|
|
|
bluntpencil2001
|
Posted: Sat, Jan 02 2010, 23:56 PM |
|
|

Player
Joined: 12 Nov 2009 Location: Scotland
|
o0GuNz_N_RoSeZ0o wrote: You have to remember that all these "Lawful Good Orcs" you're talking about are really actually Half Orcs. Orcs are a platinum coin race here. It's tons more believable and likely that Half Orcs would be lawful and/or good. They have Human blood, after all.
Likewise, a Half-Orc would be more believable as more intelligent than their Orc cousin. The Human blood can very well have had the upper hand there.
As for CE Dwarves, Abbathor. Need I say more? It's possible, just not likely.
Actually, Orcs and Half-Orcs both have -2 Intelligence and -2 Charisma. Orcs, however, also have -2 Wisdom. This means that both are just as intelligent, a maximum of 16 INT at level 1.
Also, and although I hate the Book of Exalted Deeds in general (the fact that it has mechanics for good diseases and redeeming villains by simply rolling dice bothers me), the chapter on virtue and good qualities (a decent chapter, getting across what the alignment of 'good' means) mentions this...
Page 8, Book of Exalted Deeds,
"On the other hand a good character approaches every encounter with orcs, goblinoids and even the thoroughly evil drow with heart and mind open to the possibility, however remote, that his opponents may be transformed into allies. Creatures that are "usually evil" can be redeemed.
This is not to say that a good character's first thought in an ambush should be, "How can I redeem these poor orcs?" However, if the ambushing orcs end up surrendering, there is ample opportunity to seek their redemption."
Hell, it also even states that there is a tiny glimmer of hope for redeeming chromatic dragons, too, who are listed as "Always Evil".
So, yeah, I'm playing my Paladin character as not only Lawful Good, but Exalted too, it seems. :s
As a side note, I am unsure as to whether aberrations such as Aboleths, Mind Flayers and the like, which are listed as "Usually Evil" can be redeemed properly, due to them having utterly alien mindsets. Perhaps it is possible, but not for a mortal player character.
|
|
|
|
 |
|
Galenson
|
Posted: Sun, Jan 03 2010, 0:29 AM |
|
|

Player
Joined: 26 May 2006 Location: Down Under, calculating your demise with blunt expressions.
|
o0GuNz_N_RoSeZ0o wrote: Likewise, a Half-Orc would be more believable as more intelligent than their Orc cousin. The Human blood can very well have had the upper hand there.
Not always. Grey Orcs and Orogs are both intelligent in their own right, the former nearly destroyed two human Empires (with Gruumsh anihilating a good portion of both Pantheons single handedly) and the latter being Underdark dwellers who often end up leading the tribes on the surface.
This thread's going nowhere unfortunately. It's a typical good Drow vs evil Drow debate and the answer is: open the possibility and people will take it. As lame as it is, that's how Amia operates. In saying that though, ICly my character will go out of his way to butcher good orcs or those he deems weak as its a greater crime then the existence of the elves. You have been warned.
_________________ Plays:
"I'll think of something once Amia:EE drops."
Last edited by Galenson on Sun, Jan 03 2010, 0:40 AM, edited 1 time in total.
|
|
|
|
 |
|
bluntpencil2001
|
Posted: Sun, Jan 03 2010, 0:38 AM |
|
|

Player
Joined: 12 Nov 2009 Location: Scotland
|
|
Personally, I never play good monster races, as they don't sit right with me, although I was tempted to play a Kobold Paladin of Bahamut...
The problem I find is that people forget that good characters should show mercy and forgiveness, even to monstrous things, and tell me that my paladin should fall for trying to redeem villains instead of chopping them up. Sure, it's very difficult, but so is killing dragons. Heroes do difficult things. Converting Orcs from Evil to Good? Sure, that's hellishly difficult, but so is heading into the Abyss to kick demon ass.
EDIT: Looking at the BoED again, on page 17, there's a picture of a redeemed Mind Flayer, so that answers my wondering about aberrations.
|
|
|
|
 |
|
Yurell
|
Posted: Sun, Jan 03 2010, 0:43 AM |
|
|

Player
Joined: 06 Jan 2008 Location: ANU, behind the coffee mug (+10 GMT)
|
bluntpencil2001 wrote: Personally, I never play good monster races, as they don't sit right with me, although I was tempted to play a Kobold Paladin of Bahamut...
The problem I find is that people forget that good characters should show mercy and forgiveness, even to monstrous things, and tell me that my paladin should fall for trying to redeem villains instead of chopping them up. Sure, it's very difficult, but so is killing dragons. Heroes do difficult things. Converting Orcs from Evil to Good? Sure, that's hellishly difficult, but so is heading into the Abyss to kick demon ass.
EDIT: Looking at the BoED again, on page 17, there's a picture of a redeemed Mind Flayer, so that answers my wondering about aberrations.
There's a big leap between Exalted and Good characters.
_________________ 2009's Second Most Overall Contributing Player
يمكنني استخدام مترجم جوجل
|
|
|
|
 |
|
bluntpencil2001
|
Posted: Sun, Jan 03 2010, 0:47 AM |
|
|

Player
Joined: 12 Nov 2009 Location: Scotland
|
Yurell wrote: bluntpencil2001 wrote: Personally, I never play good monster races, as they don't sit right with me, although I was tempted to play a Kobold Paladin of Bahamut...
The problem I find is that people forget that good characters should show mercy and forgiveness, even to monstrous things, and tell me that my paladin should fall for trying to redeem villains instead of chopping them up. Sure, it's very difficult, but so is killing dragons. Heroes do difficult things. Converting Orcs from Evil to Good? Sure, that's hellishly difficult, but so is heading into the Abyss to kick demon ass.
EDIT: Looking at the BoED again, on page 17, there's a picture of a redeemed Mind Flayer, so that answers my wondering about aberrations. There's a big leap between Exalted and Good characters.
Correct, although it does state that, generally, Paladins are exalted.
A good character can do evil deeds, can be intolerant, et cetera et cetera, so long as he is mostly good. An Exalted character, like most Paladins, are good all the time and do no evil.
|
|
|
|
 |
|
Yurell
|
Posted: Sun, Jan 03 2010, 0:49 AM |
|
|

Player
Joined: 06 Jan 2008 Location: ANU, behind the coffee mug (+10 GMT)
|
bluntpencil2001 wrote: Yurell wrote: There's a big leap between Exalted and Good characters. Correct, although it does state that, generally, Paladins are exalted. A good character can do evil deeds, can be intolerant, et cetera et cetera, so long as he is mostly good. An Exalted character, like most Paladins, are good all the time and do no evil.
They are not. Paladins are generally LG.
_________________ 2009's Second Most Overall Contributing Player
يمكنني استخدام مترجم جوجل
|
|
|
|
 |
|
bluntpencil2001
|
Posted: Sun, Jan 03 2010, 0:49 AM |
|
|

Player
Joined: 12 Nov 2009 Location: Scotland
|
Yurell wrote: bluntpencil2001 wrote: Yurell wrote: There's a big leap between Exalted and Good characters. Correct, although it does state that, generally, Paladins are exalted. A good character can do evil deeds, can be intolerant, et cetera et cetera, so long as he is mostly good. An Exalted character, like most Paladins, are good all the time and do no evil. They are not. Paladins are generally LG.
They are always LG, there is no generally about it... and can do no evil deeds. Period.
They can't do even tiny evils. No evil. At all. That sounds pretty exalted, and the following passage agrees that a large proportion of pallies are exalted.
BoED page 19,
"If 'Exalted Barbarian' sounds like an oxymoron, 'Exalted Paladin' probably sounds redundant. All paladins, of course, are called to be exemplars of the LG alignment, and to the extent that they succeed, they are among the finest examples of exalted PCs as well."
A paladin can Fall without changing his alignment for something as simple as lying, or committing a minor evil, even with good intent. A lawful good Paladin that lies once falls, it doesn't make him change his alignment, though. If a Paladin hasn't fallen, he's basically shoed into being exalted.
EDIT: Also note that the passages I quoted earlier state "A good character does X..." as opposed to "An exalted character does X..."
|
|
|
|
 |
|
Galenson
|
Posted: Sun, Jan 03 2010, 1:02 AM |
|
|

Player
Joined: 26 May 2006 Location: Down Under, calculating your demise with blunt expressions.
|
|
Great, all we need is Iron and this is a book worm fest.
_________________ Plays:
"I'll think of something once Amia:EE drops."
|
|
|
|
 |
|
Yurell
|
Posted: Sun, Jan 03 2010, 1:05 AM |
|
|

Player
Joined: 06 Jan 2008 Location: ANU, behind the coffee mug (+10 GMT)
|
|
Okay Blunt, let me pose you this question - would an Exalted character lose his Exalted status for condoning and promoting slavery?
_________________ 2009's Second Most Overall Contributing Player
يمكنني استخدام مترجم جوجل
|
|
|
|
 |
|
Kjetta
|
Posted: Sun, Jan 03 2010, 1:09 AM |
|
|

Player
Joined: 11 Nov 2006 Location: A Clean, Well-Lighted Place
|
|
Not caring much about lore, I share the sentiment that it would be much cooler if more adventurers acted nastily towards the monsterous races.
Most adventurers are just too nice, I suspect due to not wanting or being able to disengage from their OOC social needs. Some of the best RPers on Amia, I find, are those that manage to portray heroic bastards. Love that.
Don't mind the "learn 2 play" style either, btw: a quick, elitist and disdainful post can be good, IMO! I imagine it would take forever to write up a whole section of lore, and it seems quite needless when all you want to say is: Orcs in Faerun are not Orcs in Warhammer, or whatever.
_________________ To err is human; to forgive divine, but VENGEANCE IS MINE!

|
|
|
|
 |
|
Gunz
|
Posted: Sun, Jan 03 2010, 1:30 AM |
|
|

Player
Joined: 01 Jul 2006 Location: The City of Fallen Angels, Ca
|
bluntpencil2001 wrote: Actually, Orcs and Half-Orcs both have -2 Intelligence and -2 Charisma. Orcs, however, also have -2 Wisdom. This means that both are just as intelligent, a maximum of 16 INT at level 1. That doesn't mean they can't be smart. A human has no modifier to intelligence and some of the most intelligent humanoids in the realms are Human. All that the modifier suggests is that they would be smarter if they were all Human, by two points. That's it. Galenson wrote: o0GuNz_N_RoSeZ0o wrote: Likewise, a Half-Orc would be more believable as more intelligent than their Orc cousin. The Human blood can very well have had the upper hand there. Not always. Grey Orcs and Orogs are both intelligent in their own right, the former nearly destroyed two human Empires (with Gruumsh anihilating a good portion of both Pantheons single handedly) and the latter being Underdark dwellers who often end up leading the tribes on the surface. I didn't say always. I suggested it as possible. Kjetta wrote: I share the sentiment that it would be much cooler if more adventurers acted nastily towards the monsterous races. Most adventurers are just too nice, I suspect due to not wanting or being able to disengage from their OOC social needs. Some of the best RPers on Amia, I find, are those that manage to portray heroic bastards. Love that.
Agreed in full. Except, I do care and enjoy knowing/reading about lore.
I don't have any characters who aren't suspicious, racist or scared of certain races. Flaws = good!
_________________ My Characters: Yuilith Kethil Menaiivan Garadeth
|
|
|
|
 |
|
Yurell
|
Posted: Sun, Jan 03 2010, 1:46 AM |
|
|

Player
Joined: 06 Jan 2008 Location: ANU, behind the coffee mug (+10 GMT)
|
Yurell wrote: Okay Blunt, let me pose you this question - would an Exalted character lose his Exalted status for condoning and promoting slavery? Since you don't seem to be on, I'll answer this question for you (since it was intended as part of a discussion, rather than as a point unto itself). If you answered No, I would ask you to justify that position, since from what I see the book seems rather against that sort of thing. If you answered 'it depends', I would point out that in the context of the book, it is a lot more black and white than normal D&D. Shades of grey are minimal, and it takes a rather 'simplistic' approach to good. Either way, it would need further justification. If you answered Yes, you would have contradicted: bluntpencil2001 wrote: If a Paladin hasn't fallen, he's basically shoed into being exalted.
Since a paladin can promote and defend slavery without falling.
_________________ 2009's Second Most Overall Contributing Player
يمكنني استخدام مترجم جوجل
|
|
|
|
 |
|
bluntpencil2001
|
Posted: Sun, Jan 03 2010, 3:33 AM |
|
|

Player
Joined: 12 Nov 2009 Location: Scotland
|
|
An Exalted character could possibly promote slavery, but it would be very, very unlikely. I would say the majority wouldn't, but the possibility would be there.
'Freedom' is more often married to 'Chaotic' as opposed to 'Good', but it really depends.
At any rate, an Exalted owner of slaves would have to make sure his slaves/possessions were treated like his own children, loved etc etc. He'd have to ensure that they were happy and willing to be his slaves, without magical compulsion or trickery. Difficult again, but not impossible. If a slaveowner had free people queueing up at his door to apply to be a slave due to a true, good reputation, that would be a good indicator.
Also, is casting Summon Monster III every day to clean the house the same as having a slave? Is that evil, or is it like having a mindless golem do it?
For the record, I agree that the majority of PCs should be meaner to monster races. However, I also think that those PCs alignments' should shift towards neutral from good, making truly good characters rarer. A paladin not showing mercy would possibly fall, for instance.
Now, I'm not saying that Paladins, or other really really good people should ask a Goblin to babysit for them, or even ask them the time of day, that's stupid. But when an LG Dwarf murders an Orc that has surrendered (and, in character, he should!), he should move away from the idealised idea of Good. His alignment probably wouldn't change, but enough acts of mercilessness, and he'd be on the route to LN.
|
|
|
|
 |
|
Yurell
|
Posted: Sun, Jan 03 2010, 3:44 AM |
|
|

Player
Joined: 06 Jan 2008 Location: ANU, behind the coffee mug (+10 GMT)
|
bluntpencil2001 wrote: At any rate, an Exalted owner of slaves would have to make sure his possessions were treated like his own children, loved etc etc. It turns out I was right - page 11 of the Book of Exalted Deeds specifically mentions slavery as an act that will remove Exalted status. So no, an Exalted character cannot own slaves, or endorse slavery. A paladin, however, can, as exists in Cormyr I believe (Iron can provide more detail). bluntpencil2001 wrote: Also, is casting Summon Monster III the same as having a slave? Is that evil?
Of course not - the spell is the same alignment as the creature it summons. as per page 286 of the MM 3.5
_________________ 2009's Second Most Overall Contributing Player
يمكنني استخدام مترجم جوجل
|
|
|
|
 |
|
bluntpencil2001
|
Posted: Sun, Jan 03 2010, 3:45 AM |
|
|

Player
Joined: 12 Nov 2009 Location: Scotland
|
Yurell wrote: bluntpencil2001 wrote: At any rate, an Exalted owner of slaves would have to make sure his possessions were treated like his own children, loved etc etc. It turns out I was right - page 11 of the Book of Exalted Deeds specifically mentions slavery as an act that will remove Exalted status. So no, an Exalted character cannot own slaves, or endorse slavery. A paladin, however, can, as exists in Cormyr I believe (Iron can provide more detail).
I didn't know that, myself, obviously missed it.
In that case, said Paladins wouldn't be exalted.
However, the fact that it says slavery is evil would mean that any paladin involved in it should fall.
|
|
|
|
 |
|
Yurell
|
Posted: Sun, Jan 03 2010, 3:48 AM |
|
|

Player
Joined: 06 Jan 2008 Location: ANU, behind the coffee mug (+10 GMT)
|
bluntpencil2001 wrote: Yurell wrote: bluntpencil2001 wrote: At any rate, an Exalted owner of slaves would have to make sure his possessions were treated like his own children, loved etc etc. It turns out I was right - page 11 of the Book of Exalted Deeds specifically mentions slavery as an act that will remove Exalted status. So no, an Exalted character cannot own slaves, or endorse slavery. A paladin, however, can, as exists in Cormyr I believe (Iron can provide more detail). I didn't know that, myself, obviously missed it. In that case, said Paladins wouldn't be exalted.
And such is the point of my argument - a paladin does not have to be Exalted in order to not fall, meaning they are not bound by anything in that book (which isn't canon as far as FR is concerned at any rate). Racial tolerance only has to stretch so far.
_________________ 2009's Second Most Overall Contributing Player
يمكنني استخدام مترجم جوجل
|
|
|
|
 |
|
Selvec Darkon
|
Posted: Sun, Jan 03 2010, 3:49 AM |
|
|

Player
Joined: 12 Oct 2005 Location: On a Disk, carried by four elephants, which stand on a gigantic turtle.
|
|
Anyway, your both off topic, this is a forum about Greenskins.
_________________ I keels u with my axe!
"Do ye know where the Holy-Flamin' Frost-brand Gronk-slayin' Vorpal Hammer o' woundin' an' returnin' an' Shootin'-Lightnin'-out-yer-bum is?"
|
|
|
|
 |
|
bluntpencil2001
|
Posted: Sun, Jan 03 2010, 3:50 AM |
|
|

Player
Joined: 12 Nov 2009 Location: Scotland
|
Yurell wrote: bluntpencil2001 wrote: Yurell wrote: bluntpencil2001 wrote: At any rate, an Exalted owner of slaves would have to make sure his possessions were treated like his own children, loved etc etc. It turns out I was right - page 11 of the Book of Exalted Deeds specifically mentions slavery as an act that will remove Exalted status. So no, an Exalted character cannot own slaves, or endorse slavery. A paladin, however, can, as exists in Cormyr I believe (Iron can provide more detail). I didn't know that, myself, obviously missed it. In that case, said Paladins wouldn't be exalted. And such is the point of my argument - a paladin does not have to be Exalted in order to not fall, meaning they are not bound by anything in that book (which isn't canon as far as FR is concerned at any rate). Racial tolerance only has to stretch so far.
My point was that the vast majority of characters shouldn't be tolerant at all... but that such intolerance is still evil. This would mean that yes, lots of good Dwarves regularly commit minor evils, and it would probably mean that most humans would not be good. They'd just be neutral. Generally decent people, but not without serious flaws.
|
|
|
|
 |
|
bluntpencil2001
|
Posted: Sun, Jan 03 2010, 3:51 AM |
|
|

Player
Joined: 12 Nov 2009 Location: Scotland
|
Selvec Darkon wrote: Anyway, your both off topic, this is a forum about Greenskins.
Goblins don't have green skin, so the original post is off topic.
Last edited by bluntpencil2001 on Sun, Jan 03 2010, 3:51 AM, edited 1 time in total.
|
|
|
|
 |
|
Yurell
|
Posted: Sun, Jan 03 2010, 3:51 AM |
|
|

Player
Joined: 06 Jan 2008 Location: ANU, behind the coffee mug (+10 GMT)
|
Selvec Darkon wrote: Anyway, your both off topic, this is a forum about Greenskins.
And their acceptance by other characters, as is stipulated in the first post.
_________________ 2009's Second Most Overall Contributing Player
يمكنني استخدام مترجم جوجل
|
|
|
|
 |
|
Yurell
|
Posted: Sun, Jan 03 2010, 3:55 AM |
|
|

Player
Joined: 06 Jan 2008 Location: ANU, behind the coffee mug (+10 GMT)
|
bluntpencil2001 wrote: My point was that the vast majority of characters shouldn't be tolerant at all... but that such intolerance is still evil. This would mean that yes, lots of good Dwarves regularly commit minor evils, and it would probably mean that most humans would not be good. They'd just be neutral. Generally decent people, but not without serious flaws.
It's evil according to the BoED, but obviously not inherently so, as paladins can get away with it. So that leaves us with a problem that is readily resolved by stating that the requirements of 'goodness' for an Exalted character are different to that for a paladin.
I considered making a pro-slavery paladin, but decided against it for the reason that nobody is around when I do play, ad the entire concept is based on PC-PC interactions. A paladin may not smite an orc or goblin on sight, but why should she do more than tolerate the creature's existence? She isn't compelled to by her code, merely her own personal code of conduct. There's a difference between tolerating everyone and accepting everyone.
_________________ 2009's Second Most Overall Contributing Player
يمكنني استخدام مترجم جوجل
|
|
|
|
 |
|
bluntpencil2001
|
Posted: Sun, Jan 03 2010, 3:57 AM |
|
|

Player
Joined: 12 Nov 2009 Location: Scotland
|
Yurell wrote: bluntpencil2001 wrote: My point was that the vast majority of characters shouldn't be tolerant at all... but that such intolerance is still evil. This would mean that yes, lots of good Dwarves regularly commit minor evils, and it would probably mean that most humans would not be good. They'd just be neutral. Generally decent people, but not without serious flaws. It's evil according to the BoED, but obviously not inherently so, as paladins can get away with it. So that leaves us with a problem that is readily resolved by stating that the requirements of 'goodness' for an Exalted character are different to that for a paladin. I considered making a pro-slavery paladin, but decided against it for the reason that nobody is around when I do play, ad the entire concept is based on PC-PC interactions. A paladin may not smite an orc or goblin on sight, but why should she do more than tolerate the creature's existence? She isn't compelled to by her code, merely her own personal code of conduct. There's a difference between tolerating everyone and accepting everyone.
I fully agree here... a paladin, or another good character shouldn't kill the orcs on sight, but he also doesn't have to invite them over to dinner just so they can smash the good china and fart at the table. Sure, he could invite them over, but he'd get laughed at at best, eaten for dessert at worst.
Being merciful doesn't require that one becomes friends with defeated foes... it doesn't even require being nice to them.
|
|
|
|
 |
|
Selvec Darkon
|
Posted: Sun, Jan 03 2010, 6:24 AM |
|
|

Player
Joined: 12 Oct 2005 Location: On a Disk, carried by four elephants, which stand on a gigantic turtle.
|
bluntpencil2001 wrote: Selvec Darkon wrote: Anyway, your both off topic, this is a forum about Greenskins. Goblins don't have green skin, so the original post is off topic.
Don't be an jackass. You know what its directed at.
_________________ I keels u with my axe!
"Do ye know where the Holy-Flamin' Frost-brand Gronk-slayin' Vorpal Hammer o' woundin' an' returnin' an' Shootin'-Lightnin'-out-yer-bum is?"
|
|
|
|
 |
|
Sakkran
|
Posted: Sun, Jan 03 2010, 6:29 AM |
|
|

Player
Joined: 09 Nov 2006 Location: The Hive Ward, Sigil
|
Kraniumbrud wrote: ....i would just like to suggest that goblins and orcs read up on greenskins..that is all
I'm just going to point out that orcs aren't green. That is all.
_________________ Morgan Blancrest: The Rage from The Cage Lucas Baker: Humble Swordsman Wesley Fletcher: Greasemonkey Extraordonaire Also known as: EmoPinata
|
|
|
|
 |
|
Galenson
|
Posted: Sun, Jan 03 2010, 7:43 AM |
|
|

Player
Joined: 26 May 2006 Location: Down Under, calculating your demise with blunt expressions.
|
As grey as they are, noone understands if you call them Greyskins. We've been through this before
Now, those two arses who are talking about exalted Paladins can take their discussion to a new thread. Quite simply, this isn't the place.
_________________ Plays:
"I'll think of something once Amia:EE drops."
|
|
|
|
 |
|
Yurell
|
Posted: Sun, Jan 03 2010, 7:45 AM |
|
|

Player
Joined: 06 Jan 2008 Location: ANU, behind the coffee mug (+10 GMT)
|
|
We already finished, and the racial tolerance of these creatures is one of the main purposes of this thread, if you had gone back and read the OP.
_________________ 2009's Second Most Overall Contributing Player
يمكنني استخدام مترجم جوجل
|
|
|
|
 |
|
Galenson
|
Posted: Sun, Jan 03 2010, 8:11 AM |
|
|

Player
Joined: 26 May 2006 Location: Down Under, calculating your demise with blunt expressions.
|
Yurell wrote: We already finished, and the racial tolerance of these creatures is one of the main purposes of this thread, if you had gone back and read the OP.
And if we need twenty posts of unreadable quote pyramids to know how classes treat races, we'll let you know. You have a habit of missing the point and contradicting yourself.
As it stands, once again, this thread is a simple good Drow vs Evil Drow debate. Amia has a record of characters going against the norm because there are rules in place to prevent preventing such things from happening. If I was allowed to, I would massacre every Drow, every Tiefling every Duergar, every Kobold, every goblin, every orc and every other monstrous race I came across. I would chase them back into the holes of Amia and make sure they never pop their heads above ground again.
Unfortunately, if I did that I would be banned on the spot for the charges of grieving other people's enjoyment. I would be told there was a better way to approach the situation but quite frankly... I don't really wish to kiss a DM's arse 24/7 for the attention to do so.
Kraniumbrud, I know what angle you're coming from with this thread. Being an evil orc player I know how frustrating it is to watch huggle nuzzle monsters. But lets face it, Amia encourages "monstrous" races to have a good side to them: There's a faction area for good Drow, most UD and monstrous races are still allowed in Cordor, the PvP rules restrict killing PCs simply due to race, hell even one of the DMs plays a cuddly goblin bard.
Given the opportunity and influence as they have combined with the difficulty of actually playing as a monster, the playerbase will swoon to the good Drow, cuddly goblins and kobolds etc. You can't stop it, you can however set the example of the monster and attract others to your cause.
_________________ Plays:
"I'll think of something once Amia:EE drops."
|
|
|
|
 |
|
Yurell
|
Posted: Sun, Jan 03 2010, 8:19 AM |
|
|

Player
Joined: 06 Jan 2008 Location: ANU, behind the coffee mug (+10 GMT)
|
Galenson wrote: Yurell wrote: We already finished, and the racial tolerance of these creatures is one of the main purposes of this thread, if you had gone back and read the OP. And if we need to know how classes treat races, we'll let you know. You have a habit of missing the point and contradicting yourself.
Racial tolerance by classes is still racial tolerance. Or are you unable to see past 'Race A treats Race B like this, regardless of class'? Is a Paladin free to choose what races she can discriminate against? Oh wow, you missed the point because you don't like the discussion at hand. Believe it or not, racial tolerance is the act of tolerating races, not of races tolerating races.
There's an example in real life with socio-economic classes also - discrimination isn't the same between poor people and rich. Go to a poor part of the Bible Belt in the US and see how different stereotypes are portrayed, and different customs tolerated to a rich section of Tokyo.
And please point out where I contradicted myself, so that I may fix the error.
_________________ 2009's Second Most Overall Contributing Player
يمكنني استخدام مترجم جوجل
|
|
|
|
 |
|
Galenson
|
Posted: Sun, Jan 03 2010, 9:00 AM |
|
|

Player
Joined: 26 May 2006 Location: Down Under, calculating your demise with blunt expressions.
|
|
I'll have to word this a bit more simply. Do you only think about the total post count? The OP created a post on how monstrous races are portrayed by the players who play them, your reply was how LG and exalted Paladins are different from one another and raved on about how you wanted to make a Slave accepting Paladin.
Absolutely no relevance to the topic at hand.
Then once challenged, you started blabbing on about Socio Economics of the US in a thread about greenskins which once again has absolutely no relevance to the issue at hand. Are you serious!?
Now... back to the topic at hand. I'll put a challenge out to the playerbase. I'll start acting more like a monster and urge others to act more like monsters ICly if they are willing to do so. In return, those who aren't monsters get to treat us as monsters should be treated: bagged and thrown in a hole. Call it a trial run.
_________________ Plays:
"I'll think of something once Amia:EE drops."
|
|
|
|
 |
|
Yurell
|
Posted: Sun, Jan 03 2010, 9:08 AM |
|
|

Player
Joined: 06 Jan 2008 Location: ANU, behind the coffee mug (+10 GMT)
|
Galenson wrote: I'll have to word this a bit more simply. Do you only think about the total post count? Do you think only of your egocentric universe where everyone else must be one-dimensional with only one goal in life? Galenson wrote: The OP created a post on how monstrous races are portrayed by the players who play them, your reply was how LG and exalted Paladins are different from one another and raved on about how you wanted to make a Slave accepting Paladin.
Absolutely no relevance to the topic at hand. You are simply wrong. My response to the OP was: Yurell wrote: Kraniumbrud wrote: ....i would just like to suggest that goblins and orcs read up on greenskins..that is all That sounds nice and arrogant when you make a post saying "read up on this stuff because you don't know how to play them ... but I'm not going to give you any more information, nor any links". That said, there's already a brilliant thread on kobolds, so goblins (from the MM): Quote: This little humanoid has a flat face, broad nose, pointed ears, wide mouth, and small, sharp fangs. It walks upright, but its arms hang down almost to its knees.
Goblins are small humanoids that many consider little more than a nuisance. However, if they are unchecked, their great numbers, rapid reproduction, and evil disposition enable them to overrun and despoil civilised areas. A goblin stands 3 to 3-1/2 feet tall and weigh 40 to 45 pounds. Its eyes are usually dull and glazed, varying in colour from red to yellow. A goblin's skin colour ranges from yellow through any shade of orange to deep red; usually all members of a single tribe are the same colour. Goblins wear clothing of dark leather, tending towards drab, soiled-looking colours. Goblins speak Goblin; those with Intelligence scores of 12 or higher also speak Common. Most goblins encountered outside their homes are warriors Yurell wrote: More on Goblins (MM): Quote: Combat
Being bullied by bigger, stronger creatures has taught goblins to exploit what few advantages they have: sheer numbers and malicious ingenuity. The concept of a fair fight is meaningless in their society. They favour ambushes, overwhelming odds, dirty tricks, and any other edge they can devise.
Goblins have a poor grasp of strategy and are cowardly by nature, tending to flee the field if a battle turns against them. With proper supervision, though, they can implement reasonably complex plans, and in such circumstances their numbers can be a deadly advantage.
[...]
Goblin Society
Goblins are tribal. Their leaders are generally the biggest, strongest, or sometimes the smartest of the group. They have almost no concept of privacy, living and sleeping in large common areas; only the leaders live separately. Goblins survive by raiding and stealing (preferably from those who cannot defend themselves easily), sneaking into lairs, villages and even towns by night to take what they can. They are not above waylaying travellers on the road or in the forests and stripping them of all possessions, up to and including the clothes on their backs. Goblins sometimes capture slaves to perform hard labour in their tribe's lair or compound.
These creatures live wherever they can, from dank caves to dismal ruins, and their lairs are always smelly and filthy due to an utter lack of sanitation. Goblins often settle near civilised areas t raid for food, livestock, tools, weapons, and supplies. Once a tribe has despoiled a locale, it simply packs up and moves on to the next convenient area. Hobgoblins and bugbears are sometimes found in the company of goblin tribes, usually as bullying leaders. Some goblin tribes form alliances with worgs, which carry them into combat.
Goblin bands and tribes have noncombatant young equal in number to the adults. The chief goblin deity is Maglubiyet, who urges his worshippers to expand their numbers and overwhelm their competitors. Note, I'm retyping this from scratch, (just like the last) so I really don't give a damn about typos or that I spell things correctly. The discussion about paladins was a response to bluntpencil's post on Exalted characters, which in turn was in response to the addition to the first post: Kraniumbrud wrote: this being goblins, kobolds, orcs, orogs, ogrrillions, tanarukk, hobgoblin, bugbear, ogre, drow..and so forth...does not mean that the world will immidiately accept if you happen to one of the few who have turned from thier inheretly evil nature, fearun clearly has a very hostile position towards all these races, and to expect anything else from others rp, and start to argue this point oocly, is just plain wrong. i suggest source materials such as races of fearun for futher studies as it is approved wizard of the coast material on this very subject. With the bolded section clearly indicating that this thread is not only about how to play goblinoids (as was suggested initially) but also about player character reactions to them. Galenson wrote: Then once challenged, you started blabbing on about Socio Economics of the US in a thread about greenskins which once again has absolutely no relevance to the issue at hand. Are you serious!?
I was countering your argument that racial relations matter only on the race of those involved, and not other factors.
So get off your high horse and see that other people are entitled to discussion and opinions and that they may have no ulterior motive beyond the enjoyment thereof.
_________________ 2009's Second Most Overall Contributing Player
يمكنني استخدام مترجم جوجل
|
|
|
|
 |
|
Galenson
|
Posted: Sun, Jan 03 2010, 9:24 AM |
|
|

Player
Joined: 26 May 2006 Location: Down Under, calculating your demise with blunt expressions.
|
Yurell wrote: I hate you.
Unfortunately you're still not grasping the concept of sidetracking. Since this is beating a dead horse, I'm going to leave it there.
Final remarks: Amia's nurtured the possiblity of cuddly monsters for five years. Its going to happen, you're going to have to just deal with it. Have the balls however to let loose the monsters within and see where it goes. Its hard yes, but very rewarding if done correctly.
_________________ Plays:
"I'll think of something once Amia:EE drops."
|
|
|
|
 |
|
Yurell
|
Posted: Sun, Jan 03 2010, 9:35 AM |
|
|

Player
Joined: 06 Jan 2008 Location: ANU, behind the coffee mug (+10 GMT)
|
Galenson wrote: Yurell wrote: I hate you. Unfortunately you're still not grasping the concept of sidetracking. Since this is beating a dead horse, I'm going to leave it there. Final remarks: Amia's nurtured the possiblity of cuddly monsters for five years. Its going to happen, you're going to have to just deal with it. Have the balls however to let loose the monsters within and see where it goes. Its hard yes, but very rewarding if done correctly.
Congratulations, you can alter a quote and spam at the same time, while arguing that I'm the one detracting from the OP. You must be so proud that you can goad a depressed teenager on the other side of the country through the internet.
_________________ 2009's Second Most Overall Contributing Player
يمكنني استخدام مترجم جوجل
|
|
|
|
 |
|
O'Raghailligh
|
Posted: Sun, Jan 03 2010, 9:37 AM |
|
|

Player
Joined: 04 Jan 2009 Location: NZ
|
|
*insert DM intervention here*
|
|
|
|
 |
|
Yurell
|
Posted: Sun, Jan 03 2010, 9:38 AM |
|
|

Player
Joined: 06 Jan 2008 Location: ANU, behind the coffee mug (+10 GMT)
|
O'Raghailligh wrote: *insert DM intervention here*
The argument is over, Galenson said he'd leave it, so there's no need.
_________________ 2009's Second Most Overall Contributing Player
يمكنني استخدام مترجم جوجل
|
|
|
|
 |
|
Mr T
|
Posted: Sun, Jan 03 2010, 12:35 PM |
|
|

Player
Joined: 12 Jun 2006 Location: England
|
Quote: Kraniumbrud, I know what angle you're coming from with this thread. Being an evil orc player I know how frustrating it is to watch huggle nuzzle monsters. But lets face it, Amia encourages "monstrous" races to have a good side to them: There's a faction area for good Drow, most UD and monstrous races are still allowed in Cordor, the PvP rules restrict killing PCs simply due to race, hell even one of the DMs plays a cuddly goblin bard.
*Neatly side-steps the above fracas*
Yes Amia is far too tolerant of the monster races. I have been an advocate of change for several years now and it is slowly improving.
I occassionally play one of a pair of chaotic neutral half-orc brothers and recently an utterly irredeemable tiefling, and I have to say the reactions towards them have been suitably horrified and intolerant  !
Personally (and this is not finger-pointing) I feel the problem lies with the smaller monstrous races, the goblins and kobolds. For some reason more of them are played for the 'huggles' than say the orcs, and player reaction to them is alot more tolerant and of the 'awwww isn't cute. Can I have one...' nature
The difficulty with goblins and kobolds is that they are 'lorewise' physically weak and of a bullying mindset. So whilst seeing Orcs, hobgoblins etc alone or in pairs is fine the goblin/kobolds really ought to gravate towards each other for 'protection/support' and form big groups of nasty and spiteful bullies. However some of the playerbase is stuck on playing them as alternate Hin or child PC.
Personally you cannot nor should you change how others like to play. All you can do is play the monsters as monsters and show others that it can be fun.
Mr T
|
|
|
|
 |
|
speedgrab
|
Posted: Sun, Jan 03 2010, 12:50 PM |
|
|

Player
Joined: 07 Apr 2008 Location: That England place (Gmt+0)
|
|
coming together of goblins and kobolds would be the smart thing to do butthey way ive seen it is that it is always a fight for terrortiy and dominance between them.
and i for one say no to goodly monterous races unless RP'd really well as to why they are good
if dill ever seems to be good.. she is mostlikey using this system of goblin = cute to gain the upper hand in a rgument or to place the blame on someone else.
_________________ ~ Dill Buck-tooth ~ Alan Snowfall ~
|
|
|
|
 |
|
Mr T
|
Posted: Sun, Jan 03 2010, 12:53 PM |
|
|

Player
Joined: 12 Jun 2006 Location: England
|
Quote: she is mostlikey using this system of goblin = cute to gain the upper hand in a rgument or to place the blame on someone else.
And this is one of the reasons goblins and kobolds should be scary. They are untrustworthy, tricky little barstewards who will turn on you as soon as it is in their interest to do so. Love It!
Mr T
|
|
|
|
 |
|
Godo
|
Posted: Sun, Jan 03 2010, 14:55 PM |
|
|

Player
Joined: 26 Aug 2009
|
speedgrab wrote: coming together of goblins and kobolds would be the smart thing to do butthey way ive seen it is that it is always a fight for terrortiy and dominance between them. and i for one say no to goodly monterous races unless RP'd really well as to why they are good if dill ever seems to be good.. she is mostlikey using this system of goblin = cute to gain the upper hand in a rgument or to place the blame on someone else.
Or to steal, manipulate, and play nice to survive the situation.
One main problem as I have posted before is there are not that many monster races of any one group. We too want to have fun in RPing with others and when there are no others of the race you are playing around it makes it extremely hard.
In order for humans, elves and others to be more hostile to these monster races then the player of the monster race much be more mean and hostile to them as well. That leads to most times being alone, hunting alone, and RPing mostly alone against others in parties. It can however be very rewarding and fun to both sides when there is stalking, chasseing, fighting, and the talks between them.
|
|
|
|
 |
|
IronAngel
|
Posted: Sun, Jan 03 2010, 15:06 PM |
|
|

Player
Joined: 29 Sep 2005 Location: Helsinki, Finland
|
|
Book of Exalted Deeds is garbage. This whole concept of "exalted" is nonsense. Ugh.
Forget alignment. Play your PC's personality as it is shaped by your biological and cultural background.
_________________ On Joon, Kjetta wrote: The guy that probably has sexual fantasies about masturbation. I mean, Iron, you're a bookworm nerd that even in your wildest escapism fantasies flee to the internet to play the role of another bookworm nerd? Come on!
|
|
|
|
 |
|
bluntpencil2001
|
Posted: Sun, Jan 03 2010, 16:15 PM |
|
|

Player
Joined: 12 Nov 2009 Location: Scotland
|
IronAngel wrote: Book of Exalted Deeds is garbage. This whole concept of "exalted" is nonsense. Ugh.
Forget alignment. Play your PC's personality as it is shaped by your biological and cultural background.
I would agree for the most part, although I do think that the chapter on what is virtuous is good, especially considering that in DnD, Good is a measurable, concrete thing, unlike in real-life.
The main problem with that piece of crap is that it makes things that should be roleplayed simple dice rolls, and it basically introduces a new pantheon of archangels and pointless prestige classes, instead of making a more generic system. There is also the really crappy 'good diseases and poisons' so that people can play Moses with ten plagues and not feel guilty.
The bit saying that mercy, forgiveness and redemption are good acts, however, makes sense... it even goes on to explain that these things, in most DnD societies are rare, which also makes sense, saying that such virtues are 'ahead of their time', making it more difficult, but more rewarding, to be good.
I also find 'forgetting alignment' to be difficult when playing a class with an alignment restriction, and restrictions preventing evil acts altogether. Such a character has in-character reasons to think about the moral implications of every action taken. In effect, Paladins, Blackguards, Clerics, Rangers and Druids can't forget alignment when their oaths, religion and the like come into play. To a lesser extent, even Dwarven Defenders, Barbarians, Monks and Bards have to be aware of alignment, although this is less of a big deal.
Last edited by bluntpencil2001 on Sun, Jan 03 2010, 16:28 PM, edited 1 time in total.
|
|
|
|
 |
|
blackvswhite
|
Posted: Sun, Jan 03 2010, 16:27 PM |
|
|

Player
Joined: 08 Nov 2008
|
IronAngel wrote: Book of Exalted Deeds is garbage. This whole concept of "exalted" is nonsense. Ugh.
Forget alignment. Play your PC's personality as it is shaped by your biological and cultural background.
I love you. May I have your children?
Alignments are static, characters are dynamic. I choose an alignment that best fits my character, but no alignment defines my characters completely.
|
|
|
|
 |
|
bluntpencil2001
|
Posted: Sun, Jan 03 2010, 16:32 PM |
|
|

Player
Joined: 12 Nov 2009 Location: Scotland
|
|
Again, what if your character finds their alignment to be central to their personality? If such a character has sworn to do only good, and do no evil, and makes every effort to do such, it could become a key, central part of their character.
EDIT: I'll add an example...
I have a paladin character and a barbarian character. Both are 'good' alignment wise.
Let's say both capture a goblin, who has surrendered. My barbarian will think
'Hmph, it's a dangerous goblin, I cannae trust it, I'm nae listenin' tae its cries for mercy, that'd be stupid.' and would then decapitate it. He doesn't think 'I'm good, I can't do that', since it doesn't matter to him, it doesn't even cross his mind. He'd probably shift ever so slightly towards evil, but that wouldn't bother me at all. Such characters are good, but not saints.
However, my paladin captures a goblin who has surrendered. He, however has a problem. His train of thought would be something along the following lines,
'It would be dangerous for me to keep this goblin alive. However, killing it would be doing evil, albeit for the greater good, which I have sworn against doing. I must accept the difficulties of the path I have chosen and show mercy, even at risk to myself.'
The paladin would probably get stabbed in the back by the goblin, but nobody said being good was easy.
Last edited by bluntpencil2001 on Sun, Jan 03 2010, 16:42 PM, edited 1 time in total.
|
|
|
|
 |
|
IronAngel
|
Posted: Sun, Jan 03 2010, 16:40 PM |
|
|

Player
Joined: 29 Sep 2005 Location: Helsinki, Finland
|
bluntpencil2001 wrote: IronAngel wrote: Book of Exalted Deeds is garbage. This whole concept of "exalted" is nonsense. Ugh.
Forget alignment. Play your PC's personality as it is shaped by your biological and cultural background. I would agree for the most part, although I do think that the chapter on what is virtuous is good, especially considering that in DnD, Good is a measurable, concrete thing, unlike in real-life. [..] I also find 'forgetting alignment' to be difficult when playing a class with an alignment restriction, and restrictions preventing evil acts altogether. Such a character has in-character reasons to think about the moral implications of every action taken. In effect, Paladins, Blackguards, Clerics, Rangers and Druids can't forget alignment when their oaths, religion and the like come into play. To a lesser extent, even Dwarven Defenders, Barbarians, Monks and Bards have to be aware of alignment, although this is less of a big deal.
I find it quite annoying that a book, written by (probably less intelligent and poorly educated) people who have nothing to do with our campaign, attempts to tell the DMs what they should consider good and evil. On Amia, it's Amian DMs who say if your PC is acting good or evil. Not a book.
As for the latter point, if you are specific you will note that these PCs don't consider the game-mechanical "alignment" but rather their own codes and oaths that, in reality, define their alignment. A monk or a paladin has certain principles he follows, and doing that successfully means he remains Lawful or Lawful Good, respectively. That's because the principles are such that keep him within a certain alignment.
IC concern should be focused on those principles and values, not on the game feature known to us as alignment.
_________________ On Joon, Kjetta wrote: The guy that probably has sexual fantasies about masturbation. I mean, Iron, you're a bookworm nerd that even in your wildest escapism fantasies flee to the internet to play the role of another bookworm nerd? Come on!
|
|
|
|
 |
|
bluntpencil2001
|
Posted: Sun, Jan 03 2010, 16:46 PM |
|
|

Player
Joined: 12 Nov 2009 Location: Scotland
|
|
I agree there, to an extent (Paladins swear to do no evil, period. Regardless of values. They happen to be lawful in doing so.), but it brings up some confusing points.
As far as I am aware, in DnD and Amia, alignment is concrete, it is not a matter of opinion or culture, otherwise 'Smite Evil' and other alignment based powers would be 'Smite Infidel/Unbeliever/Opposing Pattern of Thought'.
If it is concrete, regardless of cultural norms, those that put in the effort could quite reasonably learn what those concrete values were.
If it is cultural norms, anything dependant on alignment shouldn't be, I don't think.
|
|
|
|
 |
|
IronAngel
|
Posted: Sun, Jan 03 2010, 16:50 PM |
|
|

Player
Joined: 29 Sep 2005 Location: Helsinki, Finland
|
|
On the contrary: I don't think even the gods are able to discern the full extent of Good and Evil, despite the fact that it is objective and real. Besides, values cannot be objective, if they apply to a contingent situation. It must be something beyond mundane rules such as "Don't steal." Granted, there are unfortunately some spells and abilities based on alignment, but they're gladly few and far between on Amia, and would only offer a vague approximation: OK, so this guy has lived according to standards that make him good overall. But that doesn't tell what, exactly, is pure good.
_________________ On Joon, Kjetta wrote: The guy that probably has sexual fantasies about masturbation. I mean, Iron, you're a bookworm nerd that even in your wildest escapism fantasies flee to the internet to play the role of another bookworm nerd? Come on!
|
|
|
|
 |
|
bluntpencil2001
|
Posted: Sun, Jan 03 2010, 16:56 PM |
|
|

Player
Joined: 12 Nov 2009 Location: Scotland
|
IronAngel wrote: On the contrary: I don't think even the gods are able to discern the full extent of Good and Evil, despite the fact that it is objective and real. Besides, values cannot be objective, if they apply to a contingent situation. It must be something beyond mundane rules such as "Don't steal." Granted, there are unfortunately some spells and abilities based on alignment, but they're gladly few and far between on Amia, and would only offer a vague approximation: OK, so this guy has lived according to standards that make him good overall. But that doesn't tell what, exactly, is pure good.
That works for me, and makes sense considering how often deities screw up on Faerun.
However, I'm pretty sure that basic values would be recognisable as good, especially with gods and scholars looking into it for millenia. The example I edited in above would be covering the virtue of 'mercy', for instance, which should be considered good by those who know of such, and shouldn't require knowledge beyond even the deities.
Of course, like I mentioned above, there are plenty of people, even good people, that just wouldn't care that mercy is good. I know that giving my kidney to a random sick stranger is good, but I don't do it, for instance.
|
|
|
|
 |
|
IronAngel
|
Posted: Sun, Jan 03 2010, 17:24 PM |
|
|

Player
Joined: 29 Sep 2005 Location: Helsinki, Finland
|
|
Mm, maybe so. But I'm not sure it would go to such extent as BoED and you suggest. I think two paladins who both try their best to do good can disagree on whether it's right to kill orcs on sight or give them a chance to repent, and neither can refer to any infallible revelation of Good that proves them right. You, as a player, don't even need to know what's really Good and Evil. It's enough to get into the mindset of your PC and do your best to act according to his beliefs. That's what I mean when I encourage you to forget alignment: act according to the best knowledge and the beliefs of your PC, not according to what you think/know the DM considers Good in your campaign.
_________________ On Joon, Kjetta wrote: The guy that probably has sexual fantasies about masturbation. I mean, Iron, you're a bookworm nerd that even in your wildest escapism fantasies flee to the internet to play the role of another bookworm nerd? Come on!
|
|
|
|
 |
|
bluntpencil2001
|
Posted: Sun, Jan 03 2010, 17:47 PM |
|
|

Player
Joined: 12 Nov 2009 Location: Scotland
|
IronAngel wrote: Mm, maybe so. But I'm not sure it would go to such extent as BoED and you suggest. I think two paladins who both try their best to do good can disagree on whether it's right to kill orcs on sight or give them a chance to repent, and neither can refer to any infallible revelation of Good that proves them right. You, as a player, don't even need to know what's really Good and Evil. It's enough to get into the mindset of your PC and do your best to act according to his beliefs. That's what I mean when I encourage you to forget alignment: act according to the best knowledge and the beliefs of your PC, not according to what you think/know the DM considers Good in your campaign.
I guess I'm just wound up by other players telling me what my character should think, that he shouldn't attempt to redeem enemies, for instance, and that attempting to convince evil-doers to repent should apparently make him lose the grace of Lathander... I guess I get annoyed OOC when getting PMs about such from some players, when I know, OOC, that this isn't the case.
"You should smite them if they don't repent off their own back!"
"Or, I could, you know, convince them that they are wrong and convert them to Good, even if they are ignorant Goblins. They'll thank me when I'm done, and the guilt they will feel will encourage them to do good works, and should be a fitting punishment for wrongs done.
Sure, I'll smite them if they present a threat, but if no threat is presented, it's my opinion that I should convince them to do good."
"No, Lathander will make you fall for trying to convert them if they don't want to!"
Yeah, so it's an issue that gets to me, and for some reason keeps cropping up. :/
He's going for the Dawn Cataclysm Mark II... redeem everyone, even if it is pointless and impossible!
Basically, in character, he knows that 'Mercy, Forgiveness and Redemption' are good, and possible for all but fiends, chromatic dragons and undead... so goes to extreme lengths to put these virtues into practice, even towards monstrous individuals.
When people say that such isn't a great idea in-character, that's great, since people of such opinions should be few and far between (at least until they get on their soap-box, Messiah-style, and convince everyone otherwise). It's when people say, OOC, that I'm wrong for playing my character in such a way, and even post threads about it (with mistakes regarding what proportion of certain creatures are certain alignments, too), it bothers me.
|
|
|
|
 |
|
IronAngel
|
Posted: Sun, Jan 03 2010, 18:04 PM |
|
|

Player
Joined: 29 Sep 2005 Location: Helsinki, Finland
|
|
Ah, indeed. In the end, how you play your character is your business only, and how his actions relate to objective Good and Evil is DM business only (even if I tend to go for the player interpretation, if it's remotely reasonable). Getting into such OOC arguments is pointless, because a) OOC knowledge shouldn't affect IC behaviour and b) the players don't get to play the gods, and therefore have no idea what they're talking about.
_________________ On Joon, Kjetta wrote: The guy that probably has sexual fantasies about masturbation. I mean, Iron, you're a bookworm nerd that even in your wildest escapism fantasies flee to the internet to play the role of another bookworm nerd? Come on!
|
|
|
|
 |
|
Yurell
|
Posted: Mon, Jan 04 2010, 0:16 AM |
|
|

Player
Joined: 06 Jan 2008 Location: ANU, behind the coffee mug (+10 GMT)
|
|
Just simply play your character how your character, as a person, would react. Don't play her how a person of her alignment would react, how someone of her class would react, how someone of her race would react - if your paladin would execute somebody for whatever reason, do it, and Falling be damned.
Yes, your paladin will Fall, which is part of her RP. It's important to distinguish that you didn't Fall, your character did, and it is not akin to 'losing'. Now your character has two roads before "one to death beyond dying, one to life eternal." Which will she choose. If you're RPing the character, don't choose what you think would be the right way, let the character choose - she doesn't know how the gods will react, and despite serious OOC knowledge, neither do you. It is her choice whether she ascends to redemption or becomes a bitter old woman ... or even falls into darkness.
You, as a player, play the character. Your view of inherent good or evil is probably better than the character's, but it's still in the DM's control, just as the reactions of the gods are.
Ten points for whoever guesses the book (and number in the series if it's in one) I quoted.
_________________ 2009's Second Most Overall Contributing Player
يمكنني استخدام مترجم جوجل
|
|
|
|
 |
Who is online |
Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 24 guests |
|
You cannot post new topics in this forum You cannot reply to topics in this forum You cannot edit your posts in this forum You cannot delete your posts in this forum
|
|