| AMIA ARCHIVE https://www.amiaworld.net/phpBB3/ |
|
| Views on rebuilds. https://www.amiaworld.net/phpBB3/viewtopic.php?f=2&t=54743 |
Page 1 of 1 |
| Author: | Charles1810 [ Mon, Jan 17 2011, 16:13 PM ] |
| Post subject: | Views on rebuilds. |
Not posting this in the build topic because it has nothing to do with the actually building, but rather the view of rebuilds. When the free rebuilds first started a ways back I fully supported the idea and concept of them. To myself I felt it was a great way to help the roleplaying of a toon within amia, as well as a way to help people unfamilur with nwn when simple mistakes are made. When I mention help roleplaying I specificly mean events that urge a change or force a change, within reason. Paladin becoming blackguard, fighters becoming weaponmasters, wizards into palemasters. Things that don't change the foundation of the toon, but helps better define the toon and his/her experances within amia. Of course I felt it was a good way to help new players and players that are not great at using never winter nights. Often times new players may make a simple mistake that needs minor tweaking such as skills, few ability points, or feats. Such as not using disarm out of risk of weapons being lost in pvp ect. Though the longer after the free rebuilding once a year, as well as the more openly allowed self rebuilding it has began to bother myself more and more. Just this may be myself hating change, but often I feel as though the rebuilding is being abused. Not targetting anyone or flaming anyone, just I feel it strongly nags at people to powerbuild. Often times changing a pc so much that they are nothing like the former build or concept. Just I personally feel that large changes should just be thought to make a whole diffrent toon. This is just the view and feelings of a player that is seeking to hear others views on the subject. Not suggesting removing rebuilding, or I would of placed this in improving amia. Forgive me if you feel this post was also targeted to you, was not my intent just as stated before wanting to see others views on the popular rebuilding. ((Using my cell so will edit for any typo's once I can.)) |
|
| Author: | Kudark [ Mon, Jan 17 2011, 16:32 PM ] |
| Post subject: | Re: Views on rebuilds. |
I look at it this way, so far, I've not done any changes other than a partial name change. (removed "Lonesome"). I took four level of fighter so I could solo, but once I reach level cap, I might request to have them removed because my character never had any formal fighter training, also I didn't take any "Fighter" specific feats so I think that might soften the blow. I level my character up according to what he's doing or influences he's had, but he might need a few tweaks once he reaches level cap. I say that because I don't feel comfortable changing things now, I could be wrong, it's happened once or twice in my life. I've had some build advice which helped, but because of what my character is doing, I don't think he can level to the build recommended to me. If he's not being a rogue, I wont level him as a rogue, simple really. I agree that major changes should be avoided, other than what happens to a character in role-play of course (see: The Fall of Madrik), but tweaks sometimes are necessary. DM's allow it in PnP, so why not here as well. Just use it sparingly and use common sense. |
|
| Author: | Nekhy [ Mon, Jan 17 2011, 16:33 PM ] |
| Post subject: | Re: Views on rebuilds. |
The rebuild rules were tightened quite a lot not a long ago. Self-rebuilds used to enable almost anything, but for months now everything needs to pass a RP check. |
|
| Author: | PaladinOfSune [ Mon, Jan 17 2011, 16:47 PM ] |
| Post subject: | Re: Views on rebuilds. |
I was expecting this to be a topic on the tighter restraints we've put on rebuilds lately. |
|
| Author: | Yossarin [ Mon, Jan 17 2011, 16:53 PM ] |
| Post subject: | Re: Views on rebuilds. |
That's what I was expecting, too. |
|
| Author: | Lord-Hadeis [ Mon, Jan 17 2011, 17:55 PM ] |
| Post subject: | Re: Views on rebuilds. |
I'm fine with how the rules are now. But I agree with Charles as in that it is sad that some people do try to abuse it, but then there are such people everywhere and I haven't encountered any such cases since the new rules. Personally I feel more strongly about diety or alignement changes. I feel somehow I should be seeing more smiting. |
|
| Author: | Grymia [ Mon, Jan 17 2011, 18:15 PM ] |
| Post subject: | Re: Views on rebuilds. |
I have to agree with the tightening of the rebuild restrictions, and am glad they went into effect, even if it's made me gunshy of personally rebuilding save with a darn good IC reasoning. (not that I don't have the inclination to provide the RP, just that I'm always worried I won't have enough) |
|
| Author: | Dark Immolation [ Mon, Jan 17 2011, 18:47 PM ] |
| Post subject: | Re: Views on rebuilds. |
DM's run a tight ship on rebuilds, from the little that I bother to check out. |
|
| Author: | Nysor [ Mon, Jan 17 2011, 18:55 PM ] |
| Post subject: | Re: Views on rebuilds. |
I think the rebuild restrictions are just fine. Maybe could even be stricter, though theres no need to make them so. They honestly just cut away a lot of the nonsense ideas of rebuilds, rather than prevent good ones from happening. |
|
| Author: | Charles1810 [ Mon, Jan 17 2011, 19:49 PM ] |
| Post subject: | Re: Views on rebuilds. |
Ideally I think any rebuild that isn't the same basic build minus a tweak here or there should have to first undergo a dm quest. Similar to how blackguards get their epic summon, but likely that would cause issues shortly on. Am really suprised with the topic thus far, was expecting it to get shot down or dismissed swiftly. So thanks all kinda made my day. |
|
| Author: | Nekhy [ Mon, Jan 17 2011, 19:54 PM ] |
| Post subject: | Re: Views on rebuilds. |
Well, you're a bit late with your request, hehe. Like I said, what you're saying is pretty much how things have been for a while now... so not much to disgree about. |
|
| Author: | Scimiter [ Mon, Jan 17 2011, 20:01 PM ] |
| Post subject: | Re: Views on rebuilds. |
I like the new rules and also agree that people do tend to try and rework thier PCs to the best advantage without respect for thier own RP plots. Course it cuts both ways and that's what the new rules are for. For the person who honestly needs a small fix as they have learned better. I think the one thing that people lack still is to start the rp for the change /before/ they make the request. Not a rebuild but I just had a job log wipe but before I made the request there was RP that gave cause for the change. Course being under level 10 doesn't hurt ethier. I say if you get past 10 levels without being sure you're on the right path your stuck with it |
|
| Author: | Mobile_Svensk [ Mon, Jan 17 2011, 20:59 PM ] |
| Post subject: | Re: Views on rebuilds. |
A downside is this, People may now lean towards making a new PC; instead of altering their existing PC, Which leads to a slight possible influx in new toons. Both build and RP is important for the average player. But it's only marginal. |
|
| Author: | Silvarus [ Mon, Jan 17 2011, 21:08 PM ] |
| Post subject: | Re: Views on rebuilds. |
New characters is an upside. |
|
| Author: | Mobile_Svensk [ Mon, Jan 17 2011, 21:14 PM ] |
| Post subject: | Re: Views on rebuilds. |
Silvarus wrote: New characters is an upside. Downside. There is no depth to be gained if your character has to constantly befriend new people. |
|
| Author: | PaladinOfSune [ Mon, Jan 17 2011, 21:29 PM ] |
| Post subject: | Re: Views on rebuilds. |
If your PC is a fighter and you want to play a mage, then play a mage. Hamhandedly trying to explain away how you would become an archmage over night because you want to alter your main PC is silly. |
|
| Author: | MoshingChris [ Mon, Jan 17 2011, 21:40 PM ] |
| Post subject: | Re: Views on rebuilds. |
I think free rebuilds should be done away with entirely. The one I used was on a character that was sub-level-ten to train a new DM. |
|
| Author: | Mobile_Svensk [ Mon, Jan 17 2011, 21:44 PM ] |
| Post subject: | Re: Views on rebuilds. |
They should not. People make mistakes, and should be able to correct those. (I say mistakes, because i've seen that most freebies are used to correct weird builds and such) |
|
| Author: | Nekhy [ Mon, Jan 17 2011, 21:45 PM ] |
| Post subject: | Re: Views on rebuilds. |
That's what they're intended for. I don't think it's anybody's absolute right to fix those mistakes, but I think it's a gesture we as a server can offer, that makes people's game lives a bit more pleasant. And thus, it's a positive thing. |
|
| Author: | MoshingChris [ Mon, Jan 17 2011, 22:11 PM ] |
| Post subject: | Re: Views on rebuilds. |
Yup but Amia is the -only- server I've played on which actively promotes a build thread and has people giving advice constantly on how -not- to fuck up a build. I think freebies should be done away with entirely because the benefit of having to re-level ergo party is more beneficial to making connections in the role-playing context than tweaking a build so its better at pvp. I was critical of freebies when they first came in and I am still critical of them. |
|
| Author: | corypx [ Mon, Jan 17 2011, 22:17 PM ] |
| Post subject: | Re: Views on rebuilds. |
Silvarus wrote: New characters is an upside. no, its really not. gives you a false sense of numbers, I'll take a faction with near no members who play one person and are active over alot who are less active because they have 5 others to play as well. |
|
| Author: | Wolfking6116 [ Mon, Jan 17 2011, 22:22 PM ] |
| Post subject: | Re: Views on rebuilds. |
MoshingChris wrote: I think freebies should be done away with entirely because the benefit of having to re-level ergo party is more beneficial to making connections in the role-playing context than tweaking a build so its better at pvp. I agree with you very heavily here. But what if, per say, the person is rebuilding to better reflect the RP of their character through adjustments of feats, skills, etc. As well as them not enjoying the dullness of PUG's who don't talk IC through the entire run or the repetitive nature that which is the constant running of dungeons for exxx peezz to re-acquire that which they have already achieved once already? Indeed that it isn't a good thing to see people building strictly for PVP, problem is that some RP demands people to be good at PVP. If people aren't out slaying the monsters which have already been slain before all the time, they have better chance of establishing a better IC relationship with someone other than being "Hunting Partners" Also; Cory nails it on the head. |
|
| Author: | Nekhy [ Mon, Jan 17 2011, 22:39 PM ] |
| Post subject: | Re: Views on rebuilds. |
Yeah, there's two sides to that. Some players enjoy establishing IC relationships while adventuring and for some it's just one part of the game and would rather not repeat it over and over with the same character just because they messed something up. The grind-experience is a subjective thing. I think it's nice that you can choose the way that suits your RP (and mentality) better. |
|
| Author: | ainjyll [ Mon, Jan 17 2011, 22:49 PM ] |
| Post subject: | Re: Views on rebuilds. |
I'm not going to say that free rebuilds should be done away with... quite the contrary, I enjoy them. However, I think they should make a good lick of sense. By this I mean that a Fighter/WM/Rogue should be able to adjust their levels within their pre-existing classes, but that picking up a new class should be limited to only a few levels. If they want more, then they can wait a year and rebuild the character and add more levels of the chosen class. If you play a melee-type and want to play a mage-type, then make a mage... don't try to pull some piss poor excuse for why a level 30 melee-type is suddenly a master of the arcane. If the character has to suffer the faults of being a crappy build for a bit, so be it. If the player really wants their character to make that shift, then they should have no problem with the downfall of playing a non-powerbuild character. |
|
| Author: | IronAngel [ Mon, Jan 17 2011, 23:01 PM ] |
| Post subject: | Re: Views on rebuilds. |
I'm not sure how I feel about rebuilds. On one hand, they make Amia special and entertaining, but on the other a lack of rebuilds might encourage more character circulation (which is definetely a good thing, considering the stagnation of Amian population) and attract a certain kind of audience we might want. But I definetely don't like quality control or the fact players seem happy to ask for more of it as if it was an unproblematic science. No rebuilds at all, or a lot of freedom restricted by clear practical rules rather than "quality". IMO. You can't have your cake and eat it too, and that's what people don't seem to realize. If you want freedom of expression, if you don't want other people sticking their noses into your business they know nothing about, you have to suffer the same freedom for everyone else. It means you must tolerate dumb and tasteless people "abusing" their freedom, or give up your own freedom too. There are plenty of servers where you can do the latter, and I've always delighted in the fact that Amia has chosen the former. We've been slipping from that lately, which is unfortunate. But then again, those slips are the side effects of a larger progress in the right direction. I just wish that people realized that maturity and "hardcoreness" of the server (the good things) don't have to go hand-in-hand with increased bureucracy and enforcing one taste on everyone. But can't quality control be neutral and fair, so that good concepts will be approved and only the bad ones are weeded out? Do we really have to give up any real freedom just to police the riff-raff? I suppose it's possible in theory, but it's a pipedream. There is no objective standard to judge by. The more things we subject to the arbitrary, subjective tastes and whims of the DMs, the greater the chance of conflict between your desire for freedom and the normative taste enforced upon you. And make no mistake, the DM team is mostly professional and responsible in their role but that doesn't guarantee (or even suggest a likelyhood of) good taste, accurate understanding or fair judgement. They're no better than the average player in these regards. This is no criticism of our DM team specifically, but a fact about all DMs everywhere; they can't always know better, and they will make bad calls. They will deny some things and enforce others on an irrational and unfair basis, they will shoot down good concepts and they certainly won't agree with every player's idea of good fun. This is obvious, and you need only take a look at the Requests forum to see it. (Again, I don't want to criticize the way our DMs handle requests but to point out that any way will have varying degrees of bad consequences.) That's why you should be wary of giving them your blessing to crack down on "dumb ideas" because sooner or later, your great idea will be the one shot down. There's no clear lines to be drawn here, obviously. There's always some quality control, some freedom and some chance of conflict. I think all the implications should be kept in mind: the harder you want to come down on stuff you don't like, the more likely you are to face the Law yourself. Personally, I can't stand the idea because I know I know better and don't want anyone telling me what to do. But that's just me, and others might be happy with an authoritarian system. It's not bad in itself, as long you realize you're not getting a just and flawless system based on an objective standard of quality, but a subjective, arbitrary and more or less irrational process where man is the measure of things. This is all good in moderation, but I'd rather minimize the risks by minimizing unnecessary control. |
|
| Author: | CelestialDante [ Mon, Jan 17 2011, 23:06 PM ] |
| Post subject: | Re: Views on rebuilds. |
corypx wrote: I'll take a faction with near no members who play one person and are active over alot who are less active because they have 5 others to play as well. the skeletor is a genius |
|
| Author: | Mobile_Svensk [ Tue, Jan 18 2011, 1:13 AM ] |
| Post subject: | Re: Views on rebuilds. |
Sadly, Im here with an argument 'against' Free rebuilds and Self-rebuilds overall, Contradicting my first post on the subject. It diverts time and effort away from the DM. Time that could be invested in plotting, scheming, eventing, overseeing, watching, catching mulers, etcetc And at the same time, It's a service that, inevitably, provides roleplay. Im sure our beloved DM's would think it would be more enjoyable to log in with the promise of players passionately plotting. |
|
| Author: | DerkDerkistan [ Tue, Jan 18 2011, 4:05 AM ] |
| Post subject: | Re: Views on rebuilds. |
hadeismetirion wrote: Personally I feel more strongly about diety or alignement changes. I feel somehow I should be seeing more smiting. This is what I agree with most. Such fundamental changes about a character's heart and soul shouldn't be so whimsical. I can't count the number of people I've seen move from one god to that god's (im)mortal enemy quickly and for flimsy reasons. |
|
| Author: | ainjyll [ Tue, Jan 18 2011, 4:55 AM ] |
| Post subject: | Re: Views on rebuilds. |
I agree that diety and alignment changes should be very strictly enforced, but while the former is easy to enforce with the prayer system and whatnot, the latter is quite difficult to enforce. Unless the character is tied to some diety for it's powers, there's not much a DM can really do if a player decides they want to start playing their LN fighter as CG on a whim or fancy and going all the way to NE in a month because of whatever reason. However, that's not why we're really here. Iron pretty much hit the nail on the head. While I'm all for rules that can be set in stone, arbitrary rules that are left up to interpretation by anyone, regardless of status, should be kept to a minimum. |
|
| Author: | Selmak [ Tue, Jan 18 2011, 7:23 AM ] |
| Post subject: | Re: Views on rebuilds. |
Bear in mind that not all new characters made by old players are motivated by build decisions. Some just see that their character vault is getting a little empty and decide to roll five characters in one night for the hell of it. |
|
| Author: | steveb_uk [ Tue, Jan 18 2011, 16:22 PM ] |
| Post subject: | Re: Views on rebuilds. |
Having the 1 free rebuild is a major draw for me as a new player on Amia. I don't know the build system well enough, and you can lock yourself out from getting the top feats by making mistakes early on. It also allows lvl30s to continue to grow, chopping out unused early levels to gain the extra shading that they couldn't have otherwise. Changing a warrior to a mage would be silly, but no-one's doing that. The most I've seen offered (before the tighter recent changes) is de-levelling to re-learn, in which case you're earning the mage levels IC in real time anyway, and the rp will come with that. 1 free change a year = fantastic, a really attractive thing, and gives new players the confidence to proceed with a low-mid character who may not be built ultimately well but can be tweaked later. |
|
| Author: | Selvec Darkon [ Wed, Jan 19 2011, 4:11 AM ] |
| Post subject: | Re: Views on rebuilds. |
Nekhy wrote: Yeah, there's two sides to that. Some players enjoy establishing IC relationships while adventuring and for some it's just one part of the game and would rather not repeat it over and over with the same character just because they messed something up. The grind-experience is a subjective thing. I think it's nice that you can choose the way that suits your RP (and mentality) better. This. I hate the grind. I would murder the grind. I would grind the grind. I dislike the grind. |
|
| Author: | Silent2001 [ Wed, Jan 19 2011, 4:12 AM ] |
| Post subject: | Re: Views on rebuilds. |
Grinding depends on the company. |
|
| Author: | HellScourge [ Wed, Jan 19 2011, 12:24 PM ] |
| Post subject: | Re: Views on rebuilds. |
I am not sure how many DM's need to give their ok for a rebuild, but perhaps a set number could be made so people would know what to expect. Like 3 ok's for a a simple deleveling and rebuilding. 4 ok's for a class change. 5 for 2 class changes etc, etc, etc. |
|
| Author: | IronAngel [ Wed, Jan 19 2011, 12:44 PM ] |
| Post subject: | Re: Views on rebuilds. |
No. It's an internal team matter. For all we know, they might want to assign certain type of rebuilds as one DM's responsibility. You know exactly what to expect, and that's all you need to know: Yay or Nay. You will know when it's OK, the numbers are not your problem. |
|
| Author: | HellScourge [ Wed, Jan 19 2011, 20:16 PM ] |
| Post subject: | Re: Views on rebuilds. |
Yeah, I guessed so after thinking it through again. It is done when it is done. |
|
| Author: | Estara [ Thu, Jan 20 2011, 2:46 AM ] |
| Post subject: | Re: Views on rebuilds. |
I'd be more strict on some things than what I've publicly seen and less strict on others. I tend to be stricter with those who are needy but more understanding of those who make dumb mistakes. Probably my relaxed attitude toward the game. I think some DMs want to and some don't, though, so it's just team compromise. Walkin' the fine line. Overall they do it justice and it makes me happy when they challenge rebuilders reasons. |
|
| Page 1 of 1 | All times are UTC |
| Powered by phpBB® Forum Software © phpBB Group http://www.phpbb.com/ |
|