|
|
|
Nekhy
|
Posted: Tue, Feb 24 2009, 22:05 PM |
|
|

Player
|
|
There's not a lot of rules you get punished for when you break them for the first time, written or not.
The ones you do get punished for the first time you break them are explicitly explained in the rules, as well as regularly posted as reminders.
Yossi likes people who break those rules.
|
|
|
|
 |
|
Evil-Wizard
|
Posted: Wed, Feb 25 2009, 5:58 AM |
|
|

Player
Joined: 28 Jan 2009
|
Nourm wrote: The only real danger arising from unwritten rules is the possibility of bad DM judgement.
... and annoying other players, who (somewhat rightfully) complain about others breaking the (unwritten) rules.
|
|
|
|
 |
|
TormakSaber
|
Posted: Wed, Feb 25 2009, 7:21 AM |
|
|

Player
Joined: 16 Dec 2004 Location: Somewhere
|
|
Less parentheses, more straight to the point. What are you saying?
_________________ Davion Telemos - Monk of the Four Winds Korthan Isharnos - Dragon Shaman of Thunder Spirit Zamasham
|
|
|
|
 |
|
HellScourge
|
Posted: Wed, Feb 25 2009, 8:41 AM |
|
|

Player
Joined: 17 Jan 2007 Location: GMT+1
|
|
We should've written that rule down so he wouldn't have been scolded would be my guess?
But honestly, so you broke a rule and got scolded, so what? It happened to with my Drow, I started playing after half a year and went into Cordor, back then was it allowed, but a new rule said otherwise. Fortunately a player said that and I quickly left Cordor again, no harm done, nothing bad happened. Fin.
_________________ "Most assume that all the followers of Lathander are great morning people. They're very wrong." "I think we are the only group where AD&D stands for Attention Deficit Disorder." TeroSNS wrote: Hello Everyone [...] I like tentacles [...] 
|
|
|
|
 |
|
Evil-Wizard
|
Posted: Wed, Feb 25 2009, 9:00 AM |
|
|

Player
Joined: 28 Jan 2009
|
TormakSaber wrote: Less parentheses, more straight to the point. What are you saying?
o.O Isn't it obvious?
Player A sneaks into a town. Player B notices, is annoyed, complains to a DM, the DM tells the player not to do that anymore.
Player B is still annoyed because those stupid noobies who don't even belong on a rp server... yack, yack, yack, see the posts in this thread.
Player A is even more annoyed, because he feels treated unfairly, and maybe starts a complaining thread in the forum.
Players B, C and D start complaining about the complaining, telling him to suck it up, leave or whatever.
Player E mentions it might be wise to make the rule public to prevent other incidents.
Player E gets shouted down for being an asshole who wants to change everything, until some people realize that he's just trying to help somebody out, they *gasp* had similar problems like the TE when they started playing on Amia and agree with player E, but because it's just too much trouble to copy and paste a whole sentence with parentheses and all this fancy stuff into the html code, the proposal is rejected anyhow.
Player H confuses players A and E, and furthermore believes that E is complaining about some DM action against him.
Player E vents his renewed disappointment about human nature with a deep sigh, rolls his eyes and asks himself if he'll still be around to do the "I told you so." routine when the time eventually comes.
Or in short:
It's just plain inefficient to let people break the rules first, and only then tell them what they did wrong. Imagine the reasoning behind the "we keep rules secret" rule applied to any other aspect of social life.
And finally...
*sigh*
*roll eyes*
*waves the thread goodbye*
|
|
|
|
 |
|
Nekhy
|
Posted: Wed, Feb 25 2009, 9:09 AM |
|
|

Player
|
|
It's efficient and works exactly as intended, but may differ from your expectations, that much is true. Consider that. Our goals simply are not what your goals would be in this matter.
|
|
|
|
 |
|
Eighty-One
|
Posted: Wed, Feb 25 2009, 12:10 PM |
|
|

Player
Joined: 18 Jan 2009 Location: Bangalore, India
|
Evil-Wizard wrote: o.O Isn't it obvious? Now really, it's things exactly like this one should definitely avoid when proposing a change, addition or something similar. It instantly lowers your standing in the eyes of others, and makes them less willing to listen or accept what you might have to say. Evil-Wizard wrote: Player A sneaks into a town. Player B notices, is annoyed, complains to a DM, the DM tells the player not to do that anymore.
Player B is still annoyed because those stupid noobies who don't even belong on a rp server... yack, yack, yack, see the posts in this thread.
No where in this thread has there been any mention that newbies should know every intricacy of the game the moment they join; they are expected to make mistakes, which are perfectly understandable.
It has also been said that making an innocent mistake out of ignorance once will never result in anything harsh, usually just a reminder that such is an established rule, and to please mind it.
There have been also been several posts detailing players that have learned from their mistakes which were pointed out to them by other players or DMs. These guys didn't throw a hissy fit at not having everything put up in bold and black and, as Cori said in his last post, simply took it in stride.
As Nekh said, the system seems to work perfectly for most of the player base.
_________________ ~ Alexandria Do'Maetri, Champion of Tyr
~ Glam Snowfell, of mysticism and magery
|
|
|
|
 |
|
Dev Disco
|
Posted: Wed, Feb 25 2009, 12:43 PM |
|
|

HRM Chicken I of Amia
Joined: 02 Jun 2005 Location: Amsterdam
|
Quote: Player A sneaks into a town.
I guess this is the point where your argumentation fails. You don't sneak into town out of ignorance, you sneak into town to evade the guards. Why are the guards at the gates stopping you? Because you are not welcome. So, what will about anyone in the town do when they spot you? Tada.
I mean: that's what I call 'obvious'.
_________________ Say 'no' to JSBF!
|
|
|
|
 |
|
hendrack
|
Posted: Wed, Feb 25 2009, 13:14 PM |
|
|

Player
Joined: 24 Sep 2007 Location: Vienna
|
Dev Disco wrote: Quote: Player A sneaks into a town. I guess this is the point where your argumentation fails. You don't sneak into town out of ignorance, you sneak into town to evade the guards. Why are the guards at the gates stopping you? Because you are not welcome. So, what will about anyone in the town do when they spot you? Tada. I mean: that's what I call 'obvious'.
This is why the invisiblity/sneak/GS argument fails too. Even if you get past the guards, you sit in your invisibility/sneak/GS and can do nothing but stand around, interact with nobody or you will get detected.
|
|
|
|
 |
|
Dev Disco
|
Posted: Wed, Feb 25 2009, 13:22 PM |
|
|

HRM Chicken I of Amia
Joined: 02 Jun 2005 Location: Amsterdam
|
|
Von Indeedstein zum Correcthoven.
_________________ Say 'no' to JSBF!
|
|
|
|
 |
|
Uberuce
|
Posted: Wed, Feb 25 2009, 13:34 PM |
|
|

Player
Joined: 11 Nov 2005 Location: Near the bar.
|
Evil-Wizard wrote: Or in short:
It's just plain inefficient to let people break the rules first, and only then tell them what they did wrong. Imagine the reasoning behind the "we keep rules secret" rule applied to any other aspect of social life.
People keep the rules secret from themselves, by simply not reading them until after they've been picked up for breaking them. Your argument is valid only if someone comes to Amia, reads the website and rules as recommended before going past the door. As a percentage, I'd say the number of times that happens is about one. Possibly a half.
The percentage of people that see rules as things to find loopholes in, or as sticks to beat the newbies with(your player B) is a good bit higher, methinkles. The more vague the rules are, the less this can happen.
|
|
|
|
 |
|
Brown Blur
|
Posted: Wed, Feb 25 2009, 14:03 PM |
|
|

Player
Joined: 27 Oct 2007 Location: Anywhere but Amia.
|
Uberuce wrote: People keep the rules secret from themselves, by simply not reading them until after they've been picked up for breaking them. Your argument is valid only if someone comes to Amia, reads the website and rules as recommended before going past the door. As a percentage, I'd say the number of times that happens is about one. Possibly a half.
The percentage of people that see rules as things to find loopholes in, or as sticks to beat the newbies with(your player B) is a good bit higher, methinkles. The more vague the rules are, the less this can happen.
Exactly.
The ones who seem to most thoroughly read the rules are those that bizarrely view it as 'time well spent' to come here and break them. As far as I can put myself into that mindset though, I can see how its a draw for those that get a buzz out of 'being naughty'.
_________________ "Never ascribe to malice, that which can be explained by incompetence" ~ Napoleon Bonaparte. - Clearly, Napoleon never envisioned the Internet......where I'd judge it about 50/50.
|
|
|
|
 |
|
Azrael
|
Posted: Fri, Feb 27 2009, 6:30 AM |
|
|

Player
Joined: 30 Aug 2008 Location: Some planet known as Earth
|
hendrack wrote: Dev Disco wrote: Quote: Player A sneaks into a town. I guess this is the point where your argumentation fails. You don't sneak into town out of ignorance, you sneak into town to evade the guards. Why are the guards at the gates stopping you? Because you are not welcome. So, what will about anyone in the town do when they spot you? Tada. I mean: that's what I call 'obvious'. This is why the invisiblity/sneak/GS argument fails too. Even if you get past the guards, you sit in your invisibility/sneak/GS and can do nothing but stand around, interact with nobody or you will get detected.
Naw not really there's clearly a hole left that if they do nothing but explore the supposedly only IC restricted areas just to see what is there, then that is fine because no one notices them... and I do love to explore
------------
(don't use the every single guard in every single town has dragonsight on 24/7 argument, it's ooc)... the dragon pet/umberhulk argument works though. IE major start locations like Cordor.
Now then I agree with what is in place because I know 'why' it is in place, but really this one clarification when/if added in the rules 'Is' pretty black and white, "if invading/sneaking into a town that has a racial restriction (or for whatever other reason your character is disallowed), then alert DM to watch incase NPC's need to react to said presence.
...and hope they don't:
A. have dragonsight
B. randomly cast a see invis/trueseeing if your invisible (without a listen check or something at least)
C. If they do see you then hope it's not automatically game over with a super-epic spawn, I.E epic boss level ectect. (beyond the amian player max of 30)
Now then after I feel the frustrations building, Evil Wizard had a point even if he didn't 'ask nicly'. Copy paste on rule clarification is easy but if it is not to be done then simply expect not to punish people for first time offenses (yes that is already generally the practice, to let the first one slide),but if in the future this issue was ever attempted at being resolved there 'is' a way to do it and that is by copy pasting this little clarification not to 'metagame' the guards by not asking a DM before initiating sneaking/raiding roleplay.
It's not that hard to do and it's a choice whether or not to do it. A choice that is not mine to make I am simply saying Expect future issues and problems with violators of this 'invisible obvious rule' if nothing is changed.
---counter points I see coming---
What obvious to us may not be obvious to a noob.
Can't say we don't have an issue or this topic wouldn't exist in it's current four page glory.
The time argument? ...this is 4 pages, one copy paste defeats that argument.
The "If we do this to this one rule we have to start on the avalanche of small additions to rules" argument...no you don't, this is one specific point and one we constantly have issues with it, and one that can be greatly helped, very easily.
The 10 NPC's equals 1 NPC ... speaking of metagamming *cough* Well let's see I saw 3-4 guards on cordor's main entrance ...30-40 on one small gate, humm or are we metagamming the gate being ten times it's size too... well this one doesn't hold too much water when a dm can easily spawn 10 guards in the middle of the city coming from district/guard tower. Lag issue? ...I'll take a little lag for decent rp over a automatic game over because one guard is ten times as strong as one PC on the count of his ooc 'representation'. Spawn the ten plz I'll even wait for them, ever hear of wail of banshee with an epic focus? ten guards down easy but not if it's a super powered epic boss level npc (which I would expect cordor has maby two of? the captain of the guards and his assistant?) The rest of them should be within 20-30 at their strongest, with a few weaker ones as well (see my previous post about matching the amian playerbase) That being said when the alarm is raised in a city I expect waves of guards to take down someone 'and' if it's a serious enough issue then the guard captain as well. (the super-epic). But not for those wandering about uninvited because of their race or as a common thief.
----
Evil Wizard isn't so evil perhaps he wasn't as nice as he could be ok...perhaps some of the replys back to him weren't either, two wrongs don't make a right, and blunt rudeness after a nice constructed post is just not acceptable behavior for a human being who took the time to write something out that they cared about. (not saying all of his were perfect but he did have some points not so easily overlooked.)
It's like making a work of art and having it be smashed to bits by the first person to walk by, that's what it is an equivalent to in my opinion.
...for those who did read this thanks for your time happily make logical counter points/statements.
-----
p.s. For those who didn't bother to read this, don't bother replying to this either, wouldn't want to waste your time, or mine.
_________________ Lalelilolu wrote: *Po-tee-weet?* Night is just another day without light.
|
|
|
|
 |
Who is online |
Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 7 guests |
|
You cannot post new topics in this forum You cannot reply to topics in this forum You cannot edit your posts in this forum You cannot delete your posts in this forum
|
|