AMIA ARCHIVE
https://www.amiaworld.net/phpBB3/

Heal Potions
https://www.amiaworld.net/phpBB3/viewtopic.php?f=2&t=35710
Page 1 of 4

Author:  Craig deathwalker [ Tue, Feb 24 2009, 16:26 PM ]
Post subject:  Heal Potions

Ladies and Gents, welcome to tonights debate.

Ok here is a topic about heal potions and how I and some other players have a strong dislike to the extreme effectiveness of this particular item.

In amia’s current setting there is far too much gold in the economy, now there have been various ideas brought forward to reduce the staggering amount of gold that some players possess. Sadly the amount of gold is still ever increasing, why?

I believe the reason is simple, heal potions. For a cost of 30,000(ish) Players can buy a stack of heal potions. Items which are effectively a get out of death free card. Full health restoration. These potions encourage boss farming, solo hunting and only have one counter. Dev crit.

Now in the past this has been brought up many times, the problem is that if you remove heal potions entirely you are effectively unbalancing the game. But for who exactly? Certainly not low level hunters who cannot afford 30,000 a stack. Certainly not players with the heal skill points, who will mostly find there skills useless in any PvM situation in comparison to one heal potion.

The problem with removing heal potions from the game is that we make hunting harder for the epic grinders who are filling the economy with this extra gold.

Now I am certainly not suggesting that heal potions are removed from the game, what I am suggesting however is that there effectiveness is instead capped. Possible at one hundred HP.

In my opinion as it stands right now this one item promotes solo hunting, it is the reason when a party goes hunting they do not seek out healers. Without heal potions all of amia’s classes will suffer a disadvantage at epic levels for PvM. This is a good thing, it promotes the use of healers for parties.

At the top I have added a poll, three options pick seriously and enjoy the debate.

Author:  Gravemaskin [ Tue, Feb 24 2009, 16:32 PM ]
Post subject: 

Crafty people would simply get their hands on greater restore potions or scrolls, problem solved for them. I'd like to see the 100hp healed cap tick in, but I doubt it ever will.. oh and I predict an uproar on this topic within the first 50 posts.*sagenod*

Author:  Craig deathwalker [ Tue, Feb 24 2009, 16:33 PM ]
Post subject: 

Oh i see alot of uproar, but tick the box add to the poll. Maybe there are alot of amians who are in the same mindset.

Author:  Talon [ Tue, Feb 24 2009, 16:38 PM ]
Post subject: 

Don't fix what isn't broken.

Author:  Brown Blur [ Tue, Feb 24 2009, 16:39 PM ]
Post subject: 

I voted for the 100 cap too.

Its always seemed odd that there is nothing above Cure Crit. potions until you get to Heal anyway, and yes, as has been said, full healing from a potion does seem 'excessive', to my mind, really.

Author:  Neus Scario [ Tue, Feb 24 2009, 16:41 PM ]
Post subject: 

In all honesty, Heal potions are trying to help drain the huge amounts of gold sitting on characters. They are a constant drain on the wallets of anyone who adventures, and they get consumed particularly quickly. Unfortunately, their cost (appropriately) is not high enough to counter-balance the profit made from selling loot, especially at higher levels.

There's no question that more and more gold is entering player hands and there's no sign of that stopping any time soon. Larger and larger amounts of gold are going to be worth less. This is the natural flow of things and I doubt any course of action would ever completely balance it.

I do think that we could use a source of money sinks, though. Even small amounts of gold destroyed through something like a gambling establishment where the house takes a percent of the winnings would slowly but surely help balance it out.

Long-term events where players donate gold for a plot purpose would also be helpful in that regard. I don't think making people buy more potions and unbalancing the game is a way to go about it.

Since most of the gold that changes hands in the game is from player to player, I don't know how many options you have for something like that, though.

Author:  Craig deathwalker [ Tue, Feb 24 2009, 16:41 PM ]
Post subject: 

Talon wrote:
Don't fix what isn't broken.


Care to explain how it is not broken?

As it stands right now any player can spam heal potions to stay alive. The only thing that stops this is immobilising the player. Via stun, daze, hold ,fear so that the player is unable to drink the potions. Or via instant death such as dev crit, implosion or death spells. Two of those do not have counters the rest do.

Granted a -player- can kd spam and keep the player on its back. But I do not see spawns using this tactic.

Author:  Craig deathwalker [ Tue, Feb 24 2009, 16:46 PM ]
Post subject: 

Neus Scario wrote:
In all honesty, Heal potions are trying to help drain the huge amounts of gold sitting on characters. They are a constant drain on the wallets of anyone who adventures, and they get consumed particularly quickly. Unfortunately, their cost (appropriately) is not high enough to counter-balance the profit made from selling loot, especially at higher levels.

There's no question that more and more gold is entering player hands and there's no sign of that stopping any time soon. Larger and larger amounts of gold are going to be worth less. This is the natural flow of things and I doubt any course of action would ever completely balance it.
.



If a cap was added to heal potions, they would become less effective and used at a much higher rate of consumption. Thus players would find themselves purchasing more and more of the heal potions to sustain there hunting. That or give up hunting for more rp, or create hunting parties. Gold would then be split between a number of people and not just one.

As it stands right now, mages use heal potions to heal dominated monsters and edks. Wm's throw down a heal every time they get nd and have 4-500 hp restored instantly. That is insanely overpowered, the only class that should have that healing capability is a cleric with heal domain.

Author:  ILoveIceCream [ Tue, Feb 24 2009, 16:52 PM ]
Post subject: 

I agree, there is too much money in the econmy because of people farming bosses for epic loot....a 100 hp cap or completly removing those potions will decrese the ammount of farming, or at least make them burn tons of gold....it would also encourage hunting with a cleric with heals.

Author:  Dev Disco [ Tue, Feb 24 2009, 16:54 PM ]
Post subject: 

I wouldn't be against this, I guess. You could make it a certain amount/level, or even better 1d10/level. Makes it less of an instant winner.

Author:  Neus Scario [ Tue, Feb 24 2009, 16:54 PM ]
Post subject: 

Craig Deathwalker wrote:
(snip)


I was more talking about the state of the economy than the balance of Heal potions. I'm not going to break off into a long arguement about it, but let's just say that people can easily deal 70-100+ damage in one hit, four times per 6 seconds. And if someone waits until they're near death before using a potion, that Attack of Opportunity could very well just mean they killed themselves.

Taking away convenience isn't a way to fix the gold problem. And NWN has never been and will likely not ever even be a somewhat balanced game. If you have the higher numbers, you'll win. If not, you'll lose.

Author:  herkles [ Tue, Feb 24 2009, 16:59 PM ]
Post subject: 

I though would like to see clerics be able to make these potions. They can get the feat "brew potion" yet not make heal potions, save via a DC request. if it is possible for heal to be able to be brewed that would be helpful to this.

I don't normally use heal potions, I do use potions though, but not often do I use heal potions to insta restore my health, partially because save for amareth my charachters are clerics thus will have the ability to cast the spell themselves. making them a bit more rarer might help on this. I am also wondering about making raise dead scrolls rarer, but that is probaly a thread for another day.

Author:  xordae [ Tue, Feb 24 2009, 17:02 PM ]
Post subject: 

What I would really be for is that there be a timer on the potions. Like.. you used a Heal, now you have to wait 'till next rest to use another one. Not only will that make the potion are more valued commodity (without actually making it less effective), but there will be no PCs fighting something totally out of their league and still winning it. That goes for bosses, and that goes for boring and lengthy PvP where both parties make use of the potions because they wanna win the game by all means.

That would mean putting the same restriction on Greater Restoration potions, too.

Author:  ILoveIceCream [ Tue, Feb 24 2009, 17:03 PM ]
Post subject: 

you can make heal potions on amia...if you know how to do it

Author:  Neus Scario [ Tue, Feb 24 2009, 17:03 PM ]
Post subject: 

That's a suggestion I can get behind, xordae.

Author:  ILoveIceCream [ Tue, Feb 24 2009, 17:05 PM ]
Post subject: 

Xordae's suggestion is a good one...a timer would make it better as well

Author:  Craig deathwalker [ Tue, Feb 24 2009, 17:08 PM ]
Post subject: 

Neus Scario wrote:
Craig Deathwalker wrote:
(snip)


I was more talking about the state of the economy than the balance of Heal potions. I'm not going to break off into a long arguement about it, but let's just say that people can easily deal 70-100+ damage in one hit, four times per 6 seconds. And if someone waits until they're near death before using a potion, that Attack of Opportunity could very well just mean they killed themselves.

Taking away convenience isn't a way to fix the gold problem. And NWN has never been and will likely not ever even be a somewhat balanced game. If you have the higher numbers, you'll win. If not, you'll lose.



Granted NWN will never be a balanced game, but it is certainly able to become alot more balanced than it already is. Heal potions are a large part of amia hunting. They allow players to grind solo with ease, instead of in effective parties.

Yes the higher numbers will always win, if the player knows what they are doing that is. But it does not mean players who have no clue should simply be able to avoid death via the use of one or two heal potions.

70-100+ damage is achieable yes, 4 attacks a round per 6 seconds. How often do you see two well built characters actually dealing that much damage unless a kd is brought into the mix. More to the point a player who sacrifices that much for damage has alot of weaknesses in most cases, and there sacrifices for amazing damage is pointless if all a player needs to do is chug a heal potion to null every single last bit of damage.

Concidere it like this, a cleric who is fighting leaves casting heal to the very last second. The attack of oppertunity granted not only means they can be hit and killed, but if they survive they must roll concentration to still cast the spell. No such thing is given with heal potions, they in this sense are better than the spell.

Author:  Craig deathwalker [ Tue, Feb 24 2009, 17:10 PM ]
Post subject: 

xordae Where the hell where you when i was talking this over with players! Thats a far better idea.

Author:  Yossarin [ Tue, Feb 24 2009, 17:19 PM ]
Post subject: 

Craig deathwalker wrote:
If a cap was added to heal potions, they would become less effective and used at a much higher rate of consumption. Thus players would find themselves purchasing more and more of the heal potions to sustain there hunting. That or give up hunting for more rp, or create hunting parties. Gold would then be split between a number of people and not just one.


Someone knows how to make arguments that'll catch my ear. Even if he is a hunt & peck SD'er who would clearly benefit in PvP when his victims stop quaffing heals as they are. :wink:

Author:  Silvarus [ Tue, Feb 24 2009, 17:29 PM ]
Post subject: 

Give the Salandrans some work to do.

Author:  Craig deathwalker [ Tue, Feb 24 2009, 17:32 PM ]
Post subject: 

Yossarin wrote:
Craig deathwalker wrote:
If a cap was added to heal potions, they would become less effective and used at a much higher rate of consumption. Thus players would find themselves purchasing more and more of the heal potions to sustain there hunting. That or give up hunting for more rp, or create hunting parties. Gold would then be split between a number of people and not just one.


Someone knows how to make arguments that'll catch my ear. Even if he is a hunt & peck SD'er who would clearly benefit in PvP when his victims stop quaffing heals as they are. :wink:


My damage output is more of a pitbulls bite than a peck, but nevertheless im not too keen on complete cheese builds which are can beat heal potion spammers. So id rather suggest a balanced nerf than up the rate of pure pvp builds some more :D

Author:  555444333 [ Tue, Feb 24 2009, 17:37 PM ]
Post subject: 

Leave it alone, ta.

Author:  Jas [ Tue, Feb 24 2009, 17:39 PM ]
Post subject: 

A heal kit + 10 and a pc with 33 skill points in heal heals for 44-63hp. I kind of believe someone that invested in those points deserve to heal more then the other that buys a potion that is sold everywhere or should at least have it far far cheaper.

My suggestion or two cents would be for heal and greater restore to heal 10 and 12hp per lvl respectively while at the same time having them cost far more or be rarer at least.

If it were up to me, Ill much rather they be only craftable with ingredients instead of purchasable from almost any merchant. And make them cost a fair bit too. This way its a gold sink for any that wishes to heal for 100hp or 156hp and Clerics or anyone choosing to take the heal kit have it far cheaper with less hassle.
The ingredients could be spread throughout the server instead of being consolidated on a spot of course. Potentially, different factions could try to monopolize the resource.

But at the end of the day, the cleric and the ones with heal skill should be unaffected.


Of course, some might dislike the suggestion and find it extreme i guess.

Author:  Kendera [ Tue, Feb 24 2009, 17:42 PM ]
Post subject: 

-No- changes to the restorative properties. What I suggest is a script that forces you to either wait awhile between potions, or after the second or third potion, a penalty to ability scores for the body regenereating so fast it makes mistakes.


What one server did was made it 10hp/level, and that was fine, but I think it's a waste of dev time. With the amount of money around, the only people getting hurt are lowbies.

I'd like something akin to a penalty for drinking to many in a short burst.

Author:  ILoveIceCream [ Tue, Feb 24 2009, 17:53 PM ]
Post subject: 

you know...to get rid of the money problem.....if you havee more than 1 mil....you lose 75% of the current money you have...and if you have les you lose 50%....sounds like a good idea to me

Author:  Talon [ Tue, Feb 24 2009, 18:01 PM ]
Post subject: 

ILoveIceCream wrote:
you know...to get rid of the money problem.....if you havee more than 1 mil....you lose 75% of the current money you have...and if you have les you lose 50%....sounds like a good idea to me


Just arbitrarily? Yeah, that makes sense.

Author:  ILoveIceCream [ Tue, Feb 24 2009, 18:05 PM ]
Post subject: 

yep, just randomly. it'll help...a bit...anyway. Or put a cap on wealth at like 5 mil

Author:  BlackDahlya [ Tue, Feb 24 2009, 18:14 PM ]
Post subject: 

Creating money sinks will inevitably increase hunting.

EDIT to add: Still, I would not be averse to see a healing cap on the potions.

Author:  Terra_777 [ Tue, Feb 24 2009, 18:31 PM ]
Post subject: 

If they have time/can heal in pvp you've FAILED. I think Uce went though that. :D

Author:  D-Finitiy [ Tue, Feb 24 2009, 18:33 PM ]
Post subject: 

Dev Disco wrote:
I wouldn't be against this, I guess. You could make it a certain amount/level, or even better 1d10/level. Makes it less of an instant winner.


Would that apply to the cleric spell too? Because if the potion were nerfed and the spell wasn't, clerics would become the new most-hated-class.

And regarding the main post, I don't really follow your logic connecting amia's economy with heal potions... more like you're as sick as everyone else of people turning PvP into a contest of who has the most heal potions (I do this shamelessly btw.)

But what about raising the price of the heal potions to... say ... 100,000 a stack, and make them uncraftable? That would seriously cut into the pocketbook of Amia's super-rich. It would also make heal potions unaffordable for everyone else, which isn't fair. I'm out of ideas.

Author:  Uberuce [ Tue, Feb 24 2009, 18:35 PM ]
Post subject: 

It penalises the RP builds and the frontliners more than monsterbuilds and party leeches. Find some way around that and I'll say yay. Until then: nay.

Author:  ILoveIceCream [ Tue, Feb 24 2009, 18:36 PM ]
Post subject: 

money cap FTW! 5 Mil cap....is what I saw

Author:  Sakkran [ Tue, Feb 24 2009, 18:39 PM ]
Post subject: 

If you're going to put a cap on the spell/potion, at least make it as it is in PnP- 150 HP. As it stands, Ruce is right. If someone has a chance to chug a Heal, then they've either earned it, or you're slipping up. If they have to knock back a potion every time that they stand up from a knockdown/recover from a daze/paralysis et cetera, then you're effectively doing GP damage, instead of HP damage. Small victories.

Author:  Yossarin [ Tue, Feb 24 2009, 18:52 PM ]
Post subject: 

Uberuce wrote:
It penalises the RP builds and the frontliners more than monsterbuilds and party leeches. Find some way around that and I'll say yay. Until then: nay.


It is only a penalty for me, personally, with no benefit since I never have any reason to PvP. I am torn between my desire to see everyone else suffer painfully and giving up a freedom I enjoy.

Author:  Kendera [ Tue, Feb 24 2009, 18:58 PM ]
Post subject: 

Terra_777 wrote:
If they have time/can heal in pvp you've FAILED. I think Uce went though that. :D


Yes, you have to be able to ImpKD with an AB of 50, forceful hand spam, or timestop,

to stop some twit with 5,000 potions.

Again. Ability penaly for the win. :D

Author:  Jan [ Tue, Feb 24 2009, 18:59 PM ]
Post subject: 

LEAVE HEAL POTIONS ALONE!

Author:  Teufel Eldritch [ Tue, Feb 24 2009, 19:09 PM ]
Post subject: 

I vote "leave them the way they are" but only because I have a merchant toon that sells them. Purely self-interest on my part.

I also am NOT in favor of ANYKIND of coin cap on players. Again self-interest.

Author:  QPR [ Tue, Feb 24 2009, 19:11 PM ]
Post subject: 

Dont have much to say about heal potions, as I have no char with the level to actually benefit from them. However when it comes to the economy, the problem is that Amia, like all other servers, have a money-printing press (monsters) completely outside anyones control, which ensures a steady stream of gold into the economy that does not leave, except when players occasionally buy things form NPC merchants.

The only way to controll the IG economy is to set a fixed amount of gold aviable in the game, that is transferred in three pools; player, monster, merchant, and moving between the pools. So when the monster pool is empty, no gold from hunting, or when the merchant is empty, noone will buy the stuff you find.

This is ofcourse a tedious and demanding model that I doubt any sane world-builder would actually implement, but it gives me a feeling of sounding educated when i explain it.

Short answer; unless the DM's introduce heavy taxes and fees, the inflation will only rise.

Author:  krytellan [ Tue, Feb 24 2009, 19:23 PM ]
Post subject: 

I personally hate the idea of Heal potions, but then I have never had a boss farmer or epic soloer. I would be more in favor of increasing the cost of heal potions from 3k to like 100k (or somewhere in between). This would allow those people who want to use them to invest heavily and would ultimately lead to a decrease of gold in the system without affecting their ability to boss farm.

Also, and what I like most about the idea is that it makes clerics and rogues (for epic traps) more valuable and gives them a place in the epic society.

Therefore, to keep the integrity of the Salandran or other Heal potion crafters, the cost of making these potions should correlate with the cost of purchasing them.

Author:  fjook [ Tue, Feb 24 2009, 19:23 PM ]
Post subject: 

leave them alone


I have died while chuggin 5000 heal potions, I thhink my quick sloted ones ran out and I couldn't find them in my inventory. There are plenty of ways around this, sometimes you just need to be more clever. If you lead a guy over deadly traps, he wont live to chug heal potions. Just one idea.

Author:  Yossarin [ Tue, Feb 24 2009, 19:30 PM ]
Post subject: 

krytellan wrote:
I would be more in favor of increasing the cost of heal potions from 3k to like 100k


This thread is starting to turn me on. *Fans self* There's just something about spending money...

Author:  -Dark Faith- [ Tue, Feb 24 2009, 19:34 PM ]
Post subject: 

Talon wrote:
ILoveIceCream wrote:
you know...to get rid of the money problem.....if you havee more than 1 mil....you lose 75% of the current money you have...and if you have les you lose 50%....sounds like a good idea to me


Just arbitrarily? Yeah, that makes sense.


The spellplague did it.

D-Finitiy wrote:
Would that apply to the cleric spell too? Because if the potion were nerfed and the spell wasn't, clerics would become the new most-hated-class.


I highly doubt the cleric spell would get changed. The problem is people buying stacks of potions to survive and solo / whatever it is they do, not a class using one of their skills.

fjook wrote:
leave them alone


I have died while chuggin 5000 heal potions, I thhink my quick sloted ones ran out and I couldn't find them in my inventory. There are plenty of ways around this, sometimes you just need to be more clever. If you lead a guy over deadly traps, he wont live to chug heal potions. Just one idea.


And that's just kinda sad.

Author:  Xavier [ Tue, Feb 24 2009, 19:36 PM ]
Post subject: 

Don't touch my ****ing heal potions.

Never even joke about messing with my ****ing heal potions. I listen to death metal.

Author:  Dev Disco [ Tue, Feb 24 2009, 19:37 PM ]
Post subject: 

I could also put a little backfire chance on them? So they deep fry you and serve you with pickles instead of the expected lamer effect.

Author:  Neus Scario [ Tue, Feb 24 2009, 19:39 PM ]
Post subject: 

QPR wrote:
The only way to controll the IG economy is to set a fixed amount of gold aviable in the game, that is transferred in three pools; player, monster, merchant, and moving between the pools. So when the monster pool is empty, no gold from hunting, or when the merchant is empty, noone will buy the stuff you find.


No, this is needlessly complex. The only thing you need to do is keep a steady flow going out as even more comes in. This can be done in a bunch of ways that are both interesting and beneficial; for example, the Black Caravan events (assuming they take gold, which I assume they do, assumingly) would sink a good portion of gold every time the event is held and people buy something.

Author:  belgianbonzai [ Tue, Feb 24 2009, 19:42 PM ]
Post subject: 

add an intermediate for the same price and boost "full heal potion" cost to 100k or the likes

Intermediate being 100HP heal
or 30% of target HP heal
or something like 50HP + 2x "heal skill" HP (means it maxes out around 250HP in 1 round, giving an AoO, where a heal kit can be used on anybody and maxes a little over 100)

This gives low levels a chance of healing themself fully with same ease as now, but bossfarming/epic hunting a little harder

Author:  Jas [ Tue, Feb 24 2009, 19:47 PM ]
Post subject: 

What about removing heal potions and having heal kits heal 2 or 3 times the skill invested? (20base mod + 10 heal kit +20 roll) x 2 = 100hp for instance? Or is that too much scripting etc?

Its just that Im of the opinion that not everyone should have a portable Cleric in a bottle for literally no cost or investment.

Clerics get to heal to full hp which makes them valuable in a party vs a boss or in PvP. The balance comes with the limited spell slots. Unlike say, 30 heal potions with 90k. With the effect taking place in half a round and with no way to interrupt it save a timely KD, unlike the concentration check with a spell.

How heal potions cuts down on danger when adventuring isnt much of a problem but rather it steals the niche of a Cleric. And balance wise, the kind of tide turning ability should come with a relevant investment of skills/levels/feats.

Author:  Athyonn Ursidae [ Tue, Feb 24 2009, 19:47 PM ]
Post subject: 

I voted leave them be. Heal potions have nothing to do with the amount of gold floating around. If anything it is heal potions that keep this down.

Yes players with lots of gold can get up my nose, but at the end of the day they have worked hard at it for some point and they deserves the benefits of it (lucky sods). It is perfectly reasonable to have rich adventurers and merchants who corner the market places, such is real life.

If you were to ban them all that would happen is that you would see an increase in power builds just so as they would stand to get hurt as much.

Yes it may well be broke, but I dont think that this is the way to fix it. Leave the heal potions alone *votes*

Author:  555444333 [ Tue, Feb 24 2009, 19:50 PM ]
Post subject: 

555444333 wrote:
Leave it alone, ta.

Jan wrote:
LEAVE HEAL POTIONS ALONE!

Fjook wrote:
leave them alone

Talon wrote:
Don't fix what isn't broken


Quoted for emphasis.

Author:  Craig deathwalker [ Tue, Feb 24 2009, 20:34 PM ]
Post subject: 

Uberuce wrote:
It penalises the RP builds and the frontliners more than monsterbuilds and party leeches. Find some way around that and I'll say yay. Until then: nay.



As it stands right now, I know of a variety of players who are no powerbuild and are infact heavily leaning towards rp builds. These characters can solo epic bosses with effectiveness. There will never be a disadvantage for an rp build, they are a lot stronger than players give them credit for. So reducing the effectiveness of heal potions for rp builds is a mute point. Such builds will always have much more rewards playing amia than the majority of powerbuilds.


Quote:
I have died while chuggin 5000 heal potions, I thhink my quick sloted ones ran out and I couldn't find them in my inventory.


That to me sounds alot more like a poor use of gaming environment and is more an example as to why healing potions need this cap. If your able to chug numerous potions before finnaly dieing, it says that you should not have been in the area in the first place.

Quote:
It is only a penalty for me, personally, with no benefit since I never have any reason to PvP. I am torn between my desire to see everyone else suffer painfully and giving up a freedom I enjoy.


Yoss has base stats for dex and str of 8, yet he manages to solo nearly every boss on the server. I dont see a cap to heal potions as a major disadvantage to our leading rp build, who effectively farms bosses. More so parties would suit ol yoss more than his solo hunting with summons :) Unless hes a greedy git who doesnt like to share?


As far as I've seen the only people who are detesting a nerf are people who relly on the potions. To be frank we have a builders topic, it does not need to be used to create powerbuilds, but can be used to make RP builds. More so amia's challange setting is weak, if your really relying on potions so much to even hunt your at an extreme disadvantage and deserve to be spending -alot- more on potions.

Page 1 of 4 All times are UTC
Powered by phpBB® Forum Software © phpBB Group
http://www.phpbb.com/