AMIA ARCHIVE
https://www.amiaworld.net/phpBB3/

God-like NPC factionbase defenders
https://www.amiaworld.net/phpBB3/viewtopic.php?f=2&t=36924
Page 1 of 4

Author:  Galenson [ Sat, Apr 04 2009, 23:57 PM ]
Post subject:  God-like NPC factionbase defenders

Ok, this isn't a rant so anyone who rants I'm gonna spank.


In some cases such as Cordor I can understand the need for god-like NPC defenders but from what I understand, god-like NPCs are a serious fashion trend in faction bases and cities.

I'm just curious why alot of factions have god-NPC defenders.

Author:  Yurell [ Sun, Apr 05 2009, 0:02 AM ]
Post subject: 

I thought they were just remnants from the past that the DMs left there (e.g. Shadowflame Manor I think was one).

Author:  TormakSaber [ Sun, Apr 05 2009, 0:03 AM ]
Post subject: 

So which faction did you attack that kicked your ass?

Author:  corypx [ Sun, Apr 05 2009, 0:20 AM ]
Post subject: 

I think the point of god-like/mode NPC were the fact that you were not ment to attack them unless a DM was there, and also counted as they did not want to have like 100 guards in one zone and make a butt load of lag.

one guard = 5 guards or something.

Author:  fjook [ Sun, Apr 05 2009, 0:22 AM ]
Post subject: 

The dms can bring in evilly powered salandran if the temple gets attacked.

Author:  TormakSaber [ Sun, Apr 05 2009, 1:12 AM ]
Post subject: 

The Templar really aren't that strong.

Author:  Gers [ Sun, Apr 05 2009, 1:13 AM ]
Post subject: 

Neither are the Shrine's guards. TBH, the only "god-like" NPC guards I know of are the Law Knights and Ultrinnan's guards.

Author:  Kjetta [ Sun, Apr 05 2009, 1:15 AM ]
Post subject: 

And Shadowflame's.

Author:  Yurell [ Sun, Apr 05 2009, 1:21 AM ]
Post subject: 

Kjetta wrote:
And Shadowflame's.


That was the only example I could think of beside the 'necessary' ones, which is why I used it.

Author:  Phantom-D [ Sun, Apr 05 2009, 1:22 AM ]
Post subject: 

The power of the guards really doesn't matter. If you are attacking them without a DM on you are probably metagaming. If you are attacking them with DMs on, the DM can set the power level right then and there to suit the situation.

It kind of eliminates the problems right?

Author:  BrainSplitter [ Sun, Apr 05 2009, 1:22 AM ]
Post subject: 

Winya's are pretty beasty.
Shadowflame Manor's are extremely beasty.
Cordor's are extremely beasty.
Ultrinnan's can take on all of the above at once.
Dorne can subsequently kick all of -their- arses. He deserves his own category.

Author:  Yurell [ Sun, Apr 05 2009, 1:24 AM ]
Post subject: 

WonWon wrote:
Winya's are pretty beasty.
Shadowflame Manor's are extremely beasty.
Cordor's are extremely beasty.
Ultrinnan's can take on all of the above at once.
Dorne can subsequently kick all of -their- arses. He deserves his own category.


Could you do tat and put it on youtube? I would seriously love to watch how badly the AI screws that up.

That said, I agree with Phantom in not really seeing it as an issue.

Author:  Grymia [ Sun, Apr 05 2009, 1:30 AM ]
Post subject: 

Dorne may as well be a Godslayer. ^^;

Author:  Moridan_X [ Sun, Apr 05 2009, 1:31 AM ]
Post subject: 

imo, u can't kick the city's ass, only the city can kick ur ass.

its a simple kill-switch to any threat within the city because casual adventurers could probably lay waste to dozens of NPC guards at a time, but then again probably not because the mage guards in cordor are like lvl 20+

i've seen a person RP a bomb thing in the city where he held hostages. guards sealed him in and they killed the lvl 30 within seconds

the dude with the bomb liked the joker from batman too much cuz he kept repeating the line like 6 times, "i'll be tonight's entertainment" which it kinda god annoying.

i lol'd when he got PWN3D cuz he didn't know what to expect from NPCs

Author:  Mr Mago [ Sun, Apr 05 2009, 1:35 AM ]
Post subject: 

Grymia wrote:
Dorne may as well be a Godslayer. ^^;


Who's Dorne?

Author:  Dwagin [ Sun, Apr 05 2009, 1:42 AM ]
Post subject: 

Law Knight Numero Uno.

Author:  Mr Mago [ Sun, Apr 05 2009, 1:46 AM ]
Post subject: 

Let's kill it.

Author:  Phantom-D [ Sun, Apr 05 2009, 1:49 AM ]
Post subject: 

Just get a wizard/sorc chain Time Stop gang bang going on. Who can survive that besides someone with stupid spell immunities?

Author:  Yurell [ Sun, Apr 05 2009, 1:56 AM ]
Post subject: 

Probably Dorne.

Author:  Phantom-D [ Sun, Apr 05 2009, 2:00 AM ]
Post subject: 

There is a difference between extremely challenging and just ridiculous. It is like the Demi Lich Trio versus Pun Pun. One you can get through if you have a good party and a little luck. The other you just die utterly and completely without the slightest chance at victory, even if your party rolled infinite 20s and Pun Pun infinite 1s.

It is only really interesting if the battle is actually winnable and people are trying hard to succeed. It really isn't that interesting if someone just popped up the tool set and decided to see how high they could make some character's numbers.

There is a reason people watch sports and not "squeezing stones to get blood" competitions. Unless Dorne is on that borked status, I'll maintain nothing could survive the combined ingenuity of players on the server!

Author:  BrainSplitter [ Sun, Apr 05 2009, 2:02 AM ]
Post subject: 

12 Ultrinnan Mages (armed with Hellball and Greater Ruin + Ai to use it) + 8 Ultrinnan Scouts + 10 Ultrinnan Vanguard + 30 second head start vs Sir Mark Dorne.

Sir Mark Dorne lived with 'Injured' as his status.



Sir Mark Dorne, much like the Ultrinnan Vanguard and the Cordorian Law Knights, are an IC means to an OOC ends. I'll be the first person to admit it. They are the IC Justification as to why 20 PCs can't just get together and destroy Cordor / Ultrinnan (the main RP hubs of Amia) for the heck of it, since OOCly we can't allow that to happen on a whim due to the extensive workload that'd go into, well, destroying Cordor or Ultrinnan.

Author:  tao_myst [ Sun, Apr 05 2009, 2:02 AM ]
Post subject: 

are they like, lv30 epics or actually invunrable, cause if they are invunrable it would be pointless to try even with a group of thirty against one if no DM was inside the npc, and if one was they should turn off invunrable.

personally i'm more worried about that giant thing, but then darthy already pwned that :P kind of...it started repairing...real scary stuff.

edit: he survived that O_o yikes

Author:  Mr Mago [ Sun, Apr 05 2009, 2:03 AM ]
Post subject: 

WonWon wrote:
12 Ultrinnan Mages (armed with Hellball and Greater Ruin + Ai to use it) + 8 Ultrinnan Scouts + 10 Ultrinnan Vanguard + 30 second head start vs Sir Mark Dorne.

Sir Mark Dorne lived with 'Injured' as his status.



Sir Mark Dorne, much like the Ultrinnan Vanguard and the Cordorian Law Knights, are an IC means to an OOC ends. I'll be the first person to admit it. They are the IC Justification as to why 20 PCs can't just get together and destroy Cordor / Ultrinnan (the main RP hubs of Amia) for the heck of it, since OOCly we can't allow that to happen on a whim due to the extensive workload that'd go into, well, destroying Cordor or Ultrinnan.


Has "Dorne" ever been used against a PC?

Author:  Mr. Hackums [ Sun, Apr 05 2009, 2:09 AM ]
Post subject: 

Amen. Haha, I remember when I broke free from Banite captivity with a lvl 6 or so, just because I was smart enough to chuck/throw my captor in my own cell. There was some ingenuity there, but then he started shouting, and I bolted out of the door, only to be chased for.... maybe 2-4 seconds, and put down by a Monk NPC. XD , but you know what, I dont resent that. Its all good fun. And in all reality, my character may have been smart, but he isnt strong enough to take on everyone he sees.

Besides, I'm a big fan of playing the little guy. This being said, I have no epic characters, but have played on this server for nearly 3-4 years, and defeated my fair share of epic foes. Ya just gotta be smart, thats all.

Author:  The Great Equalizer [ Sun, Apr 05 2009, 2:11 AM ]
Post subject: 

Dorne angry, Dorne smash?

Author:  Brown Blur [ Sun, Apr 05 2009, 2:12 AM ]
Post subject: 

:roll:

Author:  BrainSplitter [ Sun, Apr 05 2009, 2:13 AM ]
Post subject: 

@Mago:

A few times, however only by PC Initiative.

Two times, knights walked up to him and asked to duel him (I informed them OOCly of the circumstances and they were cool with it) for noble causes.

Once, because we had a typical powerbuilder "I can beat absolutely anything and despite the fact I'm being an idiot I'm going to proceed to kill every NPC" on a killing spree in Cordor. Dorne knocked him down a notch, ala the earlier argument of IC Reason Players can't just kill everyone in Cordor or blow up Cordor.

Every other time it's been a case of someone attacking him directly when he's doing what his Cordor Guard General job such as talking to leaders of other factions or handling specific individuals (in non-hostile circumstances. IE; diplomacy, issuing severe warnings of bans, etc). It's purposefully made painfully obvious that beating the NPC through raw force is impossible.

Author:  Gers [ Sun, Apr 05 2009, 2:16 AM ]
Post subject: 

Also, Jud sparred with Dorne once in the arena. He lasted for a few rounds, then Dorne ripped him a new butthole.

Author:  Grymia [ Sun, Apr 05 2009, 2:17 AM ]
Post subject: 

There was also an IC sparring match Bryce had with him to test his mettle, but that kinda fell short due to poor conceptual planning on Bryce's part.

Author:  The Cobbit [ Sun, Apr 05 2009, 2:17 AM ]
Post subject: 

There's a reason why Dorne is the General of the Cordor Guard.

In a city filled with half-insane to full-insane epic adventurers, city government isn't going to skimp on protection to make sure they don't get strong-armed or taken hostage. Dorne and the Law Knights are simply Cordor's taxes at work.

Author:  Mr Mago [ Sun, Apr 05 2009, 2:17 AM ]
Post subject: 

Mr. Hackums wrote:
Amen. Haha, I remember when I broke free from Banite captivity with a lvl 6 or so, just because I was smart enough to chuck/throw my captor in my own cell. There was some ingenuity there, but then he started shouting, and I bolted out of the door, only to be chased for.... maybe 2-4 seconds, and put down by a Monk NPC. XD , but you know what, I dont resent that. Its all good fun. And in all reality, my character may have been smart, but he isnt strong enough to take on everyone he sees.

Besides, I'm a big fan of playing the little guy. This being said, I have no epic characters, but have played on this server for nearly 3-4 years, and defeated my fair share of epic foes. Ya just gotta be smart, thats all.


I remember that one. Laughed my ass off.

Hort <3

But, you do realise that the Banite temple NPC guards are really, really, really sucky, right?

Author:  Mr Mago [ Sun, Apr 05 2009, 2:19 AM ]
Post subject: 

WonWon wrote:
@Mago:

A few times, however only by PC Initiative.

Two times, knights walked up to him and asked to duel him (I informed them OOCly of the circumstances and they were cool with it) for noble causes.

Once, because we had a typical powerbuilder "I can beat absolutely anything and despite the fact I'm being an idiot I'm going to proceed to kill every NPC" on a killing spree in Cordor. Dorne knocked him down a notch, ala the earlier argument of IC Reason Players can't just kill everyone in Cordor or blow up Cordor.

Every other time it's been a case of someone attacking him directly when he's doing what his Cordor Guard General job such as talking to leaders of other factions or handling specific individuals (in non-hostile circumstances. IE; diplomacy, issuing severe warnings of bans, etc). It's purposefully made painfully obvious that beating the NPC through raw force is impossible.


Which kind of sucks.

Apparently, he's the NPC equivalent of the DM radial kill button.

EDIT: Jesus christ you guys respond fast.

Author:  Drannok [ Sun, Apr 05 2009, 2:20 AM ]
Post subject: 

That's disgusting.

I'd honestly rather try to fight team evil on even terms, than throw Superman at them.

Bear in mind, I wouldn't let evil win at Cordor (or Good win at Ultrinnan). But I'd at least give them the sense of an actual fight instead of "Here he comes! To save the day!"

Author:  Grymia [ Sun, Apr 05 2009, 2:22 AM ]
Post subject: 

The thing is though..

Dorne can be beaten. Really, he can be.

It'd just be a matter of knowing HOW.

Author:  BrainSplitter [ Sun, Apr 05 2009, 2:22 AM ]
Post subject: 

The Cobbit wrote:
There's a reason why Dorne is the General of the Cordor Guard.

In a city filled with half-insane to full-insane epic adventurers, city government isn't going to skimp on protection to make sure they don't get strong-armed or taken hostage. Dorne and the Law Knights are simply Cordor's taxes at work.


Yus. As much as they serve an OOC purpose, they're also completely IC. It would've been easy to say that the Mythal's back in place to handle the same issue, however I'm strongly preferable to something people can ICly interact with and manipulate.

Sure, from a "PvP/M" Perspective he's God; if you're the sort to have the ability to handle an issue without your powerbuild's abilities, he's actually quite 'beatable' so to speak. That'd require, y'know, roleplaying and finding out ICly, of course.

Author:  Drannok [ Sun, Apr 05 2009, 2:23 AM ]
Post subject: 

He rolls a one vs devcrit?

Author:  The Great Equalizer [ Sun, Apr 05 2009, 2:24 AM ]
Post subject: 

We drow know how to beat Dorn... *Continues to wait quietly for Dorne to die of old age.*

Author:  Mr Mago [ Sun, Apr 05 2009, 2:24 AM ]
Post subject: 

Drannok wrote:
He rolls a one vs devcrit?


I'll bet he's crit-immune.

Author:  Mr. Hackums [ Sun, Apr 05 2009, 2:25 AM ]
Post subject: 

Yeah, yeah, Darth. But remember the... erm.... whole lvl 6-ness about my character. But as I said before, thats how it should be! I was lvl six, who in hell would believe that someone of that.... power(?) would be able to take on banite church...dom.

There are many, many a ways of getting what you want in Amia. Sometimes, just sometimes, they just dont come from beating someone with a wooden rod.

:D

Author:  The Cobbit [ Sun, Apr 05 2009, 2:25 AM ]
Post subject: 

Drannok wrote:
That's disgusting.

I'd honestly rather try to fight team evil on even terms, than throw Superman at them.

Bear in mind, I wouldn't let evil win at Cordor (or Good win at Ultrinnan). But I'd at least give them the sense of an actual fight instead of "Here he comes! To save the day!"


Dorne is rarely brought out though, and as Ron said it's usually the PCs instigating the fight against him.

If you're so worried about uberguards being used as a glorified DMKill, remember that you don't always have to use force, brawn, smashysmashy I kill all the NPCs so I can show off my powerbuild rawr. Put in some good effort and work and RP, and you may be able to find a variety of ways to defeat NPCs without even touching your sword.

Author:  corypx [ Sun, Apr 05 2009, 2:25 AM ]
Post subject: 

makes me want to try and fight Dorne even if I know I will get stomped it sounds fun.

lets face it, super NPC to end a fight or the DM could just spam heal on afew guards because if you can hold 300 heal potions so can every NPC guard so why waste the DM and your time YOU LOSE :cry:

Author:  Drannok [ Sun, Apr 05 2009, 2:26 AM ]
Post subject: 

I'd almost sell my soul to be able to craft Heavy Fortification enchanted armor.

... that's crit immunity, by the way.

Author:  soundofastream [ Sun, Apr 05 2009, 2:28 AM ]
Post subject: 

WonWon wrote:
The Cobbit wrote:
There's a reason why Dorne is the General of the Cordor Guard.

In a city filled with half-insane to full-insane epic adventurers, city government isn't going to skimp on protection to make sure they don't get strong-armed or taken hostage. Dorne and the Law Knights are simply Cordor's taxes at work.


Yus. As much as they serve an OOC purpose, they're also completely IC. It would've been easy to say that the Mythal's back in place to handle the same issue, however I'm strongly preferable to something people can ICly interact with and manipulate.

Sure, from a "PvP/M" Perspective he's God; if you're the sort to have the ability to handle an issue without your powerbuild's abilities, he's actually quite 'beatable' so to speak. That'd require, y'know, roleplaying and finding out ICly, of course.


Just throw Kryptonite at him *nodnod*

Author:  Mr Mago [ Sun, Apr 05 2009, 2:28 AM ]
Post subject: 

What?!

People are naturally inclined to use their characters combat abilities against NPC's, in a setting where pretty much everything evolves around going on dangerous adventures, fighting monsters, dragons and what not, where highly proficient combat abilities are crucial?

Totally outrageous.


No no. It would be much more sensible for people to RP baking cookies which they then give to Dorne, causing him to like them.

That's how you take over Cordor.

Author:  BrainSplitter [ Sun, Apr 05 2009, 2:29 AM ]
Post subject: 

Downside is, if you fight Evil on Even Teams, you get what happened about.. Maybe two months ago.


Evil just gets so many people on their side that the previously 'even' teams are no longer even, which results in having to suddenly up the other team which gets even more grumbling. You end up with a proverbial arms race which can absolutely and completely throw any sembliance of OOC Continuity out the door.


Instead, have a guy that could take on the 64 other evil powerbuilds and give him enough IC 'Defeat' points that the guy can easily deal with any (I'm going to outright say it) shortsighted and pointless attempts known as "I have a powerbuild, therefore I rock" wherein you just attempt to ply your trade by beating things up senselessly; yet the same guy remains easily defeatable through means -other- than killing him.


Rogaku's seen how Dorne can not only be beaten, but outright trounced, heh.


Dorne's extremely rarely brought out to fight. It's only happened once. He is brought out occasionally as a plot-related NPC for Cordor so PCs -can- interact with him, try and work with him / against him, however.

Author:  Drannok [ Sun, Apr 05 2009, 2:30 AM ]
Post subject: 

I understand his purpose. It's essentially a requirement in an FR setting PW like this at high levels.

I just never like seeing those sorts of NPCs having to be used.

Then again, I'm pretty sure everyone must have a good laugh when Captain Uberevil struts his stuff in Cordor and get's slapped around.

Author:  Mr Mago [ Sun, Apr 05 2009, 2:31 AM ]
Post subject: 

Why is the assumption made that attempting to kill an NPC has to go hand in hand with being an asshole of a player trying to show off his powerbuilding expertise?

Author:  The Cobbit [ Sun, Apr 05 2009, 2:33 AM ]
Post subject: 

Because 99% of the time, that's exactly what's happening.

Author:  Grymia [ Sun, Apr 05 2009, 2:33 AM ]
Post subject: 

I could tear into a quite vicious rant about this on the side of KEEPING Dorne, but instead I will speak thusly:

- He can be beaten. In spite of his superior abilities, he is not invincible.

- Given the proper effort, planning, intelligence, cunning and the proper manipulation of circumstance and situation, he likely WILL be defeated. The problem is, what would that get you?

Please, seriously think about what you're saying. Not to say you aren't in the right for saying your peace but please, think. I have a number of things I would like to say, but I don't think I could express them without a LOT of frustration being unleashed and frankly, I don't want to unleash it here where it'd do more harm then good.

Author:  BrainSplitter [ Sun, Apr 05 2009, 2:35 AM ]
Post subject: 

Sometimes that isn't what's happening.

Sometimes it's just an Evil Guy wanting to be a prick and thinking that, because he is so mighty, he should be able to beat up anything including a big-tough-Guard-General. Totally IC.

However, from an OOC perspective, we can't really just have "Mister and Mistress Macho" possess the power to just overrule or overrun a place through their powerful builds and abilities. If we ICly allowed them to, we'd prettymuch have to let everyone else unless we're playing favourites or feel like OOCly tweaking the factors in their favour (again, favourites).

Page 1 of 4 All times are UTC
Powered by phpBB® Forum Software © phpBB Group
http://www.phpbb.com/