| AMIA ARCHIVE https://www.amiaworld.net/phpBB3/ |
|
| Shapeshifting and Storks https://www.amiaworld.net/phpBB3/viewtopic.php?f=2&t=31687 |
Page 1 of 2 |
| Author: | Slig [ Sat, Oct 04 2008, 16:01 PM ] |
| Post subject: | Shapeshifting and Storks |
I'm curious. If a character shapeshifts from one race into another and has sex, for example a human shifter shapeshifts into a drow and does the wild thing with another drow, will it result in a baby drow? |
|
| Author: | Ts_ [ Sat, Oct 04 2008, 16:18 PM ] |
| Post subject: | |
Wasn't there a discussion on this already? Like shifter + DNA? I don't thing one side won the argument, but anyway. Here's the link: http://www.amiaworld.net/phpBB2/viewtop ... dna#451650 Regards Ts PS: Protip: Just don't ;) |
|
| Author: | Dwagin [ Sat, Oct 04 2008, 16:20 PM ] |
| Post subject: | |
Nobleman wrote: Just because you're shapeshifted doesn't make it legal!
|
|
| Author: | Slig [ Sat, Oct 04 2008, 16:38 PM ] |
| Post subject: | |
Okay. Say a shifter changes into an ooze, eats lots of stuff then splits into two oozes. Are there now two shifters, or is the ooze essentially the shifter's offspring? |
|
| Author: | Colapops [ Sat, Oct 04 2008, 16:39 PM ] |
| Post subject: | |
Why would you even ask this question why would you even consider it in the first place are you some sort of bestiality funky hamdang dingdong enthusiast |
|
| Author: | Slig [ Sat, Oct 04 2008, 16:44 PM ] |
| Post subject: | |
Chillmarrow wrote: Why would you even ask this question why would you even consider it in the first place are you some sort of bestiality funky hamdang dingdong enthusiast
Who mentioned animals? I think you'll find that was you, my dear. |
|
| Author: | Colapops [ Sat, Oct 04 2008, 16:45 PM ] |
| Post subject: | |
Human != drow. That's bestiality. |
|
| Author: | Slig [ Sat, Oct 04 2008, 16:47 PM ] |
| Post subject: | |
Chillmarrow wrote: Human != drow. That's bestiality. No, I'm afraid it isn't. Quote: bes·ti·al·i·ty (bsch-l-t, bs-)
n. pl. bes·ti·al·i·ties 1. The quality or condition of being an animal or like an animal. 2. Conduct or an action marked by depravity or brutality. 3. Sexual relations between a human and an animal. Above quote from, The American Heritage® Dictionary of the English Language |
|
| Author: | Colapops [ Sat, Oct 04 2008, 16:59 PM ] |
| Post subject: | |
Humans and drow are not the same species. That's bestiality. A human and human is fine; a drow and drow is fine; an orc and an orc is a spork. But mixing them, no matter how similar they are, is bestiality whether the participants are animal-like or not. This isn't Earth, where humans are the only 'non-animal' species; Toril's got so many intelligent creatures you could sleep around and go from picking hair to chitin, scales, bone, feathers or sludge from between your teeth. |
|
| Author: | Brown Blur [ Sat, Oct 04 2008, 17:09 PM ] |
| Post subject: | |
Spork! |
|
| Author: | Gravemaskin [ Sat, Oct 04 2008, 17:09 PM ] |
| Post subject: | |
Then most of Amia have commited bestiality, and it's not an issue at all |
|
| Author: | xordae [ Sat, Oct 04 2008, 17:19 PM ] |
| Post subject: | |
I think it was argued that a shifter turning into anything else but his original form can be treated as sterile. |
|
| Author: | Yurell [ Sat, Oct 04 2008, 17:39 PM ] |
| Post subject: | Re: Shapeshifting and Storks |
Slig wrote: I'm curious. If a character shapeshifts from one race into another and has sex, for example a human shifter shapeshifts into a drow and does the wild thing with another drow, will it result in a baby drow?
The short answer is possibly. The long answer is read the Book of Erotic Fantasy. A note on this - see if you can get one with text only, unless you don't mind pictures of the nature the book's title suggests. |
|
| Author: | Colapops [ Sat, Oct 04 2008, 17:41 PM ] |
| Post subject: | Re: Shapeshifting and Storks |
Yurell wrote: The long answer is read the Book of Erotic Fantasy. A note on this - see if you can get one with text only, unless you don't mind pictures of the nature the book's title suggests.
That's not official! It has no more credibility than a homeless man taken off the street! |
|
| Author: | Yurell [ Sat, Oct 04 2008, 17:42 PM ] |
| Post subject: | |
No but it made it through the publishers, who had to check that the information was reasonable enough so that there would be no retaliation by WoTC |
|
| Author: | Colapops [ Sat, Oct 04 2008, 17:51 PM ] |
| Post subject: | |
I'd point out the faulty logic there but here's a better question: why do you even own the Book of Erotic Fantasy in the first place? |
|
| Author: | Yurell [ Sat, Oct 04 2008, 17:54 PM ] |
| Post subject: | |
I don't - one of my friends gave me theirs to read while I was looking up the life cycle of elves for another thread on this forum. And I'm not going to get into an argument with you about what is considered canon and what isn't unless you create a thread specifically for the purpose, or a DM specifically lists books that are canon. |
|
| Author: | Colapops [ Sat, Oct 04 2008, 18:00 PM ] |
| Post subject: | |
That just leads to further questions such as "why would you be friends with that person" and "why would you admit to being friends with someone who owns the BoEF?" |
|
| Author: | Xaviera [ Sat, Oct 04 2008, 18:00 PM ] |
| Post subject: | |
Chillmarrow wrote: why do you even own the Book of Erotic Fantasy in the first place?
Because it's amusing, Chill. Why would someone get intimate with a giant stuffed bear? |
|
| Author: | D-Finitiy [ Sat, Oct 04 2008, 18:00 PM ] |
| Post subject: | |
Chillmarrow wrote: Humans and drow are not the same species. That's bestiality. A human and human is fine; a drow and drow is fine; an orc and an orc is a spork. But mixing them, no matter how similar they are, is bestiality whether the participants are animal-like or not.
Super! Thanks for contributing. |
|
| Author: | Colapops [ Sat, Oct 04 2008, 18:01 PM ] |
| Post subject: | |
Xaviera wrote: Because it's amusing, Chill. Why would someone get intimate with a giant stuffed bear?
Because corrupting the innocent and defenseless gets me feeling raunchy. |
|
| Author: | Yurell [ Sat, Oct 04 2008, 18:03 PM ] |
| Post subject: | |
Chillmarrow wrote: That just leads to further questions such as "why would you be friends with that person" and "why would you admit to being friends with someone who owns the BoEF?"
Don't you have anything better to do than spam forums insulting myself or my friends? |
|
| Author: | Colapops [ Sat, Oct 04 2008, 18:09 PM ] |
| Post subject: | |
Shoot, I don't know about you but I'm having fun here. |
|
| Author: | Yurell [ Sat, Oct 04 2008, 18:10 PM ] |
| Post subject: | |
Well, it stops being a debate and becomes an argument when you start hurling personal insults. |
|
| Author: | Xaviera [ Sat, Oct 04 2008, 18:11 PM ] |
| Post subject: | |
Chillmarrow wrote: Humans and drow are not the same species. That's bestiality. A human and human is fine; a drow and drow is fine; an orc and an orc is a spork. But mixing them, no matter how similar they are, is bestiality whether the participants are animal-like or not. If one adopts one of the more common definitions of 'species' (about which there is debate in the scientific community) then those who are able to successfully interbreed are members of the same species, and thus considering it as bestiality is incorrect. Humans may be homo sapiens sapiens, elves homo sapiens sylvanus, or whatever (cf. the Shadowrun game). Now, things like humans and dragons are obviously of different species, and this is where the technical questions of genetic recombination come in. Whatever the genetic material in D&D, it cant be straight DNA or any non-conspecific pairing would be sterile. It is obviously susceptible to magical alteration. Whether polymorph or shapechange bestows fertility with the species into which you change is another question - polymorph might not, shapechange might. I've tended to assume that a shapechange does bestow fertillity via a change in the genetic material as appropriate to the new form, but you need to hold the shape for ~24 hrs to allow fusion of sperm and egg otherwise the genetic material changes back to its original form and thus will not form a zygote. IMO, naturally. Yurell wrote: Well, it stops being a debate and becomes an argument when you start hurling personal insults.
Agreed. You do tend to overdo it on occasion, Chill. |
|
| Author: | Yurell [ Sat, Oct 04 2008, 18:14 PM ] |
| Post subject: | |
I'd imagine you'd need to hold the shape the entire pregnancy - changing forms might make your bodies immune system reject the creature, especially in creatures that couldn't normally interbreed. |
|
| Author: | Colapops [ Sat, Oct 04 2008, 18:17 PM ] |
| Post subject: | |
But humans and elves have drastically different sources of creation and as such they are not part of the same species or any variation/mutation thereof; they're utterly, entirely separate. The fact that they are able to interbreed successfully is explained as "magic" and not "genetics." There was no antediluvian protoplasm or primordial soup. In this world, humans are not animals because they did not evolve--they were created. Everything was created and as such the only relation species have to one another are touchy at best. In other words, humans are as genetically different from elves as they are from dragons. |
|
| Author: | Yurell [ Sat, Oct 04 2008, 18:21 PM ] |
| Post subject: | |
I could so see that in a poll "Is a human sleeping with an elf bestiality?" As for whether it is beastiality, Chill does have a point that it can be explained by magic. Although if you can have them both in a dead magic zone and successfully interbreed then everything going on is mundane and it would, by technical definition, not be bestiality. |
|
| Author: | TormakSaber [ Sat, Oct 04 2008, 19:39 PM ] |
| Post subject: | |
A shifted shifter is sterile in anything but their own form. Drop the arguements and the insults, all of you. |
|
| Author: | Ts_ [ Sat, Oct 04 2008, 20:17 PM ] |
| Post subject: | |
TormakSaber wrote: A shifted shifter is sterile in anything but their own form.
Thanks, that takes such a weight off me. She claimed it was mine and the paternity test results got lost in an interdimensional-hole to 20th century Earth. Ts PS: One more lock can't hurt, can it? Edit: 1/10 typos fixed. |
|
| Author: | TormakSaber [ Sat, Oct 04 2008, 20:18 PM ] |
| Post subject: | |
No, might as well leave one open for peacefu l discussion and to allow m to smack the next person that tries to pass off the Book of Erotic Fantasy as canon when it's not, I don't care what publishers it had to pass. |
|
| Author: | papaya taco [ Sat, Oct 04 2008, 20:22 PM ] |
| Post subject: | |
Slig wrote: Okay. Say a shifter changes into an ooze, eats lots of stuff then splits into two oozes. Are there now two shifters, or is the ooze essentially the shifter's offspring?
I would imagine, if a shifted ooze really can split, when the ooze shifts back to its original form, the shifter would be in two pieces - a state which playable races cannot usually survive. I have no source to back that up, but I seriously doubt that any sort of game balance would let there suddenly be two shifters where once there was one, just by eating stuff while shapeshifted. |
|
| Author: | Yurell [ Sat, Oct 04 2008, 20:25 PM ] |
| Post subject: | |
May I ask why they're sterile in that case? |
|
| Author: | TormakSaber [ Sat, Oct 04 2008, 20:36 PM ] |
| Post subject: | |
My personal answer is "because it's just easier that way". Because then you dn't need to get into arguements like if the child is some other race or a mix or if it happened or size differences or if it dies or if you do this or that or whatever. |
|
| Author: | Yurell [ Sat, Oct 04 2008, 20:39 PM ] |
| Post subject: | |
So for gameplay not any particular IC reason? |
|
| Author: | TormakSaber [ Sat, Oct 04 2008, 20:46 PM ] |
| Post subject: | |
Stop trying to make me look like the bad guy with loaded wording just because I said your book isn't canon. IC, fine, you want genetics, here we go: Sperm can only survive at a very specific temperature and alkalinity, same for the female eggs. When you shift, you are throwing this delicate chemical and temperature balance entirely out of whack, forcibly sterilizing yourself, be you male or female. When you return to your normal form, you are reclaiming your originial biochemistry and thus your internal repoductive functions return to normal in regards to impregnating others. If you want to pop a chub while you're in Drow form when you're normally human and have sex, that's not my problem, but you won't get Drow kids out of it, or even Half Drow kids. You won't get any kids, actually. Honestly I can only think of two viable reasons why yopu would want to have children when in shifted form, or rather, be able to, in such at you "produce your seed". 1 is rape. I will hunt you down and destroy you for this. 2 is because you want to set yourself up for some god forbidden oddball exotic race combination as the child, that you then feel entitled to play because it's special and it's part of your character's legacy and it'd be super cool and magical. I will hunt you down and destroy you for this as well. |
|
| Author: | Yurell [ Sat, Oct 04 2008, 20:53 PM ] |
| Post subject: | |
1. Not trying to make you the bad guy - if it's an OOC reason characters can still debate it IC, if it's an IC reason, then there's no debate because our characters know it can't happen. 2. I don't give a damn about the book, I just brought it up because it is actually designed for this sort of thing; I don't think it's canon, I just refuse to argue with Chillmarrow about it, just useful guidelines from people who are obviously sad enough to spend a large amount of time writing about it 3. I was assuming the decision is an absolute from the DM team, not just your unilateral response, so once again I just wanted clarification for 1. As for your response: 1. The idea of rape is just disgusting 2. I would assume any child is of the shifted form as I find it hard to believe that every part of your body would shift except your reproductive organs. |
|
| Author: | TormakSaber [ Sat, Oct 04 2008, 20:58 PM ] |
| Post subject: | |
Quote: 2. I would assume any child is of the shifted form as I find it hard to believe that every part of your body would shift except your reproductive organs. Quote: If you want to pop a chub while you're in Drow form when you're normally human and have sex, that's not my problem, but you won't get Drow kids out of it, or even Half Drow kids. You won't get any kids, actually.
|
|
| Author: | Yurell [ Sat, Oct 04 2008, 21:00 PM ] |
| Post subject: | |
I know you won't get any kids, I was just explaining why your two 'reasons' were invalid as far as it's reference to me by your use of second-person terminology. |
|
| Author: | TormakSaber [ Sat, Oct 04 2008, 21:03 PM ] |
| Post subject: | |
I'm not sure why you keep trying to separate this into IC and OOC and be able to "debate" about it. Obviously enough shifters on Amia are having sex in alternate forms so as to keep you up at night and make this a valid question to ask,so the distinct *lack* of shifter kids should be enough to tell you that a Shfter not in their normal form is sterile and incapable of having children. Why does this even matter. How often are you cybering that you REALLY need to know if you can screw a Fey, a Minotaur, a Drow, and a Dragon and successfully produce same race children with all of them? |
|
| Author: | Dwagin [ Sat, Oct 04 2008, 21:15 PM ] |
| Post subject: | |
For half dragons I always thought that it involved liberal uses of 'Enlarge' and 'Shrink' magic. |
|
| Author: | Yurell [ Sat, Oct 04 2008, 21:20 PM ] |
| Post subject: | |
TormakSaber wrote: Why does this even matter.
How often are you cybering that you REALLY need to know if you can screw a Fey, a Minotaur, a Drow, and a Dragon and successfully produce same race children with all of them? Exactly zero, is was just an academic question. |
|
| Author: | Colapops [ Sat, Oct 04 2008, 21:20 PM ] |
| Post subject: | |
fffff f uuuhh furriessssssss |
|
| Author: | Slig [ Sat, Oct 04 2008, 21:21 PM ] |
| Post subject: | |
I did actually read the book of erotic fantasy before posting this. I'm actually a little ashamed to say that. In any case, there was no mention that I could find. |
|
| Author: | Yurell [ Sat, Oct 04 2008, 21:24 PM ] |
| Post subject: | |
Slig wrote: I did actually read the book of erotic fantasy before posting this. I'm actually a little ashamed to say that.
In any case, there was no mention that I could find. So long as you're reading it for theoretical research and not actually intending to use it / read it for pleasure there's no reason to feel ashamed. But you have your unequivocal answer - no child whatsoever. |
|
| Author: | xdrone561x [ Sat, Oct 04 2008, 21:34 PM ] |
| Post subject: | |
TormakSaber wrote: Why does this even matter. How often are you cybering that you REALLY need to know if you can screw a Fey, a Minotaur, a Drow, and a Dragon and successfully produce same race children with all of them? this is by far the most amusing thing ive read all day. Kudos to Tormak! |
|
| Author: | Slig [ Sat, Oct 04 2008, 21:47 PM ] |
| Post subject: | |
I was lead to believe roleplaying sex was frowned upon on this server. I don't plan on doing it myself, as I said I was merely curious. In any case, my assumption was that if a child could be made of a shapeshifter and a creature of another race then it would be born as a full blooded child of the race both creatures were when it was conceived, not some bizarre mix of the two. As for why it matters, as part of a backstory a shapeshifter could have a child of another race than their own via an intimate moment while shapeshifted. It's not incredibly important but knowing what's possible and what's not is essential to building a good backstory. |
|
| Author: | Swallow the Stars [ Sat, Oct 04 2008, 22:46 PM ] |
| Post subject: | |
Quote: Alright, guys - there's a reason fantasy and science are two different entities. Stop trying to blend the concepts of DNA, genetics, heredity, and anything else to do with cellular biology and fantasy. They don't blend. They won't blend. You won't be able to answer every (or often any) questions about it. That's what it's fantasy - it's fantastic. It's justification is "It's magic!", and that's all that it needs.
Secondly, one could not assume that a character who shapeshifts has a DNA change or a lack thereof. First, the only reason half-dragons exist in the world of Dungeons and Dragons is because of polymorph - which, by the way, shifting is polymorphing as a supernatural ability instead of a spell; no difference in its nature, just in its mechanics. Therefore, the deoxyribonucleic acid of dragons doesn't change. Then again, the genetic material of dragons blends with that of elves, humans, orcs, half-orcs, and God-only-knows what else. According to the science we're all trying to force onto Dungeons and Dragons, any two creatures that can mate and have a fertile child are the same species. If you want to put science into Amia, you have to admit that every "race", "subrace", and even most "monsters" are all the same species. Thus, dragons are as different from humans as orientals are from caucasians. That, in and of itself, is (censored)ing retarded. Point: It shouldn't matter. As Tormy says, don't be cyberin' it up and this isn't a problem. Besides, bestiality in cybering is a whole new level of eff'd. |
|
| Author: | D-Finitiy [ Sat, Oct 04 2008, 23:37 PM ] |
| Post subject: | |
This is kind of on topic: If someone shifted into, say, dragon form, eats something really big, like a cow, what happens when they shift back to their normal form? Do they find their body stretched around a dead cow? I don't really need this question answered, but if anyone wants to shoot, please do. Wait, if this topic covers "food babies" then it is on topic. |
|
| Author: | Yurell [ Sat, Oct 04 2008, 23:53 PM ] |
| Post subject: | |
I would think that the cow would just disappear magically for gameplay, not sure what would 'really' happen though. |
|
| Page 1 of 2 | All times are UTC |
| Powered by phpBB® Forum Software © phpBB Group http://www.phpbb.com/ |
|