| AMIA ARCHIVE https://www.amiaworld.net/phpBB3/ |
|
| The bad Samaritan https://www.amiaworld.net/phpBB3/viewtopic.php?f=2&t=54806 |
Page 1 of 1 |
| Author: | My Sovereign [ Wed, Jan 19 2011, 16:45 PM ] |
| Post subject: | The bad Samaritan |
We have all been there, your suffering from some kind of wound, and a random passerby castes a healing spell or approaches you and bandages your wounds. What if you hate healing? Whats stopping you from walking up to a perfectly healthy person and casting harm or inflict wounds? I foresee this as being an odd double standard where its ok to heal someone without asking, but if you walk up to them and cast inflict, bam pvp violation. Discuss |
|
| Author: | DustSpray101 [ Wed, Jan 19 2011, 16:54 PM ] |
| Post subject: | Re: The bad Samaritan |
Traditionally, healing is not a hostile action. Otherwise feel free to wig out ICly I guess? |
|
| Author: | Uncle-Opustus [ Wed, Jan 19 2011, 16:58 PM ] |
| Post subject: | Re: The bad Samaritan |
If your character is bonkers enough to attack someone for healing her/him, it's a good enough reason. Otherwise, in general, if you've fought an opponent and someone heals your opponent, you're free to attack the healer. |
|
| Author: | Nivo [ Wed, Jan 19 2011, 16:59 PM ] |
| Post subject: | Re: The bad Samaritan |
Technically, cure and heal spells can be saved against and resisted. Though the NWN engine does not allow it unless you are being damaged by the cure/heal (silly undead). Though, technically, if your character is averted to being magically healed, you can roll a will save for half healing, or a spell resist check if you have SR gear. I'd say preempt any potential heal with an emote saying your character is going to resist the attempt. There should be RP leading to the spell, regardless. The rest is splitting hairs, I think |
|
| Author: | Aridos [ Wed, Jan 19 2011, 17:49 PM ] |
| Post subject: | Re: The bad Samaritan |
Don't just attack people for healing you. I definetly played my Gnoll for a long time rather rageful whenever ANY kind of spell was cast at him, being generally mistrustful of anyone. Usually threats and IC conflicts about a character hating healing seems completely fine to me! On the Harm hand, Having some kind of masochistic/sadistic evil cleric that finds the idea of casting Inflict spells on anyone completely reasonable seems to me like a fine idea too! Just remember to alert players of this for their approval, or emote before and let them time to try and avoid it. |
|
| Author: | Gravemaskin [ Wed, Jan 19 2011, 17:57 PM ] |
| Post subject: | Re: The bad Samaritan |
Painbearers of Ilmater take great pride in the wounds they carry for a multitude of reasons. Healing their wounds without asking first could thus be concidered a great insult. I think a good general rule all together is DON'T CAST SPELLS ON PEOPLE ICLY WITHOUT ASKING FIRST. If the character has 0 spellcraft, he can with just IC cause freak out on you, thinking it's a curse or something similar. Just randomly healing people without asking is poor RP imho anyway.. Would you go up to a bleeding man and just silently start bandaging his bleeding arm without saying anything to him first? It'd likely get you slapped in the face. |
|
| Author: | Kudark [ Wed, Jan 19 2011, 18:15 PM ] |
| Post subject: | Re: The bad Samaritan |
Gravemaskin wrote: Painbearers of Ilmater take great pride in the wounds they carry for a multitude of reasons. Healing their wounds without asking first could thus be concidered a great insult. I think a good general rule all together is DON'T CAST SPELLS ON PEOPLE ICLY WITHOUT ASKING FIRST. If the character has 0 spellcraft, he can with just IC cause freak out on you, thinking it's a curse or something similar. Just randomly healing people without asking is poor RP imho anyway.. Would you go up to a bleeding man and just silently start bandaging his bleeding arm without saying anything to him first? It'd likely get you slapped in the face. Beat me to it, but yeah, just ask first, it's simple common sense. |
|
| Author: | Scimiter [ Wed, Jan 19 2011, 18:24 PM ] |
| Post subject: | Re: The bad Samaritan |
My SD heals people under cover of shadow all the time so good luck resolving it ICly in that case but if your PC is something like a Lovaitar Flagellant etc you can use the rest menu to take harm again. Also the question of SR came up. Roll it if it matters to you and if you succeed, once again, take the damage back and conintue from there. This really is a IC thing. Someone casts Heal etc on your PC then respond ICly. Some people will not stand to see someone hurt and if they are told not to heal then they not only worry for the body but as well as the mind. I'd love to see you tell a member of the temple of Salandra not to heal. Make for great RP. |
|
| Author: | DerkDerkistan [ Wed, Jan 19 2011, 18:48 PM ] |
| Post subject: | Re: The bad Samaritan |
Scimiter wrote: My SD heals people under cover of shadow all the time so good luck resolving it ICly in that case but if your PC is something like a Lovaitar Flagellant etc you can use the rest menu to take harm again. Also the question of SR came up. Roll it if it matters to you and if you succeed, once again, take the damage back and conintue from there. This really is a IC thing. Someone casts Heal etc on your PC then respond ICly. Some people will not stand to see someone hurt and if they are told not to heal then they not only worry for the body but as well as the mind. I'd love to see you tell a member of the temple of Salandra not to heal. Make for great RP. Yeah, but the thing is, your SD is wrapping bandages around people, putting your hands all over them. It's quite easy for them to grab you, even if you're HiPSed. Remember that. |
|
| Author: | My Sovereign [ Wed, Jan 19 2011, 18:50 PM ] |
| Post subject: | Re: The bad Samaritan |
It would be very IC for any healing magic to harm my character Howl. Though his wounds would heal, it would cause him extreme pain, due to all the negative energy in his palemaster body. He also has a vulnerability to positive energy >> |
|
| Author: | DerkDerkistan [ Wed, Jan 19 2011, 18:54 PM ] |
| Post subject: | Re: The bad Samaritan |
Does he heal himself? If so, what's the difference between someone else doing it and doing it himself? Note, I am not arguing for the ninja healing. I am against it. Every First Aid course I have ever taken says that you do not touch a patient without their consent, implied consent in the case of unconsciousness. |
|
| Author: | TormakSaber [ Wed, Jan 19 2011, 19:12 PM ] |
| Post subject: | Re: The bad Samaritan |
My Sovereign wrote: It would be very IC for any healing magic to harm my character Howl. Though his wounds would heal, it would cause him extreme pain, due to all the negative energy in his palemaster body. He also has a vulnerability to positive energy >> Palemasters are not harmed by healing magic. |
|
| Author: | My Sovereign [ Wed, Jan 19 2011, 19:48 PM ] |
| Post subject: | Re: The bad Samaritan |
I picture tormak with a shovel...he uproots things. |
|
| Author: | TormakSaber [ Wed, Jan 19 2011, 19:49 PM ] |
| Post subject: | Re: The bad Samaritan |
I am the man with the Good Book, and my Bible is lore. |
|
| Author: | Mobile_Svensk [ Wed, Jan 19 2011, 19:50 PM ] |
| Post subject: | Re: The bad Samaritan |
Speaking of uprooting - I just noticed on your Signature that you're playing Yowl Seer , Growl Seer, Snarl Seer and Howl Seer. Four man tribe? Kinda cool |
|
| Author: | My Sovereign [ Wed, Jan 19 2011, 19:54 PM ] |
| Post subject: | Re: The bad Samaritan |
The four brothers, though one is a girl. I found a picture of tormak ![]() That hardhat is actually a Helm of ignorance smashing +5 |
|
| Author: | DustSpray101 [ Wed, Jan 19 2011, 19:58 PM ] |
| Post subject: | Re: The bad Samaritan |
Nah, he is totally raptor Jesus holding a DM screen and dice bag in one hand, and a +5 book of Lore that glows like the sun in his other. |
|
| Author: | HellScourge [ Wed, Jan 19 2011, 20:14 PM ] |
| Post subject: | Re: The bad Samaritan |
I like the shoveler idea more. |
|
| Author: | The Great Equalizer [ Wed, Jan 19 2011, 20:23 PM ] |
| Post subject: | Re: The bad Samaritan |
Why have one when you can have both?!
|
|
| Author: | My Sovereign [ Wed, Jan 19 2011, 20:30 PM ] |
| Post subject: | Re: The bad Samaritan |
I laughed until tears flowed from my eyes!!!! Then I showed everyone around me and they laughed too! OMG that is so priceless! |
|
| Author: | Mobile_Svensk [ Wed, Jan 19 2011, 20:37 PM ] |
| Post subject: | Re: The bad Samaritan |
You're a fangirl |
|
| Author: | Dark Immolation [ Wed, Jan 19 2011, 21:04 PM ] |
| Post subject: | Re: The bad Samaritan |
I have a character that heals people without asking. If someone wigged out IC and wanted to PvP over it, I would be more than accepting of that. Why? Because I'm casting a spell on them. Stuff happens. If the character is the type to flip out over that, then they by all means have the right to. I have cast a spell on them, whether it is "beneficial" or not doesn't matter at all. However- It is a little profound to me that I am the first to promote emoting *Attempts to touch the Orc* vs *Touches the Orc*. The first leaves room for an RP reaction from the other PC, the latter is godmodding. I never really thought about it before, but I guess when you walk up to someone and heal them(since it doesn't respect that they could touch AC or willfully resist) it is kinda god-moddy. I for one will be a little more conscious of at least emoting a motion before actually enacting the healing. But the person who is planning to resist it should be aware of a few things too. #1. Is your character reacting to the being touched or the somatic/verbal components of the spell? Jumping away because someone is reaching out to touch you is a slightly paranoid-ish action. Jumping away because the guy in the wearing the skull next to you spoke something in Abyssal as he reached out to you is more understandable. The reason I think it's important to make this differentiation is so you don't meta someone who is healing you when ICly it maybe appear that they are just trying to tap you on the shoulder, and have your PC act accordingly. And in the case of stilled, silenced, or Lay on Hands, you should be aware of what is actually "happening" IC vs what you mechanically see. #2. Got Spellcraft? If your PC has spellcraft, then they may recognize the difference someone trying to heal them or hurt them. Or otherwise. If they don't, then again, more reason to be suspicious I guess. All you know is that that guy in the black robe said Septicus Namaramu Corpsicus and is now asking you to pull his finger. |
|
| Author: | Liz [ Wed, Jan 19 2011, 22:01 PM ] |
| Post subject: | Re: The bad Samaritan |
Dark Immolation wrote: #1. Is your character reacting to the being touched or the somatic/verbal components of the spell? Jumping away because someone is reaching out to touch you is a slightly paranoid-ish action. Jumping away because the guy in the wearing the skull next to you spoke something in Abyssal as he reached out to you is more understandable. The reason I think it's important to make this differentiation is so you don't meta someone who is healing you when ICly it maybe appear that they are just trying to tap you on the shoulder, and have your PC act accordingly. And in the case of stilled, silenced, or Lay on Hands, you should be aware of what is actually "happening" IC vs what you mechanically see. #2. Got Spellcraft? If your PC has spellcraft, then they may recognize the difference someone trying to heal them or hurt them. Or otherwise. If they don't, then again, more reason to be suspicious I guess. All you know is that that guy in the black robe said Septicus Namaramu Corpsicus and is now asking you to pull his finger. Casting a spell can rarely be mistaken for simply reaching out to tap someone on the shoulder. If a spell is Silenced and Stilled, possibly, but in actual practice, that rarely if ever actually happens. What happens way, way more often (and what the thread is actually referring to) is when a character makes no attempt to disguise his/her casting, and just lays down healings on people whether they like it or not, because s/he is "nice". In that case, there are somatic and verbal components that positively scream out "Spellcasting is occurring here!" Also, the DMs have confirmed more than once that the little light shows and sparkles and VFX associated with spellcasting actually exist IC, and can be easily seen by anyone nearby. The spellcraft skill allows a character to determine which spell is being cast, yes, but the fact spellcasting is occurring is obvious to anyone watching. Recognizing that spellcasting = spellcasting is not metagaming, even for the dumbest of characters. |
|
| Author: | Dwagin [ Wed, Jan 19 2011, 22:32 PM ] |
| Post subject: | Re: The bad Samaritan |
Came for the interesting title, leaving satisfied with Raptor Jesus Tormy. |
|
| Author: | My Sovereign [ Wed, Jan 19 2011, 22:34 PM ] |
| Post subject: | Re: The bad Samaritan |
Dwagin wrote: Came for the interesting title, leaving satisfied with Raptor Jesus Tormy. I have to say, it was really the high point of this thread. |
|
| Author: | MoshingChris [ Wed, Jan 19 2011, 22:47 PM ] |
| Post subject: | Re: The bad Samaritan |
My Sovereign wrote: Dwagin wrote: Came for the interesting title, leaving satisfied with Raptor Jesus Tormy. I have to say, it was really the ONLY point of this thread. Fixed. |
|
| Author: | The Great Equalizer [ Wed, Jan 19 2011, 23:07 PM ] |
| Post subject: | Re: The bad Samaritan |
Victory: Achieved. |
|
| Author: | wiggedi2 [ Wed, Jan 19 2011, 23:07 PM ] |
| Post subject: | Re: The bad Samaritan |
I hate when that happens. I had an Ilmateri Cleric, she was always approaching the injured and kindly asked if they wanted to be healed, if they refused she said so be it but also reminded them of the possible consquences. That way it was interesting RP and meeting people. Then some time.. I had another injured character, walked up to that person, said "greetings... it appears you require healing... blabla" And then some complete retard ran to us and simply healed him... I had absolutely no idea how to react to that ICly... and the retard.. niargh! It is stupid.. or another time some random person just used a healing kit on me, in moments like these I would like to hostile them and spam implosion. Back to the cleric story, that retard had absolutely no mind for the RP that was occurring directly infront of her/him/it... It was just stupid and boring and RUDE... and stupid! If people are not able to RP a Healer properly then they shouldn't.. its not just about casting Heal on every barely injured pixelface that passes by, its about behaving like a healer.. a healer would always first ask and not just spamit... Since that day I cannot simply watch when someone is pulling that shit... it's stupid, lame and uncreative. |
|
| Author: | Nysor [ Wed, Jan 19 2011, 23:11 PM ] |
| Post subject: | Re: The bad Samaritan |
This is amazing. I think it prompts a new thread in Off Topic: Putting Torin's Face on Notable Figures for Laughs. Or PTFNFL. |
|
| Author: | Silvarus [ Wed, Jan 19 2011, 23:13 PM ] |
| Post subject: | Re: The bad Samaritan |
Nysor wrote: This is amazing. I think it prompts a new thread in Off Topic: Putting Torin's Face on Notable Figures for Laughs. Or PTFNFL. Can we use the Elitist Emo Tordek face too? |
|
| Author: | Nysor [ Wed, Jan 19 2011, 23:16 PM ] |
| Post subject: | Re: The bad Samaritan |
I think all faces should be allowed into the thread, just as long as it has that name. Oh, and Kahn is forbidden. |
|
| Author: | Silvarus [ Wed, Jan 19 2011, 23:19 PM ] |
| Post subject: | Re: The bad Samaritan |
It seems you do not know the legend of the Elitist Emo Tordek. Sadly, I have lost my awesome pictures from this epic story. Someone give me a hand? |
|
| Author: | P Three [ Wed, Jan 19 2011, 23:55 PM ] |
| Post subject: | Re: The bad Samaritan |
*Applauds* |
|
| Author: | Dark Immolation [ Thu, Jan 20 2011, 3:23 AM ] |
| Post subject: | Re: The bad Samaritan |
Lizzie wrote: [What Lizzie Said] Well that was my whole point. To say you should be aware what it is your character is jumping away from. But I guess it has to do with the order of somatics. I'd assume it'd go somatics+verbal -> actual touch. But it could always be simultaneous I suppose. *shrugs* I was just saying it wouldn't be polite meta-ing every time some reaches out to "touch" you as they're obviously casting a spell on you until something denoting spellcasting(verbals, somatics, the lights you mentioned) has been observed. For people with still spell, or spells without somatics, it's completely possible to lay you hand on someone and then cast the spell. In which case it's no longer a case of AC(if they've already succeeded in touching you, resisted or not), but Initiative: if you can pull away before they complete the spell. A second case is again with Still and short ranged buff spells Haste and Lesser Mindblank. Since the spells don't give a miss chance and 8 meters(Short Range) isn't exactly arm's reach, I'd think one would only get to roll SR versus the spell they're trying to resist, just like a regular, non-helpful spell. But then again, I guess there's always Initiative to get out of range quick enough. But I'll be damned if your average fighter has enough insight without Spellcraft to tell in the WYSIWYG little red glowing ball I'm massaging is the makings of a Protection from Good spell or Harm. That gives rise to my own question though. A Stilled Touch spell. Still requires a physical "touch", I'd assume, just not the hand/limb motions that proceed it? |
|
| Author: | ainjyll [ Thu, Jan 20 2011, 4:22 AM ] |
| Post subject: | Re: The bad Samaritan |
Dark Immolation wrote: That gives rise to my own question though. A Stilled Touch spell. Still requires a physical "touch", I'd assume, just not the hand/limb motions that proceed it? That would be correct, sir. |
|
| Author: | TormakSaber [ Thu, Jan 20 2011, 7:10 AM ] |
| Post subject: | Re: The bad Samaritan |
Yep. You have to deliver the spell somehow. |
|
| Page 1 of 1 | All times are UTC |
| Powered by phpBB® Forum Software © phpBB Group http://www.phpbb.com/ |
|