|
|
|
Elorathall
|
Posted: Mon, Aug 03 2015, 15:53 PM |
|
|

Player
Joined: 13 Mar 2011
|
|
Far more eloquent than I could put it.
_________________ Aernoud Van Brabant: Heir of the House. Proprietor of the Beer Wagon. "Go to the Mayfields, have a pint, and wait for this to blow over." Aurelius: Sunmaster of Amaunator. Contemplative. Aspirant to Transcendance. "Sol Invictus"
|
|
|
|
 |
|
serbiris
|
Posted: Mon, Aug 03 2015, 16:00 PM |
|
|

Player
Joined: 14 Sep 2010 Location: Sydney, Australia
|
|
It's a nice idea, Rock Spirit guy, in theory. I wrote about this extensively in a post in some other brainstormy thread - the problem is, when you get two factions of vastly differing strengths (eg: one well-established faction, and a freshly-spawned group) the former tends to destroy or absorb the latter. It's just the logical progression, and it only takes one person to spark that sort of conflict which is destructive, and not constructive. So without this unused fat, there's no safe places for factions to set down roots and grow strong enough to survive these conflicts that people crave. The trick of course is getting them the right level of support when they need it... And it's a real balancing act, takes a lot of dedication and a bit of luck too.
I still think "shadowscape frontier/noir werewolf/doppelganger/shapeshifter hunters" is the best idea to come out of this thread though.
_________________ @Thanatopsis#6293
|
|
|
|
 |
|
Liz
|
Posted: Mon, Aug 03 2015, 16:02 PM |
|
|

Player
Joined: 28 May 2010 Location: Smallville
|
serbiris wrote: I still think "shadowscape frontier/noir werewolf/doppelganger/shapeshifter hunters" is the best idea to come out of this thread though. Definitely sign me up for that faction.
_________________ Winner of Amia's "Most Ethical Time Traveler" award 2026 Character Portraits!
|
|
|
|
 |
|
Analog Kid
|
Posted: Mon, Aug 03 2015, 16:04 PM |
|
|

Player
Joined: 13 May 2010 Location: The Great White North Eh!!
|
|
The two places are in 'proximity' to each other by virtue of the portal but that remains the only thing the places really have in common.
Beyond that, I believe the responses so far have bee in favor of direct attention to the topic. Shadowscape and Tarkuul.
For the spirit of the OP's suggestion, there is another thread fo it called "the spread of the server", which if memory serves is a /very/ lengthy thread already.
_________________ I Am: Derrin: 'Nothing to see here' Beck: Hard working dwarf paladin. Naela 'Widow': Wandering priestess. Celinor Triellian: Paladin of Corellon.
|
|
|
|
 |
|
Krin
|
Posted: Mon, Aug 03 2015, 16:42 PM |
|
|

Player
Joined: 05 Jan 2006 Location: California
|
|
I can understand wanting the server to be less spread out, but I think a better way to generate activity in the server would be to make the city factions less powerful. Making Tarkuul, Cordor, Kohlingen, and Wiltun more vulnerable to evil/good-doers with a grudge would definitely spice things up.
I don't think PCs should be in positions of leadership in the major cities either, because it tends to slow down the story and make it more exclusive than is healthy for the server. But that's a whole other topic, I guess.
|
|
|
|
 |
|
Raua
|
Posted: Mon, Aug 03 2015, 16:50 PM |
|
|

Player
Joined: 09 Jul 2014 Location: The Land of >9000 Lakes (GMT -6)
|
Krin wrote: I can understand wanting the server to be less spread out, but I think a better way to generate activity in the server would be to make the city factions less powerful. Making Tarkuul, Cordor, Kohlingen, and Wiltun more vulnerable to evil/good-doers with a grudge would definitely spice things up.
I don't think PCs should be in positions of leadership in the major cities either, because it tends to slow down the story and make it more exclusive than is healthy for the server. But that's a whole other topic, I guess. I wholeheartedly agree with this sentiment. I've often see Players get burnt out after getting to major positions of power (Save for a few, of course). I think what makes the exclusivity of each city more prominent is that they're all pretty self-sufficient. They don't need outside help. And with that, understandably, can come a want to keep settlements separate. Because people have worked hard to get things to where they are, and don't want that work to be all for not. Which again, is understandable, but it also can very quickly lead to stagnation. Unfortunately, I don't think the server has the DM resources in order to make that possible at this time.
_________________ Occasionally seen as [DM] Raua, or playerside as...
|
|
|
|
 |
|
TormakSaber
|
Posted: Mon, Aug 03 2015, 21:09 PM |
|
|

Player
Joined: 16 Dec 2004 Location: Somewhere
|
|
The various cities do need outside help ,though. There is a great deal of trade and interactivity that goes on in the mundane behind the scenes between Kohl, Cordor, Wharftown, Bendir, Wiltun, etc etc that most PCs don't see or care about because it falls outsid etheir immediate zone of influence. Even Tarkuul isn't self reliant. Far from it: Considering it has boatloads of West Cordor refugees to actually feed, shelter, and clothe, unlike undead and a minority of mages.
As for making the cities "weaker": They are vulnerable, but as DMs for the sanity of the server, we have to maintain an explicit high bar, otherwise there will be no cities on the server left after a week. All the good guys would go after Tarkuul and Shadowscape and the Underdark and all the bad guys would go after Kohlingen and Wharftown and shattered Cordor and elsewhere. At the end I think the only places we'd have left on the server would be Forrstakkr and Endir's Point, and only bcause of apathy. This means doing things to affect cities in general must be done with a subtler hand, just to ensure that we got a place to play in at the end of the month, because we as human beings can't afford the dev time every month when people level some new Paladin alts to level 30 in 3 days and want to attack Cordor because they think the government is corrupt and what's left is easily sackable with their sorceror buddies and a lot of Hellball.
_________________ Davion Telemos - Monk of the Four Winds Korthan Isharnos - Dragon Shaman of Thunder Spirit Zamasham
|
|
|
|
 |
|
TormakSaber
|
Posted: Mon, Aug 03 2015, 21:10 PM |
|
|

Player
Joined: 16 Dec 2004 Location: Somewhere
|
Liz wrote: serbiris wrote: I still think "shadowscape frontier/noir werewolf/doppelganger/shapeshifter hunters" is the best idea to come out of this thread though. Definitely sign me up for that faction. Oh, and... I guess interested people should keep an eye out for the plot I'll be running soon. That's all I got to say on this... 
_________________ Davion Telemos - Monk of the Four Winds Korthan Isharnos - Dragon Shaman of Thunder Spirit Zamasham
|
|
|
|
 |
|
Krin
|
Posted: Tue, Aug 04 2015, 5:47 AM |
|
|

Player
Joined: 05 Jan 2006 Location: California
|
TormakSaber wrote: The various cities do need outside help ,though. There is a great deal of trade and interactivity that goes on in the mundane behind the scenes between Kohl, Cordor, Wharftown, Bendir, Wiltun, etc etc that most PCs don't see or care about because it falls outsid etheir immediate zone of influence. Even Tarkuul isn't self reliant. Far from it: Considering it has boatloads of West Cordor refugees to actually feed, shelter, and clothe, unlike undead and a minority of mages. I think the reason most PCs(and players) don't see or care about it is because it's all entirely background decoration at this point. Until these resources are made visible somehow(city score cards/trading system?), I don't think it's fair to expect players to have any idea how to attack those vulnerabilities. We can't exactly see how well-fed, happy, or filthy the NPCs in the cities are or see the bustling trade routes and merchants that are supposed to be keeping the cities alive. So, despite all the mundane background decoration, that I really don't think players should be involved in anyway, the cities are effectively self reliant. TormakSaber wrote: As for making the cities "weaker": They are vulnerable, but as DMs for the sanity of the server, we have to maintain an explicit high bar, otherwise there will be no cities on the server left after a week. All the good guys would go after Tarkuul and Shadowscape and the Underdark and all the bad guys would go after Kohlingen and Wharftown and shattered Cordor and elsewhere. At the end I think the only places we'd have left on the server would be Forrstakkr and Endir's Point, and only bcause of apathy. This means doing things to affect cities in general must be done with a subtler hand, just to ensure that we got a place to play in at the end of the month, because we as human beings can't afford the dev time every month when people level some new Paladin alts to level 30 in 3 days and want to attack Cordor because they think the government is corrupt and what's left is easily sackable with their sorceror buddies and a lot of Hellball. Ideally, I think the best way for the server to go would be for players to get out of city politics and into independent factions that can generate conflict with each other. We've had just about every mega-boss plot there is to have and, from what I've seen, I think people are a little tired of massive, slow moving plots. I think people are also tired of slow moving city RP. I've seen many fluid, healthy player-driven initiatives squashed by PC city leaders over the past couple years. Don't misunderstand me, I think the PC city leaders were acting in a way that is realistic to their positions and character types, but that doesn't dismiss the harm it does to the community IC and OOC. People get burnt out playing city leaders, but people also get burnt out having to generate RP around the whims of PC city leaders. That being said.. if the cities were made vulnerable, as in lost their deus ex machina(l ooking at you, Voice of Tarkuul), and that led to them being destroyed.... so what? So long as the destruction of Cordor/Wiltun/whatever is being brought about by in-game events, I say let it happen. More work for the devs? Yes. Obviously. But Cordor isn't going to be destroyed over night. Kohlingen isn't just going to disappear. Nobody is going to expect the ones we have volunteering to make this server for us to have big things like that done over night. Maybe the kobolds could come together and form their own village on the ruins of Cordor's outskirts? Or pirates turn what remains of Wharftown into a smugglers paradise? The end of the major Amian cities doesn't have to mean the end of Amia.
|
|
|
|
 |
|
NinjaClarinet
|
Posted: Tue, Aug 04 2015, 5:57 AM |
|
|

Player
Joined: 12 Jul 2010
|
|
It takes -days- to fix broken transitions and you think they can manage repeated city overhauls? Your expectations have to be tempered with the resources the server has. It's all fine and well to say "so what if it's more work" until you've had to try to fix a module that won't stay online for more than an hour.
|
|
|
|
 |
|
Liz
|
Posted: Tue, Aug 04 2015, 6:00 AM |
|
|

Player
Joined: 28 May 2010 Location: Smallville
|
|
I have to completely reject the idea that "city as faction" RP is inherently slow-moving RP. Slow-moving RP is RP carried out by slow-moving people, whether those people are players or DMs, and whether the RP is generated by city-factions or... whatever the opposite would be. (Independent factions?) RP stagnating because people can't get a response out of their DM is no less common than RP stagnating because of players not communicating with each other. In my time as a PC leader of Winya Ravana, I saw RP that moved like a rocket, and RP that moved like a rock, and there wasn't any overwhelming tendency toward either DMs or players being predominantly culpable.
_________________ Winner of Amia's "Most Ethical Time Traveler" award 2026 Character Portraits!
|
|
|
|
 |
|
Krin
|
Posted: Tue, Aug 04 2015, 6:16 AM |
|
|

Player
Joined: 05 Jan 2006 Location: California
|
NinjaClarinet wrote: It takes -days- to fix broken transitions and you think they can manage repeated city overhauls? Your expectations have to be tempered with the resources the server has. It's all fine and well to say "so what if it's more work" until you've had to try to fix a module that won't stay online for more than an hour. I understand that. Like I said, I don't think anyone would expect anything as major as the destruction of Cordor to happen and be built in game over night or even over a few weeks. We're (mostly) adults here. I think we all understand that the server operates on limited resources with every change coming from the sweat of some wonderful volunteer's brow. Liz wrote: I have to completely reject the idea that "city as faction" RP is inherently slow-moving RP. Slow-moving RP is RP carried out by slow-moving people, whether those people are players or DMs, and whether the RP is generated by city-factions or... whatever the opposite would be. (Independent factions?) RP stagnating because people can't get a response out of their DM is no less common than RP stagnating because of players not communicating with each other. In my time as a PC leader of Winya Ravana, I saw RP that moved like a rocket, and RP that moved like a rock, and there wasn't any overwhelming tendency toward either DMs or players being predominantly culpable. This has never been my experience with city RP led by PCs. What I've seen, and continue to see, is that the involvement of PC city leaders slows things down to a crawl and makes city RP exclusive in ways that aren't healthy for the server. I see newer players being burnt out over never being able to affect anything in the major cities more often than I've seen PC leaders step down from their positions because the player and/or character is burnt out.
|
|
|
|
 |
|
Grymia
|
Posted: Tue, Aug 04 2015, 6:51 AM |
|
|

Player
Joined: 14 Dec 2004 Location: Kohlingen, and a Basement in Canada
|
|
It's possible to try to carry out reconnisance, Intelligence gathering and research efforts to look into a city. My experience is most DMs who run cities are willing to offer the opporitunity to try to do so if you're willing.
That'll help you find vulnerabilities ,and possible things to hit.
|
|
|
|
 |
|
Lutra
|
Posted: Tue, Aug 04 2015, 7:09 AM |
|
|

Player
Joined: 12 Feb 2008
|
|
After reading this topic I'm quite surprised at the OP's suggestion. I mean, I can see the logic in that and the suggestion would be rather understandable if it was coming from a new player. However, you are playing here for four years and what you are saying suggests that you did not even pay attention to the surroundings or the events that occurred around you.
|
|
|
|
 |
|
Elorathall
|
Posted: Tue, Aug 04 2015, 7:29 AM |
|
|

Player
Joined: 13 Mar 2011
|
|
It's more a matter of what isn't happening.
_________________ Aernoud Van Brabant: Heir of the House. Proprietor of the Beer Wagon. "Go to the Mayfields, have a pint, and wait for this to blow over." Aurelius: Sunmaster of Amaunator. Contemplative. Aspirant to Transcendance. "Sol Invictus"
|
|
|
|
 |
|
Silkelock
|
Posted: Tue, Aug 04 2015, 9:17 AM |
|
|

Player
Joined: 17 Jun 2011 Location: Sweden
|
Elorathall wrote: It's more a matter of what isn't happening. Is something not happening rp wise or did you mean it in another way?
_________________ Life should be prolonged only when it serves the greater cause of the death of the world.
|
|
|
|
 |
|
Elorathall
|
Posted: Tue, Aug 04 2015, 10:18 AM |
|
|

Player
Joined: 13 Mar 2011
|
|
Well, this applies to several settlements/groups (at least) but to use the Tarkuul/Shadowscape example. Here are two settlements whose main "signature" people (being Shadowdancers and Necromancers respectivelly) have access to mysterious and powerful magic in their own right. The development of this has huge creative potential outside of the book. I only glimpse the surface of it, but I'm sure that the development of these powers in Shadowscape is just as in depth, or at the least has just as much potential, as that in Tarkuul. But there's no confrontation. No conflict for supremacy that drives such advances.
Instead, both sides are stuck in their comfort zones - and from what I can gather especially the Shadowscape players like it just fine that way. There's little need to proactively seek advantage over perceived competition. To be fair, Tarkuul is in a state of expansion and this will likely lead to conflict sooner or later. But Shadowscape has been bereft of true involvement (let alone evolution) for a long time (if ever).
It's all remarkably dull. Though this isn't entirely a design fault. This is (perhaps far more) the result of players knowing full well that the most enduring power lies within finding a place, entrenching and maintaining the status quo. There's no risk to conflict, but neither is there true reward. It's like both sides being wrapped in airbags and throwing themselves at one another until one of them gets bored and quits. Usually with a forum rant about the unfairness of being.
_________________ Aernoud Van Brabant: Heir of the House. Proprietor of the Beer Wagon. "Go to the Mayfields, have a pint, and wait for this to blow over." Aurelius: Sunmaster of Amaunator. Contemplative. Aspirant to Transcendance. "Sol Invictus"
|
|
|
|
 |
|
Mr. Hackums
|
Posted: Tue, Aug 04 2015, 13:02 PM |
|
|

Player
Joined: 22 May 2008
|
|
There are other avenues for server conflict, I think. And if memory serves, Shadowscape and Tarkuul have had bumpy history. Honestly, I think the issue is that Shadowscape should thematically be isolated. City tensions And politics is kind of outside of the theme of Shadowscape. The resident shdadow dancers not having an interest in conflict with material plane cities is probably fair.That doesnt mean that a status quo of emptiness and lack of conflict is good for Shadowscape, however! I just think that Shadowscape should find conflict within, and from their environment. All possible with the help of a dedicated DM.
If you're after city conflict, also, you're kind of looking in the wrong place with Tarkuul. Numerous players, including Tarkuulites have voiced distress with the desire to engage the server with conflict clashing against the city's defensive and unusually careful ethos. Preserving the status quo, unfortunately, is practically engraved in the stone there. It -would- be a mistake to think that Tarkuul simply doesn't interact with the world, because that's just not true. They're just covert. If it's ever known that Tarkuul had it's fingers in an incident, its widely considered a PR failure for the city-- and this a threat when they are vastly outnumbered by a highly organized and powerful alliance of cities that has historically beaten vast and powerful armies. Regretfully, this means that most people won't actually feel or experience the hidden influence of Tarkuul, leaving players with the unfortunate feeling of a lack of conflict.
|
|
|
|
 |
|
Mr. Hackums
|
Posted: Tue, Aug 04 2015, 13:10 PM |
|
|

Player
Joined: 22 May 2008
|
|
It's not a dilemma I have a definitive answer to. You're right to acknowledge that it exists, Elorathall. I think your solution does more damage than good, but there IS a distinct absence in Amia A conflict. The powers and alignments are simply not balanced in a way that allows for tension. Racial conflict between cities is possible, but I've found that most Amians don't have the stomach for the portrayal racism (which isn't really a bad thing, haha!).
I think that the answer probably lies within Single-City conflict. Like competing groups within a city. A thieves guild and Cordor Law enforcement, for instance. Or merchant families in Cordor. But there are problems with this, such as the frequency of city bans and the availability of a chaotic hub within a lawful environment (where banned people can still find Rp). Cordor West is the best example.
|
|
|
|
 |
|
Krin
|
Posted: Tue, Aug 04 2015, 14:51 PM |
|
|

Player
Joined: 05 Jan 2006 Location: California
|
Mr. Hackums wrote: It's not a dilemma I have a definitive answer to. You're right to acknowledge that it exists, Elorathall. I think your solution does more damage than good, but there IS a distinct absence in Amia A conflict. The powers and alignments are simply not balanced in a way that allows for tension. Racial conflict between cities is possible, but I've found that most Amians don't have the stomach for the portrayal racism (which isn't really a bad thing, haha!).
I think that the answer probably lies within Single-City conflict. Like competing groups within a city. A thieves guild and Cordor Law enforcement, for instance. Or merchant families in Cordor. But there are problems with this, such as the frequency of city bans and the availability of a chaotic hub within a lawful environment (where banned people can still find Rp). Cordor West is the best example. I don't think Single-City conflict works if PCs are running the city. It would all turn to city bans, arguments over whether or not NPC guards all have True Seeing,and threats of permadeath before the RP went anywhere substantial. It would be better to let the major cities be slow moving, nigh invulnerable juggernauts led by DM NPCs that come out of the closet for massive plots. Having PCs running any of the major cities only soaks up DM attention and locks huge chunks of the player base out of the RP that goes on there. I think the answer lies within player-run factions independent from any of the major cities, but, going by what I've seen in game and have heard players talk about in party chat, player initiatives like this aren't given much attention right now because the major things are going on in the cities.
|
|
|
|
 |
|
Elorathall
|
Posted: Tue, Aug 04 2015, 15:15 PM |
|
|

Player
Joined: 13 Mar 2011
|
|
There will always be people that want to get involved in the city itself. And there are always people who will want to hold positions of power within settlements. And so I circle back to Amia's lack of identity.
_________________ Aernoud Van Brabant: Heir of the House. Proprietor of the Beer Wagon. "Go to the Mayfields, have a pint, and wait for this to blow over." Aurelius: Sunmaster of Amaunator. Contemplative. Aspirant to Transcendance. "Sol Invictus"
|
|
|
|
 |
|
Krin
|
Posted: Tue, Aug 04 2015, 15:32 PM |
|
|

Player
Joined: 05 Jan 2006 Location: California
|
|
I don't think PCs leading the smaller settlements is a big deal. When you're dealing with massive NPC armies, city-state level resources, and the ability to ban characters from major social hubs.. it becomes a huge problem.
I've seen many, many players get burnt out and leave because they need to dance around PC city leaders. It's not healthy for the server.
|
|
|
|
 |
|
NinjaClarinet
|
Posted: Tue, Aug 04 2015, 15:50 PM |
|
|

Player
Joined: 12 Jul 2010
|
Krin wrote: Mr. Hackums wrote: It's not a dilemma I have a definitive answer to. You're right to acknowledge that it exists, Elorathall. I think your solution does more damage than good, but there IS a distinct absence in Amia A conflict. The powers and alignments are simply not balanced in a way that allows for tension. Racial conflict between cities is possible, but I've found that most Amians don't have the stomach for the portrayal racism (which isn't really a bad thing, haha!).
I think that the answer probably lies within Single-City conflict. Like competing groups within a city. A thieves guild and Cordor Law enforcement, for instance. Or merchant families in Cordor. But there are problems with this, such as the frequency of city bans and the availability of a chaotic hub within a lawful environment (where banned people can still find Rp). Cordor West is the best example. I don't think Single-City conflict works if PCs are running the city. It would all turn to city bans, arguments over whether or not NPC guards all have True Seeing,and threats of permadeath before the RP went anywhere substantial. It would be better to let the major cities be slow moving, nigh invulnerable juggernauts led by DM NPCs that come out of the closet for massive plots. Having PCs running any of the major cities only soaks up DM attention and locks huge chunks of the player base out of the RP that goes on there. I think the answer lies within player-run factions independent from any of the major cities, but, going by what I've seen in game and have heard players talk about in party chat, player initiatives like this aren't given much attention right now because the major things are going on in the cities. It also doesn't work when a new DM gets crushed under so much bitching for even -looking- at the status quo that they throw their hands up. Amia is eating its own cake.
|
|
|
|
 |
|
Mr. Hackums
|
Posted: Tue, Aug 04 2015, 16:01 PM |
|
|

Player
Joined: 22 May 2008
|
|
I agree. With all three.
A single, diverse city with inward conflict would have to be managed by a DM oversight. Smaller cities can be run be players, and that would cater to a different crowd. Ultimately, Amia thrives on faction conflict. It's just very hard to get traction as a group concept outside of a city, unfortunately. DM oversight is easier, developer projects are streamlined, and it helps to foster a hub when a group bases out of a city. But there are tangible downsides too- mostly having to do with the situation and arrangement of cities.
If a conflict based faction didn't require a physical base they could be great outside of a city.
|
|
|
|
 |
|
gorgometh
|
Posted: Tue, Aug 04 2015, 16:07 PM |
|
|

Player
Joined: 07 Oct 2008 Location: Southeast (USA)
|
Krin wrote: I don't think PCs leading the smaller settlements is a big deal. When you're dealing with massive NPC armies, city-state level resources, and the ability to ban characters from major social hubs.. it becomes a huge problem.
I've seen many, many players get burnt out and leave because they need to dance around PC city leaders. It's not healthy for the server. Regardless of PC leadership, if you think that any of what you described goes unchecked by DM's then you are gravely misinformed. I steered the Jarl-Wardens of Wiltun away from "guard-work" for the sole reason that it was becoming overly restrictive and not fun for anyone. But that doesn't mean the PC's and players that have chosen a hub to play get to be held hostage from protecting their hub IC, just because you don't like to play that way. Any and all of what you've described has been happening with guard factions and DM run settlements for as long as I can remember, and likely before that. I've only been here since 2008, afterall. Regardless of any PC authority in settlements or governments of the major hubs, if you as a PC try to ignore restrictions, setting peculiarities and existing laws then you've just subjected yourself to whatever consequences arise. End of story. Also, I've seen PC's get burnt out from having to keep those restriction avoiding PC's in check, so don't delude yourself into thinking it's a one way street. Your preferred fun and play style is not everyone else's. That's Amia's identity, in my opinion. - Playing the way you want, where you want and responding accordingly to how the setting evolves and is supposed to be shaped by what you do.
|
|
|
|
 |
|
bobofwestoregonusa
|
Posted: Tue, Aug 04 2015, 16:16 PM |
|
|

Player
Joined: 09 Jun 2012 Location: Eastern Washington
|
|
I don't think the issue of stagnating leadership can really be blamed on one person, I know my absence as governor for a while made things hard, but I also don't really have things to react to or try to fix when whatever DM I interact with is uninvolved, so I end up doing more or less what I perceived to be a problem elsewhere, where I just work on city building and talking to my area based dm about possibilities.
But that circle loops back around to me not giving them things to do, so I think as a whole we just need to all work harder together on it. I don't know how necessarily but I've got it in my head to try and be more proactive, and I'm hoping we can just all sort of build off each other.
That's my two cents though, I'll just try to be in game to help with stagnation.
_________________ Gerald EdmundDiscord: Metal Viking Guy #5433 DC taxation is theft!
|
|
|
|
 |
|
gorgometh
|
Posted: Tue, Aug 04 2015, 16:17 PM |
|
|

Player
Joined: 07 Oct 2008 Location: Southeast (USA)
|
|
My honest encouragement would be to play your style, stir that conflict and if you need DM support, get one of us to back you up. - If you think PC's are being unfair or untoward, then I bet the DM will snap that back right quick.
|
|
|
|
 |
|
Mr. Hackums
|
Posted: Tue, Aug 04 2015, 16:18 PM |
|
|

Player
Joined: 22 May 2008
|
|
I've actually got an idea. I'll spell it out when I get back home. It wouldn't need any design work, just players deciding to try something out.
|
|
|
|
 |
|
Krin
|
Posted: Tue, Aug 04 2015, 16:34 PM |
|
|

Player
Joined: 05 Jan 2006 Location: California
|
gorgometh wrote: Regardless of PC leadership, if you think that any of what you described goes unchecked by DM's then you are gravely misinformed. I steered the Jarl-Wardens of Wiltun away from "guard-work" for the sole reason that it was becoming overly restrictive and not fun for anyone. But that doesn't mean the PC's and players that have chosen a hub to play get to be held hostage from protecting their hub IC, just because you don't like to play that way. Wiltun is the exception on Amia. It's not a major social hub unless you choose to be part of that faction, so the consequences of PC leadership aren't felt as keenly as they would be in a city like Cordor. The Wiltun 'faction' also seems to have massive DM support because, let's face it, B-mia would just be the server loot farming grounds if Wiltun's Warden faction didn't exist. Of course it takes a lot of player initiative and hard work to get things done, and I don't mean to down play that at all, but I'm still not sold on player characters having access to NPC armies large enough to wage war across continents even if they are checked by DMs. gorgometh wrote: Any and all of what you've described has been happening with guard factions and DM run settlements for as long as I can remember, and likely before that. I've only been here since 2008, afterall. Regardless of any PC authority in settlements or governments of the major hubs, if you as a PC try to ignore restrictions, setting peculiarities and existing laws then you've just subjected yourself to whatever consequences arise. End of story.
Also, I've seen PC's get burnt out from having to keep those restriction avoiding PC's in check, so don't delude yourself into thinking it's a one way street.
Your preferred fun and play style is not everyone else's. That's Amia's identity, in my opinion. - Playing the way you want, where you want and responding accordingly to how the setting evolves and is supposed to be shaped by what you do. I'm not arguing that actions shouldn't have consequences or that everyone should play the way I want them to. I'm arguing that having PCs in charge of major cities hurts the server, turns social hub RP exclusive, and scares off newer players that want to make an impact on the server story. Don't misunderstand me, this isn't some sort of veiled critique on current PC leaders or their players. It makes sense that characters would want to be in control of armies, cities, etc. It makes sense that they would assert their authority once taking a position of leadership. But being in charge of a major social hub puts a lot of restrictions on those PC leaders and the characters operating in the cities they're in control of, which slows down plots. That leads to apathy on both ends of the spectrum and that apathy is slowly killing the server. Supporting player factions, independent from the cities, is the only real solution that I can see for this problem.
|
|
|
|
 |
|
Elorathall
|
Posted: Tue, Aug 04 2015, 17:48 PM |
|
|

Player
Joined: 13 Mar 2011
|
|
At this time, I'd like to briefly toss out a concept. This isn't a suggestion for implementation or even a discussion in its viability, but simply an illustration of my view. --- Amia would still be an island, but there would be only a single city (let's call it Cordor) and a few scattered, small pockets of civilization. A lumber camp here. A fishing village there. The city is the main hub and starting area, and the setting expands from there. The further you move away from Cordor, the more dangerous it gets.
The city itself is a cosmopolitan and varied place. It's governed by a Duke who takes a very laissez-faire approach to government, leaving individual districts to govern themselves. As long as the flow of tax money into the Duke's coffers isn't threatened or interrupted, the Duke doesn't particularly care what goes on in the districts. If it is, he sends in his personal guard and agents to restore order.
Every district has a different atmosphere and theme, and attracts different kinds of people. The Duchal district features the ducal palace and main governmental and judicial buildings. It's the administrative center of the city. It's rife with corruption - but offers considerable power for those able to play the game of politics and navigate its bureaucratic labyrinth.
The Temple district is the spiritual heart of the city, built around a great temple of the Triad. While other districts have their own shrines and chapels (some open, some hidden) non can match the grandeur and splendor of those in the district, and its people ensure that it is well maintained and clean.
The Docks district is the beating heart of the city, full of markets and warehouses. It is de facto governed by a small oligarchy of merchant guilds who have carved up the district between themselves. The guilds ensure the district is reasonably safe, as they don't want to scare customers and investors away, but there are plenty of alleys that should be avoided.
The Stone district is all but a slum, home to the poorest. Crime and disease are rampant, and the district is governed by the iron fist of a self-proclaimed Baron - who has his finger in every shady undertaking. The area also features a decaying arena where pit fighters come to earn glory for themselves. A dangerous place, even in broad daylight, there are nonetheless plenty of opportunities for the cunning and ruthless to carve out their place.
The Below literally lies below the city, carved out among its sewers and cisterns - and expanded into ancient ruins that lead yet further down to the Underdark. It is a place of shadow and darkness, of evil shrines and dark deeds. Undead roam freely, and everyone knows where those who dissapear on the surface go. Despite the efforts of goodly faiths, the Below remains a part of the Duke's realm - who turns a blind eye to the horrors there in exchange for coin and services only such a place can provide. For their part, the Below is careful not to antagonize the surface needlessly. It's dark and ruthless Overseer punishes transgressions severely. --- Though just a concept, I hope this illustrates how I see how vastly different concepts and play styles can be placed together in close enough proximity to allow frequent interaction while maintaining a place for as broad a people as possible.
_________________ Aernoud Van Brabant: Heir of the House. Proprietor of the Beer Wagon. "Go to the Mayfields, have a pint, and wait for this to blow over." Aurelius: Sunmaster of Amaunator. Contemplative. Aspirant to Transcendance. "Sol Invictus"
|
|
|
|
 |
|
gorgometh
|
Posted: Tue, Aug 04 2015, 17:51 PM |
|
|

Player
Joined: 07 Oct 2008 Location: Southeast (USA)
|
|
I just inherently disagree then, K. - I don't see those as restrictions at their core, I kind of take it as literally expanding the immersion of a place and the different ways to get involved or interact with those hubs.
Cool concept Elor. In my opinion, that is not what Amia is or ever will be.
|
|
|
|
 |
|
TormakSaber
|
Posted: Tue, Aug 04 2015, 19:56 PM |
|
|

Player
Joined: 16 Dec 2004 Location: Somewhere
|
|
That city would inevitably and probably very quickly, collapse into civil war or break under its own weight in the Amian setting, imo, due to the efforts of dozens PCs pulling in dozens of different directions.
you can manage a "Nice city"/"slum city" dynamic pretty easily, but when you start adding "holy city", "rich city", "incompetent, greedy ruler", "Corrupt government", and "actual evil district" into the mix, there's no way it would manage to stay aloft. There would be no reason for the rest of the city to tolerate the awful Below, especially not the pious Temple district. The self proclaimed Barron would quickly find himself under an encroaching thumb, and a Duke, if he didn't actually care or handle the problems, would find himself leaned on by an increasing number of influential people on all sides, let alone what happens to a bunch of corrupt bureaucrats when neither good nor evil can get anything accomplished through them.
You can't just mash themes together without a care. It doesn't work. You need to take careful stock of how those themes mesh together and the interplay between them, the dichotomy that gets created, and what the benefit of doing so is. Doing it for the sake of "conflict" will get you that conflict but very quickly and much messier and much less controlled than you would ever actually want. Suddenly you've got one single, major city that can't be toppleable because it's literally too big to fail: If you remove it or crush it, then the entire island no longer has a settlement. Not to mention if you constantly artificially preserve these districts in the face of PC initiatives for the sake of maintaining inclusiveness, you quickly run up against the very complaints that have been lodged in this topic: That the city is being forced together by the DMs and PC initiatives are being ignored. When they realize that the reigning government is incompetent and incapable of handling problems that extend beyond their tiny district walls (and problems would spill over very quickly indeed), the PCs would be making moves to change the power structure in one way or another so that the problems do get solved.
Even Waterdeep, maybe the closest thing to your suggested city, is a massive, sprawling metropolis, but is held together by a large network of overwhelmingly good aligned Masked Lords and an actual Paladin Open Lord, among other large groups and organizations that work to keep the city running. Even Underport is run by the Skulls and other powerful gangs who enforce order in an otherwise mostly lawless place, because otherwise it would collapse into anarchy and chaos. Not to mention being surrounded by Undermountain and Halaster's all-powerful influence.
_________________ Davion Telemos - Monk of the Four Winds Korthan Isharnos - Dragon Shaman of Thunder Spirit Zamasham
|
|
|
|
 |
|
Krin
|
Posted: Tue, Aug 04 2015, 20:51 PM |
|
|

Player
Joined: 05 Jan 2006 Location: California
|
|
That sounds like a really cool concept, Elor, but I think the server is a little too far down the road to make any massive changes like that right away. So I'm just focusing on the biggest issue I can see right now..which is PC leadership of city factions.
|
|
|
|
 |
|
Elorathall
|
Posted: Tue, Aug 04 2015, 22:02 PM |
|
|

Player
Joined: 13 Mar 2011
|
|
Yep it's just a thought exercise, really. Whether or not it would actually work in practice is another matter entirely. I do see the potential for Cordor to evolve into a "light" version of it.
_________________ Aernoud Van Brabant: Heir of the House. Proprietor of the Beer Wagon. "Go to the Mayfields, have a pint, and wait for this to blow over." Aurelius: Sunmaster of Amaunator. Contemplative. Aspirant to Transcendance. "Sol Invictus"
|
|
|
|
 |
Who is online |
Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 4 guests |
|
You cannot post new topics in this forum You cannot reply to topics in this forum You cannot edit your posts in this forum You cannot delete your posts in this forum
|
|