second Most Overall Contributing Player
Dev-Crit isn't an ability that's based on skill, grace, or precision. Those are sneak attacks. Devastating Critical requires 25 natural strength - meaning, basically, that you must have the raw power to pull it off.
Anyone can kill something in one hit. A level 1 fighter can kill another in a single, non-critical hit with a longsword. A Devastating Critical is just that: Devastating. This is how I imagine it, at least.
When I imagine Reese landing a Dev-Crit, I get this picture in my mind of him slamming his bastard sword hilt-deep into something, then tearing it free of its torso from the side; splitting it in half from head to toe, striking it with such force that adamantine armor doesn't even flex as its shorn.
The fact that so much Strength is necessary for the feat brings me to the belief that it isn't a "precise strike" or a "well-aimed blow". It's just hitting something with so much force, you outright kill it.
The fact that so much Strength is necessary for the feat brings me to the belief that it isn't a "precise strike" or a "well-aimed blow". It's just hitting something with so much force, you outright kill it.
Aye or else Dex based characters would be able to pull it off and be better at it!
I envision it as a blow so strong that even if the armor stops the blade the body will still be left decimated just by shear force of impact.
Joined: 12 Oct 2005 Location: On a Disk, carried by four elephants, which stand on a gigantic turtle.
As a War Knight, I dealt with death by Dev Crit a LOT. The way my WM explained it was that it became a concentrated movement of force and speed that simply slipped past his defenses with stunning skill, and if he failed the fort check, hit a vital point on his body.
Basically the attack was so overwealmingly devestating, that the strength of the blow knocked back all his defense, broke through his armor, skin, flesh and bones, to hit a vital spot on his body, such as the heart, throat or head.
This is why it required so much skill to accomplish and learn, as hitting those points is almost impossible, being that they are usually the most well protected on any creatures body.
_________________ I keels u with my axe!
"Do ye know where the Holy-Flamin' Frost-brand Gronk-slayin' Vorpal Hammer o' woundin' an' returnin' an' Shootin'-Lightnin'-out-yer-bum is?"
Just would like to add, that Dev crits aren't the -only- justification for devastating carnage. If you're a Greataxe WM without dev and score a 150 or so crit to kill something, I think that's plenty liscense to say you cut he/she/it in half.
I keep forgetting Monks when I rant about Devcrits under 100. I don't mind them, since I think of them as neck snaps, armlocks and so on. Those things(I can confirm first hand), in terms of damage do nothing... nothing... nothing... uncomfortable.. ZOMGmyarm'sgonnabreak over the course of about half an inch.
And the threat range is crud. Let's face it, I plainly mean the scimmy/rapier goobers.
Anyway, my 10-STR Ftr/WM/Rogue breaks 150 pretty often (and in Bard/Mage parties going across the fire/frost divide can break 200) with a teensy little handaxe. I RP that as a dainty hatchet strike to the back of the neck or in the case of the ASB, underneath that big frill thing it has.
I always thought it was funny to be with a hunting group and rp dev critting the fire giants by slicing at their legs like tree trunks until they were my height with nothing but their severed torso upright on the ground. ^^;
My old dawrf Keverin had a song for such occasions and it went something like this:
Bust the knee then the skull Down they go one by one Run giant run We're gonna have some fun
Cheers
_________________ The biologist wants to be a chemist.
The chemist wants to be a physicist.
The physicist wants to be God.
God wants to be a mathematician.
A big bludgeoning weapon shatters brains into little bits, a rapier or something as tasteless kills some life-important organ, an arrow gets shot between the eyes, a huge slashing weapon usually cleaves the target apart and a throwing weapon does something incredibly awesome!
That's just how I usually play it. You're allowed to go epic with Devastating Critical, use your imagination.
Don't get me started on toothpick critting weapons!
The fish model for the clubs I add.
Death by fish!
"I am allerlgic to it."
"..."
_________________ "Most assume that all the followers of Lathander are great morning people. They're very wrong." "I think we are the only group where AD&D stands for Attention Deficit Disorder."
A big bludgeoning weapon shatters brains into little bits, a rapier or something as tasteless kills some life-important organ, an arrow gets shot between the eyes, a huge slashing weapon usually cleaves the target apart and a throwing weapon does something incredibly awesome!
That's just how I usually play it. You're allowed to go epic with Devastating Critical, use your imagination.
Joined: 20 Apr 2008 Location: The downeaster "Alexa"
Uberuce wrote:
Dark Immolation wrote:
That's why I -love- my monk with dev crit. ...
Just would like to add, that Dev crits aren't the -only- justification for devastating carnage. If you're a Greataxe WM without dev and score a 150 or so crit to kill something, I think that's plenty liscense to say you cut he/she/it in half.
I keep forgetting Monks when I rant about Devcrits under 100. I don't mind them, since I think of them as neck snaps, armlocks and so on. Those things(I can confirm first hand), in terms of damage do nothing... nothing... nothing... uncomfortable.. ZOMGmyarm'sgonnabreak over the course of about half an inch.
And the threat range is crud. Let's face it, I plainly mean the scimmy/rapier goobers.
Anyway, my 10-STR Ftr/WM/Rogue breaks 150 pretty often (and in Bard/Mage parties going across the fire/frost divide can break 200) with a teensy little handaxe. I RP that as a dainty hatchet strike to the back of the neck or in the case of the ASB, underneath that big frill thing it has.
I'd just like to add my dev-monk breaks 100 crits quite often....not that he devs that often though. They're usually dead from sheer damage before I land a crit
It's all about knowing how and what to have, but this isnt a build topic. Dev Crit represents just a sheer damaging force blow that nomatter -how- strong or hefty you are, there's no way to withshand it. -Some- people can survive being run through with a sword, as in a normal longsword critical. Not many, as in 99.99999%, of PCs can withstand being sliced down the symetry line. Doesn't matter you're a lv 30 Barbarian. You're now two halves of a lv 30 Barbarian. Simple as that.
That's why I always rp my devs, especially with my dev-monk, as devastating when possible. Not armlocks. Not neck snaps. Some people in real life actually survive those and worse. His devs mean -dev-a-state-ing- death, as in you've got pieces to pick up and take home when he's done. There's a reason his martial art sytle calls its masters "Enders".
Yarp, my Dev Monk was in the same boat, assuming he had his Greater Pain or Master Gloves on. That was more "Woo, I bagged another 100" not "Only 99? Am I missing STR gear or something?"
Joined: 30 Aug 2008 Location: Some planet known as Earth
Ohh *switches setting*
Ok I'll point out the true conversation this topic is driving at...its the rule that the attacker gets to decide how hard they hit you vs the IC RP aspect of Dev Crit and what it actually does to your character.
In My Opinion It should be:
I get killed by a dev crit, sry I'm not just 'knocked down' it's OMG I got OWNED, insta-death. Pack a raise scroll and some greater restores I'll need em'.
---
If the dm's rule other-wise then *shrug* but I'll think it's lametastic.
Example:
*person gets dev crit slain in one hit*
//Oh your not dead I knocked you down, ignore the dev crit
//What? You do know what dev crit 'is' right?
//Yea but ooc rule says that I get to decide if your dead or not, or how many pieces your in.
...*blank stare*
--
I view Dev Crit as IC, not ooc, 'How did I just die in one hit if it wasn't actually an IC dev crit?'
*cheers for RP realism over ooc rules once again*
_________________
Lalelilolu wrote:
*Po-tee-weet?*
Night is just another day without light.
Last edited by Azrael on Fri, May 08 2009, 4:01 AM, edited 1 time in total.
If I'm RPing dev crit as not being lethal, it means I just got lucky and knocked you unconscious with one blow. I usually RP it as being Jud using his sword's flat or reverse edge to do damage, not the cutting edge.
If I'm RPing it as lethal, he was using the cutting edge, and probably split you from a clavicle to the opposite hip, taking out both lungs, the heart, and the liver in the process >>
_________________ Named Most Influential Character, Amia Awards 2011
Last edited by Gers on Fri, May 08 2009, 4:03 AM, edited 1 time in total.
It's up to you, methinks. The more effort you put into RPing death, the better, of course. Not everyone RP's it at all, unfortunately.
Doesn't say something about being a rule or some such, nor is it headed toward becoming a rule. Just a post about how creative people RP being devved or doing the dev themselves.
Imo given the PvP system in Amia, dev crit doesn't necessarily have to be a *killing* blow, but may also be simply a devastatingly debilitating blow.
Joined: 30 Aug 2008 Location: Some planet known as Earth
Magnum Opera wrote:
Nekhy wrote:
It's up to you, methinks. The more effort you put into RPing death, the better, of course. Not everyone RP's it at all, unfortunately.
Doesn't say something about being a rule or some such, nor is it headed toward becoming a rule. Just a post about how creative people RP being devved or doing the dev themselves.
Imo given the PvP system in Amia, dev crit doesn't necessarily have to be a *killing* blow, but may also be simply a devastatingly debilitating blow.
With that said, exploding heads are fun.
Actually it is a rule.
"The PvP settings determine what happens when you 'kill' somebody in a fight. The setting of the killer is the one that matters, and the victim (m/f) does NOT determine the outcome of the fight, neither ICly or OOCly."
The attacker decides what happens to you, in all cases, as the system is currently. It let's said person OOCly choose what happens to the people they kill ICly.
"If you are killed in PvP you will see a respawn dialog informing you about your status and respawn options:
Subdue: You are unconscious. You can respawn in 5 minutes at your current position.
Duel: You are dead. You can respawn in 5 minutes at your current position."
--
I'll just point out I like the system...I just think that Dev Crit should be an expection because of it's RP aspects. ie: guts flying everywhere.
--
I see it as a RP ability/feat. Taking the good with the bad.
Instead of:
//oh I didn't want to 'kill' you, rp your knocked out.
It's:
"Oh I didn't mean to kill him, I just hit him/her really hard and they were too fragile against my might."
(Skipped medical school and trained in hitting people very hard, not so much in weaker attacks that are not killing the target)
"Prerequisite: strength 25+, cleave, great cleave, improved critical (weapon to be chosen), overwhelming critical (weapon to be chosen), power attack"
Well I know about the subdue/duel/etc system. What I'm trying to point out is that dev-crit doesn't have to be a *killing* blow - there's no rule that it only be so. It CAN be RPed simply as a devastatingly *debilitating* blow, (subdual mode), one that instantly forces your enemy to stop in his tracks.
In short, it's not named Death/Severing/Beheading/Anything specific Crit for a reason.
Edit: Note that I'm referring more on the direction of this thread. I'd suppose you derived your assumption that this thread is about the PvP system due to that most posts here just happen to refer to how the dev-critter RPs his dev-crit. Still, it doesn't mean the dev-critee cannot RP his own demise.
Joined: 30 Aug 2008 Location: Some planet known as Earth
It's named Devistating...even worse.
Quote:
devastation –noun 1. the act of devastating; destruction. 2. devastated state; desolation.
devastate –verb (used with object), -tated, -tating. 1. to lay waste; render desolate: The invaders devastated the city. 2. to overwhelm.
Main Entry: dev·as·tate Listen to the pronunciation of devastate Pronunciation: \ˈde-və-ˌstāt\ Function: transitive verb Inflected Form(s): dev·as·tat·ed; dev·as·tat·ing Etymology: Latin devastatus, past participle of devastare, from de- + vastare to lay waste — more at waste Date: 1638
1 : to bring to ruin or desolation by violent action <a>
desolation - empty: bare, uninhabited, and deserted - alone: solitary, joyless, and without hope - grim: dismal and gloomy - devastate place: to make a place barren or deserted
Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 26 guests
You cannot post new topics in this forum You cannot reply to topics in this forum You cannot edit your posts in this forum You cannot delete your posts in this forum