AMIA ARCHIVE :: View topic - Running with sharp thingies

If you want to shove someone then emote and roll for it.

a level 1 sorcerer with 8 str is never gonna push a 30 orc barbarian with 30 base str.

My two golds.

Personally, it's also a pet peeve of mine. All adventurers should be disarmed in civilian populated area's anyway. So bloody hell, make it a law already.

If we are to discuss logic in a fantasy game, I also vote for any sharp body parts to be watted. Like horns, tails, dragon scales, spikes of whatever race ever set foot in Cordor East. Please, have all guards give out wadding.

Ultrinnan, if I remember correctly, has a no helm no unsheathed weapon policy.

Except in Bendir, there's nowhere to run too, so the complaint is pointless.

My two gp?

Get over it!

Except in Bendir, there's nowhere to run to, so the complaint is pointless.

You can take my sword when you pry it from my cold, dead hands!

Xavier wrote:

You can take my sword when you pry it from my cold, dead hands!

Funny you should say that....that gets done quite a bit in the Dale when people refuse lol

I like how people decide to post their slightly hostile comments, such as "stop whining" or "get over it" when all I was doing, is putting a -friendly- reminder up here.

Well I never take off my helm and I'm sure most people dont see me without my sheild and weapon out, but thats just who I am and have my reasons.

many servers have npc guards automatically tell you to put weapons away when seen out. Some that even attack after a certain amount of time. I'm not sure if they actually do, but the guards have threatened me... If the law is implemented, the npc thing would help greatly. wont stop them from running into you, but they won't be absentmindedly murdering

The point for me is that these people who don't have enough sense to put their weapon away don't even see it as an IC thing. They most often have an understanding of roleplay that leaves something to be desired.

What you propose is that an IC law be made to stop OOC newbies. Will they abide by it just because now it's a Cordor law? No chance in hell. Just like people not unsummoning familiars because they just were out hunting and plan to go do it again.

Putting IC laws up to make newbies and action gamers "polish up their act" will not work. What it will do is create a headache for everyone involved.

Some weapons such as staves, spears and some kind of large axes you just can't put away though. I don't know about you but I wouldn't want to clip a flail on my belt, there's a chance the knockers might smack you in the balls! Metal cups would be too uncomfortable to wear all the time.

I like how people decide to post their slightly hostile comments, such as "stop whining" or "get over it" when all I was doing, is putting a -friendly- reminder up here, to take into account that everything your character does, including running around like a crazed maniac with a sword, is an IC action, and IC actions have consequences. Seriously, this is more of a "hey lets try to remember to stay IC and make Amia better" than a complaint. Leave your unproductive comments at the door.

Edit:

hendrack wrote:

Also, no. No, this is not a good argument. I'll state again that "Fantasy" does not allow one to through suspension of disbelief, nor basic logic, out the window. You cannot use that argument for every single thing that comes up. It just doesn't work like that.

That's a reminder to everyone, by the way, not just the poster. There are limits, there is logic.

Depending on the character I have on, I remind them IC not to do it even if they are running and will probably miss the words. If they don't want to stay IC it's their loss, not mine. What I can do is try setting/being an example. *shrugs*

I also send a friendly Tell reminding them that running around with weapons drawn is supposedly dangerous especially if they are in a hurry, and that next time they should sheathe them just to avoid more OOC notes about it or an IC knockdown/PvP.

Do this. Try sending them a Tell reminding them of this. It's unlikely that the players who do that check the forums, thus, they will probably miss a reminder here.

putting a -friendly- reminder up here, to take into account that everything your character does, including running around like a crazed maniac with a sword, is an IC action, and IC actions have consequences. Seriously, this is more of a "hey lets try to remember to stay IC and make Amia better" .

Carter wrote:

Edit:

hendrack wrote:

True enough, but if we apply logic, we pwetty please apply the same logic everywhere, not just where it suits. Some PCs have so many spikes on their armor they could be member of the Gutbuster Brigade, should they wear their underwear in Bendir?

Edit:

Should a half-dragon be skinned because a child PC in Cordor may bump into them and poke their eye out? As I said, logic is dandy and all, but applying the same reasoning everywhere is the funny thing in a fantasy setting like Amia.

Author:	DarkAngelGirl [ Wed, Jan 14 2009, 11:31 AM ]
Post subject:	Running with sharp thingies
Just felt like going on a little mild rant here. Its interesting, I see people who just run around town with their weapons drawn, bumping into people, continuing on without even so much as a word, or a shoves their way past so and so. Just take into consideration that doing so could cause an accidental stabbing ICly, and the guards, at least in Cordor, would be all over you.

Author:	Zante [ Wed, Jan 14 2009, 12:02 PM ]
Post subject:
You should also consider that NWN hitboxes are larger than they realistically would be, in addition to the fact that you are not capable of finer movement and maneuvers when clicking from one place to another. In summary, lot of those bumping are not ic, but the result of imperfect game mechanics.

Author:	DarkAngelGirl [ Wed, Jan 14 2009, 12:04 PM ]
Post subject:
I know, but running with swords in hand, in town? Comeon.

Author:	Dakotaen [ Wed, Jan 14 2009, 12:04 PM ]
Post subject:
And who says it's accidental stabbings?

Author:	Yurell [ Wed, Jan 14 2009, 12:12 PM ]
Post subject:
Since you can walk, if I see someone run with weapons I assume that they're running or charging. It scares the crap out of my Svirf. EDIT: Although I accept bumping to be OOC like running or bumping if I'm told it is. Like "//no bump" and that sort of thing

AMIA ARCHIVE https://www.amiaworld.net/phpBB3/

Running with sharp thingies https://www.amiaworld.net/phpBB3/viewtopic.php?f=2&t=34276	Page 1 of 2

Author:	Uberuce [ Wed, Jan 14 2009, 12:37 PM ]
Post subject:
A fair amount of the time, the weapon in question with be that longsword with 4th and 5th bonus mage slots on it, Mythalled to +1 in their caster stat. I remember from my days in the Grove that most mages would very literally rather die than disarm. So we killed them.

Author:	HellScourge [ Wed, Jan 14 2009, 12:44 PM ]
Post subject:
Icu.. you should've disarmed them.. for real! OF with their arms! Does a The Queen impression from Alice in Wonderland OF with their arms! To the topic. Yeah, it annoys me too, but some people still just click some where and then charge though the masses even if they are standing at the sidewalk. Easy solution, build a fortress, one bench and one trable at the right places and people can't run into you at the edge of the Waukeen Temple anymore.

Author:	xordae [ Wed, Jan 14 2009, 13:11 PM ]
Post subject:
People do that because they're noobs, and Cordor is noobground. Where the wheat is separated from the chaff. Why you would complain IC, I can understand. OOC it just sounds like "I wish people wouldn't be such noobs".. with which I agree, but it's totally hopeless bringing it up. Offenders don't read the forums.

Author:	Terra_777 [ Wed, Jan 14 2009, 13:41 PM ]
Post subject:
If you want to shove someone then emote and roll for it. a level 1 sorcerer with 8 str is never gonna push a 30 orc barbarian with 30 base str. My two golds.

Author:	DarkAngelGirl [ Wed, Jan 14 2009, 13:51 PM ]
Post subject:
Terra_777 wrote: If you want to shove someone then emote and roll for it. a level 1 sorcerer with 8 str is never gonna push a 30 orc barbarian with 30 base str. My two golds. Well, they can sure try!

Author:	Sokar Rostau [ Wed, Jan 14 2009, 14:01 PM ]
Post subject:
Here's a novel idea. If you must loiter in Cordor don't do it outside of Waukeen's Temple where everybody that comes out has to bump into you. It seriously pisses me off when people do that and then complain when someone bumps them.

Author:	Gravemaskin [ Wed, Jan 14 2009, 14:10 PM ]
Post subject:
Well, the outside area of the Waukeen temple is a little fun I think.. I like to observe where people are going, and where they are walking. Like if people are going hunting, they tend to cut into the grass to save time.. if they are just walking somewhere to RP, they most of the time, walk along the cobbled street. It's a funny little observation I think, and it applies more places than that. As for running with weapons, I see the same tenancy there as well. people often run with shield and sword in hand when going to shops after hunting, or heading out. Some people walk slowly with swords. Some walk without swords at all. And when I see mages walk with swords, sometimes they actually make it a point to write that the sword is pointed downwards, so it won't cut anyone. If I drew a map of the street of Cordor, I'd do something like, designate the grass area around the temple as a small place for people to actually loiter. the same next to the potted tree. And sort of "draw" a street in, how I see it, and where I see people going. Think of it in real life.. if you're in a hurry, you just might cut into the grass to save a few extra seconds.. if people are standing there, talking.. you'll probably walk around.

Author:	Selvec Darkon [ Wed, Jan 14 2009, 14:32 PM ]
Post subject:
Personally, it's also a pet peeve of mine. All adventurers should be disarmed in civilian populated area's anyway. So bloody hell, make it a law already. Then there are us evil types, whom if we accidentally stab a couple of people as we run by, eh, no biggy.

Author:	Zanthair [ Wed, Jan 14 2009, 14:59 PM ]
Post subject:
Ultrinnan, if I remember correctly, has a no helm no unsheathed weapon policy.

Author:	maglorine [ Wed, Jan 14 2009, 15:36 PM ]
Post subject:
Come running thru Bendir with your flaming sword in your hand....................after barking at you with their tiny Hin voices and surrounding you with the sharp pointies they had tucked in their sleeves, the Lilliputians will have you hog-tied and sent back to Cordor as cargo on the next regularly scheduled Cart. The NPC's will be their usually statuesque selves but the PC's will all be dragging you down like a straggling water buffalo attacked by a pack of savage hyenas (Hinyenas?). Of course, Bendir is a Party PvP area so........I guess we're talking apples and oranges here.

Author:	Brown Blur [ Wed, Jan 14 2009, 16:42 PM ]
Post subject:
.....when Jayek would just tap his foot and NOT trade until they disarmed. Who the hell can count out coins and pick up large numbers of little bottles when they got their hands full of weapon and shield anyway? Anyway, other than saying that, I'm with Xordae and Carter....

Author:	hendrack [ Wed, Jan 14 2009, 15:19 PM ]
Post subject:
If we are to discuss logic in a fantasy game, I also vote for any sharp body parts to be watted. Like horns, tails, dragon scales, spikes of whatever race ever set foot in Cordor East. Please, have all guards give out wadding.

Author:	Carter [ Wed, Jan 14 2009, 15:21 PM ]
Post subject:
Selvec Darkon wrote: Personally, it's also a pet peeve of mine. All adventurers should be disarmed in civilian populated area's anyway. So bloody hell, make it a law already. I've said this for a good long time. It doesn't make any sense at all that adventurers (or anyone else, for that matter) would be allowed to hang around holding flailing their swords. I can't even think of a time in history that people in cities have been allowed to wield weapons publicly. Carry them in a scabbard or holster, sure, but not draw them, unless you count a very small percent of old west towns. Edit: hendrack wrote: If we are to discuss logic in a fantasy game, I also vote for any sharp body parts to be watted. Like horns, tails, dragon scales, spikes of whatever race ever set foot in Cordor East. Please, have all guards give out wadding. Also, no. No, this is not a good argument. I'll state again that "Fantasy" does not allow one to through suspension of disbelief, nor basic logic, out the window. You cannot use that argument for every single thing that comes up. It just doesn't work like that. That's a reminder to everyone, by the way, not just the poster. There are limits, there is logic.

Author:	ainjyll [ Wed, Jan 14 2009, 15:39 PM ]
Post subject:
Zanthair wrote: Ultrinnan, if I remember correctly, has a no helm no unsheathed weapon policy. Yeppers, as a general rule, no sharp pointy things and no helms. Edit: extremely gross mistype

Author:	555444333 [ Wed, Jan 14 2009, 15:41 PM ]
Post subject:
Except in Bendir, there's nowhere to run too, so the complaint is pointless. My two gp? Get over it!

Author:	hendrack [ Wed, Jan 14 2009, 15:49 PM ]
Post subject:
555444333 wrote: Except in Bendir, there's nowhere to run too, so the complaint is pointless. My two gp? Get over it! Hehe, go into Bendir with a drawn weapon.

Author:	Xavier [ Wed, Jan 14 2009, 15:52 PM ]
Post subject:
You can take my sword when you pry it from my cold, dead hands!

Author:	Bobo_Underhill [ Wed, Jan 14 2009, 15:58 PM ]
Post subject:
555444333 wrote: Except in Bendir, there's nowhere to run to, so the complaint is pointless. You'd be surprised how many people are so eager to run and speak to Jayek.

Author:	jenmeme [ Wed, Jan 14 2009, 18:41 PM ]
Post subject:
Xavier wrote: You can take my sword when you pry it from my cold, dead hands! Funny you should say that....that gets done quite a bit in the Dale when people refuse lol

Author:	HellScourge [ Wed, Jan 14 2009, 19:08 PM ]
Post subject:
hendrack wrote: If we are to discuss logic in a fantasy game, I also vote for any sharp body parts to be watted. Like horns, tails, dragon scales, spikes of whatever race ever set foot in Cordor East. Please, have all guards give out wadding. Corks for tails and horns to prevent accidental stabbing out! I so can see that and I find it hilarious. And the underdark is a completely different matter. I may say that we down there are sort of a bit elitic and enforce laws with power. On my defense, I enver knew there was such a policy down there, well the helmet one is clear, but the nos word one. never heard of that, yet I still did it because it was just the right thing I think.

Author:	Gunz [ Wed, Jan 14 2009, 19:36 PM ]
Post subject:
jenmeme wrote: Xavier wrote: You can take my sword when you pry it from my cold, dead hands! Funny you should say that....that gets done quite a bit in the Dale when people refuse lol ...Ahem... The way I look at it is really really simple. If someone runs by and bumps my character and doesn't emote it, I ignore it like it never happened. It's that simple. Truly. Try it. Sure it's annoying that people do it but hey, welcome of the world of online gaming. Bumping is instant and ignorable. It's not like when people mindlessly, habitually, or purposefully walk around somewhere like the Dale with a weapon drawn. That lasts the whole time they're there so something gets done either way. My character gives them three very simple and logical options: 1) Put it away and go on about your business, no harm no foul. 2) Leave. Alright, so you want to keep in out? Fine, get out. Not all that big of a deal if they just walk. 3) I'll make you leave. Drag you out with RP or if you want to be a tough guy and fight, I'll drag your corpse out. I think it's fair enough. More importantly, that simply the way she does things when people don't listen to the laws of the Dale or the "laws of nature." ::shrug::

Author:	DarkAngelGirl [ Wed, Jan 14 2009, 20:25 PM ]
Post subject:
I like how people decide to post their slightly hostile comments, such as "stop whining" or "get over it" when all I was doing, is putting a -friendly- reminder up here, to take into account that everything your character does, including running around like a crazed maniac with a sword, is an IC action, and IC actions have consequences. Seriously, this is more of a "hey lets try to remember to stay IC and make Amia better" than a complaint. Leave your unproductive comments at the door.

Author:	Kamina [ Wed, Jan 14 2009, 21:06 PM ]
Post subject:
DarkAngelGirl wrote: I like how people decide to post their slightly hostile comments, such as "stop whining" or "get over it" when all I was doing, is putting a -friendly- reminder up here. Deja vu.

Author:	xordae [ Wed, Jan 14 2009, 21:46 PM ]
Post subject:
The point for me is that these people who don't have enough sense to put their weapon away don't even see it as an IC thing. They most often have an understanding of roleplay that leaves something to be desired. What you propose is that an IC law be made to stop OOC newbies. Will they abide by it just because now it's a Cordor law? No chance in hell. Just like people not unsummoning familiars because they just were out hunting and plan to go do it again. Putting IC laws up to make newbies and action gamers "polish up their act" will not work. What it will do is create a headache for everyone involved.

Author:	Yurell [ Wed, Jan 14 2009, 21:52 PM ]
Post subject:
IMO if you are carrying your weapons and running about you are ICly carrying your weapons and running about. Although newbs can be forgiven for not knowing.

Author:	Basin [ Wed, Jan 14 2009, 21:52 PM ]
Post subject:
It's one of those things that wont change, just ignore it.

Author:	BlackDahlya [ Wed, Jan 14 2009, 22:52 PM ]
Post subject:
Depending on the character I have on, I remind them IC not to do it even if they are running and will probably miss the words. If they don't want to stay IC it's their loss, not mine. What I can do is try setting/being an example. shrugs I also send a friendly Tell reminding them that running around with weapons drawn is supposedly dangerous especially if they are in a hurry, and that next time they should sheathe them just to avoid more OOC notes about it or an IC knockdown/PvP. Do this. Try sending them a Tell reminding them of this. It's unlikely that the players who do that check the forums, thus, they will probably miss a reminder here.

Author:	Galenson [ Wed, Jan 14 2009, 23:34 PM ]
Post subject:
Some weapons such as staves, spears and some kind of large axes you just can't put away though. I don't know about you but I wouldn't want to clip a flail on my belt, there's a chance the knockers might smack you in the balls! Metal cups would be too uncomfortable to wear all the time.

Author:	Uncle-Opustus [ Wed, Jan 14 2009, 23:38 PM ]
Post subject:
Strap the big weapon on your back? Although, strapping a heavy flail on your back isn't a smart idea.

Author:	corypx [ Wed, Jan 14 2009, 23:59 PM ]
Post subject:
Well I never take off my helm and I'm sure most people dont see me without my sheild and weapon out, but thats just who I am and have my reasons.

Author:	soundofastream [ Thu, Jan 15 2009, 0:52 AM ]
Post subject:
Hmm Illithira only cares when they wave their weapons around menacingly. They wouldn't bump into her as she'd just likely jump out the way as a reflex action. Pork, most people would bounce off him and weapons would likely too...Eventually, he'd notice them as he looks down and then, he'd probably carve them up with his axe and eat them. nods sagely This is probably why Pork is hardly ever seen in Cordor, too many noobs would become Pork's dinner. The guards most likely don't let him into Cordor much. In both instances, I have RP reasons why not to get upset with noobs running into my toons. If they try it with Pork out of Cordor, they become lunch. If they try it with Illithira, they IC'ly wouldn't be able to, she's too agile.